The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
Vixen's post is slutshaming, but with a twist. That sort of post used to be part of the tittering and smirking at the PMF's when posters there went after Knox for the purpose of simply having a laugh. They'd often compete in making the most outrageous claim - the laugh at the expense of their victim was what they were going for.

It's the core of bullying. The problem is, it's a tired-tactic, meant to build group cohesion on that side of the fence. There simply is not enough of them any more for this sort of bullying to gain traction. Yet Vixen pulls it from her bag of tricks. (What it's got to do with the name of this thread, is beyond me. But that's just me.)

It is a straightforward explanation of how she became a columnist at WSH.
 
Vixen isn't it astonishing that us PIP got interested in this case because the evidence appeared to us as substantially weak, when in fact we were all just clueless idiots and it was quite strong, but by an amazing unrelated coincidence secret mafia actors working behind the scenes got Amanda Knox wrongfully acquitted on insufficient evidence grounds not once, but twice, profoundly enabling our delusion.

Of all the vicious killers we could have picked, we managed to incidentally pick the one with the mafia connected boyfriend. Bad luck!

You can forgive us for having a hard time accepting the truth can't you? I mean the universe is really playing with our heads here.
 
Looks like they will have another urge since Rolling Stone published an interview with Amanda today.

I thought this paragraph was perfect for Vixen.

I love the irony of this:

"I was the lucky one, because what happened to Meredith could have easily happened to me," she says.

As if Meredith would ever have done anything of the sort.

If anything, I had to bring the prosecutor [Giuliano Mignini] close to me and to my heart to understand where he was coming from when he was doing what he was doing to me.

LOL Mignini prosecuting the pair had nothing to do with evidence, of course.


That immediate warmth and that, "you're our little sister," and "we know," was the first time I had ever been in a room where I didn't have to feel the need to explain myself.

More 'arrested development' infantalisation of herself.

The thing I feel most strongly is that I am part of a tribe of people I would have never been mixed in with otherwise. They are mostly impoverished black men who are unable to defend themselves, who took the weight of other people's mistakes onto their lives. I'm humbled and honored to stand among them.

So, once again she fails to mention her contemptible crime against Patrick Lumumba yet claims to represent 'impoverished black men who are unable to defend themselves'.

They interrogated me for 53 hours over five days.

A blatant lie. Oh well, not a reliable witness, then.

Amanda Knox walked into the police station - voluntarily - at 10:30. Police told her to go home. She insisted in waiting for her boyfriend and offered to help police provide a list of persons frequenting the cottage. By 1:30 in the morning, she had signed a statement confessing to having met 'Patrick' at the basketball court outside the cottage and taken him round to have sex with Mez. She even relates all this later by her own hand in her Prison Diary.


In less than three hours, Knox had accused an 'impoverished black man', struggling in a start up business, of raping and murdering her roommate in her presence.

'53 hours of interrogation' is the same deviant type of lie as 'It could have been me', to get herself off the hook.
 
"Some accounts suggest that Ms. Knox was (consistent with Italian law) provided with legal counsel once she became an actual suspect, and that this did not occur until fairly far into the sessions (and that up then she had been regarded as someone who might become a witness, and not a suspect). If those accounts are in fact not accurate, then the treatment of Ms. Knox would be unlawful and evidence obtained then would be inadmissible under rules set forth in the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. ...."

Source: John W. Head*, Author's Update (early February 2015)
http://law.ku.edu/sites/law.ku.edu/files/docs/comparative-criminal-procedure-essay-john-head.pdf

*Wagstaff Distinguished Professor of Law, University of Kansas

There are several interesting points in the quoted excerpt from John Head's Update:

1. As a default position, he apparently assumes that Amanda Knox was provided a lawyer immediately after she incriminated herself during the interrogation. That indeed would be the law in Italy (CPP Article 63). In the Update, he does not reference his source for that assumption. In Head's original article (Criminal Procedure in Transition: Observations on Legal Transplantation and Italy’s Handling of the Amanda Knox Trial), he attributes this information to a 2009 Seattle Post interview with an Italian lawyer, Stefano Maffei.

However, Maffei and Head have this wrong. Knox was not allowed to have legal counsel until immediately before her arrest hearing on November 8, while the relevant interrogation began the night of November 5 and concluded in the morning of November 6. According to the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (CSC), none of the evidence obtained during that interrogation of Knox could be used against her for the murder/rape charges. However, the CSC ruled that because Knox had written a defensive memo in English (thus, in her own words) on November 6, after the interrogation had concluded, in which she stated that her interrogation had been coercive (she claimed to have been slapped and threatened). However, the prosecution and CSC did not regard this memo as fully repudiating her statements regarding Patrick Lumumba, so therefore the CSC ruled that her interrogation statements against Lumumba could be used as evidence of the crime of calunnia (false accusation).

2. In the Update, Head considers the possibility that his assumed information on the provision of legal counsel during the interrogation is incorrect. He then correctly deduces that the "evidence" derived during such an interrogation without counsel (and in the absence of a valid waiver) could not be used to convict anyone, based on rules derived from the European Convention, that is, to be more specific, the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights.
 
Last edited:
Well, the way I see it is this:

Knox has a story and experience which others want to hear about. If others want to hear about it - whether they pay Knox to tell them, or whether Knox does so in a voluntary capacity - then Knox has the perfect right to tell them about it.

If I'm glad about anything, it's the apparent fact that Knox doesn't care one iota about trying to change the minds of those (predominantly the small cadre of hard-core crazy pro-guilt online commentators....) who still shout all over the internet that she and Sollecito are guilty/evil/ugly/etc. I hope Knox genuinely believes this in her heart (rather than, for example, merely articulating this thought because she feel she ought to say it). I'm sure that, similarly, NASA doesn't care about the crazies who still insist the Moon landings were faked, or that the US Government doesn't care about the crazies who still insist that 9/11 was an "inside job"........


Who cares whether she is a nice person or not. In her ROLLING STONE rehabilitation attempt, she claims to be able to charm people who meet her into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all!

As if this is about personalities, and not a disgusting heinous crime.
 
Quote me where I have said Mignini prosecuted them because he "didn't like them". Go on, Vix. Back up your claims (for a change). Of course, you won't because you can't. Par for the vixen course.

In the world of Vixen, writing

She only got a column in West Seattle Herald because of the 'novelty value' in having a mu notorious criminal from Seattle writing for them, and the newspaper owner's son got to get his leg over.
is only showing dislike for Amanda's "behavior" and not directed toward her personally. Really?

Personal attacks on Knox and Sollecito don't make me angry. I expect them from years of reading them from PGP. It's what they do. It's all they have left.

According to her own publicity, wasn't she supposed to be 'engaged to be married' to a rock star, Johnny Thunderstrike Sutherland at the time she was carrying on with the other guy?

I see you are dodging providing a quote of me ever saying what you claimed I did. Not surprising. You make up more "alternate truths" than Trump. And I thought he was in a class all by himself. Seems he has company.

I know this will be an utter and complete waste of time but evidence that Amanda was engaged to Colin at the same time she was seeing Christopher?
What? What's that you say? You don't have any? :jaw-dropp
 
I'm the one who goes on and on and on about what Marasca-Bruno really said about, even-if the "Knox rubbing Meredith's blood from her hands" is true, the court ruled that that still would not be enough to convict her (or Sollecito) since that would have had to have happened at a time later than the murder, and in another part of the cottage than the murder room....

I go on and on about that, but here's the deal.

Marasca-Bruno, on behalf of Cassation, Italy's highest court, still said this about the interrogation:

​
That is simply a bizarre thing to write. Do judges of Italy's highest court really - REALLY - think that a PM taking statements is a "context free of institutionally anomalous psychological pressures", when they are taken in the middle of the night, and when the suspect has been hit and called a liar - and cannot understand the language used? (When the interpreter becomes a mediator - Doninno's own description - rather than a neutral translator?)

Just when one would want to say something nice about Marasca and Bruno, they drop that little gem in, they simply cannot resist protecting the systm at times.....

...... which makes it all the more startling when they lower the boom on that very same prosecutor for leading an "amnesiac investigation".

There is one word which describes all this.

Italy.

Yes, strange as it may seem, Knox actually wrote a memo which she presented to a nice police officer calling it a 'gift' in which she underlined her claim she wintessed 'Patrick' as the murderer.

Please don't diss Italy. Without Italy we would not have:

  • Spaghetti bolognese
  • Pavarotti
  • millinery
  • shoes
  • trattorias
  • pizza
  • lasagne
  • sun-dried tomatoes
 
I see you are dodging providing a quote of me ever saying what you claimed I did. Not surprising. You make up more "alternate truths" than Trump. And I thought he was in a class all by himself. Seems he has company.

I know this will be an utter and complete waste of time but evidence that Amanda was engaged to Colin at the same time she was seeing Christopher?
What? What's that you say? You don't have any? :jaw-dropp

And what does this possibly have to do with anything in this thread, esp. when Vixen claims that she's not obsessed with Knox, and seems to want to take a swipe at her because she might not floss every night.
 
"Some accounts suggest that Ms. Knox was (consistent with Italian law) provided with legal counsel once she became an actual suspect, and that this did not occur until fairly far into the sessions (and that up then she had been regarded as someone who might become a witness, and not a suspect). If those accounts are in fact not accurate, then the treatment of Ms. Knox would be unlawful and evidence obtained then would be inadmissible under rules set forth in the European Convention on Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. ...."

Source: John W. Head*, Author's Update (early February 2015)
http://law.ku.edu/sites/law.ku.edu/files/docs/comparative-criminal-procedure-essay-john-head.pdf

*Wagstaff Distinguished Professor of Law, University of Kansas

There are several interesting points in the quoted excerpt from John Head's Update:

1. As a default position, he apparently assumes that Amanda Knox was provided a lawyer immediately after she incriminated herself during the interrogation. That indeed would be the law in Italy (CPP Article 63). In the Update, he does not reference his source for that assumption. In Head's original article (Criminal Procedure in Transition: Observations on Legal Transplantation and Italy’s Handling of the Amanda Knox Trial), he attributes this information to a 2009 Seattle Post interview with an Italian lawyer, Stefano Maffei.

However, Maffei and Head have this wrong. Knox was not allowed to have legal counsel until immediately before her arrest hearing on November 8, while the relevant interrogation began the night of November 5 and concluded in the morning of November 6. According to the Italian Supreme Court of Cassation (CSC), none of the evidence obtained during that interrogation of Knox could be used against her for the murder/rape charges. However, the CSC ruled that because Knox had written a defensive memo in English (thus, in her own words) on November 6, after the interrogation had concluded, in which she stated that her interrogation had been coercive (she claimed to have been slapped and threatened). However, the prosecution and CSC did not regard this memo as fully repudiating her statements regarding Patrick Lumumba, so therefore the CSC ruled that her interrogation statements against Lumumba could be used as evidence of the crime of calunnia (false accusation).

2. In the Update, Head considers the possibility that his assumed information on the provision of legal counsel during the interrogation is incorrect. He then correctly deduces that the "evidence" derived during such an interrogation without counsel (and in the absence of a valid waiver) could not be used to convict anyone, based on rules derived from the European Convention, that is, to be more specific, the case-law of the European Court of Human Rights.

That essay is great. He takes an initial Dershowitz-like approach to the case, which is to take the prosecution's evidentiary points entirely at face value (forensic proof of multiple attackers, an unprompted confession etc), probably because 99.999% of the time when a prosecutor makes a claim it is backed up by real evidence. But Mignini. Italy. So later the actual real details of the case are pointed out to him by some colleagues and all of a sudden he has a real egg on his face embarrassing realization.

Yeah, this case will do that to you.
 
Yes, strange as it may seem, Knox actually wrote a memo which she presented to a nice police officer calling it a 'gift' in which she underlined her claim she wintessed 'Patrick' as the murderer.

You have two more posts to go to 10,000. What a bunch of tripe - a veritable corpus of tripe. She underlined nothing, she expressed doubt. You don't even know the basics of this case.
 
So what drives you to blind belief that everybody is wrong except you; rather like the mother watching her son on a parade, 'Oh, look, everybody is out of step except my boy!'

So what drives you to blind belief that the Supreme Court is wrong when they definitively acquitted Knox and Sollecito saying they should never have been convicted in the first place due to the shoddy investigation and lack of any evidence of them being in Kercher's bedroom? It's rather like a 3 year old having a temper tantrum screaming "I do NOT need a nap!!!! " when all the evidence says she does.
 
Who cares whether she is a nice person or not. In her ROLLING STONE rehabilitation attempt, she claims to be able to charm people who meet her into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all!

As if this is about personalities, and not a disgusting heinous crime.

You seem unwilling or unable to engage in any perspective that isn't your own. You treat the people posting in this thread like robots throwing up obstacles for you to knock down, rather than real people with actual opinions they formed in earnest. You can't seem to comprehend the coincidences and irregularities in this case that would make a narrative of a wrongful conviction compelling to many people. I see no sign of critical thinking or broader intellectual engagement of any kind.

In a case with psychopaths and sycophants I have seen almost as alarming behavior coming from the PGP.
 
You have two more posts to go to 10,000. What a bunch of tripe - a veritable corpus of tripe. She underlined nothing, she expressed doubt. You don't even know the basics of this case.

I repeat: exactly what does Vixen hope to accomplish with all these posts?
To get "justice" for Meredith? How exactly does she think she'll accomplish this? By convincing someone of the pair's guilt? No one comes here except a handful of us and she is the only PGP besides a pop-in by Machiavelli once n a great while. Is she really still under the delusion that there will be another trial and a conviction? I don't think she's that delusional...but I could be wrong.

Sadly, I've already answered the question of:

So why do they carry on posting? I can only think of one reason: because they get some kind of sick satisfaction and enjoyment out of spewing venom at Knox and, to a lesser extent, Sollecito. It feeds some psychological/emotional need. If Knox and Sollecito weren't their targets, it would be someone else.
 
I've been told but I don't know. That Knox' supporters are largely:

12. People with a 'claim to fame', such as Stacyhs, with link's to Knox' family, friends or friends of friends.

I see you are distorting the truth once again. I have no "link" to Knox or her family. I met her once briefly two years ago. I became convinced of her innocence years earlier so my meeting her has nothing to do with my support of her.

For someone who brings up Knox's "lies" ad nauseum, you have a very tenuous relationship with the truth yourself.
 
I see you are distorting the truth once again. I have no "link" to Knox or her family. I met her once briefly two years ago. I became convinced of her innocence years earlier so my meeting her has nothing to do with my support of her.

For someone who brings up Knox's "lies" ad nauseum, you have a very tenuous relationship with the truth yourself.

Someone told me you were linked to some guy linked to Knox. Is that not true then?
 
According to her own publicity, wasn't she supposed to be 'engaged to be married' to a rock star, Johnny Thunderstrike Sutherland at the time she was carrying on with the other guy?

Amanda and Colin were engaged in February 2015 and she met Christopher in August of 2015. So exactly what evidence do you have that Amanda was "carrying on" with Christopher while still engaged to Colin? Do you know when her engagement was called off? Of course you don't. As usual, you claim to know things you can't possibly know. But why let that stop an opportunity to fabricate a nasty accusation?

I see the usual crazies are predictably spamming the Rolling Stone article including their sick comments like hoping Amanda commits suicide. Turn off the lights and they come crawling out. A good can of RAID would come in handy.
 
As a former member of the Peter Cook Appreciation Society, reading this post was strongly reminiscent for me of Peter Cook holding forth on a park bench as Spotty Muldoon, where he talks in a long monotone in a seemingly intellectual fashion of subjects of infinitely great wisdom. Thank you for your amusing invective and the wonderful impersonation.

My point was that PGP show staggering levels of stupidity and the inability to grasp even the simplest things. The total inability to understand the point I made in my post proves this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom