The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

As religion declines in America (As you say), we have had
1.) Abolition of slavery
2.) Civil rights
3.) Women's Rights
4.) Rights for Homosexuals
5.) A push for improved health care for all
6.) improved environmental standards and care for the environment
7.) concern and care against sposual abuse
8.) Exposure of and work towards elliminating child abuse and molestation.
9.) increased availablility of public education and higher education.
10.) Improved discoveries of medical care.
11.) Improved methods for food development, increasing our ability to feed millions.
12.) Improved methods on avoiding pestilence and outbreaks through better health care plans.
13.) The ability to communicate with millions, instantaneously.


If these are the kinds of "declines" you see with declining christianity, then I think it's a societal decline that I fully welcome and endorse.

ETA: I wonder which of these you think are "amoral" changes?

+1
 
Did you miss the part I bolded, underlined and italicized?

Same approximate age, Doc, means...well...SAME APPROXIMATE AGE. Sure, they all have the same belief, but they're of the SAME APPROXIMATE AGE.

Well all the Christians for the last 2000 years have been the same approximate age while they were alive on earth.

Bottom line there is at least 3 explanations for the "generation" issue:

http://www.biblestudy.org/basicart/was-jesus-wrong-about-his-second-coming.html

This along with the fact Jesus told his apostles to go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature which in my mind would take longer than 30 years; and the fact that Jesus said no man or Himself knows the day or the hour of the end {Only The Father knows} is reason for me not to give too much weight to this issue. If other people want to make a issue of it so be it.
 
Well... yeah.
Jesus (and the gospel writers that most likely put words in his mouth) had little understanding of how big the world really was.
So they didn't know about Egypt and Ethiopia (whom Moses fought against according to Josephus) and Rome and Spain (where Paul eventually wanted to go) and India (where Thomas preached) and Greece and Gaul (where Mary Magelline was rumored to go)?
 
So they didn't know about Egypt and Ethiopia (whom Moses fought against according to Josephus) and Rome and Spain (where Paul eventually wanted to go) and India (where Thomas preached) and Greece and Gaul (where Mary Magelline was rumored to go)?

I see you forgot that the world also contains:
Northa and South America, Australia, ...
 
Well all the Christians for the last 2000 years have been the same approximate age while they were alive on earth.
This has to be an attempt at humour, because this can't be a serious riposte, you old Malagasy joker, you!

Bottom line there is at least 3 explanations for the "generation" issue:

http://www.biblestudy.org/basicart/was-jesus-wrong-about-his-second-coming.html
You are correct, there are at least 3, since you seem to be ignoring the obvious one.
 
The apostles did see the Kingdom of God when the saw the resurrected Christ. Have you ever heard the term "Christ the King". There are even many parochial schools with the name "Christ the King". Once Christ was risen the Kingdom had begun.

Since you seem to be banking on a rather ambiguous, and thus freely interpreted deinition of the "Kingdom of God" in the quote from Luke, let's take a look at the parallel verses in Matthew (Mt. 16:27, 28):

For the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father, and then he will repay every man for what he has done. Truly I say to you, there are some standing here who will not taste death before they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.

Now, you could argue that "the Son of man coming in his kingdom" doesn't refer to the just previous statement that "the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father and then he will repay every man fo wat he has done." However, that would be a case of special pleading. Indeed, "the Son of man coming in his kingdom" does refer back to the Son o man coming with his angels and repaying every man for what he has done (i.e. the Last Judgment), meaning that Matthew has Jesus saying the Second Coming would occir in the lifetime of his own generation.

Let us also consider what Jesus says regarding when the Apocalypse will take place. After relating the horrors of the end-times and saying the people would see (Mt. 24:30b) "the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory," and that he would send out his angles to gather in the elect, Jesus says (Mt. 24:34):

Truly, I say to you, this generation will not pass away till all these things take place.

Despite rationalizations on the part of evangelical scholars that "generation" really meant a people, in this case the jewish people, in reality the word is indeed "generation," and he meant that the world would end in his own generation

Or, again, we have what Jesus tells Caiaphas, the High Priest, in Mt. 26;64 in response to the question of wether or not he is the Christ, the Son of God:

Jesus said to him, "You have said so. But I tell you, hearafter you will see the Son of man seated at the rigt hand of Power and coming in the clouds of heaven."

I can give you more examples if you wish. The fact is, the New Testament says in spades that the world would end in the generation of Jesus, i.e. at least by the end of the first century.
 
Well... yeah.
Jesus (and the gospel writers that most likely put words in his mouth) had little understanding of how big the world really was.


So they didn't know about Egypt and Ethiopia (whom Moses fought against according to Josephus) and Rome and Spain (where Paul eventually wanted to go) and India (where Thomas preached) and Greece and Gaul (where Mary Magelline was rumored to go)?



As I said in the part you left out, they knew about the Roman world. That does include Greece, Gaul and Spain and Rome, of course (although that there is no evidence that the writers themselves were that familiar with the details).


And, as you yourself just demonstrating, it was at least, in the plan, conceivable, for the generation in question to bring the message to the furtherest corners of the world they knew.


You will notice how there is no mention South Africa. Or Iceland. Or Siberia or Japan or the South-East Asia. Not to mention Australia or the Americas.

The Roman Mediterranean world. The whole world they knew.


I also want to point out that legends dating from after the time of the gospels, such as Thomas' adventures are irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
As religion declines in America (As you say), we have had
1.) Abolition of slavery
2.) Civil rights
3.) Women's Rights
4.) Rights for Homosexuals
5.) A push for improved health care for all
6.) improved environmental standards and care for the environment
7.) concern and care against sposual abuse
8.) Exposure of and work towards elliminating child abuse and molestation.
9.) increased availablility of public education and higher education.
10.) Improved discoveries of medical care.
11.) Improved methods for food development, increasing our ability to feed millions.
12.) Improved methods on avoiding pestilence and outbreaks through better health care plans.
13.) The ability to communicate with millions, instantaneously.


If these are the kinds of "declines" you see with declining christianity, then I think it's a societal decline that I fully welcome and endorse.

ETA: I wonder which of these you think are "amoral" changes?

And I think it's worth noting that a belief in fundamental Christianity directly militates against Number 6, since if the world is destined by God to end in a flash of fire and everyone on it will be spirited away to some place or another, what reason do you have to care for the environment? Its destruction just hastens the coming of the Kingdom.
 
Well all the Christians for the last 2000 years have been the same approximate age while they were alive on earth.

I have to hand it to you Doc. That's a pretty amazing hurdle you completely failed to jump through.

As has been quoted in a different thread (thanks Headscratcher):

'When I use a word,' Humpty Dumpty said in rather a scornful tone, 'it means just what I choose it to mean - neither more nor less.'

Lewis Carroll
 
Well all the Christians for the last 2000 years have been the same approximate age while they were alive on earth.

Wow. Your mental twists and gyrations are simply amazing. Are you sure you're not a contortionist?
 
Kingdoms are an amoral form of government. Jesus' support of this concept is as poor as his condoning of slavery.

You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery. I want you to think about this, "every man is a slave to sin until Jesus sets them free!"
 
You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery. I want you to think about this, "every man is a slave to sin until Jesus sets them free!"

You must have completely not even read this post by Joobz...
Joobz said:
As religion declines in America (As you say), we have had
1.) Abolition of slavery
2.) Civil rights
3.) Women's Rights
4.) Rights for Homosexuals
5.) A push for improved health care for all
6.) improved environmental standards and care for the environment
7.) concern and care against sposual abuse
8.) Exposure of and work towards elliminating child abuse and molestation.
9.) increased availablility of public education and higher education.
10.) Improved discoveries of medical care.
11.) Improved methods for food development, increasing our ability to feed millions.
12.) Improved methods on avoiding pestilence and outbreaks through better health care plans.
13.) The ability to communicate with millions, instantaneously.


If these are the kinds of "declines" you see with declining christianity, then I think it's a societal decline that I fully welcome and endorse.

ETA: I wonder which of these you think are "amoral" changes?


ETA: I wonder if you consider child abuse a sin?
 
Last edited:
You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery. I want you to think about this, "every man is a slave to sin until Jesus sets them free!"
What a load of crap, is that the best you can come up with. That still doesn't answer why the bible and you so-called loving Jesus wasn't against slavery.

Paul

:) :) :)
 
kurious_kathy said:
You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery. I want you to think about this, "every man is a slave to sin until Jesus sets them free!"

And then that man is a slave to Jesus until logic sets him free.
 
Since you seem to be banking on a rather ambiguous, and thus freely interpreted deinition of the "Kingdom of God" in the quote from Luke, let's take a look at the parallel verses in Matthew (Mt. 16:27, 28):

For the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father, and then he will repay every man for what he has done. Truly I say to you, there are some standing here who will not taste death before they see the Son of man coming in his kingdom.

Now, you could argue that "the Son of man coming in his kingdom" doesn't refer to the just previous statement that "the Son of man is to come with his angels in the glory of his Father and then he will repay every man fo wat he has done." However, that would be a case of special pleading. Indeed, "the Son of man coming in his kingdom" does refer back to the Son o man coming with his angels and repaying every man for what he has done (i.e. the Last Judgment), meaning that Matthew has Jesus saying the Second Coming would occir in the lifetime of his own generation.

Let us also consider what Jesus says regarding when the Apocalypse will take place. After relating the horrors of the end-times and saying the people would see (Mt. 24:30b) "the Son of man coming in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory," and that he would send out his angles to gather in the elect, Jesus says (Mt. 24:34):

Truly, I say to you, this generation will not pass away till all these things take place.

Despite rationalizations on the part of evangelical scholars that "generation" really meant a people, in this case the jewish people, in reality the word is indeed "generation," and he meant that the world would end in his own generation

Or, again, we have what Jesus tells Caiaphas, the High Priest, in Mt. 26;64 in response to the question of wether or not he is the Christ, the Son of God:

Jesus said to him, "You have said so. But I tell you, hearafter you will see the Son of man seated at the rigt hand of Power and coming in the clouds of heaven."

I can give you more examples if you wish. The fact is, the New Testament says in spades that the world would end in the generation of Jesus, i.e. at least by the end of the first century.

Tim could you reference exact verses you are stating? I am especially concerned with your second paragraph as we must all be careful not to take scripture out of context or things get misunderstood.
 
Last edited:
You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery. I want you to think about this, "every man is a slave to sin until Jesus sets them free!"

And once again, we see why KK is the absolutely worst person to convert people on the JREF board. Kathy, if you are serious about wanting to convert people you would leave and send someone else to take your place. Someone who hasn't dug herself into a hole so deep that she cannot climb out of it.
 
Tim could you reference exact verses you are stating?

He gave you book, chapter, and verse. What more do you want, GPS coordinates?

I am especially concerned with your second paragraph as we must all be careful not to take scripture out of context or things get misunderstood.

Translation: Only my interpretation/excuse is the correct one.
 
kurious_kathy said:
Tim could you refernce exact verses you are stating? I am especially concerned with your second paragraph as we must all be careful not to take scripture out of context or things get misunderstood.

He did give specific references. Maybe you missed them? They're the things saying stuff like "Matthew 16: 27, 28."
And by "things getting misunderstood" you mean "taken a way I don't like."
 
Tim could you reference exact verses you are stating? I am especially concerned with your second paragraph as we must all be careful not to take scripture out of context or things get misunderstood.

How completely bizarre. Tim has already cited the exact verses: Matt 16:27-28.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom