The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

And, once more, we see just how morally bankrupt the extreme members of the Evangelical crowd truly are.

As DOC, Kurious Kathy, and Ethnikos bleat about the evil that exists in this world, about the vile works of Satan, (things like Racial Equality, Gay Rights, Living Wages, and other abominations to their god), there would seem to be a few things missing in all of this.

The first thing I see lacking is any evidence that what they're declaring evil actually is evil. Quite the contrary, what I see is that when these kind of attitudes and actions are in play, this "evil" that they say we need to abandon, society tends to work a lot better. It's far from perfect, but I fail to see how denying someone rights they are not only guaranteed in the Constitution but in Natural Law has helped anyone. Had Jerry Falwell had his way in the 1950's, people like Gordon Parks -- a constant thorn in the side of the good reverend -- would have been locked away and barred from the public debate.

But it goes a lot further than that: I would like to know where in the Bible it specifically declares that the Evangelical Community has any authority to make any such declarations about anyone. If I read Romans right, it's God and only God who hands people over to a reprobate mind. Considering God Himself is the only one with any such authority, it leaves me stumped as to how such people can run around making such declarations about anyone. Quite the opposite: Most of what I read in the Bible in years past made it clear that your first order of business is to SHUT UP and tend to your own house, first. I've yet to see any evidence of that in the actions of the posters cited. If anything, these fine folks are doing everything BUT this.

Since this seems to be the case, this last one almost seems moot: Precisely what are any of these folks doing to counter the evils they see in our society? They pray? Whoopdie-sh**. I did that, too. But I also tried like hell to get food closets going, (only to be told that we didn't want those kinds of people around the church.) I tried to get relief groups going to help those in the church who had needs. That, too, was a no-go. I watched as my wife and friends tried to sew clothes for kids who needed them for the new school year, only to have the Church Ladies, the FoPs and others thumb their noses at such efforts.

And yet, in reading James, that was precisely the kind of work the Church was supposed to be doing! Before you could speak out regarding the evils of others, before you could start crying about how a brother or sister was eating meat sacrificed to idols, you had to do your part to make sure there was food for people to eat, you had to be certain that needs were met. Bitch, piss, and moan all you like, but the reality is that most churches can cry about the evils of this world all they like, but they are doing precious little in their neck of the woods to alleviate the damage done by the very evils they object to.

I was working in Christian radio when there were member of "ministry" demanding that gays and lesbians be carted off to concentration camps due to the AIDS crisis. Don't believe me? Take a long look back at this sad display. And while I no longer have the printed material I was sent in the "name of Christ" because I worked in Christian Radio -- my father-in-law heated his home at the time with a wood-burning stove -- I'm willing to bet with some investigation, you could still find information about this. One of the few members of the Christian media who spoke out against this was Dr. James Dobson of Focus on the Family, who also incurred the anger of his fellow evangelicals by declaring that AIDS was NOT the wrath of God. (He made up for it, though, by declaring that Spongebob Squarepants was gay. Good one, Jim!)

I lost my job in Christian radio not because I wasn't good at it, but because I donated a portion of the pittance I was paid as a salary to help fight Apartheid in South Africa. Once the station found out what I'd done, they did all they could to fire me. They made it stick, too, and even trashed me when people called for a reference.

I'll put it this way: How the hell am I supposed to believe any of what these folks say when I have not only lived it, but I have done all I could to do what Scripture said I was supposed to do? And in the end, was trashed for it? What's the point? If you don't even believe it, if the extent of your "service" is your prayer, how the hell do you people expect US to believe it, particularly when the majority of us here on the board have either been though it ourselves, or have studied enough regarding this to know it's crap?

And even more to the point, when your own action (or inaction) show it's crap, how do you expect anyone to believe you?
 
You know joobz you have a real issue with slavery.
You're right I do. I think slavery (the owning of another human's life) is highly amoral. I wonder how you would view a person today preaching about how one should beat? And then reevaluate Jesus' parable of the Faithful servant.
 
You're right I do. I think slavery (the owning of another human's life) is highly amoral. I wonder how you would view a person today preaching about how one should beat? And then reevaluate Jesus' parable of the Faithful servant.

Amoral? I wouldn't even be that kind about it.
 
And, once more, we see just how morally bankrupt the extreme members of the Evangelical crowd truly are.

As DOC, Kurious Kathy, and Ethnikos bleat about the evil that exists in this world, about the vile works of Satan, (things like Racial Equality, Gay Rights, Living Wages, and other abominations to their god), there would seem to be a few things missing in all of this.
Thanks for being open in your post and putting this into concrete, easy to understand terms. These are good points. I have a similar problem, and it's not just me. We have to have kind of a club for outcasts. Our church is actually very good about the food bank and clothes thing and advocating for the homeless, but inside the church itself, as in your experience as a member, is not fun if you do not belong to the right clique.
They are not going to give us a badge to wear with the church's name on it to go into the community because that seems to be reserved for their favorites who need to get onto the ladder of advancement to social status. So we have to pretty much make up our own ministry and do it in our own name.
 
Anyway, I'm not disputing the existence of millenarianism (though I've not seen much evidence that it took hold in 1000 AD), but the specifics of the doctrine of the rapture.
I was just thinking about that this morning, that I probably am not making the right point. Years ago, when this thing came out, at least to my awareness, it seemed to be reserved to these Jesus People street evangelists. This was California, so they could do the whole sandal thing.
The point is, it was called the Secret Rapture. That part might be new, but I doubt it. If you were able to look back far enough into history, I would expect that you could find it.
Back to your point, it would be relatively new, from our present perspective. I guess your original point was that I was wrong to say that the Christian view of future world history is, whatever it was that I wrote in my post. I do not especially feel like arguing that. It was what I think it is and I admit that I am not especially concerned if it does not match the majority view because I feel the majority of Christians have been deluded by the influence of the antichrist. If you go to a Mass, you will notice there is a line the people repeat, "World without end". Great, you can pick out three words from the bible to say just about anything you want. What it means is not that this world will last forever, but that the reign of Christ will never be overturned.
 
Then you tell us that you were dead, and then brought back to life, but admit that you have absolutely no evidence to back up this story.
Just what on Earth do you hope to achieve? Nobody here is the slightest bit impressed with these stories.
It really does not make a good story and I have admitted that a couple times. It is not one I have used before I wrote about it here. I noticed what kind of response it got when I brought it up the first time so I had low expectations. I was just answering a question. Since none of my other stories that I have used on this forum are provable, I figured I would go ahead with that one too, since it is no more or less unprovable than the others.
You might impress people on Christian forums with your stories, but here we ask for evidence, laugh at anecdote, and, more importantly, understand Human biology and psychology.
I have never told any of these stories on Christian forums or to other Christians outside of my family.
So when you say that you died and that Jesus brought you back to life, I believe that you honestly believe that. When you tell us that you cousin D was shot and only survived because Jesus appeared to him and told him to hang on, I believe that both you and D believe that to be true.
Thanks and I could no reasonably expect any more than that, here.
Unfortunately, what people believe to be true, and what is actually true are often completely unrelated. So unless you have any evidence, your stories are completely worthless, regardless of how much you believe them to be true.
Other than to maybe satisfy some's curiosity for why I would be such a strong believer. The answer is that I may be the least of believers because it is not a stretch for me because I have been given a lot of evidence in my personal life that God is real. That being said, no amount of miracles can just give you correctness or superiority in theology because it takes dedication and work for that.
 
Tim could you reference exact verses you are stating? I am especially concerned with your second paragraph as we must all be careful not to take scripture out of context or things get misunderstood.

Is that doubt I hear?
 
I have been given a lot of evidence in my personal life that God is real.

What would you say to the millions of people who have been "given a lot of evidence" that a radically different God is real? What would you say to Mohammad Atta, for example? Or the followers of David Koresh? Or Tom Cruise? He's been given lots of evidence - that he believes at least as sincerely as you do - that an evil Galactic Emperor called Xenu is real?

How do you square that circle?
 
The kindness of strangers, while a fine thing, is not a miracle. And perhaps you could describe how they "came out of nowhere and went off in a very not normal way."

Describe the appearance of the demons you did see, as well as the exact situation when your friend was thrown into and out of a fire. Don't just say that it was a demon when you have no proof.
Okay, next post.
All the details of these stories are on the Powerlessness of Prayer (starting at page 1) http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127489&highlight=powerlessness
 
Okay, here's my thoughts on them.

Ethnikos said:
I mean someone coming along and helping you, for no apparet reason.
I started out with the cliff story, so I could go further on that one.
When I was a kid, I was with a group and we were above the top of the tram terminal above Pam Springs. You can go to overlook spots that go straight down. Being a foolish adventurous kid, I started climbing around. I ended up being stuck and hanging from a tree branch over the abyss.
A kid was there, all of a sudden, that I noticed when he asked me if I needed help. He helped me back up and he walked off. I assumed he was from the group but I never saw him again. Very strange.

This isn't a miracle. A kid being there in time to save you is lucky, of course, but just because you didn't see him afterward doesn't mean that he was an angel that dematerialized afterward.

Ethnikos said:
One day I was climbing over a big rock-pile when right in front of me a rattlesnake rose up from under the rock I was on and blocked my path. I looked behind me and another one came up. Then ones on each side of me came up. I do not think God put those snakes there but I may have been lucky enough to stop when I was right in the middle of the rock, instead of on one of the edges, or something. They were very determined and apparently angry with me and I think would have bit me if I was close enough to them. So did God move them? No, but the fact that they came out in the order that they did, saved me.
God was not trying to kill me with a bunch of snakes, I chose to walk over a nest of rattlesnakes without realizing it. So, God did not change his mind.

You weren't "saved by God from rattlesnakes." You walked into a cluster of rattlesnakes, plain and simple. Sheer luck that the side you came in on didn't have one there too.
And for all you know, God was trying to kill you with those rattlesnakes but the stupid things wouldn't stay down!

My connection's being weird and slow, so I'm not going to take the time to read the rest right now. But from what I've read, you appear to be a guy who just has a knack for getting himself almost killed. Emphasis on almost. There's nothing miraculous about that. Maybe you should just start paying attention to where you're going.
 
What would you say to the millions of people who have been "given a lot of evidence" that a radically different God is real? What would you say to Mohammad Atta, for example? Or the followers of David Koresh? Or Tom Cruise? He's been given lots of evidence - that he believes at least as sincerely as you do - that an evil Galactic Emperor called Xenu is real? How do you square that circle?
It's a little bit more than a nice thought or something from a book, but life experience.
Did Tom Cruise get in a spacecraft and go and meet Xenu?
People can have experiences with devils pretending to be gods but you have to judge them by what they do.
As for believers themselves, that's up to Jesus. I would say, if you believe a god exists, that's good but you do not know God by just receiving benefits from Him, you must also seek Him and that is best done by looking at Jesus, as starters. God sent Jesus so we can know Him.
 
I don't believe I said that, but I've said the decaying morality is running parallel to the decline of religion in America. I'm glad that at least Christianity and the number of Christians are increasing in the rest of the world as a whole especially in China and Africa.
That's interesting, because a lot of people in China are complaining about a decline in moral standards, increases in crime rates, divorce rates, unmarried and teenage pregnancies, a decline in young peoples' respect for family and authority.....

Strange that it should coincide with the increase of Christianity in China. :oldroll:
 
Ethnikos said:
Did Tom Cruise get in a spacecraft and go and meet Xenu?

Did you get in a spaceship and go and meet God? Honestly. Glass house, man...

Ethnikos said:
People can have experiences with devils pretending to be gods but you have to judge them by what they do.

So you believe in demons as well? Sorry to burst your mythological bubble, man, but there's no such thing as demons, devils, yugoloths, or anything else. And that includes Big Sky Daddies.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom