UK establishment child abuse cover-up inquiry

Like Savile and a number of others in recent history you mean?

A lot of the later claims about Savile and his escepades in various hospitals are uncorroborated hearsay and some have been shown to be bollocks.
 
A lot of the later claims about Savile and his escepades in various hospitals are uncorroborated hearsay and some have been shown to be bollocks.
Have none been shown to be sound? Is that not what investigations are about - to discover if any accusations are well-founded?
 
You clearly haven't actually read any of the reports by individual hospitals into accusations about Savile. East Grinstead is a hoot - you should start there.

Are you suggesting that he wasn't a sexual predator who took advantage of his position? I'm sure there were a few people who jumped on the bandwagon, but the information that is in the public domain offers very strong circumstantial evidence that he was indeed a nasty piece of work, given the lack of a trial.
 
Have none been shown to be sound? Is that not what investigations are about - to discover if any accusations are well-founded?
Many of the final conclusions fall into the following categories:

a) We can find no evidence that Savile was here, so if the "assault" actually happened, it wasn't him.
b) We know Savile was here, but what we know of the visit/s suggests the "assault" couldn't have happened as described/at all.

You have to bear in mind that some of the accusations have been along the lines of someone saying they saw or were told about something happening to a third party (e.g. patient or employee), but when the latter was identified and contacted, they denied anything happened.

In many cases where patient records had retained, they conflicted with the patient's claimed recollections of when and how often they were in hospital. Recollections sometimes also conflicted with staff as to procedures and facilities at the hospital (e.g. alleging an assault while a child in a building not completed until they were an adult).
 
Last edited:
I'm no naïve idealist, but in order for this to be 'fixed' the CPS would have to be leaned on (illegally). It seems clear that the police have been 'influenced' in the past about what and who to investigate but I think the CPS is a very different proposition and rather less corruptible - if for no other reason that their decision making has to be transparent.
Or have a sympathetic consultant deem you are unfit. In this case there does seem to be hearsay that he has dementia so I doubt there is anything dodgy going on.
 
Are you suggesting that he wasn't a sexual predator who took advantage of his position? I'm sure there were a few people who jumped on the bandwagon, but the information that is in the public domain offers very strong circumstantial evidence that he was indeed a nasty piece of work, given the lack of a trial.

I think he was an dirty old man in an era of dirty old men. The information in the form of the hospital reports is very much in the public domain, and most can be accessed via this BBC link - you should try reading some of them, but here a few examples:

Queen Victoria Hospital, East Grinstead:

"No evidence was found that suggests that Savile had ever visited the hospital site at any time during his lifetime. At the time of the alleged incident he was employed in the North of England, although it is acknowledged that he undertook wrestling and cycling events that would have occurred around the country.

"The assailant present at the time of the assault [1954] was wearing a theatre gown, cap and mask and would have required clinical knowledge or training to be given the sole care of the victim at the time of the assault. There is no evidence that could be found that showed Savile had received this level of training."

De La Pole Hospital, Kingston upon Hull:

"The investigation team found no association with JS and De La Pole Hospital, beyond the visit already referred to or indeed with any hospitals within the HEY; this was despite a comprehensive search of local media and hospital archives.

"There is no evidence that any assault took place during JS’s visit. The only witness was ’third party’ and did not actually see JS assault a patient, the information was given to her from another nurse who could not be identified and was alleged to have heard this directly from the patient [Ms. A].

"Ms. A vehemently denies being assaulted by JS during his visit to the orthopaedic unit."

Portsmouth Hospital:

"The lack of any evidence that corroborates the account of the complainant and the disparities in the accounts given to the Police and myself leads me to believe that it is highly unlikely that the alleged incident took place. There is no documentary evidence that shows that this alleged incident was either reported to the hospital at the time, or investigated."

South London & Maudsley:

"The conclusion is that Savile’s contacts with our hospitals were fleeting, and there is no evidence of any allegations, reports or rumours of wrongdoing, inappropriate or criminal behaviour."

Saxondale Hospital, Nottingham:

"In summary, as a teenager and local resident, she had attended a disco hosted by JS at Saxondale Hospital in or around 1971/72. During the course of this disco, JS had raised her skirt by “a few inches” with a “hockey stick”....

By her own admission Ms X had no expectation that the matter would be the subject of further investigation, describing the incident which she reported to Operation Yewtree as being “insignificant”. She noted she had brought this matter to the attention of the police to “add” another piece to the jigsaw. She confirmed that she had experienced no lasting psychological trauma from this incident."
 
Last edited:
Hey, that's my hometown!

Funnily enough, I copped off with a girl from Nottingham while on a school skiing trip to Bulgaria. This culminated in her sneaking into my hotel room on nigth, and trying to remove my jeans. She was very eager, but I bottled it. The "interesting" dynamic was that while I was 16½, it was the day before her 14th birthday. At the time the AoC in Bulgaria was 14, so it would have been locally legal if we'd waited a day.
 
And you only have to note the reaction to Clarkson's recent assault case to see that nothing has really changed, large numbers of people are still willing to be complicit in excusing serious offences by the rich, famous and connected.

I suspect the English devotion to it's royalty extends downward to elected officials and the famous.
 
Or have a sympathetic consultant deem you are unfit. In this case there does seem to be hearsay that he has dementia so I doubt there is anything dodgy going on.

I think I read that two consultants from each side (four in all) examined Janner and they all concluded he was unfit to stand trial. I am a great believer in Establishment cover ups (that they happen, not that I support them :D) but, disappointingly, this does not seem to be one of them.
 
BBC News: What's the truth about the VIP 'paedophile ring'?

"Sensational claims of child abuse and murder were described by police as "credible and true" - but have the accused and genuine victims alike been let down by a rush to judgement?

This is the story: That some of the most powerful men in the land - a former prime minister, a future home secretary, the heads of the army, MI5 and MI6 - got together with other prominent, depraved men in rooms around London and in army bases, to torture, abuse and murder boys. They did it without fear of getting caught, and they kicked over the traces so that their secrets stayed hidden for 30 years.

As an allegation it's unprecedented, and so was the response from the police. They set up a murder inquiry called Operation Midland based only on the testimony of the person who'd come forward with the story, a man known as "Nick". Quickly, police described the claim, and Nick himself, as "credible and true".

For nearly a year, Panorama has been looking into the allegation that a murderous gang of VIP paedophiles operated in Britain in the 1970s and 80s.

What has emerged is a story which, arguably, says as much about how some of this country's most important institutions are behaving now as it does about child abuse more than 30 years ago."
 
Last edited:
WHAT is truth? said jesting Pilate,and would not stay for an answer. Francis Bacon (1561-1626)


http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/07/w...=WhatsNext&contentID=WhatsNext&pgtype=article

“It looks as though we’re now in a climate where the police are so concerned by their past failures to investigate these sorts of crimes adequately that they’re now overdoing it in the opposite direction,” Ken Macdonald, a former director of prosecutions, told the BBC. “There may be a danger that the police are now spending an undue amount of time investigating cases that have all the hallmarks of being fantasy.”
 
Police complaining that the new Panorama episode will hamper their investigations.
 
That struck me as a bit odd when I read it, but in the UK the phrase for what you're referring to is the slightly different "kicking against the traces."

Well, it wouldn't surprise me to learn that "kicking over the traces" was predominantly used in America, though I couldn't point to a particular quote that led me to believe that. I don't think I've ever heard anyone use "kicking against the traces", though, and I have associated with various horsey people in the UK from time to time. I can't find any examples of the phrase by googling, only explanations of the original phrase, in one case quoted from the OED.
 
Police complaining that the new Panorama episode will hamper their investigations.

There seems to be something of a disconnect between what Knacker would have us believe, and what Panorama reported.

The Met: "Seeing an individual make allegations and then be targeted by the media is not going to encourage others to speak out."

BBC News: "A man - who Panorama referred to as "David" - told the programme he had felt pressured by others to provide police with VIP names, including that of ex-Home Secretary Leon Brittan."

It seems the Met are more bothered about the BBC reporting the actions of said "others" rather than investigating said "others" for perverting the course of justice. That they regard allowing a alleged victim to tell their sorry unfuilted by either the "other" or the police as being "targeted by the media" demonstrates their own terror at being exposed for the bunch of guillible fools they are.

For "others" read the conspiracy-obsessed clowns Exaro News.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom