Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
The credibility of forumite's expertise has to be earned. No one is obligated to believe I'm a nurse practitioner with 4 decades of experience. I assume some people on the forum know from my posts that I am and do have that expertise. No doubt others simply don't believe it. That's their prerogative.

I believe you because you speak medical.
 
It's a bit dated but it's computer speak for what you see is what you get. In other words, I'll look at the validity of posts and citations, but anything claimed to be known from personal knowledge, not so much.

The credibility of forumite's expertise has to be earned. No one is obligated to believe I'm a nurse practitioner with 4 decades of experience. I assume some people on the forum know from my posts that I am and do have that expertise. No doubt others simply don't believe it. That's their prerogative.

There are lots of people here with all kinds of expertise that I respect. Even some I disagree with on their political positions, I respect their knowledge in other areas. But it's common knowledge that people on forums make false claims about their occupations and expertise. So you take things they assert from personal knowledge with a grain or more of salt.
I certainly respect your medical experience Ginger. I don't post a lot but I do read a lot, and I've read thousands of your posts.
 
Serious health problem? They wouldn't cover you if you'd ever had dandruff.

That's not true.

They would cover you until you had a costly illness and only then use it as a reason for denying coverage as a preexisting condition.


Maybe not literally dandruff, but certainly acne, and breast cancer
 
Last edited:
I believe her because Skeptic is part of her name. Though, I have to consider that Ginger is also in her name, so she likely doesn't have a soul. Them's the rules.

I believe you're a lawyer because you never preface your posts with IANAL. ;)
 
GOP senators suddenly turn pessimistic on repeal odds


Senators wrapped up their week on recess with an unexpected bout of pessimism over the prospects of passing a health care bill. Here's a quick sampling of comments we've seen in the past 24 hours:

Sen. Richard Burr (R-NC): "It's unlikely that we will get a health care deal, which means that most of my time has been spent trying to figure out solutions to Iowa losing all of its insurers ... I don’t see a comprehensive health care plan this year."

Sen. Jeff Flake (R-AZ): “There are some still saying that we’ll vote before the August break. I have a hard time believing that."

Sen. Ron Johnson (R-WI): Suggesting a short-term bill to stabilize the marketplace followed by a more long-term repeal effort, "To me, this may be a two-part process. I would admit that’s probably a minority view in the Republican Senate right now."

I take the Republican senators' comments here at face value. Writing a health care bill and passing it while keeping a small majority in the Senate united is a very difficult task. It may not work. It gets harder by the day to pass a bill this year, as we're nearly halfway through 2017. The party can only afford to lose two Republican senators and be able to pass a bill. Keeping conservatives and moderates on board with the same bill is hard work!


I've been calling all three of Jeff Flake's offices (DC, Phoenix, Tucson) all the time. Maybe I've made a little impact.
 
Even aside from the current republican antics, ACA is already imploding. Many of the larger regional carriers are exiting the market. There are areas of my state that will have no carriers selling individual policies at all.

The shenanigans going on in congress right now are really frustrating. I'd actually like to see someone address the issues and come up with a real plan.
 
Even aside from the current republican antics, ACA is already imploding. Many of the larger regional carriers are exiting the market. There are areas of my state that will have no carriers selling individual policies at all.

The shenanigans going on in congress right now are really frustrating. I'd actually like to see someone address the issues and come up with a real plan.

Republican human trash care don't give a **** about people having affordable healthcare.
 
You wanna know the secret? Neither do the saintly Democrats... to wit: the ACA.

Tens of millions of people gained healthcare under the ACA. Would gave been even more if not for Republican scum in red states refusing Medicaid expansion. Republican human trash are trying to take that away so that rich people can get tax cuts.
 
Last edited:
The fact there are some markets insurers are withdrawing from could have easily been fixed and the Democrats have been asking for bipartisan 'repair' of the ACA since it was rolled out.

But the GOP, having used the repeal and replace talking point for 7 years, only care about keeping a promise they cannot possibly keep. They painted themselves into a corner and instead of taking a bipartisan path to get out, they just keep painting that corner smaller and smaller.
 
The problem the Republican trash have with healthcare is that they are trying to figure out a way to make a bill that conforms to their extremist ideology while at the same time not being wildly unpopular. But it is literally impossible for them to pass a bill that will be more popular than the ACA and still conform to their extremist ideology. Most people don't want to cut taxes for the rich at the expense of taking healthcare away from tens of millions of people.
 
Last edited:
The fact there are some markets insurers are withdrawing from could have easily been fixed and the Democrats have been asking for bipartisan 'repair' of the ACA since it was rolled out.

But the GOP, having used the repeal and replace talking point for 7 years, only care about keeping a promise they cannot possibly keep. They painted themselves into a corner and instead of taking a bipartisan path to get out, they just keep painting that corner smaller and smaller.

The GOP has been running on fear and lies for so long that they have forgotten how to govern. Their voter base still believes that Obamacare set up death panels, that it pays for abortions, that it taxes middle class Americans to provide free health care for illegal immigrants and the unemployed. And that voter base is still getting most of its news from right wing sources that keep repeating these falsehoods.

The result is that we can't have a civil discussion about the ACA based on facts because we spend all of our *********** time debunking the lies and legends.

A civil discussion would look for solutions to the subsidy cliff that results in insurance premiums for those approaching Medicare age being unaffordable if when family income is just over 400% of FPL. It would look into fixing the definition of affordable used by employers so it included insurance for the family.

We could work on price gouging by drug companies that drives up costs for everyone. Investigate why scans that cost hundreds of dollars in other countries cost thousands in the US. Work on a common interchange standard for electronic records that makes them available to any medical provider treating a patient. And countless other issues that adversely affect the quality and cost of medical care in our nation.
 
Deep exploration has revealed the subsidies were not legal. So, now go with standard plan:
The usual Republican tactic:
1 withdraw funding for thing
2 wait a few months
3 declare that "thing" is no longer working
 
From the article linked by Tero:

On the campaign trail, Cassidy argues that Trump consistently promised a health care plan that would reduce premiums, eliminate mandates, ensure continuous coverage and protect people with pre-existing conditions. Any GOP plan, he says, needs to meet that bar.
Sounds reasonable to me. Also, though I'd have to spend some time learning the details, I think Sen. Cassidy's proposal to allow states to decide whether or not to keep Obamacare for themselves is a better idea than anything I expect to see passed by a GOP Congress.
 
From the article linked by Tero:

Sounds reasonable to me. Also, though I'd have to spend some time learning the details, I think Sen. Cassidy's proposal to allow states to decide whether or not to keep Obamacare for themselves is a better idea than anything I expect to see passed by a GOP Congress.
Sounds reasonable? States that want Obama care can keep it, fine. But what about this impossible claim?
reduce premiums, eliminate mandates, ensure continuous coverage and protect people with pre-existing conditions.
It's bullcrap, pure campaign promise fantasy.

If it were actually possible, they could have just introduced the legislation long before Obama's term was up. Why would Democrats turn down such a magical promise were it actually real?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom