USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

GOP Inspiring confidence.

[qimg]http://img854.imageshack.us/img854/5840/shootdog.jpg[/qimg]

Give us what we want or we will shoot this dog.
LOL!

Except that there was no serious talk about a credit downgrade before the self-inflicted threat of default.
Not true. Back in April the S&P lowered its outlook on U.S. debt to negative, that's why Geithner came out at that time and made assurances that an actual downgrade wouldn't happen. He was wrong. Regardless, again, the downgrade occurred for financial reasons, not just the "political climate".
 
Personal income tax revenue in 2010 was near 1 Trillion, upper 5% paid about 28% of it, $280 billion.

Assume their effective rate was for discussion sake 25%; at 100% rate that would be $1.12 Trillion paid (plus the other taxpayers $720 billion, total $1.840 trillion), perabus ceterus. How long do you think it'll take to figure tax haven dodges that shield more and more of their income from any US taxation? My guess; a few days to weeks.
Exactly! Thank you Al. Which is why we know that the tax rates in nations like Denmark, France, UK, etc.. are not what people claim. It's impossible. The ability to shelter assets will always result in the same equilibrium.

**** ing lying Canadians. I can't wait until the truth gets out.
 
That's only a rate of return of 6.4% or so. And the wealthy have money to invest, whereas the further down the economic ladder you get more of your net worth is in personal property, which doesn't generate a return at all.

It's hardly a surprising statistic, especially since it's not adjusted for constant dollars.
So, let me ask you this question, where could YOU go to get a guaranteed 6.9% return? Before you tell me it was never "guaranteed" look back in history and tell me how often the top 5% in America haven't gotten something close to that over any 30 year period?

I know people who can't retire because their pensions were raided or their investments tanked. You hit the nail on the head. The secret to getting a good return is to be wealthy. It's the only group the govt will bend over backwards to protect your investments even if you are gambling like a drunken sailor.
 
Powerful people are going to magically make the deficit go away, bring in more money and cut spending? Or are powerful people going to force S&P to change the rating?

Powerful people like Rupert Murdoch are going to quit financing anti-government propaganda because they will see it's costing their friends too much money. Fox News will thus weasel its way into presenting a case for increased revenue because rich, powerful people know market uncertainty will cost them more than the taxes will.

I hope.
 
No, that's not good enough.

Long ago, the Republican Party was something I respected. It had a cadre of great thinkers who brought to policy debates more than "You're a commie!" and who sometimes had ideas that swayed opinions. Hell, they even got Democrats to vote WITH them. They were not always correct, but they were rational gentlemen.

What you have now is an anti-intellectual rabble using jingoism turned inward to create hatred between countrymen over both some very narrow ideological issues and some extremist issues that brook no compromise.

If the extremists could be (figuratively) fed to the wolves, and the GOP get back to it's roots as an intellectual, civil, and thoughtful party, we could be pulled back from the abyss.
How exactly do you get pulled back from the abyss of your party's spending?

By way of compromise?

Let's see how that would work.

The committee can make a committee decision that satisfies everyone.

We'll just let you jump with little baby steps a little bit off the cliff.

Hmmm....little problem there....:)
 
Last edited:
You certainly got an excellent deal on those blinders. They're both partisan and historical.
No doubt Bush spent recklessly, particularly on military. The good news is that we have a strong push by some now to turn back the open spending spigot, although others refuse to make the tough spending cuts that need to be made, particularly in the entitlements areas.
 
No doubt Bush spent recklessly, particularly on military. The good news is that we have a strong push by some now to turn back the open spending spigot, although others refuse to make the tough spending cuts that need to be made, particularly in the entitlements areas.

Just so we're clear: Your position is no compromise of any kind. It's either all spending cuts or nothing. Is that correct?
 
You're right. There is too much government spending. So how much are you willing to cut military spending? I mean, since the military is clearly the most socialist program there is in the U.S. government.

Ok, lets cut military spending - a lot. Who do I vote for that will do that? You tell me.
 
So, let me ask you this question, where could YOU go to get a guaranteed 6.9% return? Before you tell me it was never "guaranteed" look back in history and tell me how often the top 5% in America haven't gotten something close to that over any 30 year period?

I know people who can't retire because their pensions were raided or their investments tanked. You hit the nail on the head. The secret to getting a good return is to be wealthy. It's the only group the govt will bend over backwards to protect your investments even if you are gambling like a drunken sailor.

Yet, you're calling for the government to raise taxes, in order that they can bail out more wealthy people, and pay for more unjust foreign wars. Brilliant.
 
No doubt Bush spent recklessly, particularly on military. The good news is that we have a strong push by some now to turn back the open spending spigot, although others refuse to make the tough spending cuts that need to be made, particularly in the entitlements areas.
By some you mean Republicans, right? Remember how the Republicans campaigned on ending entitlements but when they got into office and saw how much their states were getting they suddenly saw the light?

Okay, I agree, that doesn't invalidate your argument. My response to you is a fallacy. I'll concede that up front. But it is true. Which is why we see silly posturing and reckless political theater.
 
Yet, you're calling for the government to raise taxes, in order that they can bail out more wealthy people, and pay for more unjust foreign wars. Brilliant.
End the wars. Now. Don't ever bail anyone out again. Break up the banks the way Teddy Roosevelt broke up the monopolies. THAT would be brilliant.

BTW: To answer your question. No. But nice try.
 
End the wars. Now. Don't ever bail anyone out again. Break up the banks the way Teddy Roosevelt broke up the monopolies. THAT would be brilliant.

I agree. Screw giving this corrupt government any more of my taxes though.

BTW: To answer your question. No. But nice try.

So the answer is no, thus you have the implicit expectation that you can continue to throw busloads of tax money at this clown show of a government and expect them to do a 180 from business as usual. How realistic do you think that expectation is?
 
Last edited:
Ok, lets cut military spending - a lot. Who do I vote for that will do that? You tell me.
I've signed petitions and written my representatives. I will vote for whoever is most likely to do that. It sucks only having one vote. But that's Democracy. Before anything can happen though we have to realize how idiotic it is to fail to heed Eisenhower's warning.
 
I agree. Screw giving this corrupt government any more of my taxes though.
It sucks but we live in a Republic whose leaders are elected Democratically. Like it or not it is our bed and we made it. I want to say more about paying for the meal we ordered but mixing metaphors is bad form. :)

"We have seen the enemy and it is us" --Pogo
 
So the answer is no, thus you have the implicit expectation that you can continue to throw busloads of tax money at this clown show of a government and expect them to do a 180 from business as usual. How realistic do you think that expectation is?
I don't claim it's easy or that there will be no graft or waste. I think it likely. But your argument is as compelling as expecting govt to actually cut spending without focusing on the things that will hurt the most without focusing on the fraud and corruption that will hurt them the most.
 
I've signed petitions and written my representatives. I will vote for whoever is most likely to do that. It sucks only having one vote. But that's Democracy. Before anything can happen though we have to realize how idiotic it is to fail to heed Eisenhower's warning.

Actually, it's not "democracy", it's called plurality voting, which necessarily results in two sad jokes for political parties. There is this thing called runoff voting which can actually make third parties viable by giving you more votes. Like the idea? Good, I do too :D Lets implement it. Now, if only we could vote for a party that would. Hmm.....
 
It sucks but we live in a Republic whose leaders are elected Democratically. Like it or not it is our bed and we made it. I want to say more about paying for the meal we ordered but mixing metaphors is bad form. :)

"We have seen the enemy and it is us" --Pogo

I'm sorry, but I'm under no illusions that this was my fault. I've been on this forum for years advocating against the status quo. I'm not paying the bill for 300 million morons.
 
Actually, it's not "democracy", it's called plurality voting, which necessarily results in two sad jokes for political parties. There is this thing called runoff voting which can actually make third parties viable by giving you more votes. Like the idea? Good, I do too :D Lets implement it. Now, if only we could vote for a party that would. Hmm.....
I don't disagree with you except for one thing. I'm not sure how "plurality" and "democracy" are mutually exclusive. You'll have to explain that one for me. :)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom