• Security incident: ISF was recently accessed by intruders. Please change your password, and change it anywhere else you used it. Read more
The 'Havana Syndrome' Fiasco

I will get back to the conclusion of the Anderson-Entous podcast tomorrow.
In the meantime, I can recommend Robert Bartholomew's new article:

KEY POINTS
* A new government report has concluded that 'Havana Syndrome' was not caused by a secret weapon, but an array of health conditions and anxiety.
* While 'Havana Syndrome' appears destined to fade from the headlines, confirmation bias is likely to perpetuate its persistence.
* History is replete with examples where scientists have advocated for a particular position, only to have their claims discredited.
(...)
The intelligence community found that ‘Havana Syndrome’ was the result of a variety of existing health conditions, environmental factors, and anxiety—all of which were lumped into a new catch-all category. A contributing factor was the laundry list of common symptoms that were associated with it: headaches, nausea, dizziness, difficulty concentrating, memory problems, fatigue, tinnitus, insomnia; even nose bleeds. The most serious claims of brain damage and hearing loss were never proven. While the full intelligence report has not been released, officials familiar with it note that “environmental factors” included health conditions induced by such devices as malfunctioning air conditioning and ventilation systems.
What We Can Learn From the 'Havana Syndrome' Fiasco (Psychology Today, Mar 20, 2023)
 
Anderson & Entous, continued: Of People Killed by Skepticism

AE: You know, for me, I don't know the cause of this. But when you talk to the people that we spoke to who had been affected, you realize that they were, you know, type A personalities. These people were at the peak of their careers. They were really, in some cases, very experienced or had been deployed to very dangerous places. These were not pushovers. These were really, really serious people.

And they were completely destroyed. I mean, physically destroyed. And they have no incentive to make up a story. Telling a story to their bosses, basically destroyed their careers.
They were basically shipped off - you know I think it's episode two where you hear Tony tell the story of how he, you know, was so frustrated with his deterioration. Having gone from basically being Jason Bourne in real life to being hobbled.
He was gonna kill himself, you know.

And that is a story that I've heard from so many of these people. So we are talking about here, like the prime, like the best of the best suddenly being, you know, really debilitated. And they saw their careers crash and burn over this. So really, my heart goes out to these people. Who, you know, have suffered a tremendous amount, right? And that skepticism, you know, it kills them. It really does. It kills them.
And I feel so bad for them. Because they don't really have futures anymore.


Anderson and Entous make the same mistake as the JAMA studies: They confuse psychogenesis with having an incentive. As if people who suffer from mass psychogenic illness are faking it in order to achieve some kind of benefits. But they aren't faking their symptoms. They misunderstand their symptoms as caused by something that doesn't actually cause them: in this case an imaginary sonic attack due to the specific trigger in this specific case: the misinterpretation of the sound of crickets. In another context, the trigger could have been a smell, What Happened to the Girls in Le Roy (NYT, Mar 7, 2012). Remember that a smell also triggered an outbreak of MPI at the U.S. embassy in Havana 30 years ago (see post 1,695).

So A&E make two mistakes about mass psychogenic illness (MPI):
They think that MPI is either 1) caused by a particular susceptiblity, a weakness: They must be "a bunch of nervous nellies". Or 2) the victims are faking it, i.e. they must have an "incentive to make up a story".

And since the 'Havana Syndrome' victims are so very experienced, prime, type A personalities, and really, really serious people, they can't possibly have come down with a bad case of MPI because that only happens to nervous nellies and pushovers.
The same argument against MPI as the cause of 'Havana Syndrome' appeared in this thread only seven minutes after I had posted the OP, and it has popped up a couple of times since then.

As for skepticism killing 'Havana Syndrome' sufferers, it's another one of those drama queen tricks used by Anderson & Entous. Nobody has died, be it from the 'syndrome' or from skepticism about it. So far, the 'Havana Syndrome' has only made people sick, which is bad enough. Skepticism is not what made them sick. What made them sick in the first place was the interpretation of cricket sounds as signs of an ongoing attack.
One of the things that contribute to making these people stay sick is bad journalism.
Bad journalism helps ruin these people's lives. It really does!

To be continued ...
 
Anderson & Entous, continued: So Why Did the Alleged Attacks Stop?

AE: In my understanding, there ... haven't been cases being reported anywhere around the world since approximately February-March of last year, which is - maybe it's a coincidence or not - that's when Russia invades Ukraine. And roughly since then, there haven't been any reported cases. And I met recently with a senior official, who very much follows this and points to that correlation between when the invasion of Ukraine happens and when suddenly Havana Syndrome cases stop being reported.
And that person sees a connection, whether there is a connection I don't know.
(...)
But we really still don't know ... the US government hasn't figured out what happened.


We do know. The U.S. government has figured out what happened. All the headlines told us so:
'Havana syndrome not caused by foreign adversary, US intelligence says
'Havana syndrome' not linked to foreign adversary, says US intelligence
US Finds No Evidence to Link Adversaries to 'Havana syndrome'
'Havana syndrome' not caused by foreign adversary, U.S. intelligence finds
There is even this article by Adam Entous, who must have changed his mind since March 1, 2023:
Foreign Adversarries 'Very Unlikely' to Blame for Havana Syndrome, Intelligence Review Finds

As for the "coincidence or not": The CIA interim report was released on Jan 20, 2022. One week earlier, on Jan 13, there were still media reports about 'syndrome' cases, this time in Paris and Geneva, and Russia was still the suspected adversarial perpetrator:
Four more US diplomats working in Geneva and Paris have fallen ill with a suspected neurological illness known as "Havana syndrome", US media report.
Three diplomats became sick in the Swiss city and one in the French capital last summer, with some 200 people affected over five years.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken said the American government was working to get to the bottom of the mystery.
There are fears an adversary may have targeted diplomats with microwaves.
Mr Blinken said the issue had been raised with Russia but no determination had been made.
'Havana syndrome': US baffled after new cases in Europe (BBC, Jan 13, 2022)


After the CIA interim report telling intelligence officials, diplomats and other U.S. government workers all around the world that there was no reason to fear that "an adversary may have targeted diplomats with microwaves," the alleged attacks stopped. Not even David Relman's minority report in early February and CBS 60 Minutes later that same month pushing the attack narrative were able to revive the 'syndrome' - except in the community of Targeted Individuals. The fears of U.S. government employees seemed to have been assuaged.
Coincidence? Very unlikely!

It is absurd to use Russia's invasion of the Ukraine as an argument for the hypothesis that the 'syndrome' was caused by a Russian microwave attack. Another very outspoken fan of the Russian-microwave-attack idea (see post 1,820):
Mr. Polymeropoulos calls “directed-energy technology” the perfect covert weapon because it can remove the most capable officers from the battlefield, create fear and distract. It also leaves no fingerprints like a pistol would so it’s “nonattributable.” With a home-field advantage, it wouldn’t be hard to unleash it on unsuspecting Americans.


Why the **** would the Russians stop using a weapon that "can remove the most capable officers from the battlefield, create fear and distract" just when it would be needed the most to remove capable Ukrainian officers from the battlefield? Why abstain from using it when "it wouldn’t be hard to unleash it on [the] unsuspecting" Zelensky?!
The idea is absurd, no matter how many senior officials have managed to persuade Anderson and Entous that it is sound! (Pun not intended, but now that it's there, I really, really like it! :))

The end - for now.
But it just occurred to be that I should probably comment on the weird alliance that has been formed between the Russian media and the Targeted Individuals. Also interesting in this context: For some reason, the TIs seem to be very fond of James Giordano!
 
Last edited:
David Relman's NAS panel, microwaves & the Frey effect

The title is a little misleading. Faye Flam knows that the 'Havana syndrome' is not a mystery. She knows what causes it. And she knows what doesn't:

The microwaves emitted in ovens are absorbed by water, which is present in food, and turned into heat. That causes food to get hot, from the outside in, which Rofer points out should be obvious to anyone who has tried to defrost meat. Similarly, a microwave weapon would burn the outside of your head long before it would cook cells on the inside.
Another point against the microwave weapon theory is a large body of research conducted over decades on the safety of exposure to military radar equipment, power lines, mobile phones and WiFi.
Bioengineering professor Ken Foster of the University of Pennsylvania started conducting such studies for the Navy in the 1970s. When I interviewed him for this 2018 column, he told me he found that microwaves can stimulate the cochlea and cause people to hear a clicking sound — something called the Frey effect. He tested this on himself.
The Frey effect was the prime suspect, according to a panel assembled by the National Academy of Sciences, but Foster says this panel was mostly medical doctors and didn’t include physicists with the right expertise. He says this effect would not be able to cause internal damage without also causing external damage.
Havana Syndrome Is a Mystery, But Not of Physics (Bloomberg, Mar 2, 2023)
 
Replicating 'Havana Syndrome' in Ferret Brains

After PETA, another society for the protection of animals has joined the protest against the DoD's experiments with ferret brains:
Stop Replicating "Havana Syndrome" in Animals' Brains (National Anti-Vivisection Society (NAVS))

But the NAVS has misunderstood what this experiment is actually about.
There is no doubt that the DoD has granted money for the torture of ferrets in the name of (alleged) science, but "Replicating "Havana Syndrome" in Animals' Brains" requires that the animals are 1) exposed to the sound of crickets, and 2) persuaded to believe that it is the sound of an attack that will damage their brains.

1) is easily accomplished by using either actual crickets or recordings of cricket sounds.
However, the animal psychologists I've spoken to all assure me that
2) is impossible. It just can't be done.
 
Last edited:
But it just occurred to be that I should probably comment on the weird alliance that has been formed between the Russian media and the Targeted Individuals. Also interesting in this context: For some reason, the TIs seem to be very fond of James Giordano!


In post 1,752, I mentioned that Targeted Individual Len Ber was on RT / Whistleblowers with John Kiriakou. Also here: Havana Syndrome (Sovren.media, Mar 3, 2023)

The community of Targeted Individual thinks that the mainstream media is biassed against them, so it it not surprising that Len Ber, a former citizen of Russia, uses Russian media to get his message out. For a transcript of parts of the video see post 1,752 above.

But what makes Russia interested in this? I have noticed a far-from-subtle change in Russian media's reporting about the 'syndrome' over the years. I may have missed something because Google tends to hide articles from RT and Sputnik (and also from Chinese Xinhua) unless you specifically search for those. RT was happy to report when researchers revealed the sound of the attack to be recordings of crickets (as was I). Also here. And at one point, an RT studio host actually wore a tinfoil hat when reporting on the 'Havana syndrome'! I posted about this in the thread, but my link from that post is dead now. And back then, Russian media also called the idea of microwave weapons 'science fiction'. (Cuba still does!)

But at one point, when both Blinken and Burns, more or less openly, had started accusing Russia of being the perpetrator of the alleged 'syndrome' attacks, Russian media went on the offensive and countered with their own accusations: The 'syndrome' was real and US intelligence agencies were the perpetrator. And nowadays Russian media loves the TIs, who believe that the CIA and/or similar agencies are V2K'ing them.
RT used to refer to the crickets to ridicule the USA, but now they accuse the USA of dismissing the allegedly very plausible 'syndrome' "as the product of crickets", nnd Len Ber is invited into the studio to talk about how he is being attacked almost permanently on U.S. soil.

In 2016, American diplomats began complaining of a variety of medical symptoms that included things from physical pain to ringing in the ears to cognitive difficulties. These symptoms were largely ignored at first. And then the term Havana Syndrome was coined. Dr. Leonid ‘Len’ Ber joins John Kiriakou to discuss his own case of Havana Syndrome and why the FBI is blaming crickets.
https://sovren.media/video/havana-syndrome-2565.html (Whistleblowers/RT, Mar 2, 2023)


With the ODNI report, the US government has declared that there never was any attack by a foreign adversary, whereas Russia has embraced the idea of 'Havana Syndrome' and supports the TI community. I assume that this is Russia's way to sow confusion and distrust in the U.S. government. I can't imagine that it will help Russia in any way. After all, the TI community is small and very fringe, and I don't think that this will change. Or maybe it is meant for a Russian audience as a kind of 'This is what the USA is like'.

I have seen no sign that Cuba intends to follow suit. In all the Cuban articles about the 'syndrome' I've seen, Cuba has remained devoted to science and facts and hasn't embraced or even aired these conspiracy theories. And this is not the only point where Russia and Cuba go their separate ways.
 
Last edited:
The U.S. Department of State has agreed to settle an engineer's suit alleging he was denied promotions and positions overseas after suffering a brain injury brought on by the so-called Havana Syndrome
State Dept. Strikes Deal To End 'Havana Syndrome' Bias Suit (Law360, Mar 22, 2023)


The suing engineer is probably Mark Lenzi, who claimed to have been attacked in Guangzhou (see posts 1702 and 1,655). Post 1,655 has links to five earlier posts.
 
Patients are tormented by creeping, crawling sensations in their skin, but docs say there is no evidence of bugs or parasites
(...)
Are there any other characteristics of Morgellons besides the itching symptoms and skin lesions?
Patients often become extremely invested in studying their condition. I've had people who send me photographs tell me that they have invested thousands of dollars in very sophisticated microscopes to track these so-called organisms living in their skin. (According to the MRF, the condition also causes, "joint pain, debilitating fatigue, changes in cognition, memory loss, mood disturbance, and serious neurological manifestations.")
What is Morgellons Disease? Is it a physical or psychological condition? (Scientific American, May 13, 2009)


So sensations that something physical is going on, i.e. 'their symptoms are real', but no evidence whatsoever of a causative agent.
The symptoms are very similar to 'Havana syndrome'. Electromagnetic hypsersensibility would be a serious neurological manifestation, wouldn't it?!
 
For some reason, the TIs seem to be very fond of James Giordano!


As I have mentioned before:
On the one hand, the community of targeted individuals aren't happy with the way the U.S. government has handled the 'Havana syndrome'. They think that their own problems are being neglected because the government agencies have been focussed on diplomats, spies, military personnel and other government staff, and they want the same recognition as being the victims of targeted attacks by (some kind of) adversary/-ies. It's the MeToo! movement of people who believe that they are the victims of electronic harassment (Wikipedia) and envy 'official' victims like Marc Polymeropoulos (MP):
Replying to @MicrowaveNews, @ODNIgov and @MpolymerBut is he buying that civilians are also attacked? The amount of looking down upon civilian cases is almost as big as a Chinese balloon. Marc, this is not a dig. I understand your situation more than you imagine. But the longer you hide your head in the sand, the sillier it gets. #HavanaSyndrome is not some kind of exclusive club for people of government importance. Be the reasonable man you aspire to portray.
Len Ber MD (on Twitter, Mar 20, 2023)
It refers to the recent WSJ article based almost exclusively on claims made by Marc Polymeropoulos (see posts 1,820 and 1,823).

There is no doubt that Len Ber understands MP's situation. Probably not more than MP can imagine, but as much as MP fears and hates. MP isn't happy with this attempt by Len Ber to embrace him because it threatens to ruin his claim to be suffering from a "combat injury" (see post 1,659) that he got when he was allegedly attacked by Russians with microwave weapons. Where "Mr. Polymeropoulos sees the release of this [ODNI] report as an effort by Washington to sweep the whole thing under the rug," the whole thing being "the war between U.S. and Cuban intelligence," and doesn't see anybody who was not a combatant in this war as entitled to recognition and support, Len Ber sees him as a fellow sufferer of electronic harassment who doesn't want to share.

But on the other hand, the recognition of 'Havana syndrome' as an attack was the very thing that gave the TIs hope that they might somehow achieve the same recognition as victims of an attack, which is why he appeals to the reasonable man MP allegedly aspires to portray. A lot of good that will do him since neither MP nor the U.S. government will ever recognize the claims of the TI community the same way that 'Havana syndrome' was at one point fully recognized as having been caused by a sonic or microwave (or whatever) attack:
The government resorts to labeling plaintiffs claims as absurd, fantastical, and conspiratorial in the historic lawsuit filed by Targeted Justice and 18 plaintiffs (Positively NOT a legal opinion)
Condescension - Defendant’s Strategy Revealed (Len Ber on Substack, Mar 23, 2023)


The irony is that the TI claims aren't the least bit more absurd, fantastical, and conspiratorial than the 'Havana syndrome' claims. There never was the least bit of evidence for any of them. And as for what appeared to be medical evidence of radio frequency attacks, Dr. Michael Hoffer appears to have diagnosed several cases in people who were never anywhere near a combat zone, a real one or the imaginary one in Havana.

As for the two recent podcast series, Entous & Anderson's on ViCE and Nicky Woolf's on Project Brazen, judged by Len Ber's poll, members of the TI community seem to favor Nicky Woolf's. I don't really see why they favor any one of them over the other since both series carefully avoided mentioning other targeted individuals than the ones who were officially recognized as having been targeted by foreign adversaries in AHI attacks. (I am not 100% sure that the TI community was never mentioned, but I'll spare myself from having to listen to the two series again. I don't remember TIs being mentioned, and mentioning them would ruin the story that both podcast series were trying to tell: that innocent diplomats and spies were targeted in a real attack by real enemies with real RF weapons.)

If I have to venture a guess, I think that Nicky Woolf's podcast series appeals more to the TIs because Beatrice Golomb figures so prominently in it.

And then there's James Giordano. Why is Len Ber so fond of Giordano?

I am not sure that he has actually read what Giordano writes. If he has, I don't think he fully understands what he read. I criticized James Giordano's article in detail in post 1,795. I think that Len Ber may have been taken in by James Giordano's appeal to compassion and pity for the victims. But 1) Giordano's appeal to compassion is nothing but an attempt to cancel all criticism of his own attack narrative, and 2) he would never dream of appealing to compassion for the ordinary, noncombatant TIs. Like all the other warmongers, Giordano sees them as jeopardizing his claim to being one of the researchers who have allegedly discovered an entirely new syndrome. (Is the Nobel Prize Committee watching?!)

Unlike Michael Hoffer (apparently), James Giordano won't let just anybody into the fold. For his claim to stand a chance, which I don't think it will for much longer, he knows that he will have to insist on the exceptionalism, the uniqueness, of the cases that he deemed worthy of being recognized as having been caused by microwave attacks.
Giordano may accept cases like Polymeropoulos's, but cases like Len Ber's ruin the picture he is trying to paint.
 
Last edited:
Poison gas attack or mass psychogenic illness? Microwave attack or MPI?

On March 9, in post 1,774, I mentioned the case of Iranian schoolgirls that appeared to have been victims of a gas attack, but in many ways it looked more like mass psychogenic illness.
Rob Palmer, 'The Well-Known Skeptic', has a conversation with Robert Bartholomew about this recent Iranian MPI case and the 'Havana Syndrome':

Iranian Schoolgirl Gas Attacks and Havana Syndrome: A Conversation with Robert Bartholomew (Skeptical Inquirer, The Well-Known Skeptic, Mar 15, 2023)

In November 2022, reports first surfaced about a poison gas attack at a school in Iran affecting over 200 students. This was just the beginning. Reports of poison gas attacks happening all across the country quickly followed. As of this writing, the count of victims stands at over 7,000. The victims: mostly girls and women students at over 100 schools in nearly as many cities.
Speculation regarding a villain has ranged from the Iranian government seeking revenge for the ongoing mass protests regarding compulsory wearing of the hijab to this being a false flag operation performed by enemies of the Iranian government who are seeking to make the authorities look evil. But is there another explanation—perhaps one where there are actually no evildoers poisoning helpless children and civilians for political ends?
Indeed, an expert in mass psychogenic illness, Dr. Robert Bartholomew, believes that is the case here. He believes there have been no such poison gas attacks against schoolgirls in Iran, just as he has for years maintained that no American (or Canadian) diplomats were mysteriously attacked in Cuba or elsewhere despite nearly six years’ worth of claims about Havana Syndrome made by the U.S. government.
I have been fascinated by Bartholomew’s skeptical take on Havana Syndrome since 2017 when the story of the “Sonic Attacks in Cuba” first hit the media, and I’ve written about this subject on three occasions for Skeptical Inquirer. I Interviewed Bartholomew for two articles and also wrote a review of his seminal 2020 book Havana Syndrome: Mass Psychogenic Illness and the Real Story behind the Embassy Mystery and Hysteria.
For those unfamiliar with this topic, let me provide an overview: Beginning in 2017, the U.S. government claimed there were ongoing attacks against its embassy personnel in Cuba by unknown forces using unknown weapons. In subsequent years, the scope of these claimed attacks broadened to include intelligence agents, other government officials, and even family members stationed in a long list of countries.
Iranian Schoolgirl Gas Attacks and Havana Syndrome: A Conversation with Robert Bartholomew (Center for Inquiry on YouTube, Mar 15, 2023 - 34:42 min.)



ETA: The European Parliament seems to believe that the girls in Iran have actually been exposed to real poison attacks. I can believe that the Iranian government may have tried to "silence women and girls", but the poison story still sounds more like a case of MPI, which I assume is the reason why no "transparent and definitive report on the chemical attacks" has been issued and no "alleged perpetrators" have appeared in court.
This lack of perpetrators and 'smoking guns', i.e. traces of chemicals, sounds familiar, doesn't it?!

The European parliament has adopted a resolution calling on the UN Human Rights Council to conduct an independent probe into a wave of chemical attacks on Iranian schoolgirls.
The motion, which passed by 516 votes in favor, five against and 14 abstentions on Thursday, vehemently condemned “this atrocious attempt to silence women and girls in Iran,” and expressed “its deep solidarity with the Iranian students poisoned in the incidents and with their families.”
(...)
The Iranian government, police and judiciary have not issued a transparent and definitive report on the chemical attacks, vaguely claiming that dozens of arrests were made, without any sign of court action against alleged perpetrators.
European Parliament Demands Investigation Over Chemical Attacks On Iranian Schoolgirls (Iranintl.com, Mar 16, 2023)
 
Last edited:
The syndrome sufferers DID know about each other and each other's experiences

Short video presenting most of the theories that have been proposed as explanations for the 'syndrome', ending with mass psychogenic illness:

Finally, some researchers have debated the possibility that this could actually be a modern example of a mass psychogenic illness, a shared but otherwise unexplained psychological reaction, perhaps to the stressful working conditions that some Americans might have felt.
Although again, there isn't wide support for this conclusion. For one, many of the syndrome sufferers were reportedly unknown to each other or at least unaware of their colleagues' comparable experiences. It is not as if any one person was influencing the behavior of anyone else.
But another reason why some doubt the psychogenic explanation is because it's thought that any of the symptoms just wouldn't have been triggered by something like that, including the almost universal characteristic: ringing in the ears.
Havana Syndrome: Conspiracy Theory or Genuine Threat? | Unveiled (Daily Motion, Mar 23, 2023 - 8:15 min.)


The lies are being repeated again and again as they have been since the beginning. This is how "one person was influencing the behavior of" everybody working at the U.S. embassy in Havana on New Year's Eve, 2017:
And he records it and he actually brings the recording, this is around Christmas time, New Year's. He actually goes to a New Year's party at the embassy. And he brings the recording and plays it for some of his colleagues to see if that is also what they heard, right?!
The ‘Havana Syndrome’ with Jon Lee Anderson and Adam Entous (Why Is This Happening? The Chris Hayes Podcast, Apple Podcasts, Feb 21, 2023 - 54:21 min.)

After that, the State Department and the media took over and spread the lie to U.S. government staff all over the world.
As for the "almost universal characteristic:ringing in the ears," it was only almost universal in Havana, Cuba, where it was due to either crickets, in the majority of cases, or ordinary tinnitus in the rest.

It would be nice if the lies could be stamped out, which may allow Cuba to return to pre-'syndrome' conditions and get back the tourists that the country lost due to the exacerbated blockade and the pandemic:

Cubans dance to their carnival rhythms in Havana (Daily Motion - 1:06 min.)
Cuba cabaret stars don't fade, even in their 70s (Daily Motion - 1:59 min.)
Cuban Neighbourhood Restaurant (Daily Motion - 1:52 min.)
Cuba before Corona (Daily Motion - 2:08 min.)
Rooftop Salsa, Cuba (Daily Motion - 2:43 min.)
Buena Vista Social Club Documentary movie (Daily Motion - 1:33 min.)
Buena Vista Social Club - Buena Vista Social Club At Carnegie Hall (Full Album) (Daily Motion - 1:28:15 min.)
Afro Cuban All Stars - A Toda Cuba Le Gusta (Full Album (Daily Motion - 55:49 min.)
A Tuba to Cuba (Daily Motion - 1:23:59 min.)
Cubans Dancing Salsa, Rumba & Reggaeton in London (Dancers from "Rakatan" (Daily Motion - 2:25 min.)
 
Yes, it is MPI. And no, it's not a mystery.

I mentioned and linked to this article by neurologist Robert Baloh when it first appeared on The Conversation on Sep 30, 2021. It was updated on March 7, 2023, i.e. after the ODNI report, and it is as relevant now as it was then: Havana syndrome fits the pattern of psychosomatic illness – but that doesn’t mean symptoms aren’t real.

Other websites have noticed its relevance after the release of the ODNI report and republished it from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license, sometimes with a new title. The most recent example is: Is the mysterious 'Havana Syndrome' really a psychosomatic illness? (Unexplained Mysteries, Mar 24, 2023).

It you didn't read it then (and even if you did), you should use the opportunity to catch up.
 
Anderson & Entous, revisited: So Why Did the Alleged Attacks Stop?

In post 1,823, I quoted Adam Entous saying:
In my understanding, there ... haven't been cases being reported anywhere around the world since approximately February-March of last year, which is - maybe it's a coincidence or not - that's when Russia invades Ukraine. And roughly since then, there haven't been any reported cases. And I met recently with a senior official, who very much follows this and points to that correlation between when the invasion of Ukraine happens and when suddenly Havana Syndrome cases stop being reported.
And that person sees a connection, whether there is a connection I don't know.


In the same post, I pointed out that there was a much more likely reason why the reports of new cases of the 'Havana Syndrome' stopped after January 2022: the release of the CIA interim report on Jan 20, 2022:
As for the "coincidence or not": The CIA interim report was released on Jan 20, 2022. One week earlier, on Jan 13, there were still media reports about 'syndrome' cases, this time in Paris and Geneva, and Russia was still the suspected adversarial perpetrator:
Four more US diplomats working in Geneva and Paris have fallen ill with a suspected neurological illness known as "Havana syndrome", US media report.
Three diplomats became sick in the Swiss city and one in the French capital last summer, with some 200 people affected over five years.
Secretary of State Antony Blinken said the American government was working to get to the bottom of the mystery.
There are fears an adversary may have targeted diplomats with microwaves.
Mr Blinken said the issue had been raised with Russia but no determination had been made.
'Havana syndrome': US baffled after new cases in Europe (BBC, Jan 13, 2022)

After the CIA interim report telling intelligence officials, diplomats and other U.S. government workers all around the world that there was no reason to fear that "an adversary may have targeted diplomats with microwaves," the alleged attacks stopped. Not even David Relman's minority report in early February and CBS 60 Minutes later that same month pushing the attack narrative were able to revive the 'syndrome' - except in the community of Targeted Individuals. The fears of U.S. government employees seemed to have been assuaged.
Coincidence? Very unlikely!

It is absurd to use Russia's invasion of the Ukraine as an argument for the hypothesis that the 'syndrome' was caused by a Russian microwave attack.


But Adam Entous, Jon Lee Anderson and the anonymous "senior official" are not alone:
True, reports of Havana Syndrome have sharply dropped off since the start of the war in Ukraine. That gives the intelligence community breathing room to put this issue to bed.
For the time being. Given space, the Russians will advance.
US intelligence community has proven it can't investigate Havana Syndrome, it should let UK and Australia try (Washington Examiner, Mar 1, 2023)


It may comfort Anderson and Entous that there may be a career opportunity for them at the Washington Examiner (Media Bias/Fact Check).
 
Last edited:
I had my brain scanned in 2019 and didn't ask to see the results. I wouldn't have known what to look for anyway. I was quite content when the neurologist told me that nothing was abnormal.

OCD can't be diagnosed only with brain scanning.
 
More disinformation from new member Random person.

Brain scanning is actually useful when diagnosing OCD: What does an OCD brain look like? (Yale School of Medicine, Oct 10, 2014)

OCD is an interesting phenomenon, but in the context of the 'Havana Syndrome' it seems to be of limited relevance. I have only seen it mentioned here:
If a Frey-like effect can be induced on central nervous system tissue responsible for space and motion information processing, it likely would induce similarly idiosyncratic responses. More general neuropsychiatric effects from electromagnetic stimuli are well-known and are being used increasingly to treat psychiatric and neurologic disorders. In 2008, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approved transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) to treat major depression in adults who do not respond to antidepressant medications (Cook, 2018). Ten years later, the FDA approved office-based TMS as a treatment for obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) (FDA, 2018) and portable TMS to treat migraine (Jeffrey, 2013).
An Assessment of Illness in U.S. Government Employees and Their Families at Overseas Embassies (2020), Chapter 4, Plausible Mechanisms (The National Academies Press)
And I haven't seen anybody suggesting that foreign adversaries were using portable TMS to treat migraine in diplomats and spies in Havana or anywhere else.

In other contexts, for instance in cases of "harassment and/or stalking", the possibility of OCD should be factored in:
Unsurprisingly, some persons with OCD engage in harassment and/or stalking. Meloy has argued that there is the convergence of five psychosocial factors in stalking: social incompetence, isolation and loneliness, obsessional thinking, pathological narcissism and aggression.
Obsessive compulsive disorder and obsessive compulsive personality disorder and the criminal law (National Library of Medicine, May 5, 2020)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom