Tricky family argument

tdn

But that's the problem. You can't get mad at Christians for being Christians.

Just relax. Realise the damage was done to them a long time ago. The scar tissue over what should be thinking portions of their brain is thick and calloused.

Besides, when you are angry, you are definitely off-balance and not thinking at your best. What you're arguing with is nothing more than a scripted conditioned response in most cases. Anyone can beat that, no matter how elaborately programmed into them, IF you keep cool and be patient.

Then you can simply attack the "argument" using any of a number of techniques. You can tell when their decision tree has "crashed", because they'll go flipping berserk. Otherwise it'll terminate with "I'll pray for you!", or any of a number of other default actions. Highly predictable.

Normally, I simply get the stranger to tell me their life's story. It's not difficult. If you're patient, they'll witness to you by default. It's fascinating how similar the stories are to each other.

I was a {drug abuser}. Then I found Jesus. Then I {began associating with previous friends} and {fell off the wagon}. Then {something scarey happened} and I knew it was God warning me. I have been {good} ever since.

The details in {} change, but generally the same template. It makes me wonder whether they actually get trained to tell this story, no matter whether it really happened to them.

I don't mind engaging them in polite conversation, because they will always gush on and on about their mythology in the most entertaining manner. Only ask polite questions to clarify minor points.

In the end, you get yet another clear reinforcement that your godlessness was a good decision, based on the comedic marionette-like behavior you could be exhibiting, had you worked to become one of these poor specimens.
 
evildave said:
Just relax. Realise the damage was done to them a long time ago. The scar tissue over what should be thinking portions of their brain is thick and calloused.

Why you say that? Do you take courage by shouting your beliefs in that way?
 
evildave said:
But that's the problem. You can't get mad at Christians for being Christians.

Just relax. Realise the damage was done to them a long time ago. The scar tissue over what should be thinking portions of their brain is thick and calloused.

Besides, when you are angry, you are definitely off-balance and not thinking at your best. What you're arguing with is nothing more than a scripted conditioned response in most cases. Anyone can beat that, no matter how elaborately programmed into them, IF you keep cool and be patient.

Meh. Don't worry about me. I really don't get mad about it all that often. I'm more bemused by it than anything else. And I'm definitely a live-and-let-live kind of guy. You want to believe in the wackiest, craziest things? Knock yourself out. Just realize that if you want to accuse me, judge me, or challenge me, be prepared for a fight. My girlfriend learned this long ago. ;)
 
Cleopatra
No, as I say, I am calm and polite. The shouting and accusations usually start from the other side of the conversation, typically the first time I ask for a clarification of some trivial-seeming point that reveals or derails their decision-tree (i.e. they don't know any of the supporting material for their spiel).

I do visualize irrational and entrenched beliefs as 'scarring'. It makes it easier to understand that this mesh of beliefs is like a fortification against reason. You're not going to make more than a tiny dent in it if you try, and underneath, it's usually quite sensitive, so you should avoid probing into it too deeply.

It is better to go into a dispassionate mode and study the phenomena than to attack it, is all. It will also help you to understand where the speaker is coming from, and evaluate whether they will be receptive to hearing any sort of opinion not in harmony with their own. This is an important part of communication.

Someone who has a strong opinion will tend to want to voice it. It is only courtesy to allow them to speak their peace. If they are polite, they will be more receptive to hear you out in turn.

It doesn't matter when they're rude and unreceptive to reciprocating your patience and tolerance. You always learn something, and incidentally, "win" when they become rude. Not that any conversation should be a contest.
 
Cleopatra said:
Why you say that? Do you take courage by shouting your beliefs in that way?

I think what evildave said could apply to about 95% of the population, not just Christians. Most people just absorb the culture around them without thinking critically, and take it as absolute truth. If you are in the other 5%, I don't think you fall under the umbrella of the insult.
 
tdn said:
I think what evildave said could apply to about 95% of the population, not just Christians. Most people just absorb the culture around them without thinking critically, and take it as absolute truth. If you are in the other 5%, I don't think you fall under the umbrella of the insult.
I am a common person of an average intelligence I don't belong to the special group of 5% do you think that you belong to the 5%?
 
tdn Yes, I have a neighbor who is convinced she's 'psychic'. It is more or less the same thing. She believes it, and nothing I say will make a difference, so let it lie.

She, like many others, could not accept that I didn't believe in any gods. I only let her know in the most polite manner possible, that I don't believe in other 'supernatural' phenomena, and that unpredictablity of her experience and coincidence are not particularly seperable to me and my experience.

Yes, I have had useful intuitive flashes in the past. I don't believe they were particularly "supernatural" phenomena more than common sense asserting its self.
 
Cleopatra said:
I am a common person of an average intelligence I don't belong to the special group of 5% do you think that you belong to the 5%?

That did sound awfully arrogant of me, didn't it? But yes, I do believe I am one of the few that questions everything I encounter. I don't think that makes me special in any way, just willing to become better informed.
 
tdn said:
That did sound awfully arrogant of me, didn't it? But yes, I do believe I am one of the few that questions everything I encounter. I don't think that makes me special in any way, just willing to become better informed.
No I didn't find it arrogant. If you belong to the special group of 5% that applies critical thinking why you mentioned the anecdote of your friend Mary and you projected to the Christians these beliefs? I am asking out of curiosity because I want to improve myself, leave the class of the mediocres and join the class of the gifted 5%. :)
 
evildave said:
She, like many others, could not accept that I didn't believe in any gods.

Yeah, that's a problem. Some people are so convinced that there is a god (or psychic phenomena, or UFOs, or whatever) that they simply cannot believe that others don't see what should be obvious. Might as well say you don't believe in trees. Like my girlfriend says, "I have never believed in God -- I've just always taken Him as undisputed fact. No belief is required."

Of course, non-believers hold to a position that might seem just as obvious. Anything else is, on its face, patently absurd.

This makes communication between the two a real bear, to say the least.
 
Cleopatra said:
No I didn't find it arrogant. If you belong to the special group of 5% that applies critical thinking why you mentioned the anecdote of your friend Mary and you projected to the Christians these beliefs?

I projected it onto Christians because Mary got her attitude from Christianity. More specifically, the particular brand of Catholicism that she practices, and the way she interprets it. I didn't mean to impugn all of Christianity in relating that tale, but if you ask Mary herself why she thinks the way she does, you'll get a bible verse as an answer.
 
Cleopatra said:
I am a common person of an average intelligence I don't belong to the special group of 5% do you think that you belong to the 5%?

I don't know what the percentage of any particular group is, offhand.

I do know that it isn't a general thing more than in spefic areas of reasoning.

For instance, many very religiously fundamentalist types can be readily convinced of certain other things, or laudibly skeptical of other kinds of things.

People might (for instance) be readily convinced that a gas/electric hybrid car is more fuel efficient than an SUV, yet not give up their SUV.

I would put this '5%' figure (or 11%, or whatever) on a religious skepticism, rather than on an intelligence or generic sort of thing.

Lots of people, being what people are, have 'blind spots' in their perceptions of reality. Being too 'mystical minded', or not being 'mystical minded' enough.

I am in the latter category on most issues, and actually in a minority for it. This is neither 'good' or 'bad'.

For the time being, I will reject 'mystical' thinking until there is acceptable, repeatable evidence for it. Big claims, big proof. Little claims, little proof. I'll certainly clean house on the previously accepted little claims if they are used to support a "big" claim. That's just how I go about it, and that personal research really is more work than most people are willing to do. I am willing to leave certain kinds of answers "questionable" for indefinite periods of time.

The core minority status is recognizing that there is no such thing as "absolute" truth. Not anywhere. One of the most annoying attributes you would eventually notice in me if you met me is that I don't tend to even answer simple questions with an absolute. Probably. Probably not.

Some might call this 'agnosticism' applied more or less evenly to everything. It's properly 'Apathetic Agnosticism' in relation to religions, and I have my Ordination and Master of Nescience to prove it. In matters of gods, afterlives, etc., I officially don't know, and I officially don't care.

I lean toward probably not on these matters. Parsimony and all that.
 
Excellent post, Tricky. I see it's already been nominated for Post of the Month, which saves me the trouble of doing that.

A few nitpicks:
The Pilgrims came here to escape religious oppression (from other Christians!), and now people are trying to insert their own version of religious oppression into everyone's life ("you MUST say this pledge to God").
This risks misleading your reader into thinking that a movement is afoot to reverse the 1943 Supreme Court decision holding that people are never obligated to recite the Pledge of Allegiance, which so far as I'm aware is not the case.
Would you like this to be a country a theocracy, meaning "a country ruled by a religion"? Take a look at the theocracies in the world today, such as Iran, and decide if you want us to be like them.
(I can only think of two true theocracies in the modern world - Iran and the Vatican - so it'd be a pretty brief look.)

In fairness you probably ought to point out to your niece that there is a lot of middle ground between church/state relations in America on one hand and theocracy on the other, and consider discussing the "slippery slope" fallacy in this context with her.

It would be a little more realistic to ask "Take a look at the countries with established religions in the world today, such as Greece, Norway, Denmark, Sweden, England, Iceland or Finland, and decide if you want us to be like them." Or even "Take a look at the countries in the world today with greater entanglement between government and religion than the United States, such as Ireland, Germany, Austria, Belgium or even France, and decide if you want us to be like them."

Of course, many of these countries are frequently cited by researchers as fostering a level of religious freedom equal to or greater than that enjoyed in the United States. Like you, I would hate for the degree of separation of church and state in the United States drop below that currently guaranteed under the U.S. Constitution, but perhaps we ought to acknowledge that there does not appear to be a necessary correlation between church/state entanglement (or even official establishment of religion) and a reduction in religious freedom – which is, of course, what we are chiefly concerned about.

You don't want your niece to get the mistaken impression that keeping "under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance will put America on the inevitable path to established religion (to say nothing of theocracy), or that even if it did, it would necessarily result in reduced religious freedom (judging from the example of other modern countries).
But I feel there is not any absolutely correct way to interpret the Bible. The wide variety of sects and denominations of Christianity should indicate that.
The point behind your statement is obviously a good one. As good logicians, however, we know that, strictly speaking, the existence of a multiplicity of interpretations of the Bible is irrelevant to the question of whether one of them might not be the absolutely correct one.
 
tdn said:
I projected it onto Christians because Mary got her attitude from Christianity. More specifically, the particular brand of Catholicism that she practices, and the way she interprets it. I didn't mean to impugn all of Christianity in relating that tale, but if you ask Mary herself why she thinks the way she does, you'll get a bible verse as an answer.
How the anecdotal story of one person out of the 96% of the Americans that believe in God can be useful in extracting conclusions about the Christians in general and why you use her example and not Tricky's brother who supports an adopted child? Why don't you use Tricky's anecdotal story of one person out of the 96% of the Americans that believe in God to conclude that Christians are nice people?
 
tdn said:
Like my girlfriend says, "I have never believed in God -- I've just always taken Him as undisputed fact. No belief is required."
That is so EXACTLY how I was before I started questioning...

I never even thought about not believing or questioning or seeking alternatives. I thought God existed just like the sun and the moon and the stars. Then my boyfriend (now my husband of almost 24 years) forced me to question my assumptions. I am so grateful to him for doing so. Once I opened my mind and let myself truly THINK about what I was just blindly accepting, there was no way that I could continue to accept it. I can't even imagine now believing in gods or superstitions of any sort. It seems so unbelievable that I ever did!

There's hope for your girlfriend yet...
 
Cleopatra said:
How the anecdotal story of one person out of the 96% of the Americans that believe in God can be useful in extracting conclusions about the Christians in general and why you use her example and not Tricky's brother who supports an adopted child? Why don't you use Tricky's anecdotal story of one person out of the 96% of the Americans that believe in God to conclude that Christians are nice people?

Ah. I see where you're going with this. My assertion that 95% of people don't bother to think (note that I never said anything about Christians) and the anecdote about Mary are two seperate things. I never meant for one to prove the other. Lift and seperate, please.

I think you are trying to fit several of my posts together to come to some sort of conclusion that I never intended to draw.
 
Cleopatra said:
I will pray for her to open her mind and become like you and tdn. :)

Please don't. I love her just the way she is, thankyouverymuch.

She's not an idiot, she's dealt with more wacky thinking than you could know (she's a shrink, after all), and has come out smelling like a rose. We have just come to opposite conclusions on the matter, but neither of us did that blindly.

I have no interest in trying to "convert" her.
 
Actually, if we're going to bring up the Pilgrims, there is a little more to the story than "religious persecution".

Yes, they were persecuted in England. No question about that.

When they went to Amsterdam where they were NOT persecuted at all. They only feared their culture/religion would be absorbed into the local culture, and hence disapear.

http://www.rootsweb.com/~mosmd/

Of particular note, there are the other histories about the histories of the "saints" and the "strangers" (based on ship logs and diaries on the Mayflower) that indicate that they didn't get along very well.
 
evildave said:
...typically the first time I ask for a clarification of some trivial-seeming point that reveals or derails their decision-tree (i.e. they don't know any of the supporting material for their spiel).


Hey evildave,

Can you give an example(s) of something that derails this decision-tree?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom