Wanted: debunking of financial advisors, managers, planners, stock brokers...

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
Please read the following citation and contribute your comments.

Taken from SKeptics Society Forum, http://www.skepticforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=7664

======================

Author Message
yrreg
Valued Contributor



Joined: 07 Nov 2005
Posts: 62

Posted: Mon May 14, 2007 3:21 am Download Post #1 Post subject: Are make-money experts essentially gambling with your money?

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

By make-money experts I understand all kinds of people who enable you to make money from your money, like financial planners, advisers, stock brokers, etc., and you pay them for the service.

freedictionary said:
http://ie.encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/Financial Planner


A Financial Planner or Personal Financial Planner is a practicing professional who helps people deal with various personal financial issues through proper planning, which includes but is not limited to these major areas: tertiary education planning, retirement planning, investment planning, risk management and insurance planning, tax planning, estate planning and business succession planning (for business owners). The work engaged in by this professional is commonly known as personal financial planning. In carrying out the planning function, he is guided by a process known as the financial planning process which should result in creating a detailed strategy for making their clients as wealthy as possible. [Bolding provided by Yrreg]



[The article is copied from Wikipedia but it is not the up to date version of the Wikipedia article which is being edited continuously.]
.​

When I read the line in bold I laughed loudly.

Skeptics deal with so many topics but this is one topic that they have not gone or do not go into. [Buddhism is another one.]

.​

Questions:

1. Are not make-money experts essentially gambling with their clients money and getting paid handsomely for it?

2. Can we get to see the records of their successes with one particular client and with all their clients -- in a specified period of years?

3. What then is their kind of knowledge and skills qualifying them to be make-money experts for other people with the latters' money?

4. If they are experts in making money for others, shouldn't they be using their knowledge and skills to make money for themselves with their own money or borrowed money?​

.​

What do the financial or economic or monetary experts in this forum say?


Yrreg

Back to top


========================

yrreg
Valued Contributor



Joined: 07 Nov 2005
Posts: 62

Posted: Fri May 18, 2007 12:45 am Download Post #2 Post subject: Well, I am right...

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

...that skeptics talk about so many things which have been talked to death, but there are things which they prefer not to talk about, like money-expert people who get paid to help you make money with your own money, and whether you gain any profit or not and even lose money, they get paid handsomely just the same.


I invite skeptics to give their attention to this kind of people and show how their profession is beyond debunking or really full of debunkable premises and unjustifiable confidence from their clients.


Yrreg

Back to top


Display posts from previous:

.​

Thanks for your contributions if any.


Yrreg
 
Appreciate that you put this in humour, to save us the time pointing out how laughable it is. And nice how you managed to put in yet another lie about skeptics and buddhism. I mean, you wouldn't be yrreg if you couldn't show your prejudices against buddhism in every thread you make, would you?
 
You miss the beef by going into an obiter.

I am going into sacred cows that skeptics don't go into; the run of the mill are so self-complacent beating dead horses they can't see anything else to investigate, thereby they have not seen anything new or different to exercise critical thinking on and exact empirical evidence over, unlike yours truly who is the genuine, universal, all around, and open ended skeptic, for whom there are no sacred cows.


Just for humor, please, no offense.


Yrreg
 
Zzzzzz....

Wake me up when you have something informative to say and aren't just being self-congratulatory and arrogant, will you?
 
I suggest you search this forum for terms like efficient market hypothesis, EMH, random walk theory, Malkiel, Warren Buffett, Berkshire, Fama and French, to see that in fact we have discussed these things in detail, and with a sceptical eye.

But it sounds like you have reached a conclusion, and are now looking for an argument, so that's all I'll say for now until I see how the thread progresses.
 
Yours is the first sensible reaction to my topic.

Congratulations!

That is what I found so disappointing in my discussions with the Buddhists of this JREF forum who claim to be skeptics but are Buddhists, and they don't see any inconsistency, why? because they resort to the expediency of defining Buddhism and specifying the genuine, original, authentic, etc. message of Buddha, so that there is nothing in their kind of Buddhism that Buddha himself could recognize to be any teaching from him.

Do we have any kind of people here? who are genuine experts of critical thinking and adepts at empirical evidence who can be approached for their determination whether a discussant is being true to the canons of skepticism in any particular question or just exploiting the label of skeptic even though acting against critical thinking and empirical evidence.

=================


There are to my impression so many subjects that skeptics can train their attention on to unearth the facts and expose the myths in current society and civilization, but they have concentrated on paranormal phenomena and pseudoscientific materials of a limited enumeration, and thereby miss helping ordinary people know answers to questions like the ones I put forward in my OP about all kinds of make-money experts.

Good for a laugh, my impressions; well, you are welcome.

===============

Take for example this question, is the challenge of Randi in consonance with the canons of skepticism or not. I have always wondered how he can set himself up to be the judge on whether an event or an action is factual or chicanery, when right away anyone with critical thinking will say that no one can be judge in his own cause.

===============


roger said:
I suggest you search this forum for terms like efficient market hypothesis, EMH, random walk theory, Malkiel, Warren Buffett, Berkshire, Fama and French, to see that in fact we have discussed these things in detail, and with a sceptical eye.

But it sounds like you have reached a conclusion, and are now looking for an argument, so that's all I'll say for now until I see how the thread progresses.


I searched in JREF forum the word financial before I introduced my topic, and it did not return anything reminiscent of my interest.

You being a veteran here, perhaps can refer me to a board here where the questions dealt with are focused on financial -- if I may use the term, myths.


Just the same, I congratulate you for the first one to my impression to have issued a sensible reaction to my OP.


About my request to you as a veteran member here, to tell me a specific board where financial myths are treated, you will perhaps tell me to do my own homework; that is the recurring dodge of Buddhist skeptics here.

If you know for being a veteran skeptic here, you can do me the favor; if not, just say you don't know.



I put this topic here in humor because in humor there is truth or there is the fact.



Yrreg
 
Efficient Market Hypothesis
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-9300.html
http://www.randi.org/forumlive/showthread.php?t=44071&page=3
http://www.shanekillian.org/jref/macroeconomics.html

Random Walk
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=79200
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/archive/index.php/t-79622.html

There is a tendency for skeptics to discuss specific theories that financial firms are often misguided by (or misguide their clients with) rather than go for a blanket denouncement.

Financial planners don't get the wholesale debunking (or financial services in general) in skeptic forums (fora?) ... as opposed, say, to psychics... because there is already so much healthy skepticism out there and many regulatory bodies, watchdog groups, and so on, looking out for the more fraudulent.

In general, financial planners (particularily the certified variety) are honest about the limitations of their profession and what they are actually doing for you.

Any "psychic" who says, "actually, I have no special insight; I am charging you so I can cold-read you, provide vague allusions for you to self-validate, to produce the illusion of special powers." I have no problem with.
 
Last edited:
I found the freedictionary article quoted in OP a tad odd... it seemed way to offhand for a responsible resource... I checked. And, indeed, the definition is there.

However, the rest of the entry qualifies the earlier statements quite nicely, then it moves on to a direct crib of the wikipoedia entry for the same... a much more sober approach.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Financial_planner
A Financial Planner or Personal Financial Planner is a practicing professional who helps people to deal with various personal financial issues through proper planning, which includes but not limited to these major areas: tertiary education planning, retirement planning, investment planning, risk management and insurance planning, tax planning, estate planning and business succession planning (for business owners). The work engaged in by this professional is commonly known as personal financial planning. In carrying out the planning function, he is guided by the financial planning process to create a detailed strategy tailored to a client's specific situation, for meeting a client's specific goals.

I think the quoted entry says more about the deficiencies in the dictionary than it does of Financial Planning.

Taken skeptically - which, I note, you have not done (you merely invited skeptical comment from others) - I see that the bold text does not offer anything concrete... the aim: "to make the client as wealthy as possible" is qualified by that "possible".

To specific topics next post.
 
Questions:

1. Are not make-money experts essentially gambling with their clients money and getting paid handsomely for it?

No. You are thinking of financial investors, like stockbrokers.
But there is nothing wrong with that unless the investor deliberately leads yau to think that a particular investment is a "sure thing".

2. Can we get to see the records of their successes with one particular client and with all their clients -- in a specified period of years?

... in NZ, these things are covered by privacy legislation. However, financial companies are required to publish a prospectus and there are conditions under which an audit can be performed. Various certification authorities may require some "openness" to the books as well.

The principles that financial planners use have been researched and peer reviewed in academic institutions around the world - though the feild is far from exact. Of course, there are crooks in any profession.

3. What then is their kind of knowledge and skills qualifying them to be make-money experts for other people with the latters' money?

They have the benefit that comes with any specialist study. Anyone can manage anyones money, some people are better at it than others. These people have been trained to be better at it than others. Refer to the dictionary or wiki for specifics. If you have a specific objection, then voice it.

4. If they are experts in making money for others, shouldn't they be using their knowledge and skills to make money for themselves with their own money or borrowed money?

They do. Financial planners naturally take advantage of their own services. Part of this is making money by offering their services for sale... thus, they are following a course they would advise to their clients.

If a client had a skill set that wasn't being exploited, it would be sound to advise them to do so don't you think?
 
That is really educational for me, thanks a lot!

Simon Bridge, again, thank you very much.


That distinction between stock brokers and the broad term financial expert, whatever, is truly enlightening.

Enlightening myself with folks here more learned and more experienced than myself, is what I am after. No, not endless arguing where discussants go into all kinds of semantic acrobatics just to not admit something on first sight already fishy from as I said the standpoint of critical thinking and empirical evidence.

I will digest your responses more attentively, in the meantime, may I just ask you what you think about the lie supposedly I am making with my opinion on the inconsistency between being skeptics and being Buddhists, and also about the challenge by Randi not in accordance with the canons of skepticism for appointing himself judge as a conditio-sine-qua-non for anyone taking on his challenge.


Again, thanks a lot!!!


And I am very glad to know you who don't hurl accusations of lying around in your messages -- well, so far not.



And let's see what other skeptics have to say about my topic.



Yrreg
 
No. You are thinking of financial investors, like stockbrokers.
But there is nothing wrong with that unless the investor deliberately leads yau to think that a particular investment is a "sure thing".

The worst of the lot are the "stock promoters". You find a lot of them in jail these days. That industry could be a little better policed, IMO.

Financial planning as a profession provides value, but individual planners vary in quality. That profession could use a better certification process.

My wife and I hired a Financial Planner when we got married and set up her medical practice, to ensure that our investment and insurance planning was sound.

In contrast, I hired a CA/Management Consultant to assist with the legals, orgchart, and launch of my business.

I think they're a great investment, allowing you to tap into decades of experience and thousands of hours of research for a small one-time cost.
 
"The value of your investment can go down as well as up!"

That well used warning by financial advisers covers just about all of the above, so why all the fuss?
 
That is the ultimate disclaimer, isn't it.

I recall a few years ago when Warren Buffet was asked about whether he knows with any degree of certainty what the market will do, say, over the next quarter. He said, "Yes! I know exactly what the market will do over the next quarter! It will fluctuate unpredictably."
 
yrreg,

I know of no forum that specifically devotes itself to sceptical analysis of finances. There are forums out there devoted to things like Benjamin graham style investing - who is quite the sceptic.

I assert that finances have come under significant sceptical analysis, albeit not by JREF groups (though we have addressed it, it's just not a focus on this forum). Broadly, my thoughts on the topics:

There are classes of knowledge that are helpful: how to minimize your tax exposures, risk/rewards of different asset classes, how to arrange for retirement, etc. None of these disciplines is a "get rich quick" scheme; it stands to reason that people would choose these careers as a career - a way to make a steady stream of income.

Then there are endless "newletters" which promise to pick hot stocks, predict the market, etc. They are widely regarded as woo in the investment community. No one has demonstrated the ability to predict the market. These are classic get rich quick schemes - i.e. the auther gets richer, the buyers get poorer.

There are two broad methods of analysis in stocks: technical and fundamental. Technical analysis consists of looking at past prices, 'analyzing' (i use the term loosely) trends, and predicting what the future will bring. IMO, it's shear voodoo. Studies back me up. MACD, one instrument, has a success rate in the low 30 percent range.

Fundamental analysis works by looking at the underlying performance of the company - what cash flows does it generate, what are the likely cash flows in the future, and what price should we pay today for that future cash flow.

It's a more rational approcah, but it has it's detractors. The biggest thing is that you are trying to predict the future based on past performance. The second biggest thing is that if enough people are doing this analysis, won't the future performance of the stock be priced into the stock, giving it no advantage?

I won't go into my thoughts on the latter, but I recommend reading Malkiel's "A random walk down wall street", where he analyzes these issues in great detail. He is often described as an efficient market theorist - someone who argues that stock prices are as efficient as possible - that all known data is already priced into them, and thus we cannot find an 'edge' and pick a stock that will perform better than others. He is not, in my opinion. He has significant intellectual sympathy for fundamental analysis, and agrees that markets are often very irrational. However, he argues that we haven't gathered enough data to show that we can take advantage of these irrationalities. If we cannot, then the market is weakly efficient. Prices may be stupid, but we don't have enough information to take advantage of it.

From that we have modern portfolio theory (I left out decades of research and huge names in the field - I'd get an F if I wrote that for a class, but bear with me, this is already too long). Google is your friend here, but the general idea is forget about picking individual stocks. You are basically rewarded for risk - a treasury bond has no risk, so the return is low. Corporate bonds are more risky, so the returns are higher. Stocks are more risky, so the returns are higher still. As risks increase,so does the flucuation in prices, so it's not a slam dunk just to invest in the riskly stuff. MPT looks at your time horizon - how long can you leave the money in the market, and chooses a portfolio that minimizes risk relative to that time period while maximizing gain. You generally invest in broad asset classes - the S&P 500, an index fund for mexico stocks, an index fund for junk bonds, etc. There's the further idea of how to hedge - choosing investments that are orthogonal or even have negative correlation, so that if investment A goes down B goes up, but that is far beyond the topic of this post.

In short, this topic has received ample sceptical attention in acedemia. I would not be adverse to JREF focusing more attention on the clear charlatans - cold callers (stock salesman), the newletter writers, etc., because they are out to deceive and take your money as are psychics. But Randi is a magician; no insult, but he has no special insight into financial markets, but he has keen insight into magic fakery so often used by dowsers, psychics, etc. It's not hard to see why JREF does not pay attention to financial 'advisors'.
 
Last edited:
You are basically rewarded for risk - a treasury bond has no risk, so the return is low. Corporate bonds are more risky, so the returns are higher. Stocks are more risky, so the returns are higher still. As risks increase,so does the flucuation in prices, so it's not a slam dunk just to invest in the riskly stuff.

Good summary. I think a huge distinction can also be made between investing/gambling money in situations where the average outcome results in a loss vs. a gain.

Casinos, lotteries and commodity or stock options generally just redistribute the investors' money, with the house or brokers taking their cut. The total money paid out is equal to the total money coming in, minus fees. So the "average" investor will lose by the amount of fees, though some will gain. It requires some particular skill or luck to make money in those cases.

Stocks, on the other hand, can actually pay out more than was put in, because they take wealth from the economy at large, not just from the pool of investors. So the "average" investor gains over the long run, making the odds extremely high that a diversified portfolio, like an index mutual fund, will go up over a long period of, say, ten or fifteen years, without any particular skill or luck.
 
I am going into sacred cows that skeptics don't go into; the run of the mill are so self-complacent beating dead horses they can't see anything else to investigate, thereby they have not seen anything new or different to exercise critical thinking on and exact empirical evidence over, unlike yours truly who is the genuine, universal, all around, and open ended skeptic, for whom there are no sacred cows.


Just for humor, please, no offense.


Yrreg

The title of this post is now my sig line.
 
Man, I've seen broad brushes before, but this one is the width of a small planet.

Yyreg said:
4. If they are experts in making money for others, shouldn't they be using their knowledge and skills to make money for themselves with their own money or borrowed money?
My primary financial planner is my father. Trust me, he's investing his own money, too.

~~ Paul
 
This thread hasn't built much steam, but I thought I would quote from Philip Fisher's 1958 classic "Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits". To put the quote in context, he is writing about the amount of effort people put into predicting the future of the markets, and how fruitless it is.

The amount of mental effort the financial community puts into this constant attempt to gues the economic future from a random and probably incomplete series of facts makes one wonder what might have been accomplished if only a fraction of such mental effort had been applied to something with a better chance of proving useful. I have already comapred economic forecasting with chemistry in the days of alchemy. Perhaps this preoccupation whith trying to do something which apparently cannot yet be done properly permits another comparison with the middle Ages.

That was a period when most of the Western world lived in an environment of unnecessary want and human suffering. This was largely because the considerable mental ability of the period was devoted to fruitless results. Consider what might have been accomplished if half as much thought had been given to fighting hunger, disease, and greed as was devoted to debating such points as the number of angels that could balance on the head of a pin. Perhaps just part of the collective intelligence nowadas employed in the investment community's attempt to guess the future trend of the business cycle could produce spectacular results if it were harnessed to more productive purposes.

A perfect example of an sceptical analysis of the field, and of an astute mind recognizing how much time we spend pursuing fruitless activities. I feel Mr. Fisher would be quite at home on this forum, or rubbing elbows with Dawkins, Sagan, et. al.
 
I must congratulate you on your choice of target, yrreg, you certainly don't make life easy for yourself.

Let me tell you how it works, as a former senior manager of a large bank - as opposed to the jack-#### outfits you're talking about:

Financial advisors & brokers make suggestions to their customers about investment strategies. Some work, some don't. Over a long period of time, it is very simple to tell whether an advisor has made + or - returns for his investors.

Those who consistently make a good + return live to fight another day.

Those with - don't.

I don't know about USA, but in NZ, Oz, UK, the rules for all people who participate in the finance industry in any way, but especially in advisory capacities, have very strict regulations covering their operations.

Maybe you could find an easier target? Like real estate agents and used-car salesmen, finance brokers are a thin veneer of respectability over a con, but you're wasting your time - nobody is forced to use advisors.

Caveat emptor.

The end.

Looks like nobody gives a rat's arse about your war against Buddhists (shocking target, by the way) and you're on a dead-set loser here.

Have fun.
 
Skeptics deal with so many topics but this is one topic that they have not gone or do not go into.


Do you have any evidence that skeptics are not appropriately skeptical of financial and investment advisors?


Parenthetically, I was talking with my own financial advisor today about a client who had a $600,000.00 whole life policy payable to his sibling. He was paying $15,000.00 a year, had built up a lousy $40,000.00 equity and the money would go on death to a person who isn't even dependent on his income in life. He's unmarried and has no children. The financial advisor told him to get a $100,000.00 term policy for about $500.00 a year. He saved the guy $14,500.00 per year. And, since the advice did not result in the purchase or sale of securities, he was paid exactly nothing for it.

Good financial advisors make themselves known by producing happy clients. The money they earn for their efforts is the result of a valuable service. The ones who suck, who are just salesmen or who are criminals may survive for a while but will never thrive for long. The market polices itself (with the help of actual police). Skepticism in whom to trust and what methods they employ is appropriate at the micro level. I'm not sure what exact skepticism needs to be applied at a macro level.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom