The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
As I have mentioned previously PGP posters have displayed disgusting hypocrisy when attacking Amanda and Raffaele for telling umpteen lies whilst telling umpteen lies themselves. When PGP bang on about the supposed umpteen lies told by Amanda and Raffaele, I feel there is an element of projection and when PGP talk about Amanda and Raffaele telling umpteen lies they are referring to the umpteen lies they tell themselves.

A shadowy guilter pseudo-named Harry Rag/The Machine at one time listed these supposed-lies, as well as an anonymous blogger whose blog is now off-line.

Here's a re-post of what (unless someone can add to it) the alleged lies either Knox or Sollectio told....

This is a reconstruction from two sources, first Peter Quennell's page, post by The Machine aka. Harry Rag.

Lie one. Raffaele Sollecito first claimed in an interview with Kate Mansey from the Sunday Mirror that he and Amanda Knox were at a friend’s party on the night of the murder. It would have been obviously a tad difficult for Sollecito to find any witnesses who had attended an imaginary party to provide him and Knox with an alibi. This alibi was predictably abandoned very quickly.

Lie two. Sollecito then claimed that he was his apartment with Amanda Knox. This alibi is flatly contradicted by a silent witness: forensic evidence. According to the scientific police, there are six separate pieces of forensic evidence, including an abundant amount of his DNA on Meredith’s bra clasp, that place him in the cottage on Via della Pergola on the night of the murder.

Lie three. Sollecito then came up with a third alibi. He claimed that he was alone at his apartment and that Knox had gone out from 9pm to 1am. Both Sollecito and Knox gave completely different accounts of where they were, who they were with and what they doing on the night of the murder. These weren’t small inconsistencies, but huge, whopping lies.

Lie four. Sollecito and Knox told the postal police that he had called the police before the postal police had turned up at the cottage and were waiting for them. Sollecito later admitted that this was not true and that he had lied because he had believed Amanda Knox’s version of what had happened.

Lie five. He said he went outside “to see if I could climb up to Meredith’s window” but could not. “I tried to force the door but couldn’t, and at that point I decided to call my sister for advice because she is a Carabinieri officer. She told me to dial 112 (the Italian emergency number) but at that moment the postal police arrived. He added: “In my former statement I told you a load of rubbish because I believed Amanda’s version of what happened and did not think about the inconsistencies.” (The Times, 7 November, 2007).

Lie six. Knox and Sollecito said they couldn’t remember most of what happened on the night of the murder, because they had smoked cannabis. It is medically impossible for cannabis to cause such dramatic amnesia and there are no studies that have ever demonstrated that this is possible.

Lie seven. Sollecito claimed that he had spoken to his father at 11pm. Phone records show that there was no telephone conversation at this time. Sollecito’s father called him a couple of hours earlier at 8.40pm.

Lie eight. Sollecito claimed that he was surfing the Internet from 11pm to 1am. The Kercher’s lawyer, Franco Maresca, pointed out that credible witnesses had shattered Sollecito’s alibi for the night of the murder. Sollecito still maintains he was home that night, working on his computer, but computer specialists have testified that his computer was not used for an eight-hour period on the night of Meredith’s murder

Lie nine. Sollecito claimed that he had slept until 10pm the next day. However, he used his computer at 5.32am and turned on his mobile phone at 6.02am. The Italian Supreme Court remarked that his night was “sleepless” to say the least.

Lie ten. When Sollecito heard that the scientific police had found Meredith’s DNA on the double DNA knife in his apartment. He told a cock and bull story about accidentally pricking Meredith’s hand whilst cooking at his apartment. “The fact that Meredith’s DNA is on my kitchen knife is because once, when we were all cooking together, I accidentally pricked her hand." Meredith had never been to Sollecito’s apartment. Sollecito could not have accidentally pricked her hand whilst cooking. (Note: this is the one uncontested, and only one, bona fide lie Sollecito told. It was remarkable as an awkward lie.)

Now from the blog there are.....

Lie eleven. - Finally, a lie from Amanda, about how Knox gave a sontaneous confession to Mignini in interrogation, a lie about Patrick Lumumba.

Repeat of lie 1. Just two days after the murder, Raffaele Sollecito gave an interview to Kate Mansey of the UK’s Sunday Mirror in which he explained his first version of the events. “It was a normal night. Meredith had gone out with one of her English friends and Amanda and I went to party with one of my friends.”

Lie twelve. - from Amanda, about the spot of blood she saw in the bathroom - "At first I thought they had come from my ears. But then when I scratched the drops a bit, I saw they were all dry, and I thought ‘That’s weird. Oh well, I'll take my shower.’” After that, she dried her hair, got dressed and calmly returned to Raffaele’s apartment.

Lie thirteen. “…Then he came out and we made breakfast, and while we were preparing it and drinking coffee, I explained to him what I had seen, and I asked him for advice, because when I went into my house, everything seemed in order, only there were these little weird things, and I couldn't figure out how to understand them.” This is hardly the panicked girl that Raffaele described. (Note: So this is a lie attributed to Raffaele?)

Repeat of lie #2, although the blog calls it a "change of story". - Raffaele told police that he and Knox stayed at his flat the entire night of November 1, 2007 (night of the murder)

Repeat of lie #3, although the blog calls it a "change of story". - During his November 5, 2007 interrogation and subsequent arrest, Sollecito wanted to come clean, and he told police that his previous version to them was “un sacco di cazzate” (a load of rubbish). “In my former statement I told you a load of rubbish because I believed Amanda’s version of what happened and did not think about the inconsistencies.” (The Times, 7 November, 2007). He said he and Knox returned to his flat at approximately 8:30pm, and that Knox left his apartment, while he stayed there, and she returned at around 1:00am. He claimed that he believed that she went to see if she had to work that evening. This was clearly an attempt to exonerate himself from any culpability, as Knox had received a text message from her then boss, Patrick Lumumba, at 8:19pm that evening informing Knox that it was slow at the bar and she would not be needed to work that evening.

Variation of lie #3, although the blog calls it a "change of story". - after his arrest, Raffaele wrote several letters to his father while in prison. This was written under no duress. In the letter, Raffaele explains to his father that he and Knox had arrived at his flat at about 8 – 8:30 pm on the night of the murder. “Amanda had [then] left for work,” he writes, but he could not remember how long she was gone—but he writes that he is “certain” that Knox had stayed with him the “entire night.”

Variation of lie #3. - Then, he shows uncertainty whether or not Knox had committed the murder (or knew something about it) and blatantly calls her a liar...Raffaele writes to his father: “I try to understand what Amanda's role was in this event. The Amanda that I know is an Amanda who lives a carefree life. Her only thought is the pursuit of pleasure at all times. But even the thought that she could be a killer is impossible for me. I have read her version of events. Some of the things she said are not true, but I don't know why she said them.” (Note: this says precisely the OPPOSITE of what the blogger claims it says.)​

There you go. See if you agree whether or not these are bona fide lies.

Compare and contrast with the lies told about Raffaele and Amanda.
 
Read Giunt'as testimony.

There are THREE prints on the door of Raff's. #68 is on the outside of Mez' door. OK so far?

#72 is TWO prints on the metallic part of the inner edge of the door.

Giunta identifies them as Raff's.

Clear now?

Yes. The best evidence the prosecution had this whole case is just now making its appearance on part 26 of our silly little thread. Amazing that nobody spotted this before.
 
LOL! You're citing an astrologer, claiming that as a peer review of Peter Gill's work. LOL!

For the umpteenth time - it is not up to a court to find contamination, or up to the defence to provide a route for contamination. As presented here countless times, a lab which does LCN work must be certified for it, which Stefanoni's lab was not.

When I asked for a forensic-DNA expert who would back Stefanoni's work, I wasn't asking for an astrologer's point of view.

Tut, tut, Bill. Someone who is into a holistic lifestyle is just as qualified to spot the glaring contradictions in Peter Gill's book as anybody.

Quit the ad hominem. It is not becoming of you.
 
Stacyhs said:
That is not a quote from Gill. It is a quote of Ergon/N. Ahmad. Provide GILL saying that. And, please, do just continue to ignore where GILL has been quoted saying otherwise.
PAGE 76 - 77

How hard can it be to provide a quote? Until you do your point remains an assertion.
 
Tut, tut, Bill. Someone who is into a holistic lifestyle is just as qualified to spot the glaring contradictions in Peter Gill's book as anybody.

Quit the ad hominem. It is not becoming of you.

Since when is calling someone an astrologer an ad hominem?

For the umpteenth time, provide a cite to a forensic-DNA expert which confirms Stefanoni's work.
 
PAGE 76 - 77

Whether Gill said this or not is irrelevant as evidence has been posted that DNA transfer is detectable beyond 24 hours. Logically there is no reason for a time limit on transfer. If DNA is detectably present it is transferrable (by definition as it has to transfer from the site on to the swab to be detectable).

ETA let us consider transfer as proposed by Vixen
Transfer 1 DNA from Kercher on Knox
Transfer 2 (secondary) DNA of Kercher from Knox's hands on to basin (along with Knox's DNA a primary transfer).
Transfer 3 (tertiary) DNA of Kercher from the basin onto the swab (along with Knox's DNA a secondary transfer).

If we consider the Luminol positive prints that were DNA positive.

Transfer 1 Kercher's DNA onto floor.
Transfer 2 Kerchers DNA from floor onto Knox's feet
Transfer 3 Kercher's DNA from from Knox's feet to floor
Transfer 4 Kercher's DNA from floor (some six weeks after the murder) to swab.

Now if we are to believe Vixen a quaternary transfer of DNA six weeks later is impossible so we can only conclude that the forensic police must have made up the results.
 
Last edited:
Since Raffaele never had any reason to step foot in Meredith's room in the one or two times he visited the cottage, and since he never admitted to ever doing so, and since his fingerprints were found on the inside of her door after the murder, I have no choice but to become a 100% born again guilter. It is now me and Vixen vs the world.

My only regret is that the prosecution did not make this damning evidence the front centerpiece of their case, and instead went with blood negative DNA negative blurry stains, and tales of floating turds. He got away with it :mad:
 
#68 is on the outside of the door. the two #72 prints are on the inner door.


Holy smoke. Sollecito's discovered prints are on the surface of the (interior) door which faces the corridor. Not on the surface which faces into Kercher's room.

End.

Of.
 
Whether Gill said this or not is irrelevant as evidence has been posted that DNA transfer is detectable beyond 24 hours. Logically there is no reason for a time limit on transfer. If DNA is detectably present it is transferrable (by definition as it has to transfer from the site on to the swab to be detectable).

ETA let us consider transfer as proposed by Vixen
Transfer 1 DNA from Kercher on Knox
Transfer 2 (secondary) DNA of Kercher from Knox's hands on to basin (along with Knox's DNA a primary transfer).
Transfer 3 (tertiary) DNA of Kercher from the basin onto the swab (along with Knox's DNA a secondary transfer).

If we consider the Luminol positive prints that were DNA positive.

Transfer 1 Kercher's DNA onto floor.
Transfer 2 Kerchers DNA from floor onto Knox's feet
Transfer 3 Kercher's DNA from from Knox's feet to floor
Transfer 4 Kercher's DNA from floor (some six weeks after the murder) to swab.

Now if we are to believe Vixen a quaternary transfer of DNA six weeks later is impossible so we can only conclude that the forensic police must have made up the results.


No, no! Naseer Ahmed, in his no-doubt IMPECCABLY OBJECTIVE "analysis" of Gill's work, has decreed otherwise. And he's even provided page numbers of Gill's work!!!

What more evidence could anyone possibly need?

I tell you once again, Planigale:

PAGE 76-77

:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D:D
 
The following is what Dr. Peter Gill says about the reality of DNA-contamination in the Kercher case. And I'm even going to provide the link which you can check!!!!!!! Just to see if I'm making all this up.

http://www.fsigenetics.com/article/S1872-4973(16)30033-3/fulltext

Highlights:

- Transfer of DNA found on the evidential material was either contamination or ‘innocent’.

- (Hellmann and Zanetti) acquitted Knox and Sollecito, accepting defence arguments on the lack of evidence and contamination.

- Given the proven innocence of Knox/Sollecito we are confronted with multiple instances of the CSI effect, where prosecutors, scientists and judges, allow speculation to override logical thought processes.

- One officer who handled the knife at police headquarters had been in Kercher’s apartment, and specifically in Knox’s room, earlier in the day. Police officers did not remove other knives or test them to control for background contamination.

- (the knife) was allegedly tested approximately seven days after the last testing of a sample belonging to Kercher. Anti-contamination procedures were not documented (or disclosed);

- it is unknown if or how surfaces were sterilized; what protective equipment was used; whether equipment was cleaned after each run; or how often technicians changed gloves. This was contrary to the European Network of Forensic Science Institutes (ENFSI) guidelines on contamination prevention (for example) which state clearly: “There must be written procedures for cleaning and decontamination of facilities and equipment.”

- (Gill criticizes the Nencini court for reversing the implication of Stefanoni not providing documents concerning control runs to Conti and Vecchiotti.)

- (Nencini's) was also a serious error of interpretation. The negative control is simply a blank or empty tube run concurrently with the samples in the laboratory beginning at the extraction stage of the analytical process. Consequently, it can only be used as a control for potential reagent contamination. It cannot be used to discount possible contamination, either at the crime scene or in the examination room.​
I'm not going to go on, you can read it for yourself.

Suffice it to say that you can read a forensic-DNA expert (who also may or may not be an astrologer in his spare time) completely discredit Stefanoni's work, as well as the judicial mistakes that both Massei as well as Nencini made, when they tried to be the "expert of the experts".
 
Last edited:
Since Raffaele never had any reason to step foot in Meredith's room in the one or two times he visited the cottage, and since he never admitted to ever doing so, and since his fingerprints were found on the inside of her door after the murder, I have no choice but to become a 100% born again guilter. It is now me and Vixen vs the world.

My only regret is that the prosecution did not make this damning evidence the front centerpiece of their case, and instead went with blood negative DNA negative blurry stains, and tales of floating turds. He got away with it :mad:

I'm to blame. Vixen tried to get into the buildings housing Cassation on the Tiber in Rome, but I'd said to her, "O look! Squirrel!" and she got distracted. Before she could recover with this view-changing evidence, Cassation had acquitted and exonerated the pair.

Definitively.

My bad.
 
Oh Bill, will you never learn??

Here's a perfect example of how it actually works. Ready? OK:


Here's the Michael Jackson quote:

Try listening to Michael Jackson's "You are not alone" where he contradicts himself on the premise of the song by saying you are "alone" (0:59 into the song)

- From a review by LondonJohn


0:59, Bill!

0:59
 
What does it say at the top of the fingerprint map?
"DIREZIONE CENTRALE ANTICRIMINE SERVIZIO POLIZIA SCIENTIFICA UACV"
so it should be clear "who/what the original source for the diagrams are". ;)

Well, it looks like whoever made that "fingerprint map" mislabeled the prints on the inside of Meredith Kercher's bedroom door. This is from the final fingerprint report made by the Direzione centrale anticrimine della polizia di Stato (page 6):


Long story short: prints Fr.73 and Fr.83 are mislabled in the map as Fr.72 :(

Thanks Methos. Since you winked I won't take it as a personal affront. I was to focused on the fake wiki's 'zoom' of Meredith's room to notice the heading on the full document.
 
Holy smoke. Sollecito's discovered prints are on the surface of the (interior) door which faces the corridor. Not on the surface which faces into Kercher's room.

End.

Of.

I am honestly completely baffled how Vixen functions on a day-to-day basis. She has never posted anything that is correct. Ever. How is that even possible? Like shouldn't she be right accidentally sometimes....?
 
Thanks Methos. Since you winked I won't take it as a personal affront. I was to focused on the fake wiki's 'zoom' of Meredith's room to notice the heading on the full document.

Good. It wasn't meant that way. The one who seems to have reading comprehension problems isn't you, but, well, we know who. ;)
 
Read Giunt'as testimony.

There are THREE prints on the door of Raff's. #68 is on the outside of Mez' door. OK so far?

#72 is TWO prints on the metallic part of the inner edge of the door.

Giunta identifies them as Raff's.

Clear now?


Well, I'm not sure who put your little collage together but it contains some mistakes. First, so as to ensure we're dealing with the correct information, here's Giunta's court testimony;

***
Giunta: We can repeat it, I'm 17 - we said what reliefs are - 5 fragments at Sollecito Raffaele are the relief 12), we can even say the annular and left little finger, it was found ...

Comodi: I know it, but not as much as I do. Here, where has this fingerprint been found?

Giunta: Inside the bedroom door behind the living room with kitchenette on the ground floor.

Massei:In the bedroom ...

Giunta: The ground floor is the only floor we have also done because ...

Massei:Excuse me, what bedroom?

Comodi: And so, in short, the famous edge of the Mezzetti room, the Mezzetti room door, right?

Giunta: 12) should be that of the Mezzetti. Then the 68), the left palm, the outside face of the victim's bedroom door.

Comodi: Outside?

Giunta: External face, then external face access.

Comodi: Yup.

Giunta: Pad 70) left thumb, victim's bedroom outdoor door side and 1'86, pad 86) left palm at fridge door.

Comodi: Well, these are the ones that have been attributed to your Solicitors by your colleagues?

Giunta: Exactly, 5 fragments etc, etc. 1 fragment was attributed to Knox, and it is the relief 103) the right glass index found on the kitchen sink.

***

To summarize;

(12) Laura's bedroom door
(68) Outside face of Meredith's door
(70) Outside face of Meredith's door
(86) Refrigerator

So, the mistakes in your collage;

12 is from Laura's door, not the refrigerator
86 is from the refrigerator, not Laura's door
68 and 70 are from the outside of Meredith's bedroom door.

Giunta makes no mention of Fr. 72. That's because Fr. 72 was unidentified and so not relevant. The print diagram is entirely correct except they wrote 72 instead of 70 for the second print on the outside of Meredith's door, as proven by Giunta's testimony.

If you think any of this is incorrect then please provide Giunta testimony that contradicts the testimony I quoted above.

Clear now?

ETA: Interestingly, in your collage you correctly point out that Fr. 12 constitutes two of Sollecito print fragments - the ring finger and the little finger - yet you go on to claim there are three prints on the door, Fr. 68 and two prints identified as Fr. 72. If this was true then there would have been six Sollecito fragments, not five. Who the hell is doing your proof thinking? ....I'd fire 'em!
 
Last edited:
PAGE 76 - 77

Ergon <snip> does not provide the surrounding context of what he claims Gill wrote. In fact, unless he has a copy of the book itself, all he can read from it is from the "Look Inside" search on Amazon. And this is the only part that Ergon paraphrases:

Try reading Peter Gill's "Misleading DNA Evidence" where he contradicts himself on the case by saying chances of getting a reportable profile via passive transfer is "very low" >24 hrs after last contact (p76-77)


By looking at the Look Inside results on Amazon, we can see that Gill is discussing published scientific literature but we cannot see what Gill himself is saying about it. This is the abstract describing the chapter wherein pages 76-77 are included:

Abstract

It is never a good idea to highlight problems without providing the remedy. “Trace-DNA” is valuable evidence provided it is reported by constant reference to the published literature to support inferences. DNA evidence retrieved from underneath fingernails is used as the example. This is the best-researched evidence transfer that is commonly reported in serious violent assaults. Typically, a victim defends him/herself against an assailant and DNA is transferred from the perpetrator. Once a suspect is identified, a common defense will be that the transfer was from innocent transfer via passive social contact several days earlier. It is possible to evaluate the relative likelihoods of the prosecution vs. the defense propositions of transfer and persistence by referring to published experimental evidence. A generalized statement format is described, along with the limitations of evidence that can be adduced. The method explained follows the “scientific method” in order to avoid “speculation” on the part of the scientist. This reduces the chance of cognitive errors, especially confirmation bias.
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780124172142000036

So, no. PAGE 76-77 is not providing a quote from GILL. It merely cites the pages from which ERGON is paraphrasing something that Gill is referencing.


Edited by Loss Leader: 
Edited, possible Rule 8
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Well, I'm not sure who put your little collage together but it contains some mistakes. First, so as to ensure we're dealing with the correct information, here's Giunta's court testimony;

***
Giunta: We can repeat it, I'm 17 - we said what reliefs are - 5 fragments at Sollecito Raffaele are the relief 12), we can even say the annular and left little finger, it was found ...

Comodi: I know it, but not as much as I do. Here, where has this fingerprint been found?

Giunta: Inside the bedroom door behind the living room with kitchenette on the ground floor.

Massei:In the bedroom ...

Giunta: The ground floor is the only floor we have also done because ...

Massei:Excuse me, what bedroom?

Comodi: And so, in short, the famous edge of the Mezzetti room, the Mezzetti room door, right?

Giunta: 12) should be that of the Mezzetti. Then the 68), the left palm, the outside face of the victim's bedroom door.

Comodi: Outside?

Giunta: External face, then external face access.

Comodi: Yup.

Giunta: Pad 70) left thumb, victim's bedroom outdoor door side and 1'86, pad 86) left palm at fridge door.

Comodi: Well, these are the ones that have been attributed to your Solicitors by your colleagues?

Giunta: Exactly, 5 fragments etc, etc. 1 fragment was attributed to Knox, and it is the relief 103) the right glass index found on the kitchen sink.

***

To summarize;

(12) Laura's bedroom door
(68) Outside face of Meredith's door
(70) Outside face of Meredith's door
(86) Refrigerator

So, the mistakes in your collage;

12 is from Laura's door, not the refrigerator
86 is from the refrigerator, not Laura's door
68 and 70 are from the outside of Meredith's bedroom door.

Giunta makes no mention of Fr. 72. That's because Fr. 72 was unidentified and so not relevant. The print diagram is entirely correct except they wrote 72 instead of 70 for the second print on the outside of Meredith's door, as proven by Giunta's testimony.

If you think any of this is incorrect then please provide Giunta testimony that contradicts the testimony I quoted above.

Clear now?

ETA: Interestingly, in your collage you correctly point out that Fr. 12 constitutes two of Sollecito print fragments - the ring finger and the little finger - yet you go on to claim there are three prints on the door, Fr. 68 and two prints identified as Fr. 72. If this was true then there would have been six Sollecito fragments, not five. Who the hell is doing your proof thinking? ....I'd fire 'em!

I can guess who drew up that diagram with the wrong information. Speaking of incorrect photoshopped creations. who can forget Knox's shoeprint being found on the paper in Filomena's room? :D

Can I be forgiven for getting some satisfaction (ok....a good laugh) when Vixen provides the links that actually disprove her own claims?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom