Trump: "[health] insurance for everybody," Replacing the ACA

Status
Not open for further replies.
If people don't have a right to health care, why would this matter?

Why might something bad happening matter? Because it is something bad. Isn't this when people often say, "to promote the general welfare"? There are things part of promoting general welfare that are not rights.
 
Orin Hatch: You greedy, grubby peasants need to stop pestering your betters for money.

"The public wants every dime they can be given," he said. "Let's face it, once you get them on the dole, they'll take every dime they can. We've got to find some way of getting things under control or this country and your future is going to be gone."
 
Severely?

I don't think so.

Severely to a wealthy person is whether or not they can afford that second or third vacation home.

When they have to choose between buying food or buying the meds they need to stay alive ... then they can talk about 'severely'.

Until they reach that point they are just inconvenienced.

A 50% reduction in income is severe, regardless how it impacts you.


Bull ****.

If a 50% reduction in income only affects the amount and expense of luxury toys someone can buy, while leaving them more than amply funded for the needs of day to day survival, that is nothing but an inconvenience .

"Waahhh! I can't afford ALL of the ridiculously expensive toys I want ... right away."
​
When it affects someone's ability to buy enough food, or a minimum of healthcare, or to have to choose between those and a roof over their head, to the point that their very survival is at risk ... THAT is severe.

Yours is the kind of thinking which has enabled the redistribution of wealth from people who have to work daily for enough to merely get by at all, and put it in the pockets of a tiny fraction of the population who already have more wealth than they can use in any rational fashion.

Wealth inequality is a real threat to this society, and it is liable to become the core cause of its downfall.

In 1989 the top 10% of families in the U.S. owned about 30% 0f the nation's wealth. In 2013 that 10% owned over 75%.

Meanwhile, the bottom 50% own about 1% of the wealth.

All that time, worker productivity was skyrocketing, but none of that improvement was reflected in the incomes of the workers who were doing the producing.

The wealthy don't deserve anyone's concern for impacts on their wealth which don't affect anything but their ability to buy increasingly bigger yachts than the guy they winter next door to in Monte Carlo.

We would have plenty of wealth to improve the lives of most Americans if it wasn't being directed to the pockets of that minuscule percentage of the population. A percentage who would still be fabulously wealthy by any realistic standards of comparison even after a substantial cut to their incomes.

When they have to choose between paying the rent or eating every day, that's when they can consider themselves to be severely affected.
 
I would add to this that ERs are only required to stabilize the emergent conditions of the patient, not to treat them. If you come in with cancer, they will treat your immediate discomfort then refer you to an oncologist. They will NOT start you on chemotherapy. If you walk in and demand a physical, they WILL turn you away.

Or even give you the medicine to not die in the next couple days.
 
Bull ****.

If a 50% reduction in income only affects the amount and expense of luxury toys someone can buy, while leaving them more than amply funded for the needs of day to day survival, that is nothing but an inconvenience .

"Waahhh! I can't afford ALL of the ridiculously expensive toys I want ... right away."
​
When it affects someone's ability to buy enough food, or a minimum of healthcare, or to have to choose between those and a roof over their head, to the point that their very survival is at risk ... THAT is severe.

Yours is the kind of thinking which has enabled the redistribution of wealth from people who have to work daily for enough to merely get by at all, and put it in the pockets of a tiny fraction of the population who already have more wealth than they can use in any rational fashion.

Wealth inequality is a real threat to this society, and it is liable to become the core cause of its downfall.

In 1989 the top 10% of families in the U.S. owned about 30% 0f the nation's wealth. In 2013 that 10% owned over 75%.

Meanwhile, the bottom 50% own about 1% of the wealth.

All that time, worker productivity was skyrocketing, but none of that improvement was reflected in the incomes of the workers who were doing the producing.

The wealthy don't deserve anyone's concern for impacts on their wealth which don't affect anything but their ability to buy increasingly bigger yachts than the guy they winter next door to in Monte Carlo.

We would have plenty of wealth to improve the lives of most Americans if it wasn't being directed to the pockets of that minuscule percentage of the population. A percentage who would still be fabulously wealthy by any realistic standards of comparison even after a substantial cut to their incomes.

When they have to choose between paying the rent or eating every day, that's when they can consider themselves to be severely affected.

That is proof that the new economic system is working. That wealth is sure to trickle down any century now. Otherwise all those conservative economists would be wrong and that is outright heresy that will get you burned at the stake.
 
That is proof that the new economic system is working. That wealth is sure to trickle down any century now. Otherwise all those conservative economists would be wrong and that is outright heresy that will get you burned at the stake.

OF course its going to trickle down, in a great gushing golden stream...

Else it'll be the same manner as 1789, or 1917....
 
That is proof that the new economic system is working. That wealth is sure to trickle down any century now. Otherwise all those conservative economists would be wrong and that is outright heresy that will get you burned at the stake.

Kudos for the Rich&Wealthy to be able to hold it in for so long....
 
Reporter attested. He claims for doing his job and repeatedly asking whether domestic violence counts as a preexisting condition. They claim he was belligerent and pushing past security. He says he has never been attested for this before. They claim other reporters asked questions and weren't arrested, just him. Hard to say for sure without seeing the whole interaction but good to keep an eye out for increased reporter arrests.

http://thehill.com/homenews/adminis...king-hhs-secretary-price-healthcare-questions
 
That still amounts to a right to health care since poor people use the ED as their regular doctor.

No they aren't. Poor people can't go the ER to get a regular checkup. Nor can they get an evaluation for a non-emergent condition.

ERs treat emergent and urgent conditions. They can, and will, turn away anyone (regardless of ability to pay) who comes in seeking routine or maintenance care.
 
No they aren't. Poor people can't go the ER to get a regular checkup. Nor can they get an evaluation for a non-emergent condition.

ERs treat emergent and urgent conditions. They can, and will, turn away anyone (regardless of ability to pay) who comes in seeking routine or maintenance care.

I think you're talking past each other. If you assume that people see their 'regular doctor' primarily for annual checkups and preventative care, then Emily's Cat is quite correct. But, if you assume that people use their 'regular doctor' primarily for acute medical needs, then Skeptic Ginger's point is valid: For poor people, who either can't afford insurance at all or can't afford the constant co-pays to see a primary care physician, using the ER to treat acute (though perhaps minor) problems *is* just like using a 'regular doctor'.
 
They don't advertise free care.
No, they don't. But they have set themselves up as the first place a person thinks to go to when they are having an emergency as well as the place where people are taken who have been in serious accidents or are having life-threatening issues. Thus, they can be seen has having an obligation to provide this care to all comers.
If people don't have a right to health care, why would this matter?
Because it isn't about a right to health care per se as much as it is a right to have life-saving treatment in an emergency. It's a very limited right. And hospitals can still charge for the services, they just can't refuse services because the patient has no way to pay.
That still amounts to a right to health care since poor people use the ED as their regular doctor.
No they don't. That's a myth; EDs can and do turn people away who do not have emergency conditions.
When a person's life is on the line, the hospital's bottom line doesn't matter.
How is that not a right to care? If the ED wasn't required by law to treat people regardless of their ability to pay, there wouldn't be any hospital liability for turfing a patient or letting them die on the steps.
Like I said, it's a very limited right to care: a right not to die from a treatable emergency condition. This does not imply a right to all medical care.

That's faulty logic. Even with a right to health care, people can't just go anywhere anytime.
OK. I see where you are coming from. Yes, we all have a right to health care, just as we all have a right to food and shelter. But this does not imply that all providers must provide it regardless of our ability to pay. We have created an entitlement for people who meet the definition of "needy" to provide them healthcare. You are talking, really, about entitlements -not rights.

Again this is faulty logic. My argument is said responsibility to provide that care should be spread out over the whole community aka paid for with taxes. Yes they have a right to care. No, that is not the responsibility of any one individual, it is the responsibility of the community.
But, much as food and shelter, having a right to healthcare does not imply that the community has an obligation to provide it. We don't currently have such broad entitlements for food and shelter.

I see it differently than you do, obviously. I think that the community has an obligation to ensure that even the poorest are taken care of. We have created entitlement programs to ensure that the needy receive food and shelter. We also have an entitlement program to provide some of them medical care. In my view, Medicaid does not go far enough; too many people are excluded. For example, in Texas, adults who meet the income levels do not qualify unless they are caring for children. I think that should be changed and I'm "mad" at Texas for not expanding that coverage. So, while I am in favor of expanding the entitlements to cover more people in need, I am not in favor of expanding the entitlement to cover every citizen. People should generally provide for their own care just as they do their own food and shelter.

Let me rephrase my question: Do you, as a healthcare provider, feel that every patient is entitled to your services and that you must accept whatever the community decides is appropriate as your payment?
 
I think you're talking past each other. If you assume that people see their 'regular doctor' primarily for annual checkups and preventative care, then Emily's Cat is quite correct. But, if you assume that people use their 'regular doctor' primarily for acute medical needs, then Skeptic Ginger's point is valid: For poor people, who either can't afford insurance at all or can't afford the constant co-pays to see a primary care physician, using the ER to treat acute (though perhaps minor) problems *is* just like using a 'regular doctor'.
The problem is that the ER is not obligated to provide care for minor problems. They can and do turn people away for inability to pay.
 
Let me rephrase my question: Do you, as a healthcare provider, feel that every patient is entitled to your services and that you must accept whatever the community decides is appropriate as your payment?

Just a clarification on how remuneration is managed in Canada... the fee schedule is negotiated between representatives of the professional body in question (BCMA for MDs, BCNA for nurses, BCHEU for porters, housekeepers, &c) and the Ministry of Health as the single employer.
 
Just a clarification on how remuneration is managed in Canada... the fee schedule is negotiated between representatives of the professional body in question (BCMA for MDs, BCNA for nurses, BCHEU for porters, housekeepers, &c) and the Ministry of Health as the single employer.
Thanks for that.

I guess my larger point is that, in the US, doctors and other health providers generally have the right to negotiate their own fees directly with payers. If they don't like the reimbursement, they are free to refuse to accept that payer's customers as patients. Many other providers eschew third-party payers entirely and bill patients directly.

Moving to a single-payer system will mean losing this ability to negotiate* with and accept insurance as they see fit. In short, they will be forced to accept all comers and take whatever reimbursement the government decides to dole out. I just wonder if providers are prepared to accept that consequence of a single-payer system. I haven't run across one yet that is.

*I'm sure that the AMA and other provider groups will lobby/negotiate for higher reimbursements, but they do that now and Medicare/Medicaid reimbursement is simply not high enough. What happens when those provider groups have no leverage -the ability for their members to opt-out?
 
Thanks for that.

I guess my larger point is that, in the US, doctors and other health providers generally have the right to negotiate their own fees directly with payers. If they don't like the reimbursement, they are free to refuse to accept that payer's customers as patients. Many other providers eschew third-party payers entirely and bill patients directly.

Moving to a single-payer system will mean losing this ability to negotiate* with and accept insurance as they see fit. In short, they will be forced to accept all comers and take whatever reimbursement the government decides to dole out. I just wonder if providers are prepared to accept that consequence of a single-payer system. I haven't run across one yet that is.

Yep. That's why the USA is in this situation. They missed the window of opportunity to migrate to a new paradigm, and now this system is culturally embedded with invested interests.



*I'm sure that the AMA and other provider groups will lobby/negotiate for higher reimbursements, but they do that now and Medicare/Medicaid reimbursement is simply not high enough. What happens when those provider groups have no leverage -the ability for their members to opt-out?

It will drive their reimbursement down. Thus their objections.
 
....
Moving to a single-payer system will mean losing this ability to negotiate* with and accept insurance as they see fit. In short, they will be forced to accept all comers and take whatever reimbursement the government decides to dole out. I just wonder if providers are prepared to accept that consequence of a single-payer system. I haven't run across one yet that is.
....

I note -- again -- that universal coverage and single-payer are not the same thing. A number of countries around the world -- including France, Germany, Switzerland and Japan -- provide universal coverage through private insurance companies that are closely regulated, like utilities.

Moving to a single-payer system will mean losing this ability to negotiate* with and accept insurance as they see fit. In short, they will be forced to accept all comers and take whatever reimbursement the government decides to dole out. I just wonder if providers are prepared to accept that consequence of a single-payer system. I haven't run across one yet that is.

*I'm sure that the AMA and other provider groups will lobby/negotiate for higher reimbursements, but they do that now and Medicare/Medicaid reimbursement is simply not high enough. What happens when those provider groups have no leverage -the ability for their members to opt-out?

Who gets to say what's "high enough?" Many providers do accept Medicare, and they are willing to trade reduced administrative costs and the certainty of payment in exchange for the last marginal dollar. The resistance to universal coverage is similar to the resistance to Medicare before it was enacted: "socialized medicine," "commie takeover," "government doctors," etc. But Medicare has worked out pretty well for people who might have been completely without coverage previously, and there's no reason why an expanded Medicare for All program couldn't work out well for everyone.
 
Medicare has worked out pretty well for people who might have been completely without coverage previously, and there's no reason why an expanded Medicare for All program couldn't work out well for everyone.

Providers probably disagree, though.

xjx388 has raised the main challenge: the US healthcare economy is proportionally larger than other countries while producing less outcome. It's a mix of inefficiency and higher margins. Fixing inefficiency means layoffs (mostly administrators, marketing, and lawyers). Lower margins means less cash for those who remain employed (the actual health service providers, such as doctors and nurses).

The end users will benefit, the taxpayers will benefit, but the current crop of service providers will probably lose half their dough. That's a big hit, and I understand why they are lobbying hard against it. The longer the gravy train lasts, the more invested they will be, the more wealth they can throw at Congress to kill anything that gives taxpayers and end users the value they want to keep for themselves.

The window of opportunity may have passed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom