USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Forgive my ignorance, but what does this mean in real terms, both for the U.S. and for the rest of the world?
 
What I don't understand is the White House's response to this. They should be agreeing wholeheartedly and adding in a few "I told you so"s while pointing out that the blame for this should be placed squarely on the Tea Party Caucus.

Because the administration knows it won't matter who was actually at fault. Obama is the only president in history who was in power when the credit rating of the United States was downgraded.

-Bri
 
Because the administration knows it won't matter who was actually at fault. Obama is the only president in history who was in power when the credit rating of the United States was downgraded.

-Bri
The fact that Bush presided over the 9/11 attacks did not seem appropriate fodder for a campaign. In fact I recall the argument that we haven't been hit by an attack that bad since 9/11 touted as a triumph of the previous administration, and the Dems just let that sit. Yet the scruples of the opposition are quite different in this case, as is the critical thinking skills of their base, thus the blame machine is already in full force.
 
Dream on. Although we both get the real answer in 2012. I suspect Tea Party candidates will do well.
Sadly I think things will get much worse. The public has no way of knowing who to trust or who to vote for. 8 years of Bush's wars and wreckless spending (yes, and two years of Obama's), deregulation that first led to the SNL scandal, then Enron and then the meltdown of the banks. We didn't learn from the Great Depression. Safegaurds that led to economic expansion and security have been gutted for greed's sake and a promise of even greater economic expansion. Nonsense. The system can only grow within certain limits. But it might very well take another depression for us to learn what we already know.

What I would like to know is this, why wasn't 8T enough? How many boats can you water ski behind?

"In 1985, the top five percent of the households, wealthiest five percent, had net worth of $8 trillion, which is a lot. Today, after serial bubble after serial bubble, the top five percent have net worth of $40 trillion," he explained.

"The top five percent have gained more wealth than the whole human race had created prior to 1980." (David Stockman)
 
The Democrat Party is already formed.

...

No, that's not good enough.

Long ago, the Republican Party was something I respected. It had a cadre of great thinkers who brought to policy debates more than "You're a commie!" and who sometimes had ideas that swayed opinions. Hell, they even got Democrats to vote WITH them. They were not always correct, but they were rational gentlemen.

What you have now is an anti-intellectual rabble using jingoism turned inward to create hatred between countrymen over both some very narrow ideological issues and some extremist issues that brook no compromise.

If the extremists could be (figuratively) fed to the wolves, and the GOP get back to it's roots as an intellectual, civil, and thoughtful party, we could be pulled back from the abyss.
 
"In 1985, the top five percent of the households, wealthiest five percent, had net worth of $8 trillion, which is a lot. Today, after serial bubble after serial bubble, the top five percent have net worth of $40 trillion," he explained.

"The top five percent have gained more wealth than the whole human race had created prior to 1980." (David Stockman)
So I'm not sure why you think a tax on assets is a bad idea. Taxing the 'income' for that bunch does little.
 
What you have now is an anti-intellectual rabble using jingoism turned inward to create hatred between countrymen over both some very narrow ideological issues and some extremist issues that brook no compromise.
I'm a registered Republican. I want my party to grow up and stop with all the big govt social nonsense.
 
So I'm not sure why you think a tax on assets is a bad idea. Taxing the 'income' for that bunch does little.
I'm not sure why you categorically make such a claim. Why not set the rate at zero if taxes "do little"? What is your basis for your claim?
 
Read again what the S& P said. It wasn't that the deficit is the problem. It's that the political climate in Washington is unstable, ineffective and unpredictable. They cite in particular using the debt ceiling as political leverage:
LOL, no the rating didn't drop just because of the "political climate". There were very real fiscal reasons the rating dropped. Go back and read the report.


What I don't understand is the White House's response to this. They should be agreeing wholeheartedly and adding in a few "I told you so"s while pointing out that the blame for this should be placed squarely on the Tea Party Caucus.
Kind of hard to do a "told you so" when Geithner was totally wrong when he said there was no chance of a downgrade- http://thehill.com/blogs/on-the-money/budget/156747-geithner-no-risk-that-us-loses-its-top-credit-rating
 
The US should have been taken down several more notches, and this should have happened a long time ago. The US is not on a path of financial responsibility and I don't see anything except collapse that will divert our brainless rush towards collapse.
 
LOL, no the rating didn't drop just because of the "political climate". There were very real fiscal reasons the rating dropped. Go back and read the report.
GOP Inspiring confidence.

shootdog.jpg


Give us what we want or we will shoot this dog.
 
I'm not sure why you categorically make such a claim. Why not set the rate at zero if taxes "do little"? What is your basis for your claim?
I was referring specifically to that top 5%. Even a 100% tax on their income would be miniscule compared to the problems we face.

Middle class must suffer, too, to tax our way to a fix. Or we actually cut expenditures.

ps. I agree with Ben's screed. The Republicans began to emulate Democrats, except for a few issues like abortion, govt funded stem-cell research, and gay marriage.
 
I was referring specifically to that top 5%. Even a 100% tax on their income would be miniscule compared to the problems we face.
No, that wouldn't be miniscule. In any event I don't think anything should be in concrete.
 
I was referring specifically to that top 5%. Even a 100% tax on their income would be miniscule compared to the problems we face.

Middle class must suffer, too, to tax our way to a fix. Or we actually cut expenditures.

Most experts seem to agree with your overall point that taxes are going to have to be raised across the board (not just for the rich) in addition to spending cuts.

However, given the increased discrepancy between the rich and poor in recent years, it probably makes sense to raise the rate for the higher-income brackets more than for the middle- and low-income brackets if the intent is to balance the suffering.

The Democrats are going to have to come to terms with the fact that we're going to need to raise taxes for the middle class. The Republicans are going to have to come to terms with the fact that we're going to have to raise taxes.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
LOL, no the rating didn't drop just because of the "political climate". There were very real fiscal reasons the rating dropped. Go back and read the report.

Except that there was no serious talk about a credit downgrade before the self-inflicted threat of default.

-Bri
 
No, that wouldn't be miniscule. In any event I don't think anything should be in concrete.

My opinion of the way you assign a tax structure is you define;

1. How much money do we need?

2. Study how much impact will taxation at a particular level have on the population as broken down by income, because if I tax a man with a family who makes $20,000 a year at 25%, that takes him WAY below a living wage anywhere I know of, but if you tax a man with a family who makes $250,000 a year at 25%, it is quite likely you'd hardly be able to tell the difference in his ability to meet the needs of his family.

3. You create a table of the "pain threshold" numbers you determined in step 2, and those become absolute limits for a simulation of various tax brackets and rates to heuristically find the rates which will generate the amount of revenue you need, or determine that you cannot generate that revenue between those limits. Bias towards more, rather than fewer, brackets, and a heuristic soft limit a bit below the pain threshold.
 
Forgive my ignorance, but what does this mean in real terms, both for the U.S. and for the rest of the world?
It means even though the US is hurting the rest of the world is even worse so the US dollar will remain the reserve currency for the foreseeable future.
 
"In 1985, the top five percent of the households, wealthiest five percent, had net worth of $8 trillion, which is a lot. Today, after serial bubble after serial bubble, the top five percent have net worth of $40 trillion," he explained.
That's only a rate of return of 6.4% or so. And the wealthy have money to invest, whereas the further down the economic ladder you get more of your net worth is in personal property, which doesn't generate a return at all.

It's hardly a surprising statistic, especially since it's not adjusted for constant dollars.
 
No, that wouldn't be miniscule. In any event I don't think anything should be in concrete.
Personal income tax revenue in 2010 was near 1 Trillion, upper 5% paid about 28% of it, $280 billion.

Assume their effective rate was for discussion sake 25%; at 100% rate that would be $1.12 Trillion paid (plus the other taxpayers $720 billion, total $1.840 trillion), perabus ceterus. How long do you think it'll take to figure tax haven dodges that shield more and more of their income from any US taxation? My guess; a few days to weeks.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom