The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

I see your point about KK's version. If it was only people on Earth who were witnesses, they would most likely be about to be fried themselves, and any lesson to be gained would be wasted on them.
The solution I am apparently supporting is that there are people on other planets who had gotten to know these spirit power entities, or whatever, back in the day when they were free to roam about the Universe unhindered. Plus some other individuals of this class of being who had not fallen. These people and non-people would be interested to know what the fate would be for these who are to be judged. If it was not done in a clearly just manner, it would infect the universe with a spirit of discontent that would eventually bring everything down to ruin. The Bible evidence is pretty sparse and any details beyond that are apparently not considered to be something we need to know.

You don't know for sure what you are supporting? I assume that is the function of the word "apparently"?

Ok with that caveat, have I got this right?

You say that there will be an unleashing of really nasty beings who will be freed to do their worst on our planet and to us. And the reason for this is to satisfy the sense of justice of aliens who will be watching. Some of those aliens are like us in that they have also "fallen". But unlike us they are to have a physical demonstration of what is to happen if they do not follow god's rule. Are they all called Thomas, by any chance? The others have not "fallen" and so I can see no point in the demonstration at all.

But the bottom line is that you believe that these people will be satisfied that this is done in a clearly just manner, even though god is going to torture a whole population just so they can learn a lesson? It does not occur to you that they might see a tyrant and become a little discontented ?

Wow
 
I know I did, til I stumbled on a method to control the experience.
But it wasn't until I found myself in this thread and followed the link to the Wiki article that I actually understood WTF had occurred in my dealings with hypnagogia.
Sorry about what happened to you. I only had that happen to me once, or whatever it was that I had happen. I did not find the medical explanation completely satisfying. I might have to look at some case histories sometime.
[/quote]

Well, auditory and visual hypnagogic hallucinations are actually a very simple and straightforward neurological experience, so I'm not sure that everybody is even on the same page here. I've experienced them quite a bit-- a substantial portion of the population can have them almost nightly for stretches of time-- and personally, I have a very hard time understanding how anybody could mistake them for visions of heaven and/or hell.
 
So Jesus is just our lawyer then, Ethnikos? Lucky he's the son of the judge or we'd be in some ◊◊◊◊, lol.
One thing he does. That is a good thing, and I am glad you get that.
If you admit that translations of the NT are opinion, how can any one of them be validated as right? There are so many misconceptions, contradictions, and flat out lies all over the place in all the different variations of this religion that to call your form correct without any viable proof, is just flat out ignorant.
The punishment is for the ones who hate it. Being right is not what saves anyone. Mostly there is a lot of examples of what not to do. If you block out a fundamental concept that is something that should be evident to a seeker of the truth, all the minutia and finer points are not going to do a person any good. This is what happens. You cherish a little bit of what gets passed around as religion, and when you find evidence against it, you block it out, for the sake of the pleasant error. Then you have cut off the life giving connection to God.
Do you see? You are associated with so many forms of Christianity that just the shear fact you associate yourself with Jesus and actually give him credit for ANY part of your life means that this whole conversation with you is useless.
Maybe I do not see. What is it? If I believe in Jesus, then it is not possible to see the folly in it? I have sold my mind into slavery to a creation of my imagination? Thus rendering my mind incapable of useful thought?
Atheists and non-believers will not see your light because they require EVIDENCE and proof. If God was omniscient, wouldn't he help us non-believers to see the light?
He can. "I believe, help thou my unbelief" was what the man said to Jesus as his child lie dying.
I guess not, its better that he makes it so that the only way you can prove you believe in him, is by following whacky, outdated rules and giving up every part of your individuality to become a 'soldier of the lord.' If he's such a loving god, why is there a hell at all?
Hell is death and forget Dante and other fiction writers who invent punishments for the damned. Apparently someone did a bad job of evangelizing you. Did they ever say something like, "I am high on Jesus"? It sounds like the sort of stuff those people will tell someone. You might be shocked if you hung out with our group. Individuality is the rule of the day. I don't know what rules you think you have to keep. I just made 45 copies, to mail out, of a sermon on how God uses individuals who do not fit some mold, to be of use for His work. People are different for a reason because it takes people with different talents, working together, to get things done. Uniformity is death, really, to an organization.
I would assume that an omniscient god that knows everything, knows why I made the choices I made and understands my reasoning, would accept me for who I am and thus wouldn't need me to get on my knees to prove my loyalty. Perhaps living life in a way that is most fun and least wasteful is god's will? I could argue that much better as the meaning of life rather than 'spreading the word of christ'.
God knows everything about you. People love to run around spouting off happy talk about free will. Forget it. We are in a bondage to sin and our will with it. We are not so free and circumstances dictate our choices for us. Proving things is no necessary because, like you said, He knows your thoughts. Non-wasteful fun sounds good. I do that in kayaks. No pollution and there are places designated "no motors" where I am.
I believe it is these people, that believe they know exactly what God is and what it wants, are the ones that truly do not cherish life. They're willing to give it up and waste it away in hopes that they can please the big guy in the sky and have a better 'afterlife'.
Like live in a convent, or something? I don't know anyone personally who is wasting there life, like you describe. I also don't know anyone obsessed with pleasing God like that. Maybe if you were a christian living in a Muslim country, you would be giving something up. God wants us to be good people and have love and compassion and honesty. We do not have to do a pilgrimage to a shrine where you crawl up steep stone steps with bloody knees. Life is a reward but you don't do things to get that. you just do things because they are right and you want to do them.
I can't wait for judgment day personally, I wanna see how god resurrects everyone that ever lived on earth.
Not that big a deal. They say that you could take everyone in the world and have them live comfortably in the state of Texas. There are more people alive today than everyone else who lived before, all put together.
 
A top scientist or researcher or professor of history is not going to be totally objective, especially when he has to be somewhat subjective, as in breaking it down to what is relevant.
.
You are so far below a "top scientist" in what you present here that it is pathetic to watch.
Ignorance of just about everything, with invocations of the wildest fantasies, which are completely unsupportable by anything rational.
You have no idea what is or isn't "relevant" to this subject.
Get an education in it, and come back in a few years.
 
That sounds a lot like a hypnagogic hallucination.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypnagogia
-----------------------------------------------------------
Ethnikos;4971454]Sorry about what happened to you. I only had that happen to me once, or whatever it was that I had happen. I did not find the medical explanation completely satisfying. I might have to look at some case histories sometime.[/QUOTE]
Nothing to be sorry about, Ethnikos. Apparently it's a common phenomena. Obviously the fact that it's an observed phenomena is not as 'satisfying' as deluding yourself that you've had a spiritual experience.
And rather than look at some case histories, why not address yourself to the OP.
 
. . .and found trapped air from 12,000 years ago which, because it's high carbon dioxide content, contributed to the climatic cooling and the formation of glaciers. Dispute that all you YECs!
I just don't understand why these people can ignore so much physical evidence of an old earth and cling to their bronze age explanations about life and our planet.
Don't look at me! I can go with 12,000 years. Oops, I guess that would be young, too. The world is a very strange place and a lot of things have happened to it that are hard to explain.
The important thing, from a Bible stand point, is that there was a great civilization of very powerful but evil people, and now they are gone. Calculating the age of the earth from the Bible is a fool's game. Not because the Bible is so much wasted parchment, but that you can not tell really how to calculate it, probably because that was not the purpose for all the begetting and ages of people when they had a son.
 
I know I did, til I stumbled on a method to control the experience.
But it wasn't until I found myself in this thread and followed the link to the Wiki article that I actually understood WTF had occurred in my dealings with hypnagogia.
Sorry about what happened to you. I only had that happen to me once, or whatever it was that I had happen. I did not find the medical explanation completely satisfying. I might have to look at some case histories sometime.

Well, auditory and visual hypnagogic hallucinations are actually a very simple and straightforward neurological experience, so I'm not sure that everybody is even on the same page here. I've experienced them quite a bit-- a substantial portion of the population can have them almost nightly for stretches of time-- and personally, I have a very hard time understanding how anybody could mistake them for visions of heaven and/or hell.[/QUOTE]

I appreciate your personal opinion, Maia and I daresay there is a range of degrees, from mild to intense.
According to Wiki, some artists invoke this state, something I find fascinating, now I know what was going on.
 
Well, auditory and visual hypnagogic hallucinations are actually a very simple and straightforward neurological experience, so I'm not sure that everybody is even on the same page here. I've experienced them quite a bit-- a substantial portion of the population can have them almost nightly for stretches of time-- and personally, I have a very hard time understanding how anybody could mistake them for visions of heaven and/or hell.

I appreciate your personal opinion, Maia and I daresay there is a range of degrees, from mild to intense.
According to Wiki, some artists invoke this state, something I find fascinating, now I know what was going on.[/QUOTE]

There are some fascinating scholarly articles about hypnagogic hallucinations as culturally defined experiences... I will post more info when I have some time. I don't know; I just have a hard time picturing them being that intense, both from what I've experienced and from what others have said. For some weird reason, I've often heard what sounds like someone whispering a single word in my ear. Usually the name of a South American country. "Venezula" or something. The mind's a very strange thing. ;) But you never know! They canbe frightening in these specific cultural contexts, and that might be closer to what you're talking about. Anyway, it's time for bed for now.
 
Ethnikos wrote:
I see your point about KK's version. If it was only people on Earth who were witnesses, they would most likely be about to be fried themselves, and any lesson to be gained would be wasted on them.
The solution I am apparently supporting is that there are people on other planets who had gotten to know these spirit power entities, or whatever, back in the day when they were free to roam about the Universe unhindered. Plus some other individuals of this class of being who had not fallen. These people and non-people would be interested to know what the fate would be for these who are to be judged. If it was not done in a clearly just manner, it would infect the universe with a spirit of discontent that would eventually bring everything down to ruin. The Bible evidence is pretty sparse and any details beyond that are apparently not considered to be something we need to know

Back to the OP?
 
God knows everything about you. People love to run around spouting off happy talk about free will. Forget it. We are in a bondage to sin and our will with it. We are not so free and circumstances dictate our choices for us.
.

And there is the difference between you and me. I take full responsibility for EVERYTHING I do in life. I will not beg forgiveness of someone or something that has nothing to do with the situation. And don't say "I do take full responsibility" because if you have to 'give yourself to Christ' you are no longer yourself, despite all the crap you spew about being an individual.

I'm sorry you've fallen so deep into this woo but it wouldn't be so bad if you accepted that you were blatantly wrong about what is considered the 'truth' in this situation. No one would fault you for believing in God, but all this extra baggage like god sending his son to die because we're all inherently evil? Just goes to show how much faith you REALLY have in humanity.

Why do you think you know more than me about what god wants from us? The Bible is no where near the same as it was when it was first put together. So what parts are the 'literal word of god'? And what parts can we just ignore and shrug off as BS?

Your god is outdated in this day and age. Your religion advocates the use of magic (raising from the dead, alchemy etc.) and yet condemns the other religions that use it because they're not the 'one true religion'.

(Just think how easy it was thousands of years ago to trick people into believing something magical without the variety of tests we have today by claiming some higher power did it. And here's the kicker: People are STILL falling for it even when we have mounds of evidence!)

Its all nice and dandy that you can get some good ideas from christianity but it doesn't mean that they ONLY come from christianity. There is nothing in christianity that can't be offered in some other religion and thus it is not special.

Your god is an angry, jealous, tyrant. Sin is in the eye of the beholder. You've lost faith in mankind thinking that the only way to survive is by surrendering to Jesus. Using fear of the unknown as well as promises of eternal happiness?

What a charade! It is truly despicable.
 
You don't know for sure what you are supporting? I assume that is the function of the word "apparently"?
Today I am supporting it. Like I was saying earlier, its real tricky, the just how literal you should take things. This the more literal version and simplified a little bit.
You say that there will be an unleashing of really nasty beings who will be freed to do their worst on our planet and to us. And the reason for this is to satisfy the sense of justice of aliens who will be watching. Some of those aliens are like us in that they have also "fallen".
No on the fallen thing. As of right now, the instigators have all been rounded up and forced down to this world. Whoever is looking on, they have not fallen like us. Some are people, like us but the similarity ends there. The others are angels or some other sort of spirit being that we do not know about, other than that they exist.
But unlike us they are to have a physical demonstration of what is to happen if they do not follow god's rule. Are they all called Thomas, by any chance? The others have not "fallen" and so I can see no point in the demonstration at all.
Some may have been on the verge of falling if the tempters were not removed when they were. Having Satan as a martyr might just be enough to cause a revolution.
But the bottom line is that you believe that these people will be satisfied that this is done in a clearly just manner, even though god is going to torture a whole population just so they can learn a lesson? It does not occur to you that they might see a tyrant and become a little discontented ?
The point is that God has an established order of things and they are that way for a reason. If you think you can have so-called freedom without consequences then you just made a mistake. The real thing Satan wanted was his own rule, not really something that would be good for us. The trick is to promise something we will get but Satan never keeps his promises. Instead a freedom from control by God, we get slavery from Satan. Of course he does not present it that way. He lies.
 
I was implying that you were one of those people, Ethnikos, that does not cherish life. You think you know the reason behind our existence and our purpose with no proof. In fact, today a lot of the so-called purpose proves inefficient to living a full life.

At least atheists and agnostics have the cojones to admit they don't know the answers to these questions, rather than try to answer them in a way that is clearly wrong in conjunction with our lives today.

The fact that you can apply it loosely to this day and age is no more impressive than astrology.
 
Is Ethnikos a Freeman on the Land-er?

The seventh day of the week that corresponds with the day commonly called Saturday.

The speech pattern here -- using this odd convoluted labeling, rather than just saying "Saturday" -- reminds me of their circumlocutions that have John Smith, of 123 Blank Street, insisting that he is really "the man called John of the family called Smith, currently residing in and receiving mail at the house standing on the lot numbered 123 on the street called Blank".
 
Yes. I have read the entire thread. Every page, every post.
54 pages and thus far the only reason the Christians have given for justifying their view that Christianity is superior to other religions is because it (Christianity) has Jesus.

There are many reasons to believe Christianity is the one true religion:

1) Christianity is the only religion with so many fulfilled prophecies:

http://www.reasons.org/fulfilled-prophecy-evidence-reliability-bible

2) Christianity is the main part of the greatest selling book of all time. While the number of readers don't prove veracity. Things do tend to happen for a reason.

3) Christianity seems to have more verified healings attributed to it than any other religion.

4) Christianity seems to have more personal testimonies of life changing experiences like getting off drugs and alcohol, saved marriages, being born again etc.

5) It's teachings of love your neighbor, love your enemy, do good to those who revile and persecute you seems to be the only philosophy that could save this messed up world.

6) Christ was the only person of any major religion that claimed to be part of the Godhead and to be pre-existent to the creation of this world and was at the same time a person who most historians believe actually existed.

7) Mohammed is in his grave, Buddha is in his grave, Confucius is in his grave, Joseph Smith is in his grave, but Jesus is not in his grave.

8) Christianity for some reason was initially able to rapidly and peaceably grow against all odds in the brutal Roman empire where 1000's were martyred while other religions like Islam initially grew because of the sword or like Mormonism which became large because of things like polygamy and being greatly isolated from the rest of civilization.
 
Last edited:
No on the fallen thing. As of right now, the instigators have all been rounded up and forced down to this world. Whoever is looking on, they have not fallen like us. Some are people, like us but the similarity ends there. The others are angels or some other sort of spirit being that we do not know about, other than that they exist.
Some may have been on the verge of falling if the tempters were not removed when they were. Having Satan as a martyr might just be enough to cause a revolution.

So why did god not remove the tempters from us? I don't think that is very fair ;)

So why would they care what happens to Satan: much less view him as a martyr?

The point is that God has an established order of things and they are that way for a reason.

I am quite sure you believe that god can unnecessarily torture a whole population just to encourage some other folk. If so then the reason is that he is an evil immoral bastard. It is as simple as that


If you think you can have so-called freedom without consequences then you just made a mistake.


I don't think I said any such thing


The real thing Satan wanted was his own rule, not really something that would be good for us.

Well if torturing a whole population for no reason related to their welfare but merely as an example: and then sending the majority of them to eternal damnation when you don't have to is the better option for us what, pray, is worse?

The trick is to promise something we will get but Satan never keeps his promises. Instead a freedom from control by God, we get slavery from Satan. Of course he does not present it that way. He lies.

Satan does not lie: he does not exist. God does not lie: he does not exist.

But if either of them did exist you have done a great job in making me a Satanist :)
 
Thanks, DOC, for that intriguing list.
I'm not quite sure that the "Buddha lies in his grave but JC doesn't" reason is particularly convincing, but it seems more to the point of the OP than speculation of the Earth as a sort of Botany Bay for the moral instruction of folk in another part of the galaxy, if I've understood Ethnikos.

Zooterkin. Thanks for the link to the 123 page thread. :boxedin:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom