The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
At the risk of being argumentative, Stacyhs, even this has nothing at all to do with the trials.

The issue is - why did Mignini need to make something sexual out of this, meaning why did he need to incorporate "sex-game gone wrong", which even the 2013 Cassation ruling said was the forgotten, unexplored motive to this crime?

Mignini at his 2009 closing argument, made this into a psycho-sexual contest that Amanda had imaged in her head about Meredith. Mignini-surrogates since have taken that as permission to venture into all sorts of psychopathological fantasies......

....... none of which are supported at ANY of the courts, much less the two courts which convicted. (That was the very reason why the 2013 Cassation court directed the, then, Nencini trial to re-explore, "sex-game gone wrong", which both the new prosecutor, Crini, and the court itself completely ignored.)

Other that Rudy Guede's non-consentual leaving of his DNA in the victim, no one else had a sexual motive for anything - even Judge Massei conceded that in his 2010 Motivations report, when he says he can see no reason why Amanda would have had a motive to urge Rudy to sexually assault Meredith.

It's why when the Mignini-surrogates go in that direction, they are trying, really, to rehabilitate Mignini - who lost. He did not just lose at the 2015 Cassation acquittals - which called his investigation "amnesiac" - he lost even at the courts which convicted; who'd abandoned his wild theories.

Those who are Mignini-surrogates are only taking orders.

I agree it has nothing to do with the trials, but it has everything to do with the behavior of the PGP. As I've said before, this entire case, including how the pro-guilt faction behaves online, makes a fascinating psychological study.
 
Marco Chiacchiera

Correct me if I'm wrong. Marco Chiacchiera is the only cop from the Perugian Questura not to be charged with a crime, or having allegedly abused a suspect at interrogation.

Think "The Toe of Italy".

Chiacchiera is being transferred to Lamezia Terme in Calabria. A sideways move. This is about it for the clowns who advanced a wrongful prosecution.

Wow. Just wow.
 
They interrogated me for 53 hours over five days.


A blatant lie. Oh well, not a reliable witness, then.

Amanda Knox walked into the police station - voluntarily - at 10:30. Police told her to go home. She insisted in waiting for her boyfriend and offered to help police provide a list of persons frequenting the cottage. By 1:30 in the morning, she had signed a statement confessing to having met 'Patrick' at the basketball court outside the cottage and taken him round to have sex with Mez. She even relates all this later by her own hand in her Prison Diary.


In less than three hours, Knox had accused an 'impoverished black man', struggling in a start up business, of raping and murdering her roommate in her presence.

'53 hours of interrogation' is the same deviant type of lie as 'It could have been me', to get herself off the hook.

What part of "over five days" did you not understand? The amount of hours of being at the questura or at the cottage with the police is documented by the defense in the calunnia appeal:

Knox was subjected from November 2 to November 6 2007 to a total of 53,45 hours in the hands
of the Judicial Authority between questioning and inspections at Via della Pergola.

Amanda Knox è stata sottoposta ad esame ed attività investigative e tra il 2 e il 6 novembre 2007, fino al momento del fermo, ha fornito sommarie informazioni e risposto a domande della A.G. come segue:
2 novembre 2007, ore 15.30 VENERDI’: totale ore ………….. 12,00
Verbale di sommarie informazioni della Knox, senza indicazione della chiusura. Testimoni fino alle 3.00 am del 3 novembre 2007
3 novembre 2007, ore 14.45 SABATO totale ore ……………… 8,00
Verbale di sommarie informazioni della Knox, senza indicazione della chiusura. Testimoni indicano fino alle 22,00.
4 novembre 2007, ore 14.45 DOMENICA: totale ore …………. 12,00
Verbale di sommarie informazioni della Knox, ed accesso alla villetta di Via della Pergola dalle ore 14.45 alle ore 21. Telefonata di Amanda alla zia dice 5 ore di interrogatorio in questura
5/6 novembre 2007, ore 01.45 LUNEDI’/MARTEDI’: totale ore ……..5,00
Verbale di sommarie informazioni della Knox inizio alle ore 22.00 del 5 novembre 2009.
6 novembre 2007, ore 05.45 MARTEDI’: totale ore ……………….3,45
Verbale di “spontanee dichiarazioni” della Knox con successivo breve memoriale. Dalle ore 1,45 alle 5,45 e memoriale alle ore 14,00.
In 5 giorni la Knox è stata sentita per un totale di circa 53,45 h. Per chiarezza di esposizione si riassume la tempistica delle indagini nei confronti della Knox relativa ai cruciali giorni 5, 6 novembre 2007:

Total: 53.45 hours

Do you have access to the police records to ascertain exactly where and when Amanda was questioned or with the police at the cottage? No? I didn't think so.

Are you ignorant of the fact that exhaustion and its debilitating effects are cumulative? The evidence that she was exhausted by Nov 5/6 includes:

1) her statement in the memorial:
"In regards to this "confession" that I made last night, I want to make clear that I'm very doubtful of the verity of my statements because they were made under the pressures of stress, shock and extreme exhaustion.

2) the testimony of Aida Colantone (interpreter)
"At a certain moment, I don’t know if I had gone away for a moment to speak with someone from the Flying Squad or something, in passing that room, returning to this room where I remember [Amanda] was alone, it was only her, and I was practically…I understood that this girl was truly fatigued, exhausted, she was tired because I practically found her, she was draped on a seat with her head reclined toward the wall, white in the face, with her eyes closed, white, I was very struck by her pallor and I understood that this girl was in bad shape."

3) the testimony of Rita Ficarra
"
The girl continued to talk and said that she was fed up with the fact that she was recalled multiple times by the police and that she was simply tired. At that point I reprimanded her again because I said, “You’re tired, but you came tonight, and no one invited you here. You could have been resting.” Furthermore – I said – “you don’t understand that we’re talking about a murder, of a person who you say was your friend. You lived in the same house. It happened in your house. If the police calls you, put yourself in our shoes. We need useful information.”

Your claim here, and elsewhere, that Knox did not endure 53 hours of interrogation is false.
 
I noted years ago that the PGP often tend to have some kind of fascination with Amanda's sex life, both before and after the murder. They are prone to slut-shaming, calling her a ◊◊◊◊, wh***, nymphomaniac, accusing her of cheating on boyfriends, of using sex to get jobs, etc. This obsession with her sex life is psychologically fascinating.

“Women are indeed very capable of aggressing against others, especially women they perceive as rivals,” said Dr. Vaillancourt, now a psychologist at the University of Ottawa. “The research also shows that suppression of female sexuality is by women, not necessarily by men.
”Stigmatizing female promiscuity — a.k.a. slut-shaming — has often been blamed on men, who have a Darwinian incentive to discourage their spouses from straying. But they also have a Darwinian incentive to encourage other women to be promiscuous. Dr. Vaillancourt said the experiment and other research suggest the stigma is enforced mainly by women.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/sc...pagewanted=all

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/science/a-cold-war-fought-by-women.html?pagewanted=all

It is also noted in the same article that married women are less inclined to this kind of catty behavior than single (and that would include older divorced/widowed) women:

The results of the experiment jibe with evidence that this “mean girl” form of indirect aggression is used more by adolescents and young women than by older women, who have less incentive to handicap rivals once they marry. Other studies have shown that the more attractive an adolescent girl or woman is, the more likely she is to become a target for indirect aggression from her female peers.

Does this need to slut-shame, denigrate, and insult younger and more attractive females have a connection to sexual frustration in older, single, less attractive women who just aren't getting sex anymore? I suspect it does.

I absolutely believe this nails it. While there certainly are men that are sexist and misogynistic who hold double standards I do believe they constitute a minority of men. I know I have certainly seen far more women engage in slut shaming then men.

There must be something biological that encourages women to consciously or subconsciously compete against each other and slut shaming is just one way it manifests itself.
 
What part of "over five days" did you not understand? The amount of hours of being at the questura or at the cottage with the police is documented by the defense in the calunnia appeal:





Do you have access to the police records to ascertain exactly where and when Amanda was questioned or with the police at the cottage? No? I didn't think so.

Are you ignorant of the fact that exhaustion and its debilitating effects are cumulative? The evidence that she was exhausted by Nov 5/6 includes:

1) her statement in the memorial:
"In regards to this "confession" that I made last night, I want to make clear that I'm very doubtful of the verity of my statements because they were made under the pressures of stress, shock and extreme exhaustion.

2) the testimony of Aida Colantone (interpreter)
"At a certain moment, I don’t know if I had gone away for a moment to speak with someone from the Flying Squad or something, in passing that room, returning to this room where I remember [Amanda] was alone, it was only her, and I was practically…I understood that this girl was truly fatigued, exhausted, she was tired because I practically found her, she was draped on a seat with her head reclined toward the wall, white in the face, with her eyes closed, white, I was very struck by her pallor and I understood that this girl was in bad shape."

3) the testimony of Rita Ficarra
"
The girl continued to talk and said that she was fed up with the fact that she was recalled multiple times by the police and that she was simply tired. At that point I reprimanded her again because I said, “You’re tired, but you came tonight, and no one invited you here. You could have been resting.” Furthermore – I said – “you don’t understand that we’re talking about a murder, of a person who you say was your friend. You lived in the same house. It happened in your house. If the police calls you, put yourself in our shoes. We need useful information.”

Your claim here, and elsewhere, that Knox did not endure 53 hours of interrogation is false.

PGP falsely accuse Amanda of lying and have the cheek to attack Amanda for lying.
 
Adversarial (us) versus inquisitorial (Latin countries and South Africa, strangely) is simply a description of the process.

It is the case in all modern justice systems of either type that Appeals courts, and the Supreme Court, are purely there to oversee that the law has been applied correctly.

Fact finding is 100% the remit of the trial court, and in the UK/USA formula a trial verdict by a jury of defendants peers is sacrosanct and cannot be changed except on a specif point of law, which usually has five subcategories. In italy, one of these subcategories and the most common point of appeal, is that of 'internal contradiction' in the MR. UK/USA verdict rarely have written reasons at all and successful applications for an appeal are relatively rare. In Italy every defendant has an automatic two appeals, one of which is the Supreme Court, if they wish. Catch is, the prosecution can also appeal.

So, in effect, should an appeal win re 'internal contradiction', all aan appeal/Supreme Court are remitted to do is send it back to a merits court for the facts to be reassessed as prescribed by the Appeal/Supreme Court as per the point of law in (potential) error.

Mignini is correct that Marasca erred in this matter.

A little knowledge is dangerous, Vixen.

Google is your friend...

https://www.findanattorney.co.za/content_oscar-pistorius-legal-system

I have neither the time nor the energy to pull you up on this in any more detail than a pointer. Just limit your comments to your knowledge. That should shorten your comments enormously.
 
Last edited:
I have neither the time nor the energy to pull you up on this in any more detail than a pointer. Just limit your comments to your knowledge. That should shorten your comments enormously.

It's amazing that anyone of us has the energy.

As an aside, the "Comments Section" on the recent Rolling Stone article has broken out into open warfare, reminiscent of earlier times.

If anyone doubted that there were trolls out there ready to pounce with death threats and such, just take a peek over there. This ISF/JREF thread looks sane by comparison!
 
It's amazing that anyone of us has the energy.

As an aside, the "Comments Section" on the recent Rolling Stone article has broken out into open warfare, reminiscent of earlier times.

If anyone doubted that there were trolls out there ready to pounce with death threats and such, just take a peek over there. This ISF/JREF thread looks sane by comparison!

As I said earlier regarding that comments section, the usual crazies have come out in force. One in particular has multiple ID's and likes to post supporting remarks between them making it look like there are multiple people in agreement. He's been doing it for years. That takes a really sick mind.
 
PGP falsely accuse Amanda of lying and have the cheek to attack Amanda for lying.

Add to the long hours of questioning and the emotional shock of having your roommate raped and murdered the fact the Amanda had just gotten her period. Any woman knows how fatigued the first couple of days can make you feel. For some women, it can be so draining they have to stay home from work. I wouldn't doubt it had a lot to do with why Amanda was described by Colantone as being so "white in the face" and why she "was struck by her pallor ".
 
A little knowledge is dangerous, Vixen.

Google is your friend...

https://www.findanattorney.co.za/content_oscar-pistorius-legal-system

I have neither the time nor the energy to pull you up on this in any more detail than a pointer. Just limit your comments to your knowledge. That should shorten your comments enormously.

The relevance of the citation, which discusses the South African judicial system in the context of the Oscar Pistorius trial, to the Italian judicial system may be unclear.

For the record, I will again post the provisions of Italian law (from the Italian Code of Criminal Procedure, CPP) that give the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (CSC) the authority to acquit an appealed case without remanding that case to a lower court - thus, annulling the case. The English translation is from The Italian Code of Criminal Procedure: Critical Essays and English Translation, Gialuz, Luparia, and Scarpa (editors), Wolters Kluwer Italia (c) 2014.

Article 620 Annulment without referral

1. In addition to the cases specifically provided for by the law, the Court of Cassation shall deliver a judgment of annulment without referral:

A) if the criminal act is not deemed an offence by law, if the offence is extinguished or if the prosecution should not have been started or continued;
....

L) in any other case in which the Court of Cassation believes the referral is superfluous or may proceed to the determination of the sentence {verdict} or take the necessary decisions.
___

The Marasca CSC panel cited CPP Article 620.1L. The panel, in its motivation report, stated that no re-examination of the available evidence or attempt to further examine the physical objects in evidence would provide any additional relevant information, and since there was no evidence of the guilt of Knox or Sollecito, then they must be acquitted of the murder/rape charges. And that is what the Marasca CSC panel did, all in accordance with Italian law.

Here is the Italian text of CPP Article 620 in full:

Art. 620 - Annullamento senza rinvio
1. Oltre che nei casi particolarmente previsti dalla legge, la corte pronuncia sentenza di annullamento senza rinvio:
a) se il fatto non è previsto dalla legge come reato, se il reato è estinto o se l'azione penale non doveva essere iniziata o proseguita;
b) se il reato non appartiene alla giurisdizione del giudice ordinario;
c) se il provvedimento impugnato contiene disposizioni che eccedono i poteri della giurisdizione, limitatamente alle medesime;
d) se la decisione impugnata consiste in un provvedimento non consentito dalla legge;
e) se la sentenza è nulla a norma e nei limiti dell'articolo 522 in relazione a un reato concorrente;
f) se la sentenza è nulla a norma e nei limiti dell'articolo 522 in relazione a un fatto nuovo;
g) se la condanna è stata pronunciata per errore di persona;
h) se vi è contraddizione fra la sentenza o l'ordinanza impugnata e un'altra anteriore concernente la stessa persona e il medesimo oggetto, pronunciata dallo stesso o da un altro giudice penale;
i) se la sentenza impugnata ha deciso in secondo grado su materia per la quale non è ammesso l'appello;
l) in ogni altro caso in cui la corte ritiene superfluo il rinvio ovvero può essa medesima procedere alla determinazione della pena o dare i provvedimenti necessari.

Source: http://www.leggeonline.info/leggi/procedurapenale/art620/annullamento_senza_rinvio/
 
Amanda and Colin were engaged in February 2015 and she met Christopher in August of 2015. So exactly what evidence do you have that Amanda was "carrying on" with Christopher while still engaged to Colin? Do you know when her engagement was called off? Of course you don't. As usual, you claim to know things you can't possibly know. But why let that stop an opportunity to fabricate a nasty accusation?

I see the usual crazies are predictably spamming the Rolling Stone article including their sick comments like hoping Amanda commits suicide. Turn off the lights and they come crawling out. A good can of RAID would come in handy.

Knox used her 'engagement' to Sutherland in a fake news campaign. Once again, a sociopathic attempt to manipulate all around her.

AFAICS it is Knox who claims she was nearly driven to suicide. Given the reports of how she blossomed in jail and her open lack of remorse (refusal to pay Patrick) most likely it is yet more fake news from her stable to manipulate public sympathy.
 
Knox used her 'engagement' to Sutherland in a fake news campaign. Once again, a sociopathic attempt to manipulate all around her.

AFAICS it is Knox who claims she was nearly driven to suicide. Given the reports of how she blossomed in jail and her open lack of remorse (refusal to pay Patrick) most likely it is yet more fake news from her stable to manipulate public sympathy.

This is boarish. You can't know any of this. You've just made it up. All of it.
 
Vixen,
Does it bother you that, at age 30, Amanda Knox is a far more successful author than you will ever be, after being wrongfully imprisoned for four years? She is attractive too, which probably is another source of your resentment.

This is, in fact, a straightforward explanation of why you would choose to bully and hurl abuse at her for the past 8 years. :)

All in your mind, Babe.
 
No it wasn't.

Or can you provide evidence to support your claim that (not-a-real-doctor) Stefanoni stated that the pattern of blood drops over the sink and bidet was "the same as that of a dripping knife"?

No. Thought not. Another "fact" pulled out of thin air. Quelle surprise.

See the extracts I provided for Stefanoni's testimony, as summarised by Massei, a few days back.

Also, her contribution to Darkness Descending.
 
No, it's not, Vixen.

It's a warped fantasy pulled out of thin air, to bolster your own jaundiced view of Knox.

Or perhaps you have evidence to support your claim?

No, of course you don't Vixen. You just made it up, based on your own prejudices, didn't you?

Er you do know who Party Rock is, and who attended his book signing as the loving pair.
 
Absolutely incredible. No wonder you have things so screwed up. You can't even get the details of a short interview correct. Here's the actual quote;

"If someone wants to think of me as a femme fatale for whatever reason or wants to think that I am guilty, then they are going to see that. There is nothing that I can do to change their minds, unless say, I happen to stumble upon them and interact with them in some way and they realize, "Oh, crap. She was a real person all along." Maybe then I can change a person's mind. But I'm not setting my heart on doing that, because I don't feel like that's my job. I feel like my job is to live my life and to heal from what happened to me."

So what did you get wrong? Well, let's see...

1) "..she claims to be able to charm people" - Nope, she doesn't say that.
2) "..into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all" - Nope, she doesn't say that either.
3) You are implying she is trying to change peoples opinion about her. - Nope, she never says anything of the kind.

The point she is making is people will make her what ever they want to make her (i.e., a fictional character) and there is nothing she can do to change that. That is, unless someone actually meets her and comes to realize there is a real person behind the name and not the fictional character created by the media, authors and online bloggers. It really wasn't very difficult to follow.

So is it horrendous reading comprehension or are you just incapable of not making things up to fit your narrative?

Wow, just wow! (tm) williams

If people see her as a fictional character, then maybe she should stop 'releasing' fake news.
 
This means nothing. Rudy killed Meredith. If Amanda had returned home alone at 9 pm that evening Amanda would probably be dead.

Now you're catching on. Little slow, but still.
You just look for ways to insult her, don't you? And you don't dislike Amanda and you're a Christian. Sure.... :rolleyes:

And of course you would never buckle during an interrogation. Amanda's contemptible crime was saying the wrong thing under duress.

Get out those stones Christians. We've got a live one here.

All of the flat mates and acquaintances of Mez were interviewed exactly the same way as Knox. Not one of them claimed to have been at the scene and introduced Patrick as the killer/rapist.

Yet Amanda did. So Mignini found Amanda 'special', but not any of the 'British Birds' (as Grinder called them).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom