Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, completely. If you show up at the ER wanting a routine pelvic exam, they will turn you away.



Jenny: Hi, I'd like a pelvic exam please.
ER Triage Desk: Are you in pain?
Jenny: No.
ER Triage Desk: Do you think something is wrong or endangers your life?
Jenny: Nope.
ER Triage Desk: So... you feel fine, you don't have an emergency, and you just want routine care?
Jenny: Yep, that's right!
ER Triage Desk: Well, ma'am, here's the number for a women's health center just around the corner from here. Why don't you call them and get an appointment.
Jenny: Oh, no, I couldn't do that, I don't have any money.
ER Triage Desk: I'm sorry ma'am, we can't help you. This is an Emergency Room.

Yet your own argument shows that SG is right. In an ER the examination process starts at the front desk. This is where the Triage Nurse determines your condition and how fast they need to move you on. How do they do this? Step one is asking questions, just as you showed. Since from the questions the Nurse can determine that there is no Emergency requirements she can then skip to providing the patient with the information she needs, in this case going to a Woman's Clinic (if she can find one that the Republicans haven't shut down.) So the process that SG described; Examine, stabilize if required, provide further information, is still in effect in your example.
 
Yet your own argument shows that SG is right. In an ER the examination process starts at the front desk. This is where the Triage Nurse determines your condition and how fast they need to move you on. How do they do this? Step one is asking questions, just as you showed. Since from the questions the Nurse can determine that there is no Emergency requirements she can then skip to providing the patient with the information she needs, in this case going to a Woman's Clinic (if she can find one that the Republicans haven't shut down.) So the process that SG described; Examine, stabilize if required, provide further information, is still in effect in your example.

There's no facility fee if the triage desk turns them away. It's not a professional examination. They are not being treated. SG's process doesn't apply.

Consider... Let's say you want to work for a high-profile stock broker. You walk in and talk to the receptionist at the front desk. He takes stock of your torn tshirt and ragged jeans and is pretty sure you're not a good candidate. But he dutifully asks you some basic screening questions about your education and work history. Based on your answers, she declines to give you an application and suggests you check out Walmart.

Does that experience count as you having interviewed at that brokerage firm?
 
What? No. How did you get to that from what I said? I even gave an example. Why are you extending it to something completely different?



If there is a reasonable possibility that the patient has symptoms that are indicative of an emergent condition, they will be evaluated. If they show up with a mild cough, it could potentially be indicative of pneumonia. If after evaluation, however, it is deemed to be a common cold... the ER isn't going to provide robitussin.

I gave an example of something that was clearly and unambiguously routine care, as opposed to something that could be argued to be potentially emergent. Don't conflate something that you, in your non-professional view, would call 'routine'... with what an ER triage desk might reasonable consider to be routine.

When people talk of getting routine care at the ER, I'm pretty sure they are speaking in a "non-professional" manner.
 
What do you mean?

What I mean is that when the claim is made that people use the ER for routine care, that claim is made in the sense of what a lay-person thinks is routine care. In that sense, it is, as you say, "non-professional", but it is true that people are using the ER for things which people with insurance would see a regular doctor for.
 
What I mean is that when the claim is made that people use the ER for routine care, that claim is made in the sense of what a lay-person thinks is routine care. In that sense, it is, as you say, "non-professional", but it is true that people are using the ER for things which people with insurance would see a regular doctor for.

I'm pretty sure you're squishing the interpretation of "routine" so it perfectly fits whatever it is you're trying to argue.

End of the day, people cannot receive comprehensive care at an ER. If their symptoms are not reasonably indiciative of a possible emergent or urgent condition, they can and will turn people away. ERs are not obligated to treat patients for all symptoms. They are required to stabilize emergent and urgent symptoms and nothing more.

An ER will not administer chemotherapy for someone with cancer. They will not perform routine non-emergent gynecological exams. They will not perform routine non-emergent proctology exams. They will not provide information, support, or medication for basic dermatological complaints. They will not perform non-emergency surgeries.

FFS, I went to the ER with a uterine hemorrhage, and they didn't even discuss the possibility of an emergency hysterectomy! They provided me with sufficient liquid to stabilize my blood pressure, diagnosed a fibroid as the cause, and sent me home with a recommendation to see my regular gynecologist for further treatment! They didn't even give me a blood transfusion, despite me having lost a substantial amount of blood and already having been severely anemic!
 
Last edited:
I'm pretty sure you're squishing the interpretation of "routine" so it perfectly fits whatever it is you're trying to argue.

End of the day, people cannot receive comprehensive care at an ER. If their symptoms are not reasonably indiciative of a possible emergent or urgent condition, they can and will turn people away. ERs are not obligated to treat patients for all symptoms. They are required to stabilize emergent and urgent symptoms and nothing more.

An ER will not administer chemotherapy for someone with cancer. They will not perform routine non-emergent gynecological exams. They will not perform routine non-emergent proctology exams. They will not provide information, support, or medication for basic dermatological complaints. They will not perform non-emergency surgeries.

FFS, I went to the ER with a uterine hemorrhage, and they didn't even discuss the possibility of an emergency hysterectomy! They provided me with sufficient liquid to stabilize my blood pressure, diagnosed a fibroid as the cause, and sent me home with a recommendation to see my regular gynecologist for further treatment! They didn't even give me a blood transfusion, despite me having lost a substantial amount of blood and already having been severely anemic!

Alternatively, I think you're trying to define 'routine' in far to narrow a fashion in order to support your claim.

The folks using the ER as their only source of medical care aren't getting proctology exams, or gynocological exams, or pretty much any sort of preventative exam/care at all. They are going to the ER when they are sick, or think they have a problem, rather than only going when there is an emergency. You may not call that routine care, but I'm pretty sure most other folks would.
 
I'm pretty sure you're squishing the interpretation of "routine" so it perfectly fits whatever it is you're trying to argue.

End of the day, people cannot receive comprehensive care at an ER. If their symptoms are not reasonably indiciative of a possible emergent or urgent condition, they can and will turn people away. ERs are not obligated to treat patients for all symptoms. They are required to stabilize emergent and urgent symptoms and nothing more.
.....

I think we get that. But many people without insurance go to an emergency room or take their kids there because that's the only access to medical care that's available to them. And there has to be some basic exam to determine whether a cough is from a cold or allergy or pneumonia or TB or industrial exposure, or whether a sore ankle is from a sprain or a break, etc., etc. I'm not sure what's being debated here. Obviously ERs don't treat everybody for everything, but a lot of what ERs see isn't really an emergency either, and would be treated in a doctor's office or a walk-in clinic if they were available.
 
Last edited:
Alternatively, I think you're trying to define 'routine' in far to narrow a fashion in order to support your claim.

The folks using the ER as their only source of medical care aren't getting proctology exams, or gynocological exams, or pretty much any sort of preventative exam/care at all. They are going to the ER when they are sick, or think they have a problem, rather than only going when there is an emergency. You may not call that routine care, but I'm pretty sure most other folks would.

I think we get that. But many people without insurance go to an emergency room or take their kids there because that's the only access to medical care that's available to them. And there has to be some basic exam to determine whether a cough is from a cold or allergy or pneumonia or TB or industrial exposure, or whether a sore ankle is from a sprain or a break, etc., etc. I'm not sure what's being debated here. Obviously ERs don't treat everybody for everything, but a lot of what ERs see isn't really an emergency either, and would be treated in a doctor's office or a walk-in clinic if they were available.

My argument stems from several pages back, where Skeptical Ginger claimed that ERs being obligated to stabilize emergent conditions was tantamount to health care being a right in the US:
If it wasn't a right, why is there a US law that forbids emergency departments from turning away people who cannot pay?

The response to this was to point out that we decided that leaving a person to die of an emergent condition is something we as a community don't want:
3. Because we've (society, lawmakers, etc) decided that you have a right not to die or be seriously harmed, not necessarily to all health care.

Skeptic Ginger then countered that it was the same thing, poor people use the ER as their regular doctor:
That still amounts to a right to health care since poor people use the ED as their regular doctor.

That's where my argument came in - No, poor people do NOT use the ER as their regular doctor. They use the ER in some subset of circumstances where a person with insurance or wealth would use a primary care doctor. That doesn't however, mean that the ER is functioning as a regular doctor for those people. There's a plethora of services that a regular doctor performs that an ER will NOT perform, regardless of ability to pay. It doesn't matter how much cash you have on hand, they're still not going to give you a routine pelvic exam if there's not a worry or concern, if there aren't symptoms that suggest an emergent or urgent condition. It doesn't matter whether you're wealthy or poor, an ER still won't administer chemo drugs to a person with cancer.

An ER does not perform the function of a regular doctor. The existence of laws obligating ERs to respond in emergent and urgent situations does not imply that general health care is a right in the US.
 
Our hospital has a pretty good solution in place for non-emergent care. The ER also has an Urgent Care center. There's a FP resident, NP or PA on duty at all times and the ER docs supervise. The Urgent Care also doesn't turn anyone away, regardless of ability to pay, which was a decision made by the hospital owners (who happen to mostly be doctors in the community).
 
Anyone catch John Oliver's segment on dialysis treatment on sunday night? It's the free segment of the week, and I have to say it surprised me quite a bit.


I suppose the profiteering part is what dialysis treatment has in common with the rest of the health care system.

Having said that, I'm genuinely surprised that dialysis treatment is paid for by the government.
 
Our hospital has a pretty good solution in place for non-emergent care. The ER also has an Urgent Care center. There's a FP resident, NP or PA on duty at all times and the ER docs supervise. The Urgent Care also doesn't turn anyone away, regardless of ability to pay, which was a decision made by the hospital owners (who happen to mostly be doctors in the community).

That sounds like an excellent solution to a continuing problem. The next step would be to create walk-in Urgent Care centers in neighborhoods where there is high need, to reduce unnecessary trips to the hospital entirely. They could accept insurance from people who have it, charge reasonable fees to people who can pay cash, and send bills to others (without any real expectation of getting paid).
 
House May Be Forced to Vote Again on GOP's Obamacare

Two weeks after passage, measure still not sent to Senate

CBO report could force Ryan, other party leaders into redo

House Republicans*barely managed to pass their Obamacare repeal bill earlier this month, and they now face the possibility of having to vote again on their controversial health measure.

House Speaker Paul Ryan hasn’t yet sent the bill to the Senate because there’s a chance that parts of it may need to be redone, depending on how the Congressional Budget Office estimates its effects.*House leaders want to make sure the bill conforms with Senate rules for reconciliation, a mechanism that allows Senate Republicans to pass the bill with a simple majority.

Republicans had rushed to vote on the health bill so the Senate could get a quick start on it, even before the CBO had finished analyzing a series of last-minute changes. The CBO is expected to release an updated estimate next week.
 
Last edited:
Does he realize he's going to own this disaster?

President Donald Trump has told advisers he wants to end payments of key Obamacare subsidies, a move that could send the health law's insurance markets into a tailspin, according to several sources familiar with the conversations.

Many advisers oppose the move because they worry it will backfire politically if people lose their insurance or see huge premium spikes and blame the White House, the sources said. Trump has said that the bold move could force Congressional Democrats to the table to negotiate an Obamacare replacement.

Lawyers and other administration officials are trying to thread the needle.

Trump told aides in a Tuesday Oval Office meeting that he wants to end the payments to insurers, according to people familiar with his comments. Trump has previously expressed conflicting opinions on the issue. Insurers have been pressing for certainty as they plan for next year.
 
I don't understand why he thinks Democrats would rush to the table and help him repeal Obamacare if he does that. How does scewing up the individual market give Democrats incentive to help Trump pass his healthcare tax cut bill?

He's hoping that Democrats actually care about people being denied healthcare by this move (unlike Trump), and will cave in to protect them. Of course it won't work, since Trumps goal is to kick millions of people off of their health insurance*, and so threatening to kick millions of people off their health insurance if Democrats don't help him kick millions of people off of health insurance isn't much of a negotiating ploy.



*Well, that's not his actual goal, per se. His goal is a massive tax cut for the rich, kicking millions of people off of their health insurance is just a side-effect.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why he thinks Democrats would rush to the table and help him repeal Obamacare if he does that. How does scewing up the individual market give Democrats incentive to help Trump pass his healthcare tax cut bill?

One of his goofball defenders, Jeffrey Lord, claimed that it was akin to Martin Luther King marching his Movement into dangerous parts of the South so that the world could see the violence and hate against black people:



Of course, the reason MLK and Co. were in danger is that ******** in the South were willing to beat them. If there weren't any violent, racist white people, King would be putting no one in danger.

In the analogy, Trump is the sheriff turning loose the dogs. He's creating the danger and violence by screwing up the healthcare markets.

Their brains work in ways that I cannot follow.
 
He's hoping that Democrats actually care about people being denied healthcare by this move (unlike Trump), and will cave in to protect them. Of course it won't work, since Trumps goal is to kick millions of people off of their health insurance*, and so threatening to kick millions of people off their health insurance if Democrats don't help him kick millions of people off of health insurance isn't much of a negotiating ploy.



*Well, that's not his actual goal, per se. His goal is a massive tax cut for the rich, kicking millions of people off of their health insurance is just a side-effect.

More people would lose insurance if Trumpcare passes than if Trump stops the subsidies. So if Trump actually did stop the subsidies, Democrats wouldn't have any incentive to cave and help him pass Trumpcare. Telling Trump to **** off would result in fewer people losing insurance.
 
More people would lose insurance if Trumpcare passes than if Trump stops the subsidies. So if Trump actually did stop the subsidies, Democrats wouldn't have any incentive to cave and help him pass Trumpcare. Telling Trump to **** off would result in fewer people losing insurance.

Hey, I didn't say it was a good plan...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom