The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why does Vixen do this? Does she think we cannot click on the links she herself provides? Why does she post pics of windows at the cottage saying, "Here's a pic with no bars on the window", when the pic itself shows that there are?

Why does Vixen say that Vecchiotti said, "Vecchiotti confirmed under oath that there was no contamination risk in Stefanoni's lab," when Vecchiotti said no such thing? Why does Vixen say that Dr. Gill said that secondary transfer not happen after 24 hours when he said no such thing? Why does Vixen claim that Prof Novelli confirmed Stefanoni's forensic work, when what Novelli's told the court was that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols on multiple amplifications?

These are not even subtle mistruths. Imagine someone wandering onto this thread with no knowledge of this case whatsoever - why does Vixen think that posting demonstrable lies will convince them of Vixen's own views?

As Welshman repeats - if the case against RS and AK had been such a slam dunk, why resort to lies? Why?


Here's the Peter Gill quote:

Quote:
Try reading Peter Gill's "Misleading DNA Evidence" where he contradicts himself on the case by saying chances of getting a reportable profile via passive transfer is "very low" >24 hrs after last contact (p76-77)
- From a review by N Ahmed

As for Vecchiotti, as I have pointed to her testimony under oath when she asked several times whether Stef's labs were contaminated was forced to concur they were not.

Citation please from the court documents that the laboratory was contaminated.

No court found any contamination in the lab.

As for Novelli on Stefanoni at the Nencini Appeal (from a review of the Netflix film):

He upholds that the Forensic Police, aside from some human error, acted correctly and dismissed defence claims that Stefanoni had withheld raw data, and as claimed by ‘the experts’, citing documentary proof the information had been deposited. Nencini reinstated the convictions, 31 January 2014, and dismissed the claim of contamination. The sample on the knife ‘the experts’ had claimed was ‘starch’ and ‘too low LCN’ was successfully tested and found to be that of Amanda Knox. None of this is mentioned by Vecchiotti & Conti in the film and nor do the film makers point it out, leaving their audience to believe ‘the experts’ claim of ‘contamination is proven’.

A key finding was that Professors Novelli and Torricelli had already been the target of the criticisms raised specifically by Prof. Adriano Tagliabracci, technical consultant for the Sollecito defense, at the first instance trial court, and thus was a matter settled (res judicata). This is important to note, for Marasca later describes Tagliabracci in glowing terms as ‘world renowned’ when he reinstates the Hellmann findings in this matter, at the next level. Nencini observes, ‘Finally, it is observed that Prof. Tagliabracci’s criticism is founded on an unproven and unprovable suspicion, namely that the biologist doing the work being already in possession of reference samples supposedly used the “suspect-centric” method.’

Nencini also found that the second instance [Hellman] court undervalued the fact that the tests carried out took place during the preliminary investigation [of which the Defence was notified and had the right to attend], that at the time of those tests, there were no objections concerning the sampling and laboratory activity, nor was a pre‐trial hearing requested regarding the testing, all of which proves agreement with the [laboratory] procedures.
 
Last edited:
Here's the Peter Gill quote:

- From a review by N Ahmed

As for Vecchiotti, as I have pointed to her testimony under oath when she asked several times whether Stef's labs were contaminated was forced to concur they were not.

Citation please from the court documents that the laboratory was contaminated.

No court found any contamination in the lab.

LOL! You're citing an astrologer, claiming that as a peer review of Peter Gill's work. LOL!

For the umpteenth time - it is not up to a court to find contamination, or up to the defence to provide a route for contamination. As presented here countless times, a lab which does LCN work must be certified for it, which Stefanoni's lab was not.

When I asked for a forensic-DNA expert who would back Stefanoni's work, I wasn't asking for an astrologer's point of view.
 
This is an unbelievably foolish statement. Of course there was and is in every lab doing PCR a contamination risk. That is exactly why precautions have be taken and adhered to, to prevent contamination. That you can post this demonstrates you have no understanding of the issues.

This is particularly foolish in that the records available demonstrate a contamination event in that we have negative controls with detectable human DNA.

So not only can DNA contamination occur we know it did occur.

Nice try at wool-pulling.
 
Do you even read the links you put up?

Can we record this as another Vixen false fact?

What your link says, "Two prints matching Raffaele Sollecito (Fr. 68 and Fr. 72) are on the outside of the door." (my emphasis)

#68 is on the outside of the door. the two #72 prints are on the inner door.
 
Actually i should thank Vixen for bringing this up. Fr B is a finger print of Guede. For some reason this is not numbered like other prints. Despite there being this fingerprint at the crime scene and despite Guede's fingerprints being on record it was not an attempt to identify this fingerprint that identified Guede which just goes to show that the police made little or no attempt to identify the unknown fingerprints (although a bloody handprint was just too obvious a clue to ignore).
 
I don't think you've even read her memoir from the false statements you made about what's in it. She never said prison doctors forced her to list her partners. This is what she testified:



She does not say, or even imply, that the doctors "forced" her to make a list. Why do you feel the need to just make things up?

The statement that he couldn't remember if they'd had sex that night was taken during his Nov 6 interrogation when he confused Halloween night with Nov. 1. Since then, Raffaele does remember having sex with her that night.



Why do you insist on twisting things to fit your own view?. This is what she actually wrote:







She is writing about the letters she received. She does not see them as "confirmation" that she's "hot". Her last two lines reveal her disdain for the claims of her beauty.



She never claimed she was "forced" as I proved with her testimony above.



Apparently you care if we go by the amount of times you refer to her sex life. Why is that?


She told the latest bunch of lawyers (LA?) she was forced to list her sex partners. Do keep up with the news. (Albeit, fake.)

Ask Bill. He is the one who is obsessed with 'slut shaming' (whatever that is).
 
#68 is on the outside of the door. the two #72 prints are on the inner door.

Your link was to a 100-page report which did not (readily at least) confirm your claim. Where you got the pics you posted is still unclear. Did you photoshop them yourself?

At least this is slightly better than posting pics which show the actual opposite of what you claimed they showed.
 
She told the latest bunch of lawyers (LA?) she was forced to list her sex partners. Do keep up with the news. (Albeit, fake.)

Ask Bill. He is the one who is obsessed with 'slut shaming' (whatever that is).

I probably am. I've seen that kind of bullying behaviour used as a substitute for actual evidence. It's also been used by bullies "just because", for the fun of it.

You seem to use it as a way to avoid presenting evidence which you claim is true - like one forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's work.
 
Last edited:
#68 is on the outside of the door. the two #72 prints are on the inner door.

So you disagree with the forensic scientist who was there at the time and testified that Sollecito's fingerprints were on the outside. Do you really know better than the people who were present and did the testing?

"There are two unattributable prints on the desk (Fr. 63) and two on the door (Fr.72)
Two prints matching Raffaele Sollecito (Fr. 68 and Fr. 72) are on the outside of the door."

They are colour coded to make it easy!
 
In all fairness to Vixen (did I really say that?...) if you look at the diagram, for some reason Fr. 72 is used both for two "unattributable" prints on the inside of the door as well as one of two prints attributed to Raffaele on the outside (the other being Fr. 68). Of course, the diagram is color coded and nowhere on the diagram does it say "Fr. 72 is Raffaele", so clearly Vixen wasn't paying close attention to details, but still there is something screwed up with the diagram.

Do read Agatino Giunta's testimony, where he states under oath:

AG:
17 fragments attributed to Kercher Meredith; 5 fragments attributed to Sollecito Raffaele; 1 fragment attributed to Knox Amanda; 15 fragments attributed to Mezzetti Laura; 5 fragments Romanelli Filomena; 4 fragments Silenzi Giacomo.'

The five Sollecito fragments being as in the police photos:

'Fr 68, Fr 72 [ x 2] - MK's door to her room, Fr 86 Kitchen/Living room (fridge) and Fr 12 in Laura's room. ' See earlier link.


Look at the photos for yourself.
 
Last edited:
This is TMofMK; they have lots of things wrong.

I find it impossible to believe that Vixen would think that Sollecito's fingerprints were on the inside of the door when that would have placed him inside that bedroom. That would have been strong evidence against him yet such fingerprints are never mentioned in any of the trials. We know that. She knows that.

Have a look at Agatino Giunta's court testimony and the court police photos, for yourself.
 
We know Raff's fingerprint is on the inside of the door to Mez' room, when he claimed he couldn't open her door at all.

Go figure.

In all fairness to Vixen (did I really say that?...) if you look at the diagram, for some reason Fr. 72 is used both for two "unattributable" prints on the inside of the door as well as one of two prints attributed to Raffaele on the outside (the other being Fr. 68). Of course, the diagram is color coded and nowhere on the diagram does it say "Fr. 72 is Raffaele", so clearly Vixen wasn't paying close attention to details, but still there is something screwed up with the diagram.

This is TMofMK; they have lots of things wrong.

I find it impossible to believe that Vixen would think that Sollecito's fingerprints were on the inside of the door when that would have placed him inside that bedroom. That would have been strong evidence against him yet such fingerprints are never mentioned in any of the trials. We know that. She knows that.

I'm not sure who/what the original source for the diagrams are but the amandaknoxcase website has the same diagram, so can't blame the fake wiki for this one.

What does it say at the top of the fingerprint map?
"DIREZIONE CENTRALE ANTICRIMINE SERVIZIO POLIZIA SCIENTIFICA UACV"
so it should be clear "who/what the original source for the diagrams are". ;)

Well, it looks like whoever made that "fingerprint map" mislabeled the prints on the inside of Meredith Kercher's bedroom door. This is from the final fingerprint report made by the Direzione centrale anticrimine della polizia di Stato (page 6):
- Nr.1 (uno), contraddistinto con il nr. 72 sul montante altezza serratura della porta della camera da letto;
- Nr.1 (uno), contraddistinto con il nr. 73 sul telaio lato interno sx della porta della camera da letto;
- Nr.1 (uno), contraddistino con il nr. 83 all'interno della maniglia interna della porta di ingresso della camera;

Long story short: prints Fr.73 and Fr.83 are mislabled in the map as Fr.72 :(
 
Wow Italians couldn't secure a conviction with fingerprints of the perp on the inner door covered in blood! Incredible prosecution team! :D
 
Here's the Peter Gill quote:

- From a review by N Ahmed

As for Vecchiotti, as I have pointed to her testimony under oath when she asked several times whether Stef's labs were contaminated was forced to concur they were not.

Citation please from the court documents that the laboratory was contaminated.

No court found any contamination in the lab.

As for Novelli on Stefanoni at the Nencini Appeal (from a review of the Netflix film):

He upholds that the Forensic Police, aside from some human error, acted correctly and dismissed defence claims that Stefanoni had withheld raw data, and as claimed by ‘the experts’, citing documentary proof the information had been deposited. Nencini reinstated the convictions, 31 January 2014, and dismissed the claim of contamination. The sample on the knife ‘the experts’ had claimed was ‘starch’ and ‘too low LCN’ was successfully tested and found to be that of Amanda Knox. None of this is mentioned by Vecchiotti & Conti in the film and nor do the film makers point it out, leaving their audience to believe ‘the experts’ claim of ‘contamination is proven’.

A key finding was that Professors Novelli and Torricelli had already been the target of the criticisms raised specifically by Prof. Adriano Tagliabracci, technical consultant for the Sollecito defense, at the first instance trial court, and thus was a matter settled (res judicata). This is important to note, for Marasca later describes Tagliabracci in glowing terms as ‘world renowned’ when he reinstates the Hellmann findings in this matter, at the next level. Nencini observes, ‘Finally, it is observed that Prof. Tagliabracci’s criticism is founded on an unproven and unprovable suspicion, namely that the biologist doing the work being already in possession of reference samples supposedly used the “suspect-centric” method.’

Nencini also found that the second instance [Hellman] court undervalued the fact that the tests carried out took place during the preliminary investigation [of which the Defence was notified and had the right to attend], that at the time of those tests, there were no objections concerning the sampling and laboratory activity, nor was a pre‐trial hearing requested regarding the testing, all of which proves agreement with the [laboratory] procedures.

That is not a quote from Gill. It is a quote of Ergon/N. Ahmad. Provide GILL saying that. And, please, do just continue to ignore where GILL has been quoted saying otherwise.
 
Why does Vixen do this? Does she think we cannot click on the links she herself provides? Why does she post pics of windows at the cottage saying, "Here's a pic with no bars on the window", when the pic itself shows that there are?

Why does Vixen say that Vecchiotti said, "Vecchiotti confirmed under oath that there was no contamination risk in Stefanoni's lab," when Vecchiotti said no such thing? Why does Vixen say that Dr. Gill said that secondary transfer not happen after 24 hours when he said no such thing? Why does Vixen claim that Prof Novelli confirmed Stefanoni's forensic work, when what Novelli's told the court was that Stefanoni had not followed international protocols on multiple amplifications?

These are not even subtle mistruths. Imagine someone wandering onto this thread with no knowledge of this case whatsoever - why does Vixen think that posting demonstrable lies will convince them of Vixen's own views?

As Welshman repeats - if the case against RS and AK had been such a slam dunk, why resort to lies? Why?

Vixen constantly bangs about the overwhelming evidence against Amanda and Raffaele. The fact PGP posters have to lie so much makes a complete mockery of this claim. If you have to resort to lying to argue the case for guilt, there is no case for guilt. Lying to argue your case indicates two things. Firstly, there is a lack of genuine evidence and the only way PGP can argue their case is to make things up. As can be seen from Vixen’s posts she constantly makes things up. If there is a slam dunk case, you should never have to resort to making things up because there should be plenty of genuine evidence to base your arguments on. Secondly, the facts don’t support your case, there are flaws in the prosecution’s case and the only way you can argue your case is to tell lies which contradict the facts. We see numerous examples of this in Vixen’s posts which I detailed in the post below. The fact Amanda showed grief over Meredith’s death which was supported by witness testimony goes against the case for guilt. Vixen has to lie that Amanda showed no guilt which contradicts witness testimony. The fact there was no human biological material such as cells and tissue on the knife is a major problem with the knife. Vixen has to lie Stefanoni found human tissue on the knife to cover up this problem. The fact experts who did not work for the defence could not rule out a single attacker undermines the notion there had to be multiple attackers. To cover this up Vixen has to lie only defence lawyers argued for a single attacker. If the facts support the case for guilt, you should never have to lie about the facts.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=11938562#post11938562

As I have mentioned previously PGP posters have displayed disgusting hypocrisy when attacking Amanda and Raffaele for telling umpteen lies whilst telling umpteen lies themselves. When PGP bang on about the supposed umpteen lies told by Amanda and Raffaele, I feel there is an element of projection and when PGP talk about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies they are referring to the umpteen lies they tell themselves.
 
Last edited:
You do realise this means an internal door? As opposed to the main door? The finger prints on the 'inner' door were on the corridor not the bedroom surface. They are colour coded and finger prints of an unknown person were found on the bedroom side of the door.

Of course you may ask how much effort did the police put into tracking down whose fingerprints were in the murder room? I mean it was a judicial fact that more than one person was involved in the murder, we have fingerprints of an unknown person in the room, we have DNA of an unknown male on the bra hook. But why bother going to the effort of identifying this person? When one can just fit up someone else.

You know what I meant: inner edge of the door, in the metallic area of the lock.
 
#68 is on the outside of the door. the two #72 prints are on the inner door.

Sigh. Then please explain to us all here just why the link itself says "Two prints matching Raffaele Sollecito (Fr. 68 and Fr. 72) are on the outside of the door," and that #72 found on the inside of the door is unattributed?
 
Your link was to a 100-page report which did not (readily at least) confirm your claim. Where you got the pics you posted is still unclear. Did you photoshop them yourself?

At least this is slightly better than posting pics which show the actual opposite of what you claimed they showed.

I copied the photos from the police photo file (public domain) and for your ease of reference captioned them for you.

I even gave you fingerprint expert Giunta's direct quotes under testimony confirming these five particular fingerprints are Raff's.

I told you precisely on what page Peter Gill's own assertion that secondary transfer is unlikely to yield a full profile >24 hours (p76 -77).

What thanks do I get?
 
Nice try at wool-pulling.

"It is simple to find the contaminated negative control in Batch 4. Stefanoni’s own quantification results for Real Time run no. 564 show the negative control (NTC, or No Template Control) located at wells B10-12, and well B11 shows a “Ct” value of 34.30. (Quantificazione p. 14)"

http://www.amandaknoxcase.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/Quantificazione.pdf

Look at the results yourself. This is why access ('discovery') to the laboratory records is essential. Steffanoni testified that she had no contamination yet the negative control contained detectable human DNA; this is contamination.
 
Sigh. Then please explain to us all here just why the link itself says "Two prints matching Raffaele Sollecito (Fr. 68 and Fr. 72) are on the outside of the door," and that #72 found on the inside of the door is unattributed?

Read Giunt'as testimony.

There are THREE prints on the door of Raff's. #68 is on the outside of Mez' door. OK so far?

#72 is TWO prints on the metallic part of the inner edge of the door.

Giunta identifies them as Raff's.

Clear now?
 

Attachments

  • fingerprints 2.jpeg
    fingerprints 2.jpeg
    39.2 KB · Views: 5
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom