Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

Naaaaah, you could be Muslim, Hindu, Zoroastrian, Jewish, Daoist, animist, cargo cultist, voodoo, oh many, many choices, but Muslim and Hindu seem to be the most popular among religionistas who aren't christian.

Oh, it's all transactional is it? You're only christian 'cos there's something in it for you? No surprise there.
You left out Baron Samedi cultists, shamanists, and cannibals.
 
going to be honest, i read the name as fart ehrman and i thought there's no way that's the guys name.

well, it wasn't. but, not a bad chuckle. fart ehrman.
 
I tend to forget to look at new posts, and thus fall way behind on some threads like this one. Fortunately, now 21 pages in, it once again turns out not to matter. Arguing (if you can even call it that) with some people is as always an isometric exercise: all exertion but no movement. It seems we're back to the basic religious/mystic issue of confusing the vagueness and inadequacy of language with actual substance, along with a generous helping of hoping that arguments that fell in one thread will rise in another.

A scientist or a person who trusts scientists and the evidence they rely on "believes" in the big bang, and so forth. Certain things make sense relative to the things we observe. We can surmise things (theories, for example) based on evidence. That does not make the evidence a theory. This is not the same as the belief we see in religious faith. We lack subtle distinctions in our common language, and thus we don't, in ordinary speech, distinguish the causes and dimensions of belief.

I "believe" that if I were to get up right now and walk straight forward for approximately twelve feet I would smash into a wall, and I believe that if I did so at a certain speed I'd hurt myself. In fact, I have so much reason to believe this that I need never actually test it by smashing into the wall. This is, not surprisingly to some of us at least, not quite the same thing as believing that the great God Jehovah will answer my prayers or that there is any reality to the story of Noah's ark.

We may not entirely know the "how" for some things, and in many cases we do not know the "why," because even to presume that there is a "why" is spurious. Even so, you mustn't leave out the "what." You can see something and not know how it got there or why, but there it is!

Just a few random thoughts after skimming the pages here:

A lack of faith is not a kind of faith, just as nonbeing is not a kind of being. If you cannot accept that religious faith is a different thing from ordinary everyday belief, such as that the sun will come up tomorrow, there are tigers in India, and other things for which evidence and experience are abundant, then you not only make a serious mistake about the world of experience, but incidentally sell your faith pretty cheaply! Likewise, to call every belief you don't like a myth mistakes not only what those beliefs actually are, but what a myth actually is.

It's true that many medical providers encourage prayer. Some, of course, believe in it. Others realize that if their patients believe in it it will comfort them, and that as long as nobody substitutes prayer for actual medicine, no harm is done. Arguing that this constitutes even the slightest soupçon of evidence for a deity or for the efficacy of prayer is utter nonsense.

Attributing Trump support to brain damage is, I know, just a joke, but be kinder to us TBI sufferers please. My hearing is funny and my vision is blurred and my left foot tingles, but you'd have to blow a whole lot more gray matter out of the cracks before I'd support that miserable ball of snot.
 
Last edited:
Just wanted to add that medical providers in more secular countries do not actively encourage prayer (but will not discourage it, if the patient wants it, of course, unless it interferes with any treatment). It's not something that is part of life here, in general, but if someone wants to talk to, or pray with, any kind of religious officiant, that would of course be arranged. Not a common occurrence, however.
 
Just wanted to add that medical providers in more secular countries do not actively encourage prayer (but will not discourage it, if the patient wants it, of course, unless it interferes with any treatment). It's not something that is part of life here, in general, but if someone wants to talk to, or pray with, any kind of religious officiant, that would of course be arranged. Not a common occurrence, however.
In the same way, medical providers do not actively encourage other kinds of superstition, but if it helps the patient without interfering in the treatment, they'll try to work with it. I know a case where a patient in a hospital complained about pain caused by radio waves from a nearby cell phone antenna, and after fitting the window with tin foil, the pains disappeared!
 
In the same way, medical providers do not actively encourage other kinds of superstition, but if it helps the patient without interfering in the treatment, they'll try to work with it. I know a case where a patient in a hospital complained about pain caused by radio waves from a nearby cell phone antenna, and after fitting the window with tin foil, the pains disappeared!
Did the hat look good on him?
 
Did the hat look good on him?
There was no hat, but the nurses had to pretend that their cell phones were switched off (they were on silent mode. One of my close friends was the nurse, and she was into woo-woo herself, but not that much! She learned Reiki massage herself, and gave healing vibrations to the patients, who generally was in a bad state because it was an intensive care ward.
 
I was flown out of Nam the day after I RTB* and spend "a while" in Balboa Naval Hospital, San Diego, CA. About four months there. When I left the ward there were ~24 staff people applauding me. Still couldn't walk so I asked what the surprise was here?

"We don't usually get men out of that ward who are walking on their own power. If at all, in fact." Little spooky.


*Returned to Base.
 
I was flown out of Nam the day after I RTB* and spend "a while" in Balboa Naval Hospital, San Diego, CA. About four months there. When I left the ward there were ~24 staff people applauding me. Still couldn't walk so I asked what the surprise was here?

"We don't usually get men out of that ward who are walking on their own power. If at all, in fact." Little spooky.


*Returned to Base.
A man left my ward a few weeks ago, after a year in hospitals, walking out under his own power, with a stick. A year ago he was entirely paralysed by Guillain-Barré syndrome, able only to blink.
 
I was flown out of Nam the day after I RTB* and spend "a while" in Balboa Naval Hospital, San Diego, CA. About four months there. When I left the ward there were ~24 staff people applauding me. Still couldn't walk so I asked what the surprise was here?

"We don't usually get men out of that ward who are walking on their own power. If at all, in fact." Little spooky.


*Returned to Base.
"Still couldn't walk without a walker." Mom freaked every time I fell despite me yelling "I'm okay, I'm okay."
 
Oh, and I was transfered to Sicily after my convalescent leave was up. Tough duty included being the "on duty person" for the base "shopping bus. ("Yeah, no real malls around here. You ladies will have to settle for London, Paris, Rome, Vienna. Tough it out, you'll be rewarded in Heaven." I counted heads off and heads on. If the numbers weren't a match I'd call the Embassy then go have a cold one. Tough job, but somebody had to make that sacrifice.
 
If anyone else is wondering:

This is more about a particular way that he defines the word "myth", a word with different meanings depending on the context. Here, it doesn't necessarily mean "false."
Then it sounds like he's playing word games and is another in a long line of attention whores. Nothing to see here, move along
 
Then it sounds like he's playing word games and is another in a long line of attention whores. Nothing to see here, move along
Myth
Myth is a genre of folklore consisting primarily of narratives that play a fundamental role in a society. For scholars, this is totally different from the ordinary sense of the term myth, meaning a belief that is not true, as the veracity of a piece of folklore is entirely irrelevant to determining whether it constitutes a myth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom