Tricky family argument

Tricky

Briefly immortal
Joined
Nov 24, 2001
Messages
43,750
Location
The Group W Bench
Maybe this is too personal to be of interest to anyone, but I had an exchange with some of my deeply Christian family members recently, and I thought some good stuff came out.

What started it was a piece of forwarded Christian spam from Niece Tricky:
from Niece Tricky
AGREE OR DELETE
I was asked to send this on if I agree or delete if I don't. I've sent it to you so you know my opinion. What do you think about this?

It is said that 86% of Americans believe in God. Therefore I have a very hard time understanding why there is such a mess about having "In God We Trust" on our money and having God in the Pledge of Allegiance. Why don't we just tell the 14% to Sit Down and SHUT UP!!!

If you agree, pass this on, if not delete. . .
I get stuff like this from them often and I know they are just forwarding stuff they didn't write or think much about, but the "Sit down and shut up" comment just sent me over the edge, so I hit the "reply to all" button and typed:
Tricky replied
So I must agree or delete? Why can't I reply? My words won't hurt you.

Actually, this sort of "tyranny of the majority" makes me very angry. Perhaps 86% of people believe in "God", but which god? Allah?, Zoroaster?, Zeus? Are they all the same? If so, they certainly are described differently. Even Christians don't agree on what God is like. Some think he is a punishing god who will send people to Hell for the slightest infraction. Some think he is a loving god who forgives his children for almost anything. I might trust one of those gods, but not another. Before you (or the government) asks me to trust a god, they'd better make it pretty clear what sort of policies that god has.

And another thing that annoys me about this is that putting God into these things is against the very principles that our country is based on. The Pilgrims came here to escape religious oppression (from other Christians!), and now people are trying to insert their own version of religious oppression into everyone's life ("you MUST say this pledge to God"). Did you know that many of our founding fathers, including Washinton, Jefferson and Franklin were not even Christians, but Deists? (If you don't know what the difference is, do some reading, or I'll explain if you hate looking things up.) Why would you insult the people who gave birth to our freedom by doing the exact opposite of what they intended? Would you like this to be a country a theocracy, meaning "a country ruled by a religion"? Take a look at the theocracies in the world today, such as Iran, and decide if you want us to be like them.

But you say it is good to have us mention God in things. Just suppose that some other religion other than Christianity were predominant in the US. Every time you turned around, you would be having to "swear to Allah" or Thor or somebody else. If you were a good Christian, don't you think that would tick you off just a little? How would you like to have to use money that says "In Satan we trust"? That is why our founding fathers were so careful to make the separation between religion and government. That way, even if 86% of the people are against you, you are still treated fairly. I think that the freedom to believe what you like is the most important part of America. But feel free to disagree. I am not intolerant of your beliefs. Because I love what America stands for, I would never tell YOU to sit down and shut up. I welcome your input.

Now let's see if you are fair enough to send THIS message on to the people you sent the first one to.

With love for all,
Tricky

This brought in my big brother, who is very much a "walk the walk" Christian and a very fine person. Rather than repeat this stuff, I'll show his comments and my responses:
Bubba Tricky said:

I agree and support your right to say what you think, even though I don't agree with you. You say you don't know what type of God the statement would mean and I think that is up to the individual. But for my two cents worth, God's characteristics are pretty well laid out in the Bible. Too often people look at the history of the church when trying to label Christians. The history is pretty sad (Crusades, Catholic-Protestant, etc.) But those conflicts were pretty much guided by men who took a part of the Bible and tried to make it fit what they wanted their world to look like.

****
Tricky said

I think people are still fitting God to their world. I never see an instance where a person's way of looking at God or Jesus diverts strongly from their own morality. What I do see is people letting their religion help them try harder to live up to their own morality, and that is a good thing. But I feel there is not any absolutely correct way to interpret the Bible. The wide variety of sects and denominations of Christianity should indicate that. Do people pick one that is right, or do they pick one that is "right for them"? I think it is the latter, since I would be lothe to judge what is spiritually correct. But if it is a matter of picking what is "right for you", then you must admit that other ways of looking at the Bible are equally valid for others. To do otherwise is to engage in the exact same sort of religious chauvinism that led to the Crusades and the Catholic-Protestant schism.



Bubba Tricky said:

When looking at the attributes of God you need to look at our example of God, Jesus Christ. He did not preach going out and trying to kill everyone who doesn't agree with you. Sure he did preach that man should repent from sin and turn to God and that believers should reach out to non-believers. But the reaching out should be done with love and compassion.

****
Tricky said

There is disagreement about this too. An early split in the Baptist church between Primative and Missionary Baptists was over the question of reaching out. Primative Baptists disagreed that one of the duties of a Christian was to testify to others. In fact, it can be said that even Jesus was against this, for as he said:

Matthew, 6:5-6 - "And when you pray, do not be like the hypocrites, for they love to pray standing in the synagogues and on the street corners to be seen by men. I tell you the truth, they have received their reward in full. But when you pray, go into your room, close the door and pray to your Father, who is unseen. Then your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you."

I can see no other way to interpret this than that he meant prayers to be private. But of course, others disagree with me, especially those who benefit monitarily from being very public in their prayers. Such an interpretation would ruin them.



Bubba Tricky said:

Anyone who has experienced having religion (Christianity or other) shoved down their throats will resist. I believe that Jesus Christ is the true God by Faith. Others who don't share this faith do not have to believe, in fact the Bible clearly states that many won't no matter what is said. The choice to believe or not is a personal decision. I certainly pray for all of my family and friends that they would choose to believe.


Tricky said
And I would hope for all my family and friends to experience the joy and fulfillment of religious skepticism. I was raised in the church and am quite familiar with much of what they say. But when I overcame my indoctrination and was able to cast away the blinders that had tried to guide me into a single way of believing, it was as if I had never before known about the meaning of life, but only what I was told it was supposed be.

But I recognize that my own catharsis is not one that everyone can share. It is entirely natural that when you find a way of living that brings you such happiness, that you want to share it with others. But it is harder for a religious skeptic to do this. Few of my friends and family take joy in my "discovery". They pity me and fear for my eternal soul. Some have repudiated me. I find myself forced to keep my beliefs private (this message is a rare exception) rather than alienate those I love. Yet Christians have churches, temples and even television stations from which they can shout their beliefs to the sky. But if a religious skeptic dare speak up, he is told in mass-mailed spam messages to "sit down and shut up." That is not a message of love, and yeah, I'm a bit bummed about it.



Bubba Tricky said:

I am very active in my church and find it very fulfilling. I get new insights into God's word and have friends that I feel I can count on when times are tough. Those things are important to me, but most important is that I believe that I have a savior, Jesus Christ who guides and directs me and to whom I talk daily through prayer. I believe that He is in control of this world and I have peace that I am trying to serve him as best I can. Jesus taught that we are to be servants and I also try to do that. I know my belief has turned my life around from thinking mostly about myself and what was good for me to thinking of what I can do for others. I believe, again through faith, that Jesus came to Earth to teach of God, that He died for my sins and for the sins of everyone. I am not trying to tell anyone that they must believe as I do. I would be lying if I didn't say that I want my family and friends to believe, but I know that God gave each of us the right to choose and everyone makes their own choice.


Tricky said
I know you well, my brother. You are one of the best people I know. You apply your learnings to your everyday life and your kindness and compassion show through in everything you do. I know some of the sacrifices you have made for your family and your God, and the people, like Tricky Nick, whose lives you have made better than anyone would have dared to hope.
(Editorial note: Tricky Nick is Bubba Tricky's son, a Korean child with major health problems who Bubba Tricky adopted and is paying major bucks for his medical bills.)
Few of us could ever hope to match you in your devotion to duty. And I also know that you do not proselytize. You state your beliefs and you back them up with action. I am honored to be related to you.

I also believe that all of these good works are within the range of all compassionate persons, regardless of their religion or lack of it. In my mind, it is your heart that does these things. Jesus may be your inspiration, but it is YOU who are doing the heavy lifting. Finding a good inspiration can move one to do great things. It need not be the same inspiration for everyone.



Bubba Tricky said:

As for having "In God We Trust" on our money and in our "pledge" I do support that. It doesn't mean that as a Christian I want Christianity to take over and run the country. Some sects which claim to be Christian are so far from a Bible-based theology that they are virtually unrecognizable as Christian. It would be scary to have them in control.


****
Tricky said

It would indeed be scary, and it is in fact. I am very scared for our country. The problem is that each Christian believes that their teachings are correct. They are not intentionally perverting the meaning of the Bible. They simply have a different interpretation. Some, who believe that the rapture is coming, think that we should use up all the earth's resources as quickly as we like (like James Watt, the Interior Secretary under Reagan). I find that sort of belief very dangerous, yet it is strongly supported by Revelations.

Some believe that it is acceptable to curse and revile homosexuals based on a few selected Bible verses. One can justify absolutely anything using the Bible ("the Devil may quote scripture to his need"), yet it is the height of arrogance to claim to have the "correct" interpretation while others are "unrecognizable as Christian". Everyone's religion is valid to them. This is the exact reason why we cannot have religion in our government. It has the potential to be used for evil, and we all know that there are those who would do exactly that. Like James Watt.

As for the money, would you be comfortable with all of it saying "In Allah we trust"? Christians have been a majority here so long that they cannot relate to religious persecution. Sadly, many have decided that religious persecution is okay if the people persecuted are a minority.



Bubba Tricky said:

I also believe that God does not want a nation that forces people to believe. I want our country run by people who place their faith in Biblical teachings. I believe they are sound. I know that there are many who don't share my views. They have that right, given by God, not by a Government. I do support leaders who have a basic Biblical foundation as their basis for their actions. They aren't perfect, but no man is.


****
Tricky said

I believe that you would only support them if their Biblical foundation was similar to yours. So why even use Biblical beliefs as a litmus test? Why not support a government that acted morally, regardless of the source of that morality? If an atheist wanted the same outcomes as you for the good of the people, you should support that atheist over a Christian whose beliefs and desires differed strongly from yours.

But there is no worry about an atheist running. Religion has so much power in this country that no politician dare speak a skeptical thought because there are so many out there who want leaders with a "basic Biblical foundation" that they would vote against any admitted religious skeptic without so much as considering other issues. You know in your heart that this is true.



Bubba Tricky said:

Even Paul in his 1st letter to Timothy said we should pray for all in authority and when he wrote this Nero was the Caesar of Rome and Nero was seriously whacked. When a new set of leaders is elected, I may or may not agree with them, but I will continue to pray for them to seek God's wisdom. To not do that would be denying my own faith.


****
Tricky said
And I would hope (or pray, if I were religious) that my leaders would have wisdom. I care not where that wisdom comes from. To do otherwise would deny my own morality which tells me that we judge a person by their heart, not their hat.



Bubba Tricky said:

I know this is an area in which many disagree strongly, but I thought that I would let anyone know how I felt, just in case they didn't already.


****
Tricky said

It is indeed. That is why religion is such a taboo subject among many. I am very glad that you took the time to tell us all your beliefs. I think all of us need to examine our own beliefs from time to time, especially in the presence of somone of different beliefs. You can't learn anything from people who know the same things as you.

But although we disagree strongly, we are even more strongly united by our love and respect for each other. Growing up, I always looked up to you and wanted to be like you. I think it is good that I no longer want to be exactly like you because then I would not be my own person, but I will never stop looking up to you.

Love
Tricky
Tricky Sis wrote me back (Niece Tricky uses her account) and admonished me for sending such stuff to everyone on her mail list, including her boss, but of course it was not sent to anyone who didn't get the original message. But I still think I'm in the family doghouse. Anyone else here with similar family experiences?
 
Tricky, I must say I was very impressed with you (as usual) for having read that. Thanks for taking the time to post it :)

:clap:
 
Tricky, pass on my great respects to your brother and his family. And take a bow yourself. Both of you obviously have too much respect and love to descend to the gutter on this...thank goodness.
 
Hey, Tricky - I think many more families have religion vs. no-religion conflicts than we think. Most of my family keeps whatever "faith" practices to themselves, but then my extended family is spread across the U.S. and there isn't much communication between us. I admire your long exchange with Bubba Tricky - you 2 respect each other. Thank you for sharing this very personal exchange.
 
Next time someone suggests there's nothing wrong with the Motto, you can try tossing 'em this dipsy doodle... and most of 'em will never see it coming:

You know, there is a commandment that prohibits taking the Lord's name in vain. (Ex. 20:7, Deut. 5:11.) Accordingly, the name of God is to be used only for prayer, praise and thanksgiving. Yet our government tells us that the Motto "In God We Trust" is secular. By the government's own declaration, the Motto does not use God's name for prayer, or for praise, or for thanksgiving.

Rather than favoring the placement of the Motto on currency, it seems to me that good Christians ought to be opposed to placing the Motto on currency, because it plainly violates the commandment concerning proper usage of God's name. Christians should be strongly opposed to government-sponsored secularization of God's holy name. Shouldn't they?

Moreover, Scripture condemns accumulation of wealth (Matt. 19:23) and clearly declares that the love of money is the root of all evil (1 Tim. 6:10). Considering the condemnation of money in Scripture, placing God's name on currency is especially inappropriate, if not blasphemous. How on Earth can good Christians of conscience support such a misuse of God's name?


The same sort of argument can be applied to the Pledge. If "under God" has no religious significance and is NOT prayer or praise or thanksgiving (as is now being urged in the Supreme Court by those who wish to retain "under God" in the Pledge), then inclusion of the language in the Pledge runs afoul of the "name in vain" Commandment.

Many Christians might check their old Sunday School notes and Catachisms to find out what "taking the Lord's name in vain" means. Most authorities say that it means to use God's name for any purpose other than prayer, praise or thanksgiving.
 
Originally posted by Tricky
Tricky Sis wrote me back (Niece Tricky uses her account) and admonished me for sending such stuff to everyone on her mail list, including her boss, but of course it was not sent to anyone who didn't get the original message. But I still think I'm in the family doghouse. Anyone else here with similar family experiences?
I had 14 exchanges with my brother a couple months back on Intelligent Design.I must say that I tried to take as high a road as you and your brother, but I fell short. I fell to ridicule on his 6000 year old earth and his dinosaurs in the ark. We decided to quit before we became alienated forever.

I wonder about the lesson niece Tricky takes away from all this. Mom and Dad no doubt agreed with their daughter and could have encouraged her to send out the 'sit down and shut up message' to everyone in the address book.

Or she may not have had permission to mail her spam to everyone on the address list in the first place, and may be in some trouble for doing it. That may be her lesson. If you do sing about the lord like we've taught you, it may end up embarrassing us. Never ever send anything like that to your crazy uncle Tricky again. O why can't people sit down and shut up like they're told.

The funny part, if there's a funny part, you may be in the dog house. But they can't punish you. Poor niece Tricky might be paying a price for loving God tonight.
 
Nice letter, Tricky.

I took apart an email like this almost exactly a year ago.

Another popular bit of hate mail.

It's always the same thing. In my case, it was those damned evil atheists being blamed for lawsuits launched by Christians against other Christians who were using their position as an absolute majority to abuse.
 
Thanks to all who replied. I debated whether or not to post, but after Bubba Tricky agreed, I decided to do it. I'm glad I did now.
Atlas said:
I had 14 exchanges with my brother a couple months back on Intelligent Design.I must say that I tried to take as high a road as you and your brother, but I fell short. I fell to ridicule on his 6000 year old earth and his dinosaurs in the ark. We decided to quit before we became alienated forever.
I've come close to doing that too. Fortunately, nobody in my family tries to push biblical inerrancy. Talking to that sort of person is beyond hope. But all of my family, including my Pagan wife, believe in some version of Intelligent Design. They get fuzzy when pressed for details.

Atlas said:
I wonder about the lesson niece Tricky takes away from all this. Mom and Dad no doubt agreed with their daughter and could have encouraged her to send out the 'sit down and shut up message' to everyone in the address book.

Or she may not have had permission to mail her spam to everyone on the address list in the first place, and may be in some trouble for doing it. That may be her lesson. If you do sing about the lord like we've taught you, it may end up embarrassing us. Never ever send anything like that to your crazy uncle Tricky again. O why can't people sit down and shut up like they're told.
I'm quite sure Niece Tricky got a quick course in mail etiquette. She is a bit new to this e-mail thing. She's a really wonderful girl who works tirelessly at as a veternary assistant for really crappy pay. But she loves animals so much, it is okay with her.

And she already knows about "crazy Uncle Tricky". She spent a summer with me one year. She really should have known better. :D

Atlas said:
The funny part, if there's a funny part, you may be in the dog house. But they can't punish you. Poor niece Tricky might be paying a price for loving God tonight.
I hadn't thought of that, but maybe I should have. It is just the sort of thing that could lead to a "Christians are persecuted" belief. I certainly don't want to contribute to that.
 
Hmmm.... lets take a different direction with this argument:


It is said that 86% of Americans are white. Therefore I have a very hard time understanding why there is such a mess about having whites only seating and accomodations. Why don't we just tell the 14% to Sit Down and SHUT UP!!! (in the back of the bus)
 
Very, very nice, Tricky. My own experience with this was much briefer. When the Pledge of allegience hit the fan last year (or so), my kids were among those at school who would not say the pledge (my daughter told me only last week that her teacher still tries to get her to stand for the pledge, and she refuses). My parents have been educators for longer than I have been alive, and are good christian folk...and they had an opinion on the issue. My father thought it was all a tempest in a teapot, that it was obvious that "under god" was too broad to offend anyone, that it did not specify which god...etc., etc.. He could not see that this was worth my kids getting involved.

I took a similar tack to yours--I asked him if he would mind if it said "under Thor". He laughed. I asked about "under Allah", reminding him that Allah, as the god of Abraham, was the same deity that he worshipped under a different name (God, w/capital G). He bristled a bit at that, but saw immediately that his objection to Allah was minor compared to my son's objection. If the mere name for the same deity is problematic, the assumption of existance/non-existance of said deity must be more so. I think the thought of his grandchildren being potentially ostracized for his beliefs did the trick (aside--they are popular enough kids that I think, in this school, if it came down to a classmate choosing their friend or their religion...they might well choose to stay seated with my kids)

New Hampshire, almost every year, has some legislator propose a bill to mandate school prayer. Some years this even looks like it might pass. I have told my kids that if this happens, I will write them a prayer...full of expletives... for them to memorize, to be shouted aloud during prayer time at school (to make sure their god can hear it--he's a little deaf)...even if I have to start my own religion to do it.

But then, I never claimed to take the high road like you so honorably did in your exchange...:D
 
I had a similar exchange with my brother a few months ago. We both agreed that an e-mail discussion of our beliefs might be helpful in understanding one another. He mistakenly thought I would be an easy sell. I'm sure he expected me to ask softball questions like, "Is it true that God has a plan for me?"

I started with the inerrancy of the Bible, as that is definitely his and his church's big belief. Got all kind of excuses for why the apostles aren't listed consistently and why the genealogies of Jesus are different. Didn't seem to make any impact on him.

We talked about evolution, sin, historicity of Jesus. He didn't have any answers, just the usual Christian platitudes and poor arguments. After a couple of days, I offered to let it drop and he accepted.

At least he now understands that I'm not a wavering Christian looking for an excuse to come back to the fold.
 
Tricky said:
Anyone else here with similar family experiences?


My mom accused me of being gay when I was standing up for gay marriage at a recent family argument.
 
Hi Tricky.

Thanks for posting this dialogue. Some times I have the feeling that generally speaking atheists are tad confused and this is what makes them so aggressive and put them in desperate need to preach and make you admit that it's something wrong with you and your morals.

You on the contrary have clarified those things in your head and this permits you to fight for you ideas without becoming abusive.:)

I have the feeling that the discussion in your family just started. You will hear again about those things from your niece, even your sister. In my family we are in a continuous debate about everything religion included. :)

Of course I am in the opposite side of the river, I am a theist and my parents are not and I think that our discussions have helped both sides to develop tolerance. They belong to the smashing minority and maybe I must say that I had to learn to be tolerant but the fact that they were not confused and they knew why the were atheists helped a lot and made me respect them. I have to confess that I respect very few atheists and this is because very few are serious in their atheism and they don't exhaust it in ridiculing theists and their beliefs.

Your brother is admirable indeed. People who adopt kids are the kindest and my God ( I agree with the distinction you made in your first e-mail to your niece--each of us has his own God this is the reason why it is ridiculous to try to impose Him to other people-- ) who sees and knows everything rewards them.
 
Tricky, your brother sounds like a wonderful guy, but from the exchange you posted, it seems like he was more interested in talking than listening. Here is my take on the exchange:

Tricky: Not everyone likes candy.
Bubba: I like candy, I think everyone should like candy.
Tricky: A lot of people are diabetics.
Bubba: I like candy, I think everyone should like candy.
Tricky: That's great, but not everyone agrees with that.
Bubba: I like candy, I think everyone should like candy.
Tricky: Let's change the subject. How's mom doing?
Bubba: I like candy, I think everyone should like candy.

I seriously doubt that he truly read a single word that you wrote.

Tricky said:
You should have told her, "I am not gay, and neither is my boyfriend!"

You post this in jest, but sometimes it's not so funny. My friend Mary is not gay. She does not believe that people should be gay. She does not think that homosexuals should marry. Gayness is a sin against God, she says. And she gets this belief every Sunday in church, which she attends...

...with her female lover.
 
tdn said:


You post this in jest, but sometimes it's not so funny. My friend Mary is not gay. She does not believe that people should be gay. She does not think that homosexuals should marry. Gayness is a sin against God, she says. And she gets this belief every Sunday in church, which she attends...

...with her female lover.


WTF??
 
Cleopatra said:
Thanks for posting this dialogue. Some times I have the feeling that generally speaking atheists are tad confused and this is what makes them so aggressive and put them in desperate need to preach and make you admit that it's something wrong with you and your morals.

Really? Where did you get this idea?

I can only speak for myself here, but I am not confused at all about my atheism. It fits me very comfortably. When I get aggressive, it's usually because someone is telling me I have no morals, or telling me to to "sit down and shut up." When my feelings of anger are attributed to being "a tad confused", that makes me even madder.

I don't often try to start fights about this, but if someone picks a fight with me, you'd better believe that the gloves will come off.
 
tdn said:
Really? Where did you get this idea?

I can only speak for myself here, but I am not confused at all about my atheism. It fits me very comfortably.
That's great. I am glad about you!
 
Tony said:

"TF" being a whole lot of denial, I guess. She considers herself to be straight, or at worst bi, but in all of her 47 years, she has never had sex with a man. Not once (so I'm told by a reliable source). She did once consider marrying a guy, but that guy considered himself married to God.

She has been in a committed, monogamous, loving, and above all heterosexual relationship for about 9 years now. They recently moved in together. It just so happens that her male lover was born with all the wrong parts.

(On a related note, concerning the question of whether homosexuality is nature or nurture, her identical twin is happily married. To a man. With a penis. Go figure.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom