The Truth of Christianity vs. All Other Belief Systems

Ethnikos, is murder wrong only because your god told you not to do it?

If your god had said murder is okey-dokey with him, would you smile as someone killed your child, and thank him for it afterwards?
Yahveh would never say that if He's your God, unless, of course, you yourself have offended Him somehow, for instance by being overly happy, sucessfull and devout, in which case you smile, keep worshipping and wait for the boils. Then, in the end, you may get some kids back* and perhaps sheep.


In other words: this hypothetical is completely ridiculous.


*...by the "miracle of birth", of course, and with a new spouse, because the old one will probably also be killed.
 
Is Ethnikos a Freeman on the Land-er?
The speech pattern here -- using this odd convoluted labeling, rather than just saying "Saturday" -- reminds me of their circumlocutions that have John Smith, of 123 Blank Street, insisting that he is really "the man called John of the family called Smith, currently residing in and receiving mail at the house standing on the lot numbered 123 on the street called Blank".
I was wondering last night if someone was going to use my word pattern to make a determination of my particular form of insanity.
As for a free-land, N. Korea and Iran are good examples of that concept and why the "NWO" is so hostile towards them. Wako, the assault on Mt. Carmel, is the US "government's" object lesson to the "citizens" that no free-land will be tolerated.
The reason I worded it that way is because the word Saturday is not in the Bible. God demonstrated the week, and which day the seventh was, with the miracle of the manna. It would go bad after one day if not eaten, except on the Sabbath, since it was not lawful to gather on that day, hence the accusation against Jesus by the Pharisees for allowing his disciples to gather grain on that day.
 
Last edited:
As for a free-land, N. Korea and Iran are good examples of that concept and why the "NWO" is so hostile towards them. Wako, the assault on Mt. Carmel, is the US "government's" object lesson to the "citizens" that no free-land will be tolerated.
I'm sorry, are you saying that North Korea is a free land? You do know about the Christian woman who was just executed for distributing Bibles, yes?
 
I was implying that you were one of those people, Ethnikos, that does not cherish life.
I don't know how you make that assumption about how I feel about life.
You think you know the reason behind our existence and our purpose with no proof. In fact, today a lot of the so-called purpose proves inefficient to living a full life.
Like what? Helping others who can not repay the favor? That would be inefficient.
At least atheists and agnostics have the cojones to admit they don't know the answers to these questions, rather than try to answer them in a way that is clearly wrong in conjunction with our lives today.
If someone can not answer why they are alive, that's a problem, in my opinion. My answer may not be your answer and I would not expect it to be. Everyone should come up with an answer, however they can.
The fact that you can apply it loosely to this day and age is no more impressive than astrology.
Being taught that the world would end shortly did affect my attitude about life. Once you live long enough to see so many of your friends die, the affect wears off because you realize everyone is vulnerable, at any time, to having their life ending. Predicting how and when future events will happen is not that useful, no matter how you do it. You just have to know that when you see one thing happen, you know there will be another thing happening, shortly.
 
Last edited:
Everyone should come up with an answer, however they can.

I agree 100%, but if you agree to that, then you'd also agree that since everyone is so unique in their own way, that they should find their own connection with God. How can this be done in an institutionalized religion? This same religion will have a different answer for two different people. Do we just detach ourselves from the religion to the point that no matter what is done it can be interpreted as the will of god?

That's cheap and not helpful to anyone in the long run. Like I said, its nothing more than a charade.

There are plenty of real-world ways to help someone that can't help themselves. As you can see there are plenty of atheists that have no problem functioning in day-to-day life.

Why believe in Jesus over Horus? Horus came before Jesus so how is Jesus the real one when he's nothing more than a pagan copy? Not to mention he never even actually lived!

Are there non-biblical accounts of Jesus performing miracles? Or is that just in the bible because its used to control people and force them to believe that your take on god is correct?
 
Ethinikos I am getting the impression that you are an extreme form of calvinist. Would that be correct ?
 
I would have to disagree but the good news it is out there for people to decide themselves.
And the good news is that most people are intelligent enough to laugh at your irrational arguments.
 
And there is the difference between you and me. I take full responsibility for EVERYTHING I do in life. I will not beg forgiveness of someone or something that has nothing to do with the situation. And don't say "I do take full responsibility" because if you have to 'give yourself to Christ' you are no longer yourself, despite all the crap you spew about being an individual.
If God wanted to, He could refrain from involving Himself in the situation. He did, in the person of Jesus. Begging is not required, because belief equals forgiveness. One example would be the thief on the cross story. He said he deserved whatever he got, then showed he believed Jesus was the Messiah. There was no begging, no asking for forgiveness, just acknowledging he was guilty of something, not even specifying what it was he was guilty of.
Your 'give yourself to Jesus' could correspond to a verse that says 'make yourself a living sacrifice'. What was meant here was for the believer to conform mentally to Jesus' idea of being good, and so being of that better nature, demonstrate that God's plan is working.
I'm sorry you've fallen so deep into this woo but it wouldn't be so bad if you accepted that you were blatantly wrong about what is considered the 'truth' in this situation. No one would fault you for believing in God, but all this extra baggage like god sending his son to die because we're all inherently evil? Just goes to show how much faith you REALLY have in humanity.
You mean like destroying a country in order to have the privilege to sell the oil rights. Or destroying two or three countries in order to prevent the building of an oil pipeline that you do not own?
Why do you think you know more than me about what god wants from us? The Bible is no where near the same as it was when it was first put together. So what parts are the 'literal word of god'? And what parts can we just ignore and shrug off as BS?
I got my copy of Misquoting Jesus in the mail and am reading it.
Your god is outdated in this day and age. Your religion advocates the use of magic (raising from the dead, alchemy etc.) and yet condemns the other religions that use it because they're not the 'one true religion'.
If another religion was raising people from the dead, I would find that very interesting.
(Just think how easy it was thousands of years ago to trick people into believing something magical without the variety of tests we have today by claiming some higher power did it. And here's the kicker: People are STILL falling for it even when we have mounds of evidence!)
It would be really nice if people had video cameras to record Jesus' miracles.
Its all nice and dandy that you can get some good ideas from christianity but it doesn't mean that they ONLY come from christianity. There is nothing in christianity that can't be offered in some other religion and thus it is not special.
Maybe. If you lived in a country where you did not have the option to be exposed to Christianity, God would have to find another way to get to you. Things are possible because of Jesus' work and it may not knowingly be coming to that person from Jesus, but it would be, anyway.
Your god is an angry, jealous, tyrant. Sin is in the eye of the beholder. You've lost faith in mankind thinking that the only way to survive is by surrendering to Jesus. Using fear of the unknown as well as promises of eternal happiness?
There is a Spirit in the world of a Jesus nature that can benefit everyone, whether you surrender, or not.
What a charade! It is truly despicable.
What I find despicable is people who claim that you have to come to them, first, in order to reach Jesus.
 
Let me know what the correct answer is. Unless you mean the thing at the beginning about a papyrus. That is a New Testament text. I was talking about an Old Testament Text and it was not on that page.

You must have missed this specific section right here.

A lot of religions but I can not make a list.

I didn't ask for a list. Just run me through your top three or four.

The seventh day of the week that corresponds with the day commonly called Saturday.

So Jews and Catholics are off the hook then, yes? As well as the Seventh Day Adventists, and Seventh Day Baptists.


Which ones?

Jesus is God's Son, one way or another, he just is, . . . [snip] My point is that creating this sense of familiarity with God is a little premature. Pray to God in the spirit and have that prayer presented on our behalf by God's true Son who longs to be your advocate before the throne of glory.

This contradicts what you said earlier.

The way I remember it, he worked there and was friends with the editor. The editor let it go ahead and then got into a lot of trouble over it. He never said that it was retracted, but maybe he just skipped that part of the story. I do not remember him saying how you can find it, so something a little fishy maybe. His web side does not give a reference to it, at least that I ran across.

Stephen Meyer did not work for the Smithsonian (unless you have evidence to contrary). The editor, who allowed his paper to be published had an unpaid position as a research assistant there at one point. The article to which you are referencing, "The origin of biological information and the higher taxonomic categories", was never published by the Smithsonian. It was published, and then restracted, by Proceedings of the Biological Society of Washington for the reasons I previously stated. Here you can read the specific statement by the Biological Society of Washington. Enjoy!
 
.
You are so far below a "top scientist" in what you present here that it is pathetic to watch.
Ignorance of just about everything, with invocations of the wildest fantasies, which are completely unsupportable by anything rational.
You have no idea what is or isn't "relevant" to this subject.
Get an education in it, and come back in a few years.
So, everything I write is wrong?
I am not claiming to be a top scientist myself. I am saying there are people like that and it may be useful to listen to them, but it is still up to the individual to come to their own conclusions.
My contention is that ordinary people have the ability and responsibility to form inside their own mind, their own religion, whether it matches the one of your local church, or not.
 
Witnesses work as evidence in the courtroom and in my reasoning.
.
Witnesses testimony is at the bottom of the list for useability in a courtroom.
It's all too often biased, mistaken, and untruthful.
Gee, just like religions.
Hard evidence is much to be preferred for establishing fact.
 
My contention is that ordinary people have the ability and responsibility to form inside their own mind, their own religion, whether it matches the one of your local church, or not.
But surely religion is at it's heart a claim about absolute truth? Either there is a God, or there isn't. Either God is like this, or likes that. All personal religions can't be equally valid! Is the truth just the watered down median position of all these different personal religions..? In which case clearly it doesn't matter if God gets a special day once a week, or not. All you're left with is an idea that God exist in some sense and would prefer it if you believed in him/her/it/them. Everything else is subjective fluff that we can pick and choose as we please.
 
So, everything I write is wrong?
I am not claiming to be a top scientist myself. I am saying there are people like that and it may be useful to listen to them, but it is still up to the individual to come to their own conclusions.
My contention is that ordinary people have the ability and responsibility to form inside their own mind, their own religion, whether it matches the one of your local church, or not.
.
Everything you wrote has chaos due to ignorance of the very subject embedded in the messages.
it's as if your source book is the Baltimore Catechism or some other basic entry level tome into religious indoctrination, AND a serious scattering through the messages of fantasy and science fiction.
No attempt at research for anything you state as fact shows at all!
 
But surely religion is at it's heart a claim about absolute truth? Either there is a God, or there isn't. Either God is like this, or likes that. All personal religions can't be equally valid! Is the truth just the watered down median position of all these different personal religions..? In which case clearly it doesn't matter if God gets a special day once a week, or not. All you're left with is an idea that God exist in some sense and would prefer it if you believed in him/her/it/them. Everything else is subjective fluff that we can pick and choose as we please.


Exactly. At the point that everyone is given freedom from following any doctrine, you don't even need a Bible/Torah/Q'uran to be confused from. So Ethnikos' argument that the current Bible needs an overhaul is completely invalid, as is the concept that worshipping on a particular day, or calling God a particular name.
 
You mean like destroying a country in order to have the privilege to sell the oil rights. Or destroying two or three countries in order to prevent the building of an oil pipeline that you do not own?

Hey hey hey now, I never said I agreed with America. Of course I find that wrong. But that is completely irrelevant to religion. If anything its done in the name of Christianity as that is dubya's religion is it not?

And no religions are raising people from the dead. There are those that claim this, such as Christianity.

Can you just answer why Christianity is correct and all other religions are wrong? If you can't, then Christianity is just as wrong.

Simply put, your god contradicts what we actually know of the world. The only reason your religion lives on is because when they are proved wrong, they appeal to authority, use some fancy footwork, and next thing you know that thing they were wrong about is irrelevant.

You are a part of the same religion that believed the Earth was the center of the universe.

This has been proven to be wrong. So how can we lend credibility to all other aspects of it? We can't. All you can do is reinterpret your book into saying what fits the situation at hand.

And thats sad. You really need to think for yourself. There is NOTHING institutionalized religion has to offer that you can't get from somewhere else. And the plus side is we wouldn't get all the negativity from said institutionalized religion.

In my town of 20k people there are 76 churches. You can drive through my town in 4 minutes at 40 mph. Do those churches pay taxes? No. They're part of the reason our economy is sinking as well as our morals.

Your religion is obsolete. It doesn't fit in with todays standards and ideals. You can interpret all you want but your god is no more believable than rudolph the red-nosed reindeer.
 
Exactly. At the point that everyone is given freedom from following any doctrine, you don't even need a Bible/Torah/Q'uran to be confused from. So Ethnikos' argument that the current Bible needs an overhaul is completely invalid, as is the concept that worshipping on a particular day, or calling God a particular name.
But having been given this freedom, people start deciding that they're right and other people are wrong. Everybody is right just isn't an internally consistent position.
 
But having been given this freedom, people start deciding that they're right and other people are wrong. Everybody is right just isn't an internally consistent position.

I can see that my statement seemed to be endorsing either freedom from, or support of, doctrine. I did not mean that. I was only drawing out a conclusion based on the concept that Ethikos is trying to put forward. What you say is the point that I was trying to get across when I said that Ethikos' arguments for using the Bible, in whatever form, worshipping on a particular day, calling God a particular name, etc., are all rendered completely invalid and untenable.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom