USA has lost its AAA credit-rating from S&P's

Perhaps you missed the part where they said the deal didn't go far enough to address the deficit?


It takes two to tango to the brink without turning. Blaming this on the one of three factions that most wanted to solve the problem is quite astounding.

One faction (the GOP) manufactured this crisis. Prior to this year, the debt ceiling was always raised. 89 times. 7 times under Bush. Really, this was 100% avoidable by simply raising the debt ceiling months ago.

I know it sucks that your "side" ********** up. But they did. Big time. They caused the political instability because they think it's a good tactic. "Holding hostages for ransom", and McConnell said just this week.

It is completely irresponsible stupidity and it brought this. There's no way to spin this.
 
“We have changed our assumption on this because the majority of Republicans in Congress continue to resist any measure that would raise revenues, a position we believe Congress reinforced by passing the act.”

So says S&P.
 
He agreed to a deal without new taxes, that was irresponsible, and I lay it at his feet.

The alternative was worse, because the GOP have create a mythology about raising taxes that is so powerful it cannot be broken.

This goes back to the Reagan and Bush Governments. Cutting taxes when they could have been paying off debt. In the case of Bush, cutting taxes when he started a trillion dollar war. He should have raised taxes to pay for it.

Spending during Reagan's two terms (FY 1981-88) averaged 22.4% GDP, well above the 20.6% GDP average from 1971 to 2009. In addition, the public debt rose from 26.1% GDP in 1980 to 41.0% GDP by 1988. In dollar terms, the public debt rose from $712 billion in 1980 to $2,052 billion in 1988, a roughly three-fold increase. [7]

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reaganomics
 
Perhaps you missed the part where they said the deal didn't go far enough to address the deficit?

And how does that change what everyone's been saying? First of all, S&P didn't even mention lowering our credit rating until there was talk of not raising the debt ceiling. Had the GOP been willing to cleanly raise the debt ceiling as it's been done countless times before, there would have been no question about it.

Because of GOP hostage taking, S&P threatened to lower our credit rating unless there was a total of $4 trillion in combined cuts and increased revenue over the next 10 years. There would have been a deal that met S&P's requirements if the GOP has been willing to compromise even slightly. Even Grover Norquist said that ending the Bush tax cuts wouldn't violate his pledge to never raise taxes, but Republicans (almost all of whom signed the pledge) still wouldn't give an inch on revenue!

It takes two to tango to the brink without turning. Blaming this on the one of three factions that most wanted to solve the problem is quite astounding.

Usually I would agree with you, except in this case the Democrats bent over backwards to compromise but the GOP didn't budge. There's plenty of blame on both sides for the debt being as high as it is, but it's not even close as to which side was more to blame for the credit downgrade or which side is willing to compromise in order to balance the budget. Republicans say they want to balance the budget, but they're willing to do so only with deep spending cuts that will harm the poor and elderly when nearly every economist (including Republican ones) say that it's going to require both spending cuts and tax increases.

-Bri
 
Last edited:
I can't lay all the blame on the Elephants. Back during the lame duck session when the Asses controlled both houses, Obama should have insisted on the debt ceiling rise in exchange for retaining the Bush tax cuts. He didn't, saying that he trusted Boner not to screw around with the debt ceiling. How foolish! How naive! Obama was playing AA ball down in Podunkville while the Elephants were up in the big leagues. He threw them a great big fat one right down the middle of the plate and they hit it out of the park. They would have been dumb not to.
 
Last edited:
Standard & Poor's said on Fox News that they needed to say a bi-partisan plan to reduce the national debt by around $4 trillion over ten years. This could be done solely through spending-cuts or with increased revenue. But the key was the plan had to be bi-partisan so that a change in the control of the Senate or the House wouldn't threaten the plan.

However, it appears that the GOP & the Tea-Party failed to head the warnings of their friends at Fox News and insisted on resisting compromise with Obama and the Democrats.

So now we have lost our cherished & prized AAA credit-rating. Thanks fellows.
 
And how does that change what everyone's been saying? First of all, S&P didn't even mention lowering our credit rating until there was talk of not raising the debt ceiling. Had the GOP been willing to cleanly raise the debt ceiling as it's been done countless times before, there would have been no question about it.
Yes, let's just borrow more money. Again. And again. And again. There's always going to be a next time until someone takes a stand. And it had to happen sooner or later.

Because of GOP hostage taking,
Take your Democratic talking points paper somewhere else.

S&P threatened to lower our credit rating unless there was a total of $4 trillion in combined cuts and increased revenue over the next 10 years. There would have been a deal that met S&P's requirements if the GOP has been willing to compromise even slightly. Even Grover Norquist said that ending the Bush tax cuts wouldn't violate his pledge to never raise taxes, but Republicans (almost all of whom signed the pledge) still wouldn't give an inch on revenue!
Why do you think the government takes in too little revenue?

Why do you believe this country cannot perform its constitutional obligations with less than $2.16 trillion (the amount collected in 2010)?
 
I can't lay all the blame on the Elephants. Back during the lame duck session when the Asses controlled both houses, Obama should have insisted on the debt ceiling rise in exchange for retaining the Bush tax cuts. He didn't, saying that he trusted Boner not to screw around with the debt ceiling. How foolish! How naive! Obama was playing AA ball down in Podunkville while the Elephants were up in the big leagues. He threw them a great big fat one right down the middle of the plate and they hit it out of the park. They would have been dumb not to.

While there's some truth to what you say, it's not an entirely fair assessment. The Republicans were holding unemployment and Planned Parenthood hostage at the time. The problem is that it's very difficult to negotiate with someone who's willing to blow up the house with everybody in it if they don't get their way.

-Bri
 
Why do you believe this country cannot perform its constitutional obligations with less than $2.16 trillion (the amount collected in 2010)?
Bush's and Obama's spending. An expensive war. Commitments. We took on commitments we couldn't pay for now they won't raise taxes to pay for their malfeasance. If you have a time machine and you could go back and stop the wars then yeah. We could do that.

They ordered the Lobster and steak, this bill has come due and they don't want to pay so they want to take the money from the poor.
 
I can't lay all the blame on the Elephants. Back during the lame duck session when the Asses controlled both houses, Obama should have insisted on the debt ceiling rise in exchange for retaining the Bush tax cuts. He didn't, saying that he trusted Boner not to screw around with the debt ceiling. How foolish! How naive! Obama was playing AA ball down in Podunkville while the Elephants were up in the big leagues. He threw them a great big fat one right down the middle of the plate and they hit it out of the park. They would have been dumb not to.

This is true. The republicans' brinksmanship and refusal to consider even modest tax hikes is mostly responsible, but the democrats are responsible for allowing the hostage situation to even happen in the first place.
 
He's the one who wants to keep spending trillions more a years than the government takes in.

How could it not be his fault?

The republicans are the ones who want to keep taking in trillions less a year than the government spends.

How could it not be their fault?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom