The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

We are called to contend for the faith so we must stand against false teachings and heresy when we see it. If that's technically judging then I'm doing it for the right reasons, so many more can come to a saving knowledge of Christ.

Yes that's judging because you are making the determination as to when something is false teachings or heresy. So it's OK because you're doing it for the right (as determined by you -- more judging) reasons?
 
Ethnikos
The rapture was around in 999 AD.

References?
From Kirkus Reviews
In this lively, absorbing ``saga'' of Europe (which, the author makes clear, is as much imaginative re-creation as history) at the end of the last millennium, Reston (Galileo, 1994, etc.) depicts a turbulent Europe as expectant of an imminent apocalypse as are today's doomsayers.
Here is something that I got a hit on right away with on Google.
http://www.amazon.com/Last-Apocalypse-Europe-Year-D/dp/product-description/0385483368
I read about the year 1000 expectation a few years ago and can not remember where I had found it, but I can assure you that it exists, you know, there was an actual historical event. I do not remember the details but I found it very interesting and slightly disturbing, so I remembered it.
 
Hmm, destroying those who disagree with you...

Looks like it's time for another token Hitler reference. Just for good measure, I'm going to throw Stalin, Genghis Khan, and Pol Pot out there too.

Not near as much fun as you might think. After the Strurm und Drang there's nothing left to do but buy another game.
 
What I think is true is, Everyone on this planet who ever gets saved, are saved because of what Jesus did and what Jesus is doing now, no matter what they may believe it is that is saving them.
Based on that (which may only work for me), the less obstruction from that truth that you can have, the better.
Please identify three people who have been "saved"

Please identify three people who have been 'lost' (or whatever is the antonym for 'saved')

TYIA :)
 
Do you always fantasize about the total destruction of those who disagree with you?
Not with me, but with the clear dictates of God, as in do not commit idolatry. My fantasy would be that people will wake up to the impending crises before it is too late.
Even if you do not want to or have a rational aversion to believing in an unknowable god, don't worry. He knows that. Examine what you can see and what you can prove. Ask yourself, is this an idol? If there was a god, would this idol prevent me from being found favorably by such a god? No one owns a monopoly on god. They can not name him or contain him or prevent anyone from accessing him. First comes prophecy and you are the prophet.

Joshua 24:19-20 . . .Ye cannot serve the LORD: for he is an holy God; he is a jealous God; he will not forgive your transgressions nor your sins. If ye forsake the LORD, and serve strange gods, then he will turn and do you hurt, and consume you,. . .

We are not up to doing anything for God, but would be doing well just to not be worshiping some other god.

Hebrews 9:26b but now once in the end of the world hath he appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself.

What happened at the Crucifixion of Christ was a foreshadowing of what will happen at the absolute end, and a warning about how those who abused him will be punished. They will be brought back to life to witness Jesus returning, just in time to share in the destruction of the wicked of the world.

Matthew 13:49 So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just,

Strangely enough Jesus tells the parable of the wheat and the tares, and the tares are burnt before the wheat is gathered. In terms of the end time, that would seem to go directly against the notion of a pre-trib rapture.
 
Last edited:
Not with me, but with the clear dictates of God,

In my experience, the dictates of God have been often self-contradictory or vague.

as in do not commit idolatry. My fantasy would be that people will wake up to the impending crises before it is too late.
Even if you do not want to or have a rational aversion to believing in an unknowable god, don't worry. He knows that. Examine what you can see and what you can prove.

You can prove nothing that supports the existence of God.

Ask yourself, is this an idol? If there was a god, would this idol prevent me from being found favorably by such a god?

Is what an idol? You mentioned no idols earlier. But now that we're on the subject, the Christian church claims that many things are idolatry; basically, anything that takes your spare time away from them, especially any activities that generate cash.

No one owns a monopoly on god. They can not name him or contain him or prevent anyone from accessing him.

And yet this is exactly the Christian church's stand: that no one else can find God without their help.

Fist comes prophecy and you are the prophet.

What?

Joshua 24:19-20 . . .Ye cannot serve the LORD: for he is an holy God; he is a jealous God; he will not forgive your transgressions nor your sins.

And yet Catholics practice confession, and one of the main tenets of the Christian faith is that asking for forgiveness absolves you of your sins.

If ye forsake the LORD, and serve strange gods, then he will turn and do you hurt, and consume you,. . .

So he's vindictive and possessive.

We are not up to doing anything for God, but would be doing well just to not be worshiping some other god.

Why not? There is no proof that God will hurt you if you worship others. Whereas my own deity, the Great Priest of the Old Ones, Cthulhu, has devoured the minds and bodies of thousands.

Hebrews 9:26b but now once in the end of the world hath he appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself.

This directly contradicts your previous quote, which said that God would never forgive sin.

What happened at the Crucifixion of Christ was a foreshadowing of what will happen at the absolute end,

How so?

and a warning about how those who abused him will be punished. They will be brought back to life to witness Jesus returning, just in time to share in the destruction of the wicked of the world.

Again, sheer vindictiveness on God's part.

Matthew 13:49 So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just,

Strangely enough Jesus tells the parable of the wheat and the tares, and the tares are burnt before the wheat is gathered. In terms of the end time, that would seem to go directly against the notion of a pre-trib rapture.

Same old arguments, same old rebuttals. :cs:
 
Seriously, Kathy or Ethnikos, can either of you respond to the title of this thread without quoting scripture ("My religion is right/better because the bible says so" is a circular argument) or the standard christian sales pitch?
Straight up, Ethnikos, why is your religion more real than any other religion?
Why should I choose your god over the Inivisible Pink Unicorn?
Unlike your unicorn, Jesus is visible. That's why there is a Jesus in the first place, to make God approachable. Look at post #1458. This guy, D, who is my cousin by marriage saw Jesus. This is not just someone's imagination at work but Jesus coming to him in reality. This is not an isolated incident. This happens over and over. He was shot through the center of his body and had to have back to back surgeries. First to remove half his liver and then to remove half his stomach. It is a miracle the guy is alive and Jesus appeared to him and gave him the will to live and told him his life has a purpose. Here's a purpose. His brother told their sister I posted D's story. I brought it up for her on her laptop and she cried when she read it.
I posted a little story about myself being a recipient of a miracle, a while back on this thread. I do not have photos or anything as proof but I died. I had something happen that I knew was possible and that I would need to be rushed to a hospital when it did, or die. Well, when it did happen I was alone and did not make it. I knew it was the end and as I lied there I fealt my life slip away before the nothingness. I was shocked the next day when I got up off the floor and not only was I alive but healed.
Why would God do that? Why did God preserve D.? It could be that God needs no better reason than for us to testify to God's reality and to God's power.
I also gave some examples on the powerlessness of prayer thread of how my life had been saved a few times. There are more stories that I did not get around to but I concentrated on the ones where obviously something strange was going on, like the people who helped me apparently coming out of nowhere and going off in a very not normal way.
I also know demons exist and have seen them or in another case seen what it was doing, while the demon itself was not visible, as in watching my friend being picked up and thrown into a big fire, then thrown back out.
I also had a vision of hell, but not the lake of fire part that is probably what KK was a witness to, but the area that would be similar to the rich man and Lazarus parable.
All these things I write about are very real to me and if an angel appears and speaks to me, I do not get alarmed but follow its instructions.
 
Last edited:
Same old arguments, same old rebuttals. :cs:

Hebrews 9:26b but now once in the end of the world hath he appeared to put away sin by the sacrifice of himself.

This directly contradicts your previous quote, which said that God would never forgive sin.
He didn't. Why do you think Jesus had to die?
Well he didn't have to but did it because he loves you.

First comes prophecy, and you are the prophet.
What?
Ask Jesus for the Spirit of Prophecy, then you will know. Jesus went to a lot of trouble, like living and dieing, to be able to give this to you. This is the Spirit who brings understanding.
 
Last edited:
He didn't. Why do you think Jesus had to die?
Well he didn't have to but did it because he loves you.


It has probably been asked already, but exactly what connects the death of Jesus to my sins? Now, if Jesus had offered to burn in Hell on my behalf, I could understand, but he didn't. He just died. And it wasn't even a real death. He got a full do-over and, eventually, a kick-ass rock musical.

So how does the forgiveness for all my sins fit into that?
 
We are called to contend for the faith so we must stand against false teachings and heresy when we see it. If that's technically judging then I'm doing it for the right reasons, so many more can come to a saving knowledge of Christ.

We are at the end of the church age and Jesus warned there would be many wolves in sheeps clothing! I would encourage everyone to believe on the Lord Jesus and be saved, but start at Calvary where He died so we could live!

But you base your contention on false teachings. You spew hate and intellectual and emotional violence on others, all in the name of a god who abuses those who follow him. Where is the right reasoning in that? Or are you following Saul Alinsky's claim that a lie in the name of the revolution is no sin?

Personally, it might be easier to follow what you have to say, Kathy, if we could see anything positive in a "saving knowledge of Christ." I would question that we are at the end of the Church Age, given how wrong you have been about so much, but if you want us to follow you to Calvary, you might want to show us just what kind of a person that kind of path creates.

As it stands, what we see is racism, bigotry, homophobia, deception, abuse, cruelty, hate, cowardice, childishness, bathos, banality, rudeness, contempt, condescension, and ignorance.

When you can show you have anything better to offer, that might be worth listening to.

And, Ethnikos: It's far too easy to blame Satan. Where's your personal responsibility, or anyone else's, in your personal view? How come it's Satan that gets all the blame? At what point do people accept responsibility for their own evils, and take action to correct that? Sorry, but while the Prince of Lies may deserve blame in your view, the greatest lie is that he is solely responsible for the evil we do. We're quite competent in that regard without any further coaching needed.
 
Ethnikos said:
Unlike your unicorn, Jesus is visible.

Unless you count seeing images of Jesus in your ketchup, no he's not. Give a specific example when Jesus showed himself to more than one person at a time.

That's why there is a Jesus in the first place, to make God approachable. Look at post #1458. This guy, D, who is my cousin by marriage saw Jesus. This is not just someone's imagination at work but Jesus coming to him in reality. This is not an isolated incident. This happens over and over.

If Jesus wants to be approachable he should have stayed human rather than presuming to sacrifice himself. And yes, it is just his imagination at work. Just because it isn't isolated doesn't mean it's real. Mass delusion, crowd hallucination, etc.

He was shot through the center of his body and had to have back to back surgeries. First to remove half his liver and then to remove half his stomach. It is a miracle the guy is alive and Jesus appeared to him and gave him the will to live and told him his life has a purpose.

Claiming that someone surviving getting shot is a miracle is an insult to the families of all the people whose relatives died from gunshot wounds. And many accounts have been given of various people hallucinating during near-death situations.

Here's a purpose. His brother told their sister I posted D's story. I brought it up for her on her laptop and she cried when she read it.

What purpose is that?

I posted a little story about myself being a recipient of a miracle, a while back on this thread. I do not have photos or anything as proof but I died.

Then you wouldn't be posting here, would you now?

I had something happen that I knew was possible and that I would need to be rushed to a hospital when it did, or die. Well, when it did happen I was alone and did not make it. I knew it was the end and as I lied there I fealt my life slip away before the nothingness. I was shocked the next day when I got up off the floor and not only was I alive but healed.

What was this thing that happened? And again, if you had truly died you wouldn't be here now.

Why would God do that? Why did God preserve D.? It could be that God needs no better reason than for us to testify to God's reality and to God's power.

Why did God let the millions of other people die?

I also gave some examples on the powerlessness of prayer thread of how my life had been saved a few times. There are more stories that I did not get around to but I concentrated on the ones where obviously something strange was going on, like the people who helped me apparently coming out of nowhere and going off in a very not normal way.

The kindness of strangers, while a fine thing, is not a miracle. And perhaps you could describe how they "came out of nowhere and went off in a very not normal way."

I also know demons exist and have seen them or in another case seen what it was doing, while the demon itself was not visible, as in watching my friend being picked up and thrown into a big fire, then thrown back out.

Describe the appearance of the demons you did see, as well as the exact situation when your friend was thrown into and out of a fire. Don't just say that it was a demon when you have no proof.

I also had a vision of hell, but not the lake of fire part that is probably what KK was a witness to, but the area that would be similar to the rich man and Lazarus parable.

Is that the one where the rich man looks up from the specifically unnamed tortures of Hell and asks Lazarus for help? The "tortures" the rich man experiences are not specifically given, so what exactly did you see?

All these things I write about are very real to me and if an angel appears and speaks to me, I do not get alarmed but follow its instructions.

Has this ever happened, and have you seen a psychiatrist about it if you have?

Okay, next post.

Ethnikos said:
He didn't. Why do you think Jesus had to die?
Well he didn't have to but did it because he loves you.

This does not countermand my argument. You say that Jesus died because he loved us. It does not change the fact that the earlier quote says that God does not forgive sins, even though Jesus died so that our sins could be forgiven.

<snip>
Ask Jesus for the Spirit of Prophecy, then you will know. Jesus went to a lot of trouble, like living and dieing, to be able to give this to you. This is the Spirit who brings understanding.

Oh good God, not this one again. I can't tell you how many times I've explained this: THIS IS CIRCULAR EFFING LOGIC. You are saying, "Believe in Jesus. Then you will believe in Jesus."
 
<some snippage>

The true God is pointing out that He is not like other gods and He has in mind what He wants to do, and it will not be prevented by the opinion of someone thinking they have any sort of power of their own to change it, by way of using such devices as imagined by the Egyptians.


He is wrong.
 
Just that Judea-Christian mythology and legends state Jesus/God/The Holy Ghost showed Himself/Itself, He must be real.

This is ridiculous not only because many, many other religions, too, have gods and goddesses that reportedly showed themselves, but because if we are to trust anecdotal evidence, we must also believe in dragons, trolls, Oni, witches, ghosts, "greys", Bigfoot, and other phenomenon that many people state they've seen. Odin was last seen leading a charge in the Battle of Lena in 1012. I guess that means he, too, is real?

Not to mention the huge number of other ordinary people like Jesus who achieved godhood in the eyes of their admirers: Mazu, Elvis Presley, Kim jong-il and Kim il-sung, the Emperor of Japan during WWII, the Pharaohs, and the list goes on.
 
Look at post #1458. This guy, D, who is my cousin by marriage saw Jesus. This is not just someone's imagination at work but Jesus coming to him in reality. This is not an isolated incident. This happens over and over. He was shot through the center of his body and had to have back to back surgeries. First to remove half his liver and then to remove half his stomach. It is a miracle the guy is alive and Jesus appeared to him and gave him the will to live and told him his life has a purpose.
And lots of Muslims have the same story, except it's Muhammed who comes to them. And Jews get visited by JHWH, Buddhists get visited by the Buddha, Sikhs get visited by a Guru, Hindus are visited by, well, any one of a thousand manifestations of their God.

What you describe is a Near Death Experience, and what people see during an NDE is directly related to their cultural and religious upbringing.

I posted a little story about myself being a recipient of a miracle, a while back on this thread. I do not have photos or anything as proof but I died. I had something happen that I knew was possible and that I would need to be rushed to a hospital when it did, or die. Well, when it did happen I was alone and did not make it. I knew it was the end and as I lied there I fealt my life slip away before the nothingness. I was shocked the next day when I got up off the floor and not only was I alive but healed.
Why would God do that? Why did God preserve D.? It could be that God needs no better reason than for us to testify to God's reality and to God's power.
I also gave some examples on the powerlessness of prayer thread of how my life had been saved a few times. There are more stories that I did not get around to but I concentrated on the ones where obviously something strange was going on, like the people who helped me apparently coming out of nowhere and going off in a very not normal way.
I also know demons exist and have seen them or in another case seen what it was doing, while the demon itself was not visible, as in watching my friend being picked up and thrown into a big fire, then thrown back out.
I also had a vision of hell, but not the lake of fire part that is probably what KK was a witness to, but the area that would be similar to the rich man and Lazarus parable.
All these things I write about are very real to me and if an angel appears and speaks to me, I do not get alarmed but follow its instructions.
All of which is very interesting, but completely irrelevant. Why should anyone believe any of what you just wrote?

Let me try to explain why that long diatribe you just posted is worthless as a witnessing tool, particularly on this forum.

You believed your cousin by marriage, D, when he told you his story. But why did you believe him? Well, probably because you already believed in God, and Jesus, so he was telling you something that you were already primed to believe. But he had no evidence to offer you that he genuinely experienced such an event, you just took him at his word.

Now, you come here and tell us this same story. Only this time it's a second hand story, a retelling of an uncorroboratable event, that may not have happened, and if it did was almost certainly a Near Death Experience, which have been shown to vary due to a person's religious beliefs, and also to be a natural function of a Human brain during oxygen deprivation. In addition, you're telling this evidentially challenged second hand story to a group of skeptics!

Then you tell us that you were dead, and then brought back to life, but admit that you have absolutely no evidence to back up this story.

Just what on Earth do you hope to achieve? Nobody here is the slightest bit impressed with these stories.

You might impress people on Christian forums with your stories, but here we ask for evidence, laugh at anecdote, and, more importantly, understand Human biology and psychology.

So when you say that you died and that Jesus brought you back to life, I believe that you honestly believe that. When you tell us that you cousin D was shot and only survived because Jesus appeared to him and told him to hang on, I believe that both you and D believe that to be true.

Unfortunately, what people believe to be true, and what is actually true are often completely unrelated. So unless you have any evidence, your stories are completely worthless, regardless of how much you believe them to be true.
 
We are called to contend for the faith so we must stand against false teachings and heresy when we see it.

Well it's not much of a stand. I am a world-famous heretic, right here on the forum, and you've had me on ignore forever.

* suddenly realises the true meaning of futility *


If that's technically judging then I'm doing it for the right reasons, so many more can come to a saving knowledge of Christ.

Circular reasoning seems to figure prominently in many of your posts.

It's only your own judgement that tells you that the reasons for which you judge people are the right reasons. Or something.


We are at the end of the church age . . .

Kewl.


. . . and Jesus warned there would be many wolves in sheeps clothing!

Grr!


I would encourage everyone to believe on the Lord Jesus and be saved, but start at Calvary where He died so we could live!

Yeah, you would. Nobody is buying it though. What IS one to think?

BTW, how do you explain the people who managed to live! before this event of which you speak? I posit that it was because their belief systems contained more truth than christianity does.
 
Last edited:
...the Christians can gleefully enjoy all the horrors of the Apocalypse, because God will have already raptured them into heaven before it begins to get nasty. From on high, they will look down on the sufferings of us heathen with great satisfaction.

Do you suppose they will get popcorn and Milk-Duds?


Unlike your unicorn, Jesus is visible.

:dio: Where?
 
And Jesus warned us that the Kingdom of Heaven would be established before all the crucifixion witnesses died. Looks like Jesus doesn't have that good of a track record when it comes to predicting things.
Nowhere does the bible say the Kingdom of Heaven would be established before all crucifixion witnesses died. You are probably referring to Christ saying this "generation" shall not pass before all is fulfilled. Generation is a term that has several meanings. See this site:

http://www.mountainretreatorg.net/faq/generation.shtml

Jesus also says no one, even the Son, knows the day or the hour of the end, only the Father {God, the Father}

He also said the gospel must be preached in all the world and then the end will come.

Matthew 24;14

And this gospel of the kingdom shall be preached in all the world for a witness unto all nations; and then shall the end

By saying this he implied it was a very long way off in the future. Even today there are many people around the world who never even heard the name Jesus. So until everyone has had a chance to hear the gospel the end won't come if we are to believe Jesus.
 
Last edited:
Nowhere does the bible say the Kingdom of Heaven would be established before all crucifixion witnesses died. You are probably referring to Christ saying this "generation" shall not pass before all is fulfilled. Generation is a term that has several meanings. See this site:


So generation doesn't mean generation?
Please go here and tell me which of the 14 definitions of generation fits your statement.
http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/generation
 
Nowhere does the bible say the Kingdom of Heaven would be established before all crucifixion witnesses died. You are probably referring to Christ saying this "generation" shall not pass before all is fulfilled. Generation is a term that has several meanings. See this site:

http://www.mountainretreatorg.net/faq/generation.shtml

O.K. Generations has several meanings. I was referring to Luke 9:27 ("I tell you the truth, some who are standing here will not taste death before they see the kingdom of God.") which does not use the word generation. Therefore, this prophecy could only be fulfilled if there is a witness to the resurrection still alive today.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom