USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Standard & Poor's said on Fox News that they needed to say a bi-partisan plan to reduce the national debt by around $4 trillion over ten years. This could be done solely through spending-cuts or with increased revenue. But the key was the plan had to be bi-partisan so that a change in the control of the Senate or the House wouldn't threaten the plan.

However, it appears that the GOP & the Tea-Party failed to head the warnings of their friends at Fox News and insisted on resisting compromise with Obama and the Democrats.

So now we have lost our cherished & prized AAA credit-rating. Thanks fellows.

The problem with the GOP is that it is not really a party at the moment, it is bitterly divided. They can't even agree among themselves what they want.
 
Bush's and Obama's spending. An expensive war. Commitments. We took on commitments we couldn't pay for now they won't raise taxes to pay for their malfeasance. If you have a time machine and you could go back and stop the wars then yeah. We could do that.

They ordered the Lobster and steak, this bill has come due and they don't want to pay so they want to take the money from the poor.
Some time ago I gave a scenario in which I would support raising taxes. It involved eliminating the budget deficit without additional revenue and dedicating all the additional revenue from the tax increase to reducing the national debt. This would fall in line with your comments about paying for "malfeasance." You do not address, however, the budget deficit as it is now. Time machines won't fix what we spend now.

And don't spew that "take the money from the poor" crap. What you really mean is "give less money to the poor." There's a difference. And it's a huge one.
 
As per the Simpsons...
 

Attachments

  • democraticconventionsimpsons.jpg
    democraticconventionsimpsons.jpg
    70.9 KB · Views: 8
  • republicanconventionsimpsons.jpg
    republicanconventionsimpsons.jpg
    67.5 KB · Views: 9
Some time ago I gave a scenario in which I would support raising taxes. It involved eliminating the budget deficit without additional revenue and dedicating all the additional revenue from the tax increase to reducing the national debt. This would fall in line with your comments about paying for "malfeasance." You do not address, however, the budget deficit as it is now. Time machines won't fix what we spend now.
I'm not against cutting spending. But I AM for raising taxes for the deficit that is now.

And don't spew that "take the money from the poor" crap. What you really mean is "give less money to the poor." There's a difference. And it's a huge one.
I could not give damn about the idiotic rhetoric. Reduce the money for the poor. BFD. In the end it's less money that they get and they sure as hell didn't get rich under Bush or Obama.
 
They invented this crisis. They engineered this from the git-go with months of forethought. This problem is 100% caused by and made to the order of the GOP. Stupid *****************.

Ben, you are absolutely correct. Now we have to wait and see what happens on Monday morning....around 9:30am Eastern.
 
Some time ago I gave a scenario in which I would support raising taxes. It involved eliminating the budget deficit without additional revenue and dedicating all the additional revenue from the tax increase to reducing the national debt.
BTW, I don't gove a damn about what you would be willing to do. Taxes are too damn low.

taxesi.jpg


If Regan can raise taxes so can Obama.
 
Last edited:
Seems to be a pretty damn clear signal that perhaps we should consider raising taxes. Or we could just keep going the same route, hoping that anti-tax ideology will trump reality :rolleyes:
 
I'm not against cutting spending. But I AM for raising taxes for the deficit that is now.
If the deficit could be eliminated by cutting spending, why should we raise taxes?

I could not give damn about the idiotic rhetoric.
Coulda fooled me, since you spouted it.

Reduce the money for the poor. BFD. In the end it's less money that they get
You say that like earning money and having money taken from someone else and given to you are equivalent.
 
BTW, I don't gove a damn about what you would be willing to do. Taxes are too damn low.

[qimg]http://img191.imageshack.us/img191/2460/taxesi.jpg[/qimg]

Your graph proves nothing. It can be just as easily said that tax rates have historically been too high.
 
Taxes have been at near record lows for 10 years and the economy has not responded much. Reagan raised taxes to boost the economy, why wouldn't the Republican not offer anything to solve the problem in the way of tax increases?

Because taxes are EEEEVILLLLL!!!11!1

And, of course, because tax cuts for the rich fix every problem, all the time. Right?
 
Last edited:
If the deficit could be eliminated by cutting spending, why should we raise taxes?
It could only be eliminated with too much sacrifice to the economy and people who have paid into the system.

You say that like earning money and having money taken from someone else and given to you are equivalent.
I really don't give a ****. Go bitch to someone else.
 
Yes, let's just borrow more money. Again. And again. And again. There's always going to be a next time until someone takes a stand. And it had to happen sooner or later.

First of all, the time to "take a stand" on spending is when you're determining how much you're going to spend, during the budget negotiations -- not when it's time to pay the bills for spending you've already done. The Republicans could have cut the deficit during the last budget negotiations, but insisted only on continuing the Bush tax cuts instead. Second, the Republicans didn't seem to complain about raising the debt ceiling under Bush even though Bush had a surplus and then cut taxes while waging two wars and implementing an expensive health care program. Third, if the Republicans are really concerned about the deficit as they claim to be, they should have put tax increases on the table and negotiated a real deal that would have cut the deficit $4 trillion as Obama wanted.

So excuse me for not taking this whole "somebody needs to take a stand" talk seriously.

Why do you think the government takes in too little revenue?

Because taxes are lower than they've been in decades, and because of the recession. We probably shouldn't actually be cutting spending at all until the economy recovers. We should be investing in things that increase demand for products and create jobs, which will help the economy, which will increase revenue. But if the Republicans are going to insist on lowering the deficit now (even though it may further harm the economy to do so right now), then most economists agree -- including Republican economists -- that spending cuts and increased taxes have to be part of the equation.

Why do you believe this country cannot perform its constitutional obligations with less than $2.16 trillion (the amount collected in 2010)?

Because both parties agreed under Bush and Obama to budgets that spent more on wars, tax breaks, and health care than we gained in revenues. And because we're in a recession right now.

Again, the time to discuss lowering spending or increasing income is when you're deciding to buy that big screen TV on credit, not when the credit card bill comes due.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
Your graph proves nothing. It can be just as easily said that tax rates have historically been too high.

You're right. There is too much government spending. So how much are you willing to cut military spending? I mean, since the military is clearly the most socialist program there is in the U.S. government.
 
I find it a little fascinating to watch a company like S&P make political squeeky noises like this. Too bad they were not so in the news back in 2008.

Our S&P rating is AA+, a notch down from AAA and not as low as AA. Not all companies have followed S&P's lead.

The Tea Party block did pretty much what they said they would do if elected. The problem is in the voters, congress is just the symptom. :|
 
Yes, let's just borrow more money. Again. And again. And again. There's always going to be a next time until someone takes a stand. And it had to happen sooner or later.

Err current projections make it pretty clear that there is going to be a next time. Should we then assume that no one has taken a stand yet?

Why do you think the government takes in too little revenue

Because despite the fact the economy is currently in growth (admitedly limited) it can't meet the costs of the spending that the people's elected representatives have voted for.

Why do you believe this country cannot perform its constitutional obligations with less than $2.16 trillion (the amount collected in 2010)?

Strange as it may seem those countries which do a reasonable job of managing or rebuilding their public finances rarely do so by getting into debates about centuries old documents. Sometimes you do have to listen to the accountants.

There are a number of reasons to raise taxes as well as cutting spending when trying to reduce a deficit is a good idea.

1)It works. In fact this is a well enough recognised fact that a combination of the two is now the standard method recomended by the likes of the IMF and world bank.
2)It gives you more tools for paying down the deficit
3)It effectively locks politians into a victory death position. If you cut spending and raise taxes you can't bribe the public into voting for you so your only option if you wish to be relected is to do a decent job on the public finances.
4)More shock proof. If you only do one or the other you are going to be in trouble the first time you face an unexpected bill or a new tax loophole is found.
5)While it may be unfashionable concept it includes a greater degree of fairness. Spending cuts tend to hit the poor harder and effective tax rises tend to hit the rich harder.
 
If the deficit could be eliminated by cutting spending, why should we raise taxes?

It would let you cut it faster which means that you end up spending less money on interest payments.
 
Apparently S&P thinks that the Bush Tax cuts will be extended again:

S.&P.’s Rationale for Downgrading the U.S.

S.&P. also expects the Bush administration’s tax cuts, passed in 2001 and 2003,to remain in place past their expiration next year because of Republican opposition to their lapsing.

Others see this as a likely scenario too:
Next for U.S. Debt Deal: Democrats Capitulate on Bush Tax Cuts, Again

But here is what's going to happen: In a now agonizingly familiar pattern, Obama will appease Republicans for the greater good. Republicans will sense his weakness and they will push for as much as they can get, knowing that the president will blink, just as they did when they risked the full faith and credit of the U.S. And Obama will laud it as a victory for bipartisanship, for coming together and getting something done.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom