LondonJohn said:
As you very well know (and as any lurker deserves to know), the fake wiki "murderofmeredithkercher.com" is notoriously biassed against Knox/Sollecito in its interpretation of evidence. And that bias is evident in this instance. Your "source" is biassed and incorrect. The print was found on the corridor-side face of the door.
Welshman said:
The numerous falsehoods told by Vixen have been pointed out by myself and others and Vixen has the cheek to attack people for lying. PGP are completely shameless in their hypocrisy.
Planigale said:
Unfortunately this Ergon obviously does not understand of which he/she is writing.
Trace DNA is DNA that is not associated with a source. So the DNA from blood stains or semen is not trace. DNA from the bra hook is trace because there is no knowing if the source is blood, saliva, touch etc. Trace DNA may or mayn't be LCN but they are entirely unrelated concepts.
Steffanoni herself says that the quantity of DNA attributable to Sollecito cannot be known because it is part of a mix of DNA. But this Ergon obviously knows more than Steffanoni.
Vixen said:
You are wrong, as there is no requirement to know the source of the DNA.
Vixen, lurkers here might not have read when you say that it is possible to know the origin of trace DNA. Yes, I know that your argument in the highlighted text is a little different, but you make other arguments which require you to know the origin of trace DNA.
It's bound to come around sooner or later - you continually repeat that the last court, the one which acquitted the pair found as factual that Knox had rubbed Meredith's blood from her hands.
That was Sept 2015. Yet when one tracks back to the 2010 Massei report, the one written to justify the first (wrongful-)conviction, one finds a few curious things.
- Stefanoni herself confirmed that forensically speaking, one could not determine the origin of the trace DNA from Amanda mixed with Meredith's blood, found in the very bathroom they'd shared for weeks.
- Massei himself on behalf of the court accepts that there are no forensics, per se, to support a contention that Amanda's DNA came from skin cells
- this is even before considering that on other matters in that very same report, Massei rejects the significance of another's potential DNA being found because "DNA cannot be date-stamped".
- Massei himself claims that it had to have been Amanda's skin cells rubbed off in the action of cleaning blood from herself, only because that notion fits the other surmises he makes. That is the sum-total of his judicial reasoning.
- No one, much less Massei, has then explained how that blood got on to Knox in the first place, given that there are no forensics, and specifically blood-forensics, of Knox in the murder-room itself. (Unlike Rudy Guede who has his fingerprints in Merediths blood in the murder room!)
- In 2015, the Marasca-Bruno panel in acquitting the pair said of this that even if it were true, then Amanda would have had to have picked up this blood in another part of the house and at a time after the murder.
There's cake. There's eating it. You can't have both. It's more than that there is no requirement to know the origin of trace-DNA, it's that when you repeat ad naseam that it is proven that Knox rubbed the victim's blood from her hands, you are claiming that it becomes mandatory to know the origin of trace-DNA.
And why are we arguing this anyway? This is the bathroom that Kercher and Knox shared for weeks. When Rudy Guede entered the bathroom after murdering the victim, the former of which he readily admits he did, he spread Meredith's blood to surfaces rich with both Amanda's and Meredith's pre-existing DNA.
Unless you're now going to argue that DNA can, indeed, be date-stamped.
BTW - Massei in 2010 got around this by saying that Knox had claimed that the bathroom had been cleaned. Really? Did Knox say she'd cleaned it to the molecular, DNA-free level? This is the girl who was criticised for not being able to clean a toilet - so much so, that the 2nd prosecutor, Crini in Florence, said that the unclean toilet was the motive for murder!!!! (That's how weird this case got.)
Lurkers here might want to delve into this for themselves; this has been the guilt PR-campaign ever since the police leaked stuff to the tabloids.