UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

Oh I know dementia symptom onset can be very rapid but ever since Saunders I have to say I am very suspicious when this comes up in regards to wealthy, connected individuals.

I wonder is he in a secure hospital? I would have thought if he was still physically capable of movement and the like he's obviously still a real danger to young people, probably even more so now when he doesn't have his "higher faculties" to prevent his assaults where and when he can't cover them.

A danger? Has he been tried and found guilty then?
 
I have to say I am rather cynical of the claim he is unfit to stand trial.
It's ironic that he would deny that right to others. From the article:
Curiously, it echoes Janner’s comments in 1997 about a man spared a trial for Nazi war crimes because of his age. “I am sorry that he was not tried while he was fit enough to stand,” he said. “There was absolutely no reason why he should have escaped charges forever.”
Of course, it's always possible for the victims to initiate a civil suit for damages. You can't talk your way out of that because of health problems.
 
And you only have to note the reaction to Clarkson's recent assault case to see that nothing has really changed, large numbers of people are still willing to be complicit in excusing serious offences by the rich, famous and connected.

A good point, and nice lateral thinking. I'd never thought of making this connection before. But there is indeed something strange about the fact that, based on what I can glean from comment sections and the like, the kind of people who think that someone like Janner should be put on trial regardless of the legal feasibility of that (the same kind of people who more or less thought Jimmy Saville's corpse should have been dug up and put on trial), seem to show a considerable overlap with the kind of people who think that Jeremy Clarkson should be allowed to physically assault a coworker without being fired, because he is, well, JEREMY CLARKSON! The notion that the law should be blind never seems to apply to people who are considered "one of us" (however mistakenly).
 
I see what you did there but there was no cover up in the Clarkson case and at least one of the people you have in mind repeatedly deprecated the failure to prosecute him.
Which "establishment" figure deprecated the failure to prosecute him? And of course there was no successful cover-up else we wouldn't have it as an example of how people will excuse the criminal behaviour of the rich, famous and connected!
 
Which "establishment" figure deprecated the failure to prosecute him? And of course there was no successful cover-up else we wouldn't have it as an example of how people will excuse the criminal behaviour of the rich, famous and connected!

Your post, the one I replied to, did not refer to 'establishment figures', just 'people'. I don't understand the point you are making.
 
Your post, the one I replied to, did not refer to 'establishment figures', just 'people'. I don't understand the point you are making.
I think you assumed I was commenting on your opinion? I wasn't I was talking about the wider reactions reported, such as those like Cameron's.
 
Why would we need a trial to determine the he is a danger to the public?

Why would you think he would be a danger based on what we know?
Has it been established that he is a danger to anyone or even guilty of anything?
 
I have to say I am rather cynical of the claim he is unfit to stand trial.

I'm no naïve idealist, but in order for this to be 'fixed' the CPS would have to be leaned on (illegally). It seems clear that the police have been 'influenced' in the past about what and who to investigate but I think the CPS is a very different proposition and rather less corruptible - if for no other reason that their decision making has to be transparent.
 
I rthought we'd established that in this day and age an accusation is enough, and even stands when the actual evidence turns up wanting.
I think it would be desirable to have an investigation, following an accusation, to find out if there is in fact any evidence. Then we will know if it's "wanting" or not.
 
I think it would be desirable to have an investigation, following an accusation, to find out if there is in fact any evidence. Then we will know if it's "wanting" or not.

The funny thing is that accusations about Savile's activities at various NHS hospital have been subject to a degree of investigation, and many of them hold water like a sieve.
 
I thought this piece from the as usual sensible Joshua Rozenberg might be of interest: Critics of Lord Janner decision misunderstand justice system .

Some quotes:

I have no independent confirmation of the doctors’ reports. All I can say is that the last time I saw Janner in public – which must have two or three years ago – he could no longer remember anybody else’s name. A colleague who saw him at around the same time says he was “away with the fairies”. It would be good to see the doctors’ reports. But, whatever we are told, the conspiracy theorists will never be satisfied.
What the DPP does not spell out in her statement – because it should hardly need saying – is that the primary purpose of a criminal trial is not to “deliver justice” to alleged victims. It is not to “find out what happened”.

That’s the role of a public inquiry. The purpose of a criminal trial is to test the evidence against a named defendant. If the defendant is dead, abroad or suffering from dementia, there can be no trial.
Like the DPP, I want to know why the allegations against Janner were not put to him while he was still fit to stand trial. I hope the inquiry commissioned by Saunders – as well as the government’s public inquiry – will eventually tell us.
 
A danger? Has he been tried and found guilty then?

The primary purpose of a trial is to determine whether the state is justified in using force against a human being. Naturally we prefer this process to be relatively strict, and that the state have to clear a relatively high bar in order to justify using force against its citizens. However, we do not need to depend on the outcome of a formal trial to reach our own conclusions about guilt or innocence, danger or not.
 
To find out whether the accusations are actually true or not. A radical idea in the day and age, I know....

That's not what a trial tells us.

What a trial tells us is whether the state is able to meet a certain standard in justifying the use of force against the accused, as if the accusations were true. We're fortunate in that there's a lot of overlap in our justice system between finding the truth and justifying the state's use of force, so a trial outcome is usually a good benchmark of whether an accusation is true. But that doesn't mean we have to depend on trial outcomes to reach our own conclusions from the available evidence.
 
That's not what a trial tells us.

What a trial tells us is whether the state is able to meet a certain standard in justifying the use of force against the accused, as if the accusations were true. We're fortunate in that there's a lot of overlap in our justice system between finding the truth and justifying the state's use of force, so a trial outcome is usually a good benchmark of whether an accusation is true. But that doesn't mean we have to depend on trial outcomes to reach our own conclusions from the available evidence.

Well, given that the "available evidence" seems to be the usual uncorroborated hearsay and bollocks....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom