"Some accounts suggest that Ms. Knox was (consistent with Italian law) provided with legal counsel once she became an actual suspect, and that this did not occur until fairly far into the sessions (and that up then she had been regarded as someone who might become a witness, and not a suspect).
If those accounts are in fact not accurate, then the treatment of Ms. Knox would be unlawful and evidence obtained then would be inadmissible under rules set forth in the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. ...."
Source: John W. Head*, Author's Update (early February 2015)
http://law.ku.edu/sites/law.ku.edu/files/docs/comparative-criminal-procedure-essay-john-head.pdf
*Wagstaff Distinguished Professor of Law, University of Kansas
There are several interesting points in the quoted excerpt from John Head's Update:
1. As a default position, he apparently assumes that Amanda Knox was provided a lawyer immediately after she incriminated herself during the interrogation. That indeed would be the law in Italy (CPP Article 63). In the Update, he does not reference his source for that assumption. In Head's original article (Criminal Procedure in Transition: Observations on Legal Transplantation and Italy’s Handling of the Amanda Knox Trial), he attributes this information to a 2009 Seattle Post interview with an Italian lawyer, Stefano Maffei.
However, Maffei and Head have this wrong. Knox was not allowed to have legal counsel until immediately before her arrest hearing on November 8, while the relevant interrogation began the night of November 5 and concluded in the morning of November 6. According to the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (CSC), none of the evidence obtained during that interrogation of Knox could be used against her for the murder/rape charges. However, the CSC ruled that because Knox had written a defensive memo in English (thus, in her own words) on November 6, after the interrogation had concluded, in which she stated that her interrogation had been coercive (she claimed to have been slapped and threatened). However, the prosecution and CSC did not regard this memo as fully repudiating her statements regarding Patrick Lumumba, so therefore the CSC ruled that her interrogation statements against Lumumba could be used as evidence of the crime of calunnia (false accusation).
2. In the Update, Head considers the possibility that his assumed information on the provision of legal counsel during the interrogation is incorrect. He then correctly deduces that the "evidence" derived during such an interrogation without counsel (and in the absence of a valid waiver) could not be used to convict anyone, based on rules derived from the European Convention, that is, to be more specific, the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights.