Tricky family argument

Cleopatra said:
Hi Tricky.
Of course I am in the opposite side of the river, I am a theist and my parents are not and I think that our discussions have helped both sides to develop tolerance. They belong to the smashing minority and maybe I must say that I had to learn to be tolerant but the fact that they were not confused and they knew why the were atheists helped a lot and made me respect them. I have to confess that I respect very few atheists and this is because very few are serious in their atheism and they don't exhaust it in ridiculing theists and their beliefs.
That seems very odd to me. I have never been anyplace where atheism is the norm. Growing up, was atheism the norm in your whole culture, or just in your family?

Knowing humans, though, if atheism were the norm, there would be lots of people who would never really examine their atheism and would believe it by default.
A pious man is one who would be an atheist if the king were.
Jean de La Bruyère
 
Tricky said:
That seems very odd to me. I have never been anyplace where atheism is the norm. Growing up, was atheism the norm in your whole culture, or just in your family?
No no in Greece the 97% are Christians, my parents belonging to different religions, abstained from any religious practice, my dad is an atheist my mom doesn't care.

Tomorrow is the Greek Independance Day. What was a book of oppression for some cultures the Bible for the Greeks served as a tool of liberation. Only in the summer the Archibishop claimed that he had God's approval for an opinion he expressed. He was so ridiculed that he had to take it back. In Greece that the state is not separated from the church (the members of our newly elected government gave their oath having their hand placed on the Gospel) if the PM dared to say that he went to a War just because God told him so, he would be in serious trouble. I know that you coming from the American South have different experiences but it' s amazing, the same book creating two totally different reactions and two totally different societies.It must be some book.

Knowing humans, though, if atheism were the norm, there would be lots of people who would never really examine their atheism and would believe it by default.
A pious man is one who would be an atheist if the king were.
Jean de La Bruyère
Absolutely! I don't have any doubt about that.

originally posted by tdnAh. I see where you're going with this. My assertion that 95% of people don't bother to think (note that I never said anything about Christians) and the anecdote about Mary are two seperate things. I never meant for one to prove the other. Lift and seperate, please.

I think you are trying to fit several of my posts together to come to some sort of conclusion that I never intended to draw.
I am just reading your posts and I ask for clarifications, once given I make my comments. I am glad that you agree that the anecdote about Mary doesn't prove anything.
Please don't. I love her just the way she is, thankyouverymuch
It's ok. If you don't believe in God then you don't believe that prayers actually work.
 
Cleopatra said:
It's ok. If you don't believe in God then you don't believe that prayers actually work.

Not necessarily.... some prayers work even if you don't believe God... just as well as they do for people to do believe. It is an effective tool for self-modification, whether its with folded hands or in a lotus position. Repeat something long enough to yourself, and believe things will change about yourself, and lo and behold they will, simply because you keep it in the forefront of your mind. The human mind is really good about convincing itself about itself ;-).

Prayers effecting change in anything other than your own head are still wishes, and you can wish in one hand and spit in the other ;-).
 
Cleopatra said:
No no in Greece the 97% are Christians, my parents belonging to different religions, abstained from any religious practice, my dad is an atheist my mom doesn't care.
So you are still surrounded by religious people, even if not in your home. I would say that makes it a bit easier to break away from your "roots" because you would have so much support in the community. In the US, atheists have virtually no support.

Cleopatra said:
Tomorrow is the Greek Independance Day. What was a book of oppression for some cultures the Bible for the Greeks served as a tool of liberation. Only in the summer the Archibishop claimed that he had God's approval for an opinion he expressed. He was so ridiculed that he had to take it back. In Greece that the state is not separated from the church (the members of our newly elected government gave their oath having their hand placed on the Gospel) if the PM dared to say that he went to a War just because God told him so, he would be in serious trouble. I know that you coming from the American South have different experiences but it' s amazing, the same book creating two totally different reactions and two totally different societies.It must be some book.
(Lapsing into Southern US vernacular)
Naw, it ain't the book. It's them what's readin' it.

Cleopatra said:
If you don't believe in God then you don't believe that prayers actually work.
Many Christians here don't claim that prayers "work" in the sense that wishes are answered to the affirmative. They just mean that "God hears them".

Hmm... I see a new thread possibility here.
 
ceo_esq:
Excellent post, Tricky. I see it's already been nominated for Post of the Month, which saves me the trouble of doing that.
Agreed. (Still, such reasonableness is downright irritating ;))
It would be a little more realistic to ask "Take a look at the countries with established religions in the world today, such as Greece, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, England, Iceland or Finland, and decide if you want us to be like them." Or even "Take a look at the countries in the world today with greater entanglement between government and religion than the United States, such as Ireland, Germany, Austria, Belgium or even France, and decide if you want us to be like them."
Yes, it is odd how some countries which have a constitutionally decreed state religion are nevertheless much, much less religious than a country where the opposite is true. To compound the oddity, other countries which also have a religion's teachings integrated into their law-making are as expected very religious. Off hand, it seems there is little correlation.

It is at times like this that I wish I had a greater interest/knowledge of history. I wonder if anyone has done a study on why this state of affairs could come about.
 
Tricky said:
So you are still surrounded by religious people, even if not in your home. I would say that makes it a bit easier to break away from your "roots" because you would have so much support in the community. In the US, atheists have virtually no support.
I agree with you and this is the reason why I understand some...overreactions some times. Have you ever thought though that this minority thing has lead the atheists --or to be more accurate-- most atheists to believe that they belong to a superior category and they are sort of brights?
(Lapsing into Southern US vernacular)
Naw, it ain't the book. It's them what's readin' it.
You are right of course, after all people wrote this book but what in my eyes makes it interesting is the fact this book managed to address needs of so many people for such a long time. Other ideologies ( communism?) didn't survive even for 50 years.
Many Christians here don't claim that prayers "work" in the sense that wishes are answered to the affirmative. They just mean that "God hears them".
What ever, as you said there are many Gods I guess each God listens to his favorite song.BTW I was joking previously when I said that I would pray for the anecdotal Mary. I pray to God only when I feel competely disgusted with people and he always listens. I don' t know how it happens but it works ;)
 
DanishDynamite said:
Yes, it is odd how some countries which have a constitutionally decreed state religion are nevertheless much, much less religious than a country where the opposite is true. To compound the oddity, other countries which also have a religion's teachings integrated into their law-making are as expected very religious. Off hand, it seems there is little correlation.

It is at times like this that I wish I had a greater interest/knowledge of history. I wonder if anyone has done a study on why this state of affairs could come about.
This review of the findings of one independent study might interest you.

A couple of interesting conclusions are suggested by the report's findings (I also consulted some other sites about the same report):

Whether a state has an established religion, and whether the overall population is especially religious, do not seem to have nearly as much an effect on the level of religious oppression in a country as what the dominant religion is. If the country is predominantly Protestant or Catholic Christian, it's flat-out more likely to score well in assessments of religious freedom. If it's a predominantly Muslim country, it's certain to score badly, regardless of how secular the government is.

Contrary to what I would have expected, lack of separation of church and state in a modern country that is predominantly Protestant (as in Scandinavia) or Catholic (as in Latin America) does not seem to result in increased religious oppression. I suppose that's mildly encouraging (just in case it ever happens in the United States).
 
Tony said:


Hey evildave,

Can you give an example(s) of something that derails this decision-tree?

What derails the sales pitch differs slightly by spiel and by presenter.

Usually, the presentation drifts toward how the bible says something specific and precise about one or more modern day issue(s).

Typically this is where they show me a bible and cite some chapter/verse reference that they memorized, and quote something in or out of context to cover the modern-day scenario.

At this point, I will typically attempt to borrow the proffered holy book and actually read the cited verse and ask questions based on my interpretation of the verse.

This is usually the point where the religious sales presentation falls apart. One person actually came unglued over my request to hold his bible.

Where I stand there and read the story, my interpretation of one or more of the verses *gasp* doesn't match what the person says it MUST mean!

This is normally an abrupt end of the presentation. They'll shut down, say they'll "pray for me", or whatever their default phrase is.

Or it leads to the presenter becomming agitated, and then begin to improvise things that "god says" in an amusing way.

This is normally a 'born again' member of some church* that insists on seeking *me* out in some situation where I can't conveniently wander off. And these individuals don't tend to be well studied on the material, except in a particularly narrow, drilled-in sense.

* Possibly the 'church of the deflected addiction' - remember that template story? I heard it every single time this outcome happened.
 
When I responded to the "shut up" message, this is the response I got (ot looks just like the origional message- kinda spam-like):

"As you walk up the steps to the Building which houses the Supreme Court you can see near the top of the building a row of the world's law givers and each one is facing one in the middle who is facing forward with a full frontal view - it is Moses and the Ten Commandments!
As you enter the Supreme Court courtroom, the two huge oak doors have the Ten Commandments engraved on each lower portion of each door. As you sit inside the courtroom, you can see the wall, right above where the Supreme Court judges sit, a display of the Ten Commandments!

There are Bible verses etched in stone all over the Federal Buildings and Monuments in Washington, D.C.

James Madison, the fourth president, known as "The Father of Our Constitution" made the following statement "We have staked the whole of all our political institutions upon the capacity of mankind for self-government, upon the capacity of each and all of us to govern ourselves, to control ourselves, to sustain ourselves ACCORDING to the Ten Commandments of God."

Patrick Henry, that patriot and Founding Father of our country said, "It cannot be emphasized TOO STRONGLY or TOO OFTEN that this great nation was founded NOT by religionists but by Christians, not on religions but on the Gospel of Jesus Christ".

Every session of Congress begins with a prayer by a paid preacher, whose salary has been paid by the taxpayer since 1777.

Fifty-two of the 55 founders of the Constitution were members of the established orthodox churches in the colonies.

Thomas Jefferson worried that the Courts would overstep their authority and instead of interpreting the law would begin making law....an oligarchy....the rule of few over many. (Wow, hasn't this come true today?)

The very first Supreme Court Justice, John Jay, said, "Americans should select and prefer Christians as their rulers."

How, then, have we gotten to the point that everything we have done for 220 years in this country is now suddenly wrong and unconstitutional?

'IN GOD WE TRUST' IN ALL THINGS GIVE THANKS TO GOD"--author unknown
 
Why was the phrase "In God We Trust" added to coins during the civil war?
http://www.ustreas.gov/education/fact-sheets/currency/in-god-we-trust.html

Why was the "under god" phrase was added to the pledge in 1954?
http://www.religioustolerance.org/nat_pled.htm

Each court case that has removed religiously led prayer from government owned facilities has been a direct result of obvious religiously based abuse of other people at these facilities. These lawsuits generally were Christian-vs-Christian lawsuits.


If you don't think our government should be neutral to religion, then perhaps you would care to recommend WHICH flavor of religion will be in charge?

The Southern Baptists have been volunteering and campaigning for it for quite a while. Perhaps you would like the federal government to be run by them?

Catholicism has a lot of followers. Maybe the federal government should be Catholic?

Maybe the Mormons?

Maybe Pat Robertson's flavor of Christianity is what you want?

And THEN when we have a theocracy, we can have that holy war you may have been wanting all this time, and we can have 50 seperate states with 50 different theocracies. Maybe more.

Then some of those states can go on to make the Taliban look really, really good in comparison.
 
ca3799 said:
How, then, have we gotten to the point that everything we have done for 220 years in this country is now suddenly wrong and unconstitutional?

The idea of God is one who fills gaps. 200 years ago there were a LOT of gaps. Paraphrasing Ingersoll - Science is what we know - God is what we don't know.

God is mankind's ultimate Jungian Archetype. God is a figment of our deepest imagination. He is the fatherly comforter to our tortured minds. Why are our minds tortured? Because we KNOW we will die.

I can see signs that mankind is just beginning to come out of the religious dark ages. Eventually mankind will look back on our belief in invisible creatures and laugh.

So - why is everything we have done in 220 years in this country now suddenly wrong and unconstitutional? Because it was ALWAYS wrong. Gods do not exist.
 
I don't know if anyone has mentioned it yet but this snopes web page is very interesting.
Buildings in the U.S. capital and statements by America's founding fathers includes references to Judeo-Christian tradition: True.

The items included in the piece quoted below demonstrate a government endorsement of Judeo-Christian tradition: False.
 
Oh, thanks, I needed that.

My BS alarm was going off mightily and I was trying to look all that stuff up myself.
 
I have a sister-in-law who is a prolific Christian spammer. She will never change my mind and I will never change hers.

worldrel.gif


http://www.religioustolerance.org/worldrel.htm

You may indeed see your "In Allah We Trust" on a coin someday if the current trend keeps up according to the site above. Christianity is shrinking slightly faster than Islam is growing.

Have you ever thought that Michelangelo's "Creation of Adam" looks like God is asking Adam to pull his finger?
 
Bubba Tricky replies

Bubba Tricky has responded to my message, so if any of you are willing to wade through this again, you can have another look at my disfunctional family. ;)
Bubba Tricky said:
It is quite true that many people do fit God to their own liking. It's also true that religion helps many live up to their morality. We often try to put God into a box and make him what we want him to be. The church I am attending now has a different way of approaching the teaching of God's word and I like it. They teach all of God's word. I believe it is all true and it's writing was God inspired. We believe that there are various interpretations for some passages, but if they are not important to God's message of love and salvation then don't cause division within the church over it. An example is the rapture, is it pre-tribulation or post-tribulation. I personally believe that Jesus will rapture his church prior to the tribulation (1 Thessalonians 5:9 and other passages support this position), but whether it is before the 7 years of tribulation or after it does not affect that Jesus came to save mankind from sin and that through faith He will come and take me with Him someday. The main way I try to look at teachings now is to try and determine if they can be backed up in scripture. If they can then they are sound teachings. If not, then they fall into the category of false teachers discussed in 1&2 Timothy and Titus. God's word, though somewhat difficult to understand at times, partially due to the translation, is to instruct us and He has not made it intentionally difficult. I've found through study that the most simple direct meaning of a passage is usually correct. I'm leery of preachers who find obscure meaning in scriptures that no one else has ever seen before. I listen sometimes, but really have to make sure it's backed up in the Bible before accepting it. The Church (Calvary Chapel) I attend is non-denominational, in fact you can't even join. They don't take up an offering and accept anyone willing to come in and hear God's word. So far I have found the teachings to be sound, but I still check if something doesn't sound quite right.


Tricky said:

It sounds like an interesting church that definitely is NOT in it for the money, which I consider good. It is also good that they recognize the ambiguity in the scriptures (do you use any scriptures other than the Bible?). I simply see no point, though, for anyone to concern themselves with the rapture. When and if it comes, you will be judged. Knowing that it is coming should not change that judgment. You simply must live the way you think is right and if your God decides that is good, up you go. That is why I don't worry about my eternal soul. I know I have been a good person and I simply cannot believe that any kind of loving god would punish a person, or withold heaven, simply because that didn't dot all the i's and cross the t's. Nor can I believe that anyone who did not find Jesus will be denied heaven because of the culture he is raised in. That sort of vengeful behavior would go against everything I thing a God shoud be.

I don't know about the "simple and direct" approach. There's a whole lot of scripture, especially in the Old Testiment (especially Leviticus), that would be absolutely horrible if the simple, direct interpretation were taken. But the new testiment has some doozies too, like Luke 14:26: "If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters–yes, even his own life–he cannot be my disciple." You simply cannot take the simple, direct interpretation of this, because it would contradict all of the rest of Jesus' teachings. Yes, I know you must read things in context, but that contremands the "simple and direct" method. Let's face it, The bible is about as ambiguous as anything ever written. Not only can the devil quote scriptures incorrectly to his purpose, so can holy men. It is a mixture of true and false, reality and parable, history and philosophy, and everyone decides for themselves (or with the help of others, like a church) what is the "correct" interpretation.

Bubba Tricky said:
There is a time for private prayer and a time for public prayer. God also tells us to fellowship with other believers and to pray unceasingly. Prayers in public must be for God to be effective. The hypocrites who pray loudly in synagogues and on street corners are praying for man. They want man to say "see how religious and Holy I am". This is not God's will. Our private prayers are intended to be a time of communication with God, a time to ask Him to come into our lives and for Him to show us His will for our personal lives. The public prayer can be for community needs (there is a lot of gang and criminal activity in our area due to it being a main thoroughfare for drugs coming up from Mexico and often our prayers are for our community leaders, police and rescue workers) or it can be for other personal needs that people have submitted as prayer requests. Those who use religion for personal gain are not doing God's will, in fact it says the preacher should not be greedy for money. Some of those more well know preachers who have thought that they might as well become rich while doing God's work are trying from the Word. I don't necessarily think they started out with the intention of getting rich, but somewhere along the road they became more important than the message they preached.


Tricky said:
It is the same thing. If you are praying in public to have the police do something about gangs, then you are praying to man (the Police and local leaders). That (to me) amounts to taking God's name in vain because you are essentially using God to say, "listen to what I say or my friends in high places will punish you."

As to the money thing, well, it is a very gray area. Certainly it can be argued that the church needs money in order to spread the word of God. But how much? Is the Catholic church evil for building elaborate temples with money which could have been spent on the people's physical needs? I don't think ministers take a vow of poverty, neither should they have the kind of wealth that some do, regardless of how good they are. I think we can both agree that the Jim Bakers and Jimmy Swaggarts have crossed the line into greed, but there is a lot of ground in the middle. I think your church is admirable in its mission, but the vast majority of Christian denominations would be loath to end taking up collections. So how does your church finance itself, pay rent on the building, power bills etc.?

Bubba Tricky said:
I was somewhat raised in the church also, though we never attended very regularly. I did not accept all that was taught and as you well know I fell almost totally away from God for a long period in my life. But I did feel that my life was missing something and I found what it was when I returned to the Lord and I feel I am growing in my desire to serve Him, however He wants me to.


Tricky said:
Yes I do remember. I was living with you through some of those "years without God". And, excuse me for saying this, but I have never seen you happier than you were during that time. Maybe it was because we were young with so much ahead of us, or maybe it was the easy fellowship of the college community, but I have never seen you smile as much since those days. I do not doubt that you prefer the way you are now to the way you were then, but I miss the old smiling, joking hedonist.

Bubba Tricky said:

Do I fear for your eternal soul? Yes, I do, but, I realize that the choices everyone makes in this life are their own. Would I share God's Word with you? Yes, but only in love and if you wanted to discuss it. I don't think anyone was ever brought to the Lord by being browbeaten into it, by be shamed into believing, or by being told how wrong they are for their own beliefs. My personal philosophy on witnessing to people is that you display God and the love He has shown you in your life. I know that in the Lord I live a happy life for the most part (not to say that their aren't some really hard down and out times). If someone has issues in their own life and have seen my outlook on life, then they may come to me to ask about it. They may not, but I will be willing to share if they want my advice. I know many people are much more adamant and pushy about witnessing for the Lord, but I don't think they are any more successful than I. Another philosophy of our church is that you don't drag people to the Lord (even if you think they need it, ha ha)you love them to the Lord. Jesus said "you will know my disciples by the love they show one to another."


Tricky said:

As I mentioned, you needn't worry about my eternal soul unless God is an incredibly petty egotist. And I think you are sharing God's Word with me right now. It is a great discussion, but although I have gained much from it, there has been little to convince me that your way is correct. I have a problem with the first step, which is admitting that the Bible is the work of God. It seems to me, that once you have agreed to that, then you are no longer considering alternatives. All you are doing is hashing out the details. I simply cannot accept any philosophy in which I must first accept the basic premise that "God exists". I see too much evidence to the contrary which I cannot ignore.

And I am glad your church is non-proselytizing and I agree with your approach of letting people come to you and ask (as I am doing). Too many Christians try to essentially "put the fear of God" into you, by threatening your eternal soul, as if THEY made that sort of decision. I mean, nobody really knows the mind of God, so it strikes me as hubris to try to speak for Him.


Bubba Tricky said:

I'm sorry it bummed you out, and like I said, I don't usually respond to those mass e-mails, but I totally agree you have every right to say what you believe. To tell someone to sit down and shut-up is certainly not ever going to bring anyone around to your way of thinking. I do respond when I feel Biblical principles are being trashed, for less moral or downright immoral reasons. But I don't usually do that to individuals. If there are bills I support or don't, I'll send my Congressmen a letter stating my position. I don't let it bum me anymore when I do send things out because the receiver can read it or not.


Tricky said:

What bothers me is the generally hostile attitude that many (not all, or even most) Christians take towards non-believers. No, that silly little spam was not a big deal in and of itself, but after seeing this kind of thing everywhere, I had built up enough "bummedness" to respond. Like you, I also write my elected representatives and I write editorial letters to the newspaper. My reply to that spam was mostly to caution people to read what they forward. If you send it without comment, then you are effectively saying that you agree with it (unless it is an obvious joke). Nephew Tricky and I had a go-around about this for something he forwarded shortly after 9-11.


Bubba Tricky said:
Perhaps the things I have done are within the range of all compassionate persons, but I must confess that I didn't do a lot of the things I did because of a kind heart. In that area, Debbie has a much kinder heart than I. But I do feel that because of my love of the Lord that I do more now than I would have in the past. I now do those things willingly, knowing the Lord is leading me that I wouldn't even have considered a few years back. Also, I do them for God's glory and don't care whether it is known by others or not. I don't do it for me, if I did I would be just like the hypocrites we talked about above and I don't want to be like that at all.


Tricky said:
I hear what you are saying, but I have a hard time buying it. I know what a good person you are, Chad. I grew up with you. If you do these wonderful things to ingratiate yourself with God other than because you know how much it has helped (Nick and David and others), then I would be inclined to think less of it. But this goes back to a philosophical question of mine. Is it better to do good in hope of being rewarded, or because you know it is good? To me, the former seems a bit mercenary.


Bubba Tricky said:
I too am worried for our country but agree with you on some of your points. Yes the rapture is coming, but that doesn't mean use up everything we have. NO ONE knows when it is coming. Jesus said there would be a time of the Gentiles and after that time he would come for His church. He did not say when that would happen. Every generation feels that theirs is the last and I think God wanted it that way so that people would remain on fire for Him and His Word and that they would always be ready for His return. But that doesn't mean it will be next week. Our pastor feels like the time is near and maybe he is right, but we won't know until it happens.


Tricky said:
This I disagree strongly with. Every generation does NOT feel that theirs is the last. The groups that preach this are, in my mind, dangerous. In order to be ready for the return, simply live your life the way you feel is best, which includes (in my opinion) thinking about many future generations. I think the default position would be to assume the rapture is NOT coming anytime soon. Anything else leads to selfishness towards future generations.


Bubba Tricky said:
Certainly, I don't claim to have the correct interpretation of all of the Bible, and when I said they are "unrecognizable as Christian" it was meant to say that some churches who claim to be Christian have teachings that don't relate to the Bible or Jesus at all or at best a minor connection. I won't know all of the interpretation of the Bible until I have the opportunity to stand before God and ask, but I can read and understand much of the Bible and if someone isn't teaching of God's love and salvation through Jesus Christ, then I don't think they should call themselves Christian.



Tricky said:
I cannot think of a single Christian who would think, in total honesty, that they were not teaching of God's love and salvation through Jesus Christ. Some of them may not *behave* that way, but, I'm sure that in their hearts, they think they are doing the right thing. I wouldn't trust any human (not even you) to decide who was teaching it the right way and it is exactly this sort of thinking that leads to things like Protestant/Catholic violence. What I do trust you and me and many others to do is to make our best effort to live life morally. I agree that this too is a sticky thing to decide. Each person derives his own moral code, but I think we can mostly all agree on some of the basics (And it ain't the Ten Commandments. Churches make graven images all the time ;-) )


Bubba Tricky said:
Does that mean we shouldn't have religion in Government? I don't think religion should be in Government. I do think religious people should be in Government positions. It's not because I think they are any better, but like you said above religion helps many people to live up to their morals. I think that Government has had many immoral people elected and that they have hurt our country. That doesn't mean that religious people wouldn't have made the same mistakes. People who believe in God have made horrendous mistakes. Some have repented of them and some haven't. I guess what I'm trying to say is that I don't feel that any one religion should rule the country, but that God's basic teaching should be upheld in our Governmental decisions. I know they won't always be upheld, but I support our Government and have even when I didn't agree with he decisions being passed down. I won't quit, because whether I agree or not, I still think it's the best form of Government we could have.


Tricky said:
Who decides what God's basic teaching is? What if two religious groups disagree what it is? No, I simply cannot support any sort of "Godliness" test for whether or not people vote for someone.

A side note on immoral politicians: Most people would agree that the most moral, religious president we have had in the last 50 years was Jimmy Carter. He has continued to serve his God in many ways that put other ex-presidents to shame. Yet a majority of people would agree that he was, to be kind, ineffective as president. That says to me that adherance to God's basic teaching is in no way a qualification for public office.


Bubba Tricky said:
No, I wouldn't support "In Allah We Trust". I believe that our country was founded on a belief in God, a Biblical God. Though some of the founding Father's may not have called themselves Christians, they still adhered to the God of the Bible. And that belief has helped this country to rise to where it is now. No, Christians here haven't been persecuted, but though we try to bring people of other beliefs to God, most (not all) don't actively persecute other beliefs.


Tricky said:
Well, I disagree with you on what our country was founded on. Most of the religious language in our official documents refers to "our creator" which in no way indicates a Biblical God. Neither do I find any reference to Jesus in official documents, leading me to conclude that the country is NOT founded on Biblical principals. In fact, there is one document by our founding fathers, the Treaty of Tripoli of 1797, which states very directly, "As the Government of the United States of America is not, in any sense, founded on the Christian religion..."

It was intended to emphasize that we indeed do NOT persecute other beliefs, nor do we subscribe to an official belief. Perhaps it is a minor document compared to others, but it is the only one that I have seen which definitely says one way or other whether or not the US is a Christian nation.


Bubba Tricky said:
If I saw consistent morality demonstrated by leaders, it would not matter to me whether or not they profess to be Christian. In my experience, I haven't seen that consistent morality in most people who don't have a religious background. I know there are some and I applaud them and might support them based on demonstrated performance.


Tricky said:
Such may be the case, but still, to use religion as a basis for deciding without considering politics is prejudice. I realize we cannot always know about every political race (well, I know I don't) and I tend to vote without complete knowledge, based on things such as "party". Still, it is not really an issue, because almost every politician is an avowed Christian. If you study them to see which ones are actually behaving the way you think a Christian should, then you are judging them on merit, which is a good thing. We should all pay more attention to our elections, especially local ones.


Bubba Tricky said:
I love you too and have always respected you. I agree to disagree with you on these issues, but I strongly support your right to have your own opinions on them. Well, I've stayed at work about an hour too long, so I guess I'll close for now. I hope (and since I am a believer in Christ) pray that all is well with you.


Tricky said:
And since I am not a believer in Christ, I will hope that all is well with you. Thank you for a very interesting exchange.
 
Wow Tricky...

I am impressed by Bubba (Chad is his name?). He seems to have a well-reasoned, well-thought out way of discourse and seems to be aware of the limitations and boundries of religion (maybe not politically, but within one's own life). It is refreshing to hear such good exchanges and honesty in comparison to some of the things here *cough* *cough*, Christian forums, and my own life. Even when talking to my parents about these topics we are not so civil. Perhaps e-mail is a better way to go in these things, as it allows you to be a bit more dispassionate, and have time to make well-reasoned responses... hmm....
 
I forgot...

Also,

Thanks Tricky (I meant it in the last post, then got lost at the end...). I appreciate your efforts to put so much into your posts. Though long, these two have been very educational towards my dealing with people about religion. Thanks again.
 
If you have been told that "unless you accept Jesus" God will not let you into heaven, You should read the true story of the Four Chaplins and realized that something must to be wrong.

I have yet to hear a good reason why the Rabbi would NOT be allowed in while all or some of the rest would be. If the Rabbi would get in, than a belief in Jesus is not necessary. Would it matter if one of them had been Muslin? or Hindu? or Atheist?

This is one of many unreconcilable issues I have with religion, all of them.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom