Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
Providers probably disagree, though.

xjx388 has raised the main challenge: the US healthcare economy is proportionally larger than other countries while producing less outcome. It's a mix of inefficiency and higher margins. Fixing inefficiency means layoffs (mostly administrators, marketing, and lawyers). Lower margins means less cash for those who remain employed (the actual health service providers, such as doctors and nurses).

The end users will benefit, the taxpayers will benefit, but the current crop of service providers will probably lose half their dough. That's a big hit, and I understand why they are lobbying hard against it. The longer the gravy train lasts, the more invested they will be, the more wealth they can throw at Congress to kill anything that gives taxpayers and end users the value they want to keep for themselves.

The window of opportunity may have passed.

This was a problem even back in the days of the UK UHCs, the famous phrase from then is by Bevan: "stuffed their mouths with gold" - he was talking about what he had to do with the medical consultants to get the NHSs founded.

It could be that the USA will have to accept there will not be overall lower costs for the short term just that everyone has good healthcare from cradle to grave, I would have thought that would be a benefit well worth having.

But again that is only if a system like one of the UKs NHSs is decided on. There are many other models for achieving good healthcare for all (some with better outcomes than the UK) that still require all the paraphernalia of private business.
 
Last edited:
:confused: If you lump all the companies in any given industry together, they are essentially a monopoly on that industry.


ETA: the author of that article appears quite ignorant of the topic about which he/she is writing.

I suspect that oligopoly would be a better description
 
The problem is that the ER is not obligated to provide care for minor problems. They can and do turn people away for inability to pay.

Really, you sure about that? :rolleyes:

I think you are confusing a couple of things. The ED is not required to provide uncompensated follow-up care. They can also tell you what you need, such as a medication, but not dispense it.

But in order to determine if any patient has a true emergency, you have to examine the patient. If a hospital didn't do that they'd be open to lawsuits if the person had an inapparent emergency condition. I don't know of any ED that doesn't at least treat the initial problem including dispensing medications.
 
Last edited:
Really, you sure about that? :rolleyes:
Yes, completely. If you show up at the ER wanting a routine pelvic exam, they will turn you away.

I think you are confusing a couple of things. The ED is not required to provide uncompensated follow-up care. They can also tell you what you need, such as a medication, but not dispense it.

But in order to determine if any patient has a true emergency, you have to examine the patient. If a hospital didn't do that they'd be open to lawsuits if the person had an inapparent emergency condition. I don't know of any ED that doesn't at least treat the initial problem including dispensing medications.

Jenny: Hi, I'd like a pelvic exam please.
ER Triage Desk: Are you in pain?
Jenny: No.
ER Triage Desk: Do you think something is wrong or endangers your life?
Jenny: Nope.
ER Triage Desk: So... you feel fine, you don't have an emergency, and you just want routine care?
Jenny: Yep, that's right!
ER Triage Desk: Well, ma'am, here's the number for a women's health center just around the corner from here. Why don't you call them and get an appointment.
Jenny: Oh, no, I couldn't do that, I don't have any money.
ER Triage Desk: I'm sorry ma'am, we can't help you. This is an Emergency Room.
 
Last edited:
Yes, completely. If you show up at the ER wanting a routine pelvic exam, they will turn you away.



Jenny: Hi, I'd like a pelvic exam please.
ER Triage Desk: Are you in pain?
Jenny: No.
ER Triage Desk: Do you think something is wrong or endangers your life?
Jenny: Nope.
ER Triage Desk: So... you feel fine, you don't have an emergency, and you just want routine care?
Jenny: Yep, that's right!
ER Triage Desk: Well, ma'am, here's the number for a women's health center just around the corner from here. Why don't you call them and get an appointment.
Jenny: Oh, no, I couldn't do that, I don't have any money.
ER Triage Desk: I'm sorry ma'am, we can't help you. This is an Emergency Room.
Are you claiming that people do not go to the emergency room when they have a cough? Because I know people with no insurance who have done that. I would call that routine care, and something that people with insurance would see a family doctor for.
 
Seems like there might be some anger out there over this.

A Tennessee woman hated that her congressman voted for the controversial Republican health-care bill in the House of Representatives, authorities said.

So Wendi L. Wright tried to run Rep. David Kustoff (R-Tenn.) off the road after he visited the University of Tennessee at Martin, they said.

The Weakley County Sheriff’s Department said Wright tailed the car carrying Kustoff. At some point, the congressman and his aide became afraid and worried that Wright wanted to force them off the road.

They then turned into a driveway and stopped. That’s where Wright got out, screamed at the congressman and struck the windows of his vehicle, even reaching inside the car, the sheriff’s department said.

Authorities said Wright then stood in front of the vehicle to try to keep Kustoff from leaving. At some point, someone called 911, but Wright left before authorities arrived.

The incident happened on May 8, four days after House Republicans narrowly passed a bill to overhaul the country’s health-care system.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/news...-care-vote-police-say/?utm_term=.9e9525a2b4ab
 
Are you claiming that people do not go to the emergency room when they have a cough? Because I know people with no insurance who have done that. I would call that routine care, and something that people with insurance would see a family doctor for.
But they have to wait until the cough becomes an emergency to get treatment.
 
Last edited:
I am not sure I understand any of this as it relates to Health care. Where I live (Geelong, pop. 195,000), we as in everybody in Australia, have Universal Health Care, nationally funded by a tax levy, but all medical services can also be obtained through private cover from non-Government organisations.

So, Geelong, one publicly funded provider - Barwon Health, and three private self-funded Hospitals and every medical practitioner can charge what he/she wishes, and the public gets a % of that charge returned from public funds.

The private Hospitals seem to be doing just fine. St John of God recently built a six story addition, and added an ER. Likewise, none of the Private Health insurers seem to be going belly up either.

But, if I happen to get hit by a truck, I will be taken to hospital (in an ambulance - for me, free) and get public ward and free access to emergency care. If, as I recover, I want my own specialist, I can then choose to do so, and pay for the service.

Elective surgery is exactly that. If you want it, you pay for it, although at times "elective" means what the Government says it means. Hip replacements, cataracts are public, but low end of the scale, and are loosely defined under "elective". So if you want one quickly, you pay for it.

Norm
 
I am not sure I understand any of this as it relates to Health care. Where I live (Geelong, pop. 195,000), we as in everybody in Australia, have Universal Health Care, nationally funded by a tax levy
Communist!

So your government steals from hard-working rich people, and gives the ill-gotten gains to moochers who deliberately let themselves get sick? That might be acceptable to a people whose ancestors were all convicts, but not here!
 
I am not sure I understand any of this as it relates to Health care. Where I live (Geelong, pop. 195,000), we as in everybody in Australia, have Universal Health Care, nationally funded by a tax levy, but all medical services can also be obtained through private cover from non-Government organisations.

So, Geelong, one publicly funded provider - Barwon Health, and three private self-funded Hospitals and every medical practitioner can charge what he/she wishes, and the public gets a % of that charge returned from public funds.

The private Hospitals seem to be doing just fine. St John of God recently built a six story addition, and added an ER. Likewise, none of the Private Health insurers seem to be going belly up either.

But, if I happen to get hit by a truck, I will be taken to hospital (in an ambulance - for me, free) and get public ward and free access to emergency care. If, as I recover, I want my own specialist, I can then choose to do so, and pay for the service.

Elective surgery is exactly that. If you want it, you pay for it, although at times "elective" means what the Government says it means. Hip replacements, cataracts are public, but low end of the scale, and are loosely defined under "elective". So if you want one quickly, you pay for it.

Norm

Yes, but are you "free" to go without health coverage and then die/go bankrupt if you get sick?
 
These two things are not the same...

So Wendi L. Wright tried to run Rep. David Kustoff (R-Tenn.) off the road after he visited the University of Tennessee at Martin, they said.

The Weakley County Sheriff’s Department said Wright tailed the car carrying Kustoff. At some point, the congressman and his aide became afraid and worried that Wright wanted to force them off the road.

So did she actually try and force them off the road, or did they just think that she might try and force them off the road because of her aggressive driving?
 
Reporter attested.

The Trumpublicans had a lady arrested for laughing at an absurdity said at a Trumpublican press conference. They said she was disruptive. Now they arrest this reporter for asking a challenging questions, saying he was disruptive. Comey was fired for treating Hillary bad in an investigation, or being a showboat, but definitely not because Trump wants to stop investigations into Russia.

They tell lies that only the Trumpsters will believe, but that's good enough for them because Trumpublicans control all three branches of government.

The USA is a cleptocracy.
 
They tell lies that only the Trumpsters will believe, but that's good enough for them because Trumpublicans control all three branches of government.

I don't even think the Trumpsters actually "believe" these lies. More that they accept them because, you know, it puts those liberals in their place, and therefore it's acceptable.
 
I don't even think the Trumpsters actually "believe" these lies. More that they accept them because, you know, it puts those liberals in their place, and therefore it's acceptable.

Some of them do, for sure. After all, some say that they will support Trump even if it is proven that he colluded with Russia to become POTUS.
 
Are you claiming that people do not go to the emergency room when they have a cough?
What? No. How did you get to that from what I said? I even gave an example. Why are you extending it to something completely different?

Because I know people with no insurance who have done that. I would call that routine care, and something that people with insurance would see a family doctor for.

If there is a reasonable possibility that the patient has symptoms that are indicative of an emergent condition, they will be evaluated. If they show up with a mild cough, it could potentially be indicative of pneumonia. If after evaluation, however, it is deemed to be a common cold... the ER isn't going to provide robitussin.

I gave an example of something that was clearly and unambiguously routine care, as opposed to something that could be argued to be potentially emergent. Don't conflate something that you, in your non-professional view, would call 'routine'... with what an ER triage desk might reasonable consider to be routine.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom