The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

You are aware that this story is a 17th century concoction, aren't you, and only believed by certain Christian sects?

But there's a whole series of books about the rapture. Surely there must be some truth to those books... I mean, no one would write a fictitious account, right?
 
Oh, True. I forgot that. I just looked at the title, and you are right. Somehow I was thinking it was about the superiority of Christianity. Thanks for trying to get me on topic.
I was posting last night from a lap top in the midst of a post-baptism party which seems like an oxymoron to me.
Did I miss the post where you actually returned to the topic, rather than just establishing we weren't on topic? Let me just pose the question then: What makes you sure your brand of Christianity is the one true religion, as opposed to all other brands of Christianity, and all other religions?

Thanks.
 
You are aware that this story is a 17th century concoction, aren't you, and only believed by certain Christian sects?

"And the nations were angry, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth."

It's in the Bible, so it's not exactly a new idea.
 
How did you Ever establish that?

The people who are supposed to be running the planet are really doing a crappy job. It is not because they can not do a better job, it is because they do not want to. Ether these are the rich, or payed off by the rich to make sure they will always stay rich, over the dead bodies of the poor.
Or is it the Satan thing?
Ok, really bad people, for some undiscernable, inexplicable reasons behave as if there was some sort of spiritual entity directing an orchestra of death.
 
Did I miss the post where you actually returned to the topic, rather than just establishing we weren't on topic? Let me just pose the question then: What makes you sure your brand of Christianity is the one true religion, as opposed to all other brands of Christianity, and all other religions?
Thanks.
Thank you. What I think is true is, Everyone on this planet who ever gets saved, are saved because of what Jesus did and what Jesus is doing now, no matter what they may believe it is that is saving them.
Based on that (which may only work for me), the less obstruction from that truth that you can have, the better.
Idolatry is half the battle of our eventual unity with God, and there are idols set up everywhere to distract us from the truth, and it can include you own religion.
Loving someone who is not you is the second half of what we need to learn on our journey to unity.
What helps you on your way is good, what hinders or stops you on your way is bad.
 
"And the nations were angry, and thy wrath is come, and the time of the dead, that they should be judged, and that thou shouldest give reward unto thy servants the prophets, and to the saints, and them that fear thy name, small and great; and shouldest destroy them which destroy the earth."

It's in the Bible, so it's not exactly a new idea.

And yet, prior to the 17th century nobody actually believed in the idea of rapture and the 'end times' and so on as believed by some evangelical churches today, primarily in the US.

Can you point to where in the bible this is clearly laid out, not constructed by picking and choosing isolated verses?
 
The people who are supposed to be running the planet are really doing a crappy job. It is not because they can not do a better job, it is because they do not want to. Ether these are the rich, or payed off by the rich to make sure they will always stay rich, over the dead bodies of the poor.
Or is it the Satan thing?
Ok, really bad people, for some undiscernable, inexplicable reasons behave as if there was some sort of spiritual entity directing an orchestra of death.

Everything you've said, even if we allow for the elephant-sized broad brush you're using, can be accounted for quite simply with three words:

They're only human.

There's no need to bring some supernatural entity into it, but people do so because it helps them comfort themselves over their lack of control.

People do these things to one another. It frightens us to think that, because it means it's possible we might do terrible things, too. It's hard to accept that we are capable of good deeds and bad ones. So we shirk our responsibility, and of all things, we create imaginary beings to take the blame!

This is the work of grown-ups, mind you. Creating bugaboos and scary beings of pure evil or pure good to take the blame or the credit for the things we, and we alone, do to ourselves and each other.

But I understand why people need those beings. It's just a shame we can't appreciate ourselves.
 
Thank you. What I think is true is, Everyone on this planet who ever gets saved, are saved because of what Jesus did and what Jesus is doing now, no matter what they may believe it is that is saving them.
Based on that (which may only work for me), the less obstruction from that truth that you can have, the better.
Idolatry is half the battle of our eventual unity with God, and there are idols set up everywhere to distract us from the truth, and it can include you own religion.
Loving someone who is not you is the second half of what we need to learn on our journey to unity.
What helps you on your way is good, what hinders or stops you on your way is bad.
I appreciate your response, but I honestly haven't the vaguest idea how this is supposed to answer my question.
Let me explain: I asked you how you know that what you believe is the one and only truth. You answered this by stating things that you believe are true. I hope you'll agree that this is not an answer to my question.

Again, I would like to know why you believe these things are absolutely beyond doubt, and how you can be sure Buddhists, Catholics, Ancient Romans, Vikings, Jehova's Witnesses, Scientologists, Hindus, and Taoists are mistaken.
 
And yet, prior to the 17th century nobody actually believed in the idea of rapture and the 'end times' and so on as believed by some evangelical churches today, primarily in the US.

Can you point to where in the bible this is clearly laid out, not constructed by picking and choosing isolated verses?
There may be a reason why Americans came up with a lot of interpretations. The fact that when these ideas came out was when everyone in the country could read and every house had a Bible in it. It is not because Americans are all insane.
Start out learning to read with the Bible and read it your whole life and you just might be able to come up with a religion. That's why there is a Bible. You don't need some dude in a black robe to tell you what to believe.
I gave a quote that puts it in a concentrated way. Then you have to pick your way around to fill it in.
The rapture was around in 999 AD. When people think there is some sort of significant date coming up and that it might correspond to some prophecy with numbers of days, or whatever, then people get excited and start thinking about how they can get off the planet. It's not new, it just has to go through a resurgence, and then it seems new.
 
Belz... said:
Jesus didn't really die, did he ?

No, he didn't. He didn't exist.

However, if he did exist and he was the Son of God, his sacrifice still meant nothing. He knew he would come back to life. It was an empty gesture, basically posing and saying "Look how great I am!" He was one arrogant zombie.

Or there's always the option that he did exist but he wasn't the Son of God, and he just died. In which case it was nothing special. At least until the Apostles came along and basically made him the biggest martyr in history.
 
Could you explain how an immortal god that is the first and the last can actually die?
I think you've been conned.
.
There are lots of pretend gods which are so many stories. Then there is a real god and no one seems to know anything about this God. We can not judge the real God with a comparison against something made up. God does not have to follow a "Guidebook to How to be a God".
Moses saw a burning bush and asked it what it was. It said "I am whoever and whatever I decide on my own that I want to be". We do not have a role or form that God has to comply with, or a name to make Him do our will.
Jesus can say I am in the Father, and the Father is in me. How can you say he is wrong? He is speaking God's word, and doing God's deeds. He seems to be able to exhibit the powers of God, but you can cut him and make him bleed. Oh, he must be a human! Ha ha! Then the clouds come and suddenly it is black as night in the middle of the day! Huge bolts of lightning come and strike the ground in front of you and loud sounds of enormous angry gods speaking to each other about Can we just kill them all now, and the earth quakes and you run away. What's the problem? he's just a man you said. Can't you back up your words, as you search for cover to protect you.
 
Last edited:
Ethnikos said:
There are lots of pretend gods which are so many stories.

Agreed.

Then there is a real god and no one seems to know anything about this God.

No, there isn't a "real god." That's like saying that there's a "real Ender Wiggin." But the point that no one seems to know anything about this (allegedly) real god is one of the main reasons for atheism.

There is, however, a "real Cthulhu."


We can not judge the real God with a comparison against something made up.

Where did this come from? I wasn't aware that anyone was comparing God to anything. But that aside... Why not? He is something made up.

God does not have to follow a "Guidebook to How to be a God".

Too bad - the universe would probably be running more smoothly if he did.

Moses saw a burning bush and asked it what it was. It said "I am whoever and whatever I decide on my own that I want to be".

Can you verify this? The only evidence you have for the support of this claim is the Bible. And large sections of the Bible are verifiably false. This throws major doubt on the truth of the rest of it. The story of the bush is no exception. It sounds like Moses was on a bad acid trip.

We do not have a role or form that God has to comply with, or a name to make Him do our will.

You've returned to the "open your heart" standby. The essence of this statement is "God is ineffable, above your judgment and petty mortal standards of 'proof' and 'logic.' You must simply believe."

Jesus can say I am in the Father, and the Father is in me. How can you say he is wrong?

The same way you can say he's right.

He is speaking God's word, and doing God's deeds.

He is (was) either a philosopher or a madman being touted as the messiah. Or, you know, he didn't exist.

He seems to be able to exhibit the powers of God, but you can cut him and make him bleed. Oh, he must be a human! Ha ha!

No, he could just be any other kind of animal that bleeds. Most do.
And as for the "exhibits the powers of God," think about this. The main method of communication back then was word of mouth. If someone came along and told you that, in a city far away, a man named Jesus had restored sight to a blind man, you would probably accept it, because you have never been there and everyone knows that people Over There Are Not Like Us. However, today we have telephones, news, and the incredible internet resource known as the blogosphere. Almost any news is readily verifiable or can be easily proven false from a few minutes spent on Google. If someone came up to you on World of WarCraft and said, "Hey, I live in Tanzania and there's a guy named Jesus going around restoring sight to blind people!" you would laugh in his face, because you can prove it false.
But back then, they couldn't prove it false. So eventually, after all this is over, the Bible gets written and all these stories about Jesus are compiled together (of course, a few scenes are added on, because anyone with rumor experience knows how quickly these things grow). This man gets called the messiah and the Son of God simply because these people couldn't prove that these stories they were hearing were false.


Then the clouds come and suddenly it is black as night in the middle of the day! Huge bolts of lightning come and strike the ground in front of you and loud sounds of enormous angry gods speaking to each other about Can we just kill them all now, and the earth quakes and you run away. What's the problem? he's just a man you said. Can't you back up your words, as you search for cover to protect you.

This is probably one of the scenes added on when the Bible writers decided to name Jesus the messiah. They had to make it appear as if his death meant something Up There. And again, you have only the stories of these people from more than two thousand years ago.

And there we go.
 
There are lots of pretend gods which are so many stories....

Bleeding doesn't automatically make one assume immortality has disappeared. You just made that up.

Prometheus did a fair bit of bleeding but was still immortal.

Is your particular god immortal or not? A simple yes or no would suffice.

Any god that's not immortal is doing a pretty poor job of godding, IMHO.

Without the immortal bit it's just a guy pretending and "so many stories...".



.
 
As to the Rapture, derived from the latin rapere, meaning to seize or snatch away, there are a few passages in the New Testament on which it is based. Referring to the coming of the Son of man Matthew says (Mt. 24:40, 41):

Then two men will be in the field; one is taken and the other is left. Two women will be grinding at the mill; one is taken and one is left.

Here are the parallel verses in Luke (Lk. 17:34, 35):

I tell you, in that night there will be two men in one bed; one will be taken and the other left. There will be two women grinding together; one will be taken and the other left.

There is no parallel verse in Mark, one of the few times when Matthew and Luke agree against Mark. Therefore, this teaching may well come from "Q."

Describing the coming of the Lord, Paul says in 1 Thessalonians (1 Thess. 4:16, 17):

For the Lord himself will descend from heaven with a cry of command, with the archangel's call, and with the sound of the trumpet of God. And the dead in Christ will rise first; then we who are alive, who are left, shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and so we shall always be with the Lord.

So there is a scriptural basis for the doctrine of the Rapture, particularly in Paul's quote, although he obviously didn't envision pilotless planes falling out of the sky or speeding automobiles being left driveress. Rabture doctine has even evolved to the point where there are different schools of thought on when it will occur: before, during or after the Tribulation (the seven year rule of the Beast), i.e. "Pre-Trib", "Mid-Trib" and "Post Trib." Not surprisingly, the Pre-Trib view is most popular. That is, the Christians can gleefully enjoy all the horrors of the Apocalypse, because God will have already raptured them into heaven before it begins to get nasty. From on high, they will look down on the sufferings of us heathen with great satisfaction.
 
Ethnikos, from your answers in this thread I get the idea that the question posed in the OP simply does not compute. Could you rephrase the question from the OP in your own words? I'm not asking this to be mean; I'm honestly having trouble figuring out your train of thoughts.
 
Ethnikos, from your answers in this thread I get the idea that the question posed in the OP simply does not compute. Could you rephrase the question from the OP in your own words? I'm not asking this to be mean; I'm honestly having trouble figuring out your train of thoughts.
It seems like most people can safely just jump into the middle of a thread and make a comment on a point in someone else's post, without any serious repercussions. When I do that, someone will ask me how I could possibly say such a thing. By tying to explain my first comment, I apparently attract another question. So there is no train of thought and no consideration for what the actual thread is about. Just me reacting to whatever posts come up that I feel compelled to answer.
To stop the train, just make a post like, "I think you are wrong and no amount of your personal testimony of your faith will ever persuade me to think otherwise. PS, this is not in the form of a question, so please do not respond to this post."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom