Three "Myths" Atheists Believe - Bart Ehrman

This might be a good time to review the absurdity instead of contributing to it. The highlighting is my own.

It requires faith.
Due to a lack of empirical evidence for:

1. The Big Bang: ...

2. The Origin of Life (Abiogenesis): ...

3. The Emergence of Consciousness: ...
We know those have happened. We can still see the remnants of the big bang so, as you have already been told, there is actual evidence for it. We know that the conditions of the early universe were not compatible with life, so abiogenesis must have taken place. We know* that consciousness must gave emerged because a) we're conscious and b) see above.

*Or at least I do as I know I'm conscious. I merely assume that you are also conscious because I see no reason that I should be special. It's always possible that you aren't actually conscious, in which case you wouldn't actually know that consciousness has emerged.
All taken on faith. Because there is no empirical evidence for the HOW and WHY.
@Rusty Tyler started out saying all three things require faith due to a lack of empirical evidence.

Responding to @Mojo, however, he changed his tune. Facing the difficulty of insisting there is no empirical evidence for the emergence of his own consciousness, @Rusty Tyler quickly switched to saying there is no empirical evidence for the HOW and WHY of his own consciousness. Which might be easier than continuing to insist there is no empirical evidence for the fact of his own consciousness.

There is, however, a great deal more empirical evidence for the Big Bang and abiogenesis than there is for Rusty's own consciousness.

When I pointed out that Rusty accepts and even relies upon the reality of many real things, both arcane and mundane, without knowing their HOW or WHY, he tried to ignore the factual question of whether those things are real by hiding behind his obsession with HOW and WHY:
Are you planning to tell me why?

Or how for that matter.
Unless @Rusty Tyler was genuinely trying to deny the reality of GPS, fluorescent lights, neon signs, LED monitors, USB drives, DVD and Blu-ray players, solar cells, sunlight, MRI scanners, transistors, and digital cameras, that answer of his was an implicit admission that lots of things are real even though he doesn't understand their HOW or WHY.

Which means he has implicitly admitted that HOW and WHY are as irrelevant to the reality of the Big Bang or evolution as they are to the reality of fluorescent lights etc.

Explain the big bang. Where did it come from? And what caused it?
As it happens, I explained the big bang way back in April of 2014, in the "Quick Question on the beginning of the Universe" thread.

  1. FLRW solutions for a flat, expanding universe
  2. corrections, part 1
  3. corrections, part 2
Between the first and third of those posts, a number of knowledgeable folk contributed to elaborating that explanation.

The big bang is a mathematical singularity that arises when Einstein's general theory of relativity is used to model the large-scale evolution of the universe. Basically, the mathematical reality of the big bang comes down to the very real fact that FLRW models of an expanding universe cannot be extended indefinitely into the past.

If those models had no empirical support, the big bang would be a mathematical curiosity, and no one would care about it beyond citing the big bang as a failed prediction of Einstein's general theory of relativity. In reality, however, the big bang is one of relativity's many spectacularly successful predictions.

The physical reality of the big bang comes down to the very real fact that there is a great deal of empirical evidence in support of those models.

Rusty's problem is not only that (1) there is a great deal of empirical evidence for the big bang, but also that (2) Rusty doesn't understand that evidence and, most of all, (3) Rusty doesn't want to understand that evidence.
 
Are parallel universes possible?

If so, why not a physical and a spiritual realm?
(running in parallel - sort of)
Only the physical realm would be subject to time and space constraints.
Pure speculation, not fact - to defend obvious lies.

All analogies are flawed, but yours is worse. Our universe exists, and we know some of its properties. If another universe exists then it likely has 'similar' properties. The spirit world is an illogical fantasy. Of course it isn't subject to time and space constraints, because it's an invention of the human mind. Imagining something doesn't make it real, no matter how much you insist otherwise.
 
A list of myths atheists believe:

All of them.

EOF

Memo to self, read your posts before posting. DOH
My head was in a bad place when I posted this. Should have been "disbelieve".
Not just room. The supernatural doesn't exist by definition. Believing in something that cannot exist isn't faith, it's delusion.
"Well, you have to have faith."
 
@R. Ramjet: The Maori creation stuff is pretty good. It's both vague and authoritative-sounding,
and it doesn't futz around with how or why or Einstein etc. It explains without elucidating and it
arrives at light, land, and water, things we can all see. Who could ask for anything more satisfyingly
Neolithic?

It's better than the Norse version, which sounds rather mead-soaked to yerz trooly.
 
This might be a good time to review the absurdity instead of contributing to it. The highlighting is my own.




@Rusty Tyler started out saying all three things require faith due to a lack of empirical evidence.

Responding to @Mojo, however, he changed his tune. Facing the difficulty of insisting there is no empirical evidence for the emergence of his own consciousness, @Rusty Tyler quickly switched to saying there is no empirical evidence for the HOW and WHY of his own consciousness. Which might be easier than continuing to insist there is no empirical evidence for the fact of his own consciousness.

There is, however, a great deal more empirical evidence for the Big Bang and abiogenesis than there is for Rusty's own consciousness.

When I pointed out that Rusty accepts and even relies upon the reality of many real things, both arcane and mundane, without knowing their HOW or WHY, he tried to ignore the factual question of whether those things are real by hiding behind his obsession with HOW and WHY:

Unless @Rusty Tyler was genuinely trying to deny the reality of GPS, fluorescent lights, neon signs, LED monitors, USB drives, DVD and Blu-ray players, solar cells, sunlight, MRI scanners, transistors, and digital cameras, that answer of his was an implicit admission that lots of things are real even though he doesn't understand their HOW or WHY.

Which means he has implicitly admitted that HOW and WHY are as irrelevant to the reality of the Big Bang or evolution as they are to the reality of fluorescent lights etc.


As it happens, I explained the big bang way back in April of 2014, in the "Quick Question on the beginning of the Universe" thread.

  1. FLRW solutions for a flat, expanding universe
  2. corrections, part 1
  3. corrections, part 2
Between the first and third of those posts, a number of knowledgeable folk contributed to elaborating that explanation.

The big bang is a mathematical singularity that arises when Einstein's general theory of relativity is used to model the large-scale evolution of the universe. Basically, the mathematical reality of the big bang comes down to the very real fact that FLRW models of an expanding universe cannot be extended indefinitely into the past.

If those models had no empirical support, the big bang would be a mathematical curiosity, and no one would care about it beyond citing the big bang as a failed prediction of Einstein's general theory of relativity. In reality, however, the big bang is one of relativity's many spectacularly successful predictions.

The physical reality of the big bang comes down to the very real fact that there is a great deal of empirical evidence in support of those models.

Rusty's problem is not only that (1) there is a great deal of empirical evidence for the big bang, but also that (2) Rusty doesn't understand that evidence and, most of all, (3) Rusty doesn't want to understand that evidence.
And, if you don't like the Big Bang Theory, what's your explanation for the observed Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB) radiation?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom