Merged Thread to Discuss The Excellent Analysis of Jones latest paper

... The question remains now as it ever did.

What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911.
It is called dust, it really does burn. OMG, if they found jet fuel in the dust they would have 10 times the energy. WOW.

Paper has more energy than the dust tested by Jones, and his ban of paranoid conspiracy nuts. What if they found paper, they would think they had some super new explosive. You hooked up with a big pile of woo manufactured by Jones.

Paper beats thermite as a heat source. Sorry, but I took chemistry, and Jones paper's conclusion is nonsense.

Did you look at the paper, the energy of the chips don't match thermite. The best part, it takes 2,600 Tons of Thermite to beat the office fires in the towers before the collapse, then the fires burning after 911 were an order of magnitude larger. Who will check my math, Not Jones. Jones has a fantasy of thermite, and he faked the conclusion of his paper.

Funny, paper has more energy than thermite. And it burns at 430-450C, auto ignition.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/JetFuelandWoodBeatThermite.jpg
Jet fuel ten times the energy of thermite. Lucky they did not find jet fuel in the dust. Why we use gasoline instead of super nano thermite for our cars. Does anyone take physics? Jones has to hope you don't.
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/JonesHarritDelusion.jpg
Chips don't match the heat energy of thermite. The found, dust. Is Jones a chemist? Does Jones still say the USA caused the earthquake in Haiti?


Funny 2, Jones has Pulitzer prize winning conclusions, but no evidence. Why is there no Pulitzer after 11 years? Are there zero newspapers who will team with Jones to make history? The reality is, there are no Pulitzer for the kind of fantasy Jones has made up. Jones is very personable, but he has insane claims. Jones has a problem, he is in a politically biased state where he has to spread lies about undefined bad guys.
 
Hi Remo,

I'm sure you are aware that I am no scientist just an uneducated average Joe probably like most truthers ?

As far as I am aware thermite consists of two main ingredients, aluminium dust and rust ?

Bearing in mind the towers were clad from top to bottom with aluminium and the structure was made of steel which is prone to rust.

Why do you think it would be unusual to find aluminium and rust in the wtc dust ?

I would also like to ask you which of the locations did the thematic chip come from ?
 
On the one hand you argue the found traces of elemental Al so necessary for this composite to be considered 'thermitic material' or not, was due to 'mis-reading' data due to angles, vantage points, orientation - "at least in part from the aluminum pedestal that the chip is mounted on", data gained by 'inexperienced technicians' where "ordinary" scratching/friction [can] contaminate[ing] primer surface with aluminum".

On the other, you freely acknowledge that 'different specimens' tested by Harrit/Jones WERE ignited:["The chips they ignited in the DSC or under a flame were different specimens."] Which were reported by Harrit/Jones as energetic ignitions [ejections] producing iron rich spheroids. A known material result of thermitic reaction.

The question remains now as it ever did.

What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911.

remo,,

you seem to impressed by some vague idea of what the word "energetic" might mean, but apparently don't understand what it really means.

"Energetic" means nothing more, nothing less, than that they contain some amount of (chemical, in this case) energy that can get released by a chemical reaction.

You can test a hair from your head, and you will find that it is "energetic". You can pick up any bit of garbage from your bit and test it, and chances are it is "enegetic". You can scratch some paint from the wall, and be pretty sure it is "energetic".

There is nothing unusual at all about things being chemically energetic. In fact, almost all organic substances are "energetic".


Now Jeff Farrer put some chips in the DSC to measure just how energetic these are. Unfortunately, if he characterized them before the test, he forgot to include that in the paper, so we don't really know much about what they looked like, what elemental composition they had etc. But we know they had a gray layer, which the paper describes as iron oxide NOT mixed with much of anything else and thus inert (that means: Would not react chemically, is not energetic), and they had a red layer. The red layer in turn very probably consisted mainly of an organic matrix, into which small particles of minerals were mixed.
Now, do you remember what I said about organic materials a bit further up? Here's what I said:
almost all organic substances are "energetic"​
That's an important consideration. For example, a gram of epoxy, an organic polymer, releases about 25 Kilojoules of energy when you burn it.

Mark Basile, who many truthers think had replicated and confirmed the Harrit results, has quantified the red layer: According to his quantification, the red layer consists to >70% of the element carbon, and <5% of the elements that could, theoretically, make up thermite. So Mark Basile apparently has proven:
The proportion of organic material to thermite is 70:5 = 14:1 at best, perhaps worse (in fact, his quantification is consistent with an interpretation where easily 85% of his red layer is organic, 0% is thermite).

My hunch is that Basile's quantification is not quite precise, and that the proportions aren't quite so extreme, but an organic proportion of 50-75% for all chips is highly likely. Also, some chips have Aluminium and Iron contents that could, in theory, make up up to 10% thermite.



Back to Farrer. To repeat: He tested the energy content of red-gray chips by burning them in the DSC, and they consisted of
- a gray layer that was, as a firt approximation, half (50% by volume) of the chip
- Of the other 50%, the red layer,
- - 50-75% was organic material, which has a very high probability of being energetic
- - up to 10% could be speculated to be thermite, given the elemental composition, i.e. up to 2.5% Al (if you assume that all the Al was elemental - an unproven and highly unlikely assumption) and 7.5% iron oxide
- - the rest, 15-40%, was various mineral particles, uncharacterized. Some of this no doubt more iron oxide, and also silicon compounds, and possibly others.

Now if red and gray layer have both the same volume, the red layer would have less than 50% of the mass, because the organic material would have a lower density than the gray iron oxide layer. But let's be generous again and say the two layers are 50:50 by mass.

Then it follows that
- 25-37.5% of the entire chip are (that's a fact) combustible, "energetic" material
- At most <5% of the entire chip could be (that would be unproven speculation) thermite, also "energetic"
- The rest, 57.5-75%, of the chip would probably be inert (non-energetic)

Now if Farrer managed to get the maximum amount of thermit to burn, and only the thermite to burn (note: To only get the thermite to burn, he should have done the DSC experiment under an oxygen-free gas, such as pure nitrogen, but he didn't, he did it under air), and the thermite reaction proceded perfectly, how much energy would he have measured? That is easy to calculate:
Thermite is known to have an energy density of slightly under 4 kJ/g. Since no more than 5% of the chips' mass could have been thermite according to elemental composition, he would have measured <5% of the 4 kJ/g, that's <0.2 kJ/g.

What, on the other hand, if there really wasn't any thermite, and all Farrer did was burn the organic matrix? This, too, can be computed: You can look up energy densities of many many organic polymers, and you will find that they range from ca. 15 kJ/g to 40 kJ/g. Since ca. 25%-37.5% of the chip's mass was organic, you would thus measure anything from 3.7 to 15 kJ/g - provided the reaction is complete. That would be 18 to 75 times more energy than Farrer could have measured from thermite alone!!


What DID Farrer measure in fact?
His resulte for the four chips he measured were
1.5 kJ/g
3 kJ/g
4.5 kJ/g
7.5 kJ/g

So that's between 7.5 and 37.5 times as much measured energy than would theoretically possible from thermite if only thermite were responsible for the energy density.

In other words: At least between 87% and 97%, and up to 100%, of the energy that Farrer measured, of the DSC traces that he showed, and of the chemical and physical changes observed in the residue, must be attributed to the organic matrix, not thermite.

In deriving these numbers, all my assumptions were "thermite friendly". In reality, it is impossible that all the Al would be elemental, and it is impossible that the reaction procedes perfectly and yields the theoretical energy density of 4 kJ/g. Thus, at least perhaps 95-99% of the measured energy release must have come from organic combustion.

That is still theory.

In reality, there was no thermite reaction.




Now you may say: "But what about the iron-rich microspheres"?
Buddy, with <5% thermite in the chip, you'd end up with less than 2.5% elemental iron. Basile and Jones show a lot more that they deem "iron-rich".

What you forget is that most of your chip is iron-rich to start with: The gray layer really is originally steel!

Why do you find spheres? I don't know, I didn't do the experiment and so I am not responsible for it to have been done so incompetently. But what I calculated above proves that the "energetic" chips get almost all of their energy from something other than thermite.



So to answer your question "What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911": They are paint chips. Paint is usually some organic vehicle mixed with pigments. One typical organic vehicle material is epoxy - for example, the LaClede steel primer, with which the WTC floor trusses were painted, contains 71.5% by weight epoxy. Epoxy has an energy density of 25 kJ/g. So LaClede paint could be expected to have an energy density of over 15 kJ/g. A chip of LaClede paint on steel scale would then have perhaps 5 kJ/g - right in the range of what Farrer measured!
These unreacted "energetic" paint chips are in the dust, because that's what paint chips are! It is wholly unremarkable for organic substances to be energetic!
 
On the one hand you argue the found traces of elemental Al so necessary for this composite to be considered 'thermitic material' or not, was due to 'mis-reading' data due to angles, vantage points, orientation - "at least in part from the aluminum pedestal that the chip is mounted on", data gained by 'inexperienced technicians' where "ordinary" scratching/friction [can] contaminate[ing] primer surface with aluminum".

On the other, you freely acknowledge that 'different specimens' tested by Harrit/Jones WERE ignited:["The chips they ignited in the DSC or under a flame were different specimens."] Which were reported by Harrit/Jones as energetic ignitions [ejections] producing iron rich spheroids. A known material result of thermitic reaction.

The question remains now as it ever did.

What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911.
Iron rich spheres just like those in the paper can be found in the fly ash of municipal waste incinerators and coal combustors. Are you saying that coal and household waste contains thermite?

Why are you concentrating on one tiny aspect?

Why have you not commented on any of my analysis? I show comprehensively that the material is paint. Paint with a thin layer of oxidised steel forms iron rich microspheres when heated to high temperatures. So what?

Why not actually look at what the material is rather than what forms when it's heated? The material is a red layer consisting of an epoxy matrix with particles of iron oxide pigment and kaolin adhered to a thin layer of rust. That isn't thermite. Why get concerned about what happens to it when it burns around the temperature that epoxies react?

The material is clearly paint. Jones and Harrit are not interested in independent testing of their material. If they were they'd have already had a lab(s) confirm their findings and they would be the topic of conversation in every house, every bar and every university on the planet for months.
 
...
Jones and Harrit are not interested in independent testing of their material. If they were they'd have already had a lab(s) confirm their findings and they would be the topic of conversation in every house, every bar and every university on the planet for months.

Oh really?

Jones recently wrote:

ProfJones said:
I will say that after our paper was published, we went to another lab trying to get XRD patterns that would definitively resolve the question of whether elemental aluminum was present. But like Dr Farrer's TEM results, there was no clear pattern of ANY aluminum-bearing compound in the XRD results. These results have surprised me, not satisfied me. So we go to further experiments.
So Jones DID go to another, possibly independent lab.
He had it look specifically for what the Aluminium in the chips really is.
They used a competent method (XRD)
They didn't find any Aluminium.
More specifically, they didn't find any elemental Aluminium in the red-gray chips.
This negative result was never published!

Jones and friends have done competent experiments, at other labs even, but didn't like the results and thus did not publish them. That violates usual standards of scientific ethics. Researchers are expected to publish negative and inconclusive results as well as positive results. Not doing so gives the scientific community a biases, skewed picture of reality.

remo, please continue to urge Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and all the others to publish all their results ASAP!
The FTIR results
The TEM results
The XRD results!
All of them! Especially the negative results!
 
Last edited:
Oh really?

Jones recently wrote:


So Jones DID go to another, possibly independent lab.
He had it look specifically for what the Aluminium in the chips really is.
They used a competent method (XRD)
They didn't find any Aluminium.
More specifically, they didn't find any elemental Aluminium in the red-gray chips.
This negative result was never published!

Jones and friends have done competent experiments, at other labs even, but didn't like the results and thus did not publish them. That violates usual standards of scientific ethics. Researchers are expected to publish negative and inconclusive results as well as positive results. Not doing so gives the scientific community a biases, skewed picture of reality.

remo, please continue to urge Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and all the others to publish all their results ASAP!
The FTIR results
The TEM results
The XRD results!
All of them! Especially the negative results!

Since you obviously read Prof. Jones's response at 911Blogger.com, why not respond to the JREF questions he posed following the quote you mined?

Prof. Jones said:
"To the fellows at Jref, I wish to emphasize a few questions:

1. Why do iron-rich spheres appear in the residue of the red/gray chips following ignition in the DSC, which also provides a sharply-peaked heat trace? Do these results not imply SOME type of highly exothermic reaction, beyond that which can be reached by burning paint in air? That is -- where do the iron-rich spheres ( in the ignition residue) come from?

2. Our Figures 31,32 in the Active Thermitic Materials paper show multiple layers, and Fig. 33 shows the composition of the "light gray" layer. We published these results, and any future study of the WTC dust should also look for these multiple-layered red-gray chips. I intend to explore the dust once again for such multi-layered chips with the new (and skeptical) collaborating scientist.
Now my question to the Jref fellows: It is difficult to see how a "paint" applied to steel could result in such multiple-layered chips as we observed in the WTC dust and published -- have you attempted to account for the multiple-layered chips which we reported finding in the WTC dust? Millette does not mention them.

For further discussion on this point, see:
http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-07-06/us-patent-5505799-looks-manual... and my comments therein.
"



MM
 
MM: You seem to overlook that Oystein answered thoroughly (as is his habit:o) to this Jones' post and the answer was pasted by Zica on 911Blogger, Fri, 09/14/2012 - 11:00pm.

Prof. Jones has not reacted yet, as expected:rolleyes:
 
At the risk of drifting off topic...

Prof Jones:
But like Dr Farrer's TEM results, there was no clear pattern of ANY aluminum-bearing compound in the XRD results. These results have surprised me, not satisfied me. So we go to further experiments.
​
Does that mean that he's only satisfied if there's thermite? Shouldn't it be more satisfactory to know that there's no aluminium and thus no thermite at all, proving that there is no trace whatsoever of anything that helped the buildings fall?

Unless...
 
Sunstealer wrote: "If they were they'd have already had a lab(s) confirm their findings and they would be the topic of conversation in every house, every bar and every university on the planet for months."

Beachnut wrote (again): "Jones has Pulitzer prize winning conclusions, but no evidence. Why is there no Pulitzer after 11 years?"

It's rather off-topic in the thread on WTC paint chips, but the real discovery of tens of tons thermite in WTC would hardly end just with some debates in bars and/or Pulitzer Prize for Prof. Jones. Sooner or later, any hypothetical proof of CD of WTC would led to the lost of credit of the USA, to the deep political destabilization worldwide, and quite probably to the World War 3. Among others.

This was really off-topic, but for me, this is one of the numerous important reasons why red-gray chips from WTC dust are paints, to be on-topic again:o)
 
Since you obviously read Prof. Jones's response at 911Blogger.com, why not respond to the JREF questions he posed following the quote you mined?

MM

I completely and thoroughly answered all the questions already:

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8615302&postcount=1055

Since 911Blogger engages in total censorship and I can't post there, zica thankfully (but without text formatting, thus a bit difficult to read) copy&pasted it here:
http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses#comment-257580

Jones's response is here:
http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses#comment-257588
but it fails to answer the most important questions.

I in turn responded here:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=8623515&postcount=1078



Jones then dropped the ball.

He has not answered appropriately whether he understands now that his team looked at different kinds of red-gray chips.

His reply to the question of further primer paints ín the WTC is sophistry.

He ignores the problems with the DSC test, hoping that people will forget he is no longer sure the test was even done right.

Most importantly, he avoids a commitment to publish all their data, including the negative and inconclusive results, from FTIR, TEM and XRD testing. This is a violation of scientific ethics.
 
Today, Frank Legge chimes in:

http://www.911blogger.com/news/2012-09-08/letter-regarding-redgray-chip-analyses#comment-257750

Frank Legge said:
and not only that,

the existence of elemental aluminium in the red chips is proven by the formation of the microspheres in the DSC, largely iron. What else can start to rip the oxygen out of iron oxide at below 400 deg C, then have a runaway temperature increase at least to the melting point of iron?

Those who dispute this on the grounds that oxygen was present, and that the energy came from the combustion of organic material, must provide an explanation for why such special conditions are required in a blast furnace to produce iron. The idea that you could heat a little kaolin and coke and iron oxide to a mere 400 deg C and see it suddenly run away and produce molten iron is clearly a fantasy.
http://www.thepotteries.org/shelton/blast_furnace.htm

Thanks for the link, Frank.

It shows that CO starts to reduce Fe2O3 at 450 °C, Fe3O4 at 600°C, and FeO at 700 °C.

You are wrong to say youi heated the chips "to a mere 400 deg C". Please look at your own paper: The chips were heated slowly to 700 °C! I.e. hot enough to let CO reduce some iron oxides to FeO.

Now I am not saying this is what happened. How could I know? Dr. Farrer forgot to characterize the chips that he wasted in these experiments, so it would be wild speculation to guess what reactions were possible.

The organic matrix surely decomposed starting well under 400 °C, and apparently burned with air somewhere above 400 °C. It would depend very much on the composition of that organic matrix if it releases CO, or even hydrogen, under these circumstances.

What your team should have done to prove a thermite reaction is
a) Prove, and quantify, elemental Al in the specimen before putting them in the DSC. You didn't do that.
b) Prove, and perhaps quantify, Al-oxide after the test. You didn't do that.

Tillotson and Gash, for their paper that you refer to, and from which you showed the DSC trace in Fig 29 for comparison, didn't need to do step a) - they produced their nano-thermite from scratch, so they knew pretty well how much Al, Fe2O3 and organic material (10%) they had: Probably in the vicinity of 25% Al, 65% iron oxidede. But Tillotson and Gash analysed the residue with PXRD and found Al2O3. Frank, why didn't your team follow Tillotson's and Gash's lead and also look for Al2O3?

It must be noted, again, that while Tillotson and Gash knew their material was ca. 90% thermite, 10% organic, your team didn't know this in advance. Have you attempted to quantify the elemental compositions of the red layers? I think you would have found that they had typically roughly 70% organic material, but only perhaps 2.5% Al.

So your material hat 7 times as much organic matrix as Tillotson's, but they had 10 times more Al. The differences between both materials was 70-fold. Did you ever realize that? Did this concern you when you compared Tillotson's graph to Farrer's?

Have you realized by now that >98% of the energy and power that Farrer measured in the DSC must come from organic combustion, not thermite, since there was only such a small proportion of total Al (even if you unrealistically assume all the Al was elemental)?

In light of these realities, I think you should reconsider your opinion on how those spheres formed, and what they actually are.





(As always, I will submit this to 911Blogger, but don't expect to ever make it through their censorship)
 
remo,,

you seem to impressed by some vague idea of what the word "energetic" might mean, but apparently don't understand what it really means.

"Energetic" means nothing more, nothing less, than that they contain some amount of (chemical, in this case) energy that can get released by a chemical reaction.

You can test a hair from your head, and you will find that it is "energetic". You can pick up any bit of garbage from your bit and test it, and chances are it is "enegetic". You can scratch some paint from the wall, and be pretty sure it is "energetic".

There is nothing unusual at all about things being chemically energetic. In fact, almost all organic substances are "energetic".

By your definition, all substances are "energetic", since all matter is energy. :rolleyes:

Sorry, but this is just wrong. The definition of "energetic" in the context of chemical compounds means that it has the ability to release great amounts of energy in a short burst, creating an explosion or propulsion of some kind. Examples: explosives, pyrotechnic compositions, propellants and fuels.

Hair and paint don't do this, except perhaps in the fantasy world of 9/11 Beliebers.
 
By your definition, all substances are "energetic", since all matter is energy. :rolleyes:

Sorry, but this is just wrong. The definition of "energetic" in the context of chemical compounds means that it has the ability to release great amounts of energy in a short burst, creating an explosion or propulsion of some kind. Examples: explosives, pyrotechnic compositions, propellants and fuels.

Hair and paint don't do this, except perhaps in the fantasy world of 9/11 Beliebers.
What a cute word, beliebers. Did you get that with your moon size debris pile physics course? Is your chemistry as good as your physics? Oh yes

Paper has more energy than thermite. Feel free to present the joules released for thermite and paper. Take a look at wood, jet fuel, plastic.


Hair? Hair has 3.6 times the energy of thermite. Oops. There goes your energetic claptrap nonsense, and confirmation your chemistry is the same as your physics. Good luck with 11 years of solid failure.
 
By your definition, all substances are "energetic", since all matter is energy. :rolleyes:

Sorry, but this is just wrong. The definition of "energetic" in the context of chemical compounds means that it has the ability to release great amounts of energy in a short burst, creating an explosion or propulsion of some kind. Examples: explosives, pyrotechnic compositions, propellants and fuels.

Hair and paint don't do this, except perhaps in the fantasy world of 9/11 Beliebers.

Nonsense.

There was no explosion or anything like that in the experiments that Farrer, Jones etc. conducted. The chips reacted slowly over the course of many minutes.
 
Nonsense.

Are you suggesting that hair and paint can create explosive or propulsive events?

Oh wait, you are. :eye-poppi


There was no explosion or anything like that in the experiments that Farrer, Jones etc. conducted. The chips reacted slowly over the course of many minutes.

What were you expecting from chitps measuring less than a mm?

And you are incorrect. The chips reacted very quickly once ignited. It was a very brief, very dramatic exothermic event.
 
On the one hand you argue the found traces of elemental Al so necessary for this composite to be considered 'thermitic material' or not, was due to 'mis-reading' data due to angles, vantage points, orientation - "at least in part from the aluminum pedestal that the chip is mounted on", data gained by 'inexperienced technicians' where "ordinary" scratching/friction [can] contaminate[ing] primer surface with aluminum".

On the other, you freely acknowledge that 'different specimens' tested by Harrit/Jones WERE ignited:["The chips they ignited in the DSC or under a flame were different specimens."] Which were reported by Harrit/Jones as energetic ignitions [ejections] producing iron rich spheroids. A known material result of thermitic reaction.

The question remains now as it ever did.

What were unignited energetic material chips DOING in the Dust of 911.

To sum up Oystein's response in terms for the simplest layman:

Based upon Farrer's data, all of the energy released can be attributed to burning of the epoxy matrix, because the test was not done under an inert atmosphere, and no determination was made of the mass of the epoxy matrix.

The data do not support any energy being released as part of a thermitic reaction, as Farrer has not controlled his variables, as described above. The fact that much ferric oxide remained after the test further argues against any thermitic reaction.
 
...
And you are incorrect. The chips reacted very quickly once ignited. It was a very brief, very dramatic exothermic event.

You don't understand. The most dramatic thing here is your misinterpretation of the graphs. The "narrow" peaks are actually so wide it indicates a reaction time of many minutes. That was a slow smoulder.
 
Can anyone tell me or link me to the follow up work of the Bentham paper.

The reason I ask is because paragraph 10 of the conclusion mentions more tests need to be carried out.

Thanks
 
Can anyone tell me or link me to the follow up work of the Bentham paper.

The reason I ask is because paragraph 10 of the conclusion mentions more tests need to be carried out.

Thanks

As far as follow up work by the authors of the Bentham paper is concerned:
  • Page 28 mentions FTIR tests that they allegedly had already done at the time and would publish elsewhere - never been published
  • The Opening Post of this thread at 911Blogger by Steven Jones repeats that they have done TEM-tests, but these have never been published. But: "[Farrer] did not see a pattern demonstrating that aluminum was in a form he recognized by this method, which surprised us" - i.e. no elemental Al found
  • Jones reveals in a comment to the above post that they had XRD-tests done by another lab, which also failed to find elemental Al - again, these results have never been published
Others - informally published
Future studies:
  • There is talk that Mark Basile, with the help of Rick Shadduck (spelling?) is trying to collect funds and commission another independent (forensic?) lab to replicate the study and do a new analysis of red-gray chips. This has been hinted at since at least february in blogs, but I haven't heard about any progress.
  • And now, ProfJones reports about an anonymous researcher who wants to do DSC and XRD tests (among others) and is seeking advice. That's what his post at 911Blogger that I linked to above is about.




I think this is a complete list of all studies, published, unpublished and contemplated, on that matter.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom