The Trials of Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito: Part 26

Status
Not open for further replies.
It is a straightforward explanation of how she became a columnist at WSH.

Vixen,
Does it bother you that, at age 30, Amanda Knox is a far more successful author than you will ever be, after being wrongfully imprisoned for four years? She is attractive too, which probably is another source of your resentment.

This is, in fact, a straightforward explanation of why you would choose to bully and hurl abuse at her for the past 8 years. :)
 
Last edited:
That essay is great. He takes an initial Dershowitz-like approach to the case, which is to take the prosecution's evidentiary points entirely at face value (forensic proof of multiple attackers, an unprompted confession etc), probably because 99.999% of the time when a prosecutor makes a claim it is backed up by real evidence. But Mignini. Italy. So later the actual real details of the case are pointed out to him by some colleagues and all of a sudden he has a real egg on his face embarrassing realization.

Yeah, this case will do that to you.

Yes, it's interesting that even some lawyers, including some of those who teach law, may write about a case without learning the actual details that are important to the outcome and meaning of that case. I have learned to be more skeptical of "professional" legal opinions given in the media because of this case.

Professor Head's summary of the attempted change in the Italian legal system, from inquisitorial to more adversarial, carries some weight, but his use of this case as an illustration is incomplete; even the the Update that he adds does not fully address the violations of Italian law and the European Convention that were carried out by the police, prosecution, and some of the judges/courts (such as Massei, Chieffi, and Nencini). Head fails to address the displays of arbitrariness by the Italian courts.
 
Last edited:
In a case with psychopaths and sycophants I have seen almost as alarming behavior coming from the PGP.

Migini and the core PGP have the same core personality traits (ok... disorders if you want to be technical) where they refuse to ever admit they could be wrong or not know/understand something, and fall back on bullying and abuse of the victim, lies, and manipulation of information so that they can maintain their own distorted view of reality and "control" of the situation (in their own disordered mind). And their own inflated view of themselves (people with narcissistic personality disorder absolutely could not admit they failed so badly at comprehending this case for a full 8 years). It would imply they're actually really stupid, when their disorder refuses to allow them to admit that because it's a core part of their ego.

As I've said before, this kind of behavior would be sad and funny if it were about Bigfoot or the Loch Ness monster, but when it is directed at innocent people it becomes vile and disgusting rather quickly.
 
Last edited:
I'm waiting for what lunacy post 10,000 will bring. Will it include a link to something which actually refutes the point being made? Maybe it'll be a repost of the window with bars on it, which will claim there are no bars.

Maybe it will finally be a post with one forensic-DNA expert who agrees with Stefanoni's work. Maybe it will be the forensic proof that Knox had rubbed blood from her hands, which if offered should be shown to the convicting judges who said there was no proof.

Maybe it'll be a repeat of the classic claim of not being a slutshamer, then in the next breath calling someone a nymphomaniac. That was a classic.

Yup. We're going to hit 100 continuations, with Mignini turning 80 and Rudy turning 50.
 
So what drives you to blind belief that everybody is wrong except you; rather like the mother watching her son on a parade, 'Oh, look, everybody is out of step except my boy!'


What the hell are you on about now?

Look: I'll make this perfectly simple for you. Ready?

1) You stated that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation".

2) I requested that you provide proper evidence to support this claim.

3) I suggested that if you are unable to provide proper evidence to support this claim, you apologise and withdraw it.

4) To date, you have provided zero evidence in support of this claim.

5) I therefore suggest that you either pony up the evidence that I am "prone to hero-worship or infatuation" pretty sharpish, or you apologise and withdraw the claim.


Is that clear enough for you? What the hell is "everybody is wrong except you"? What does it mean and how is it in any way whatsoever relevant to the issue at hand here?

Please answer my request. Not some bizarre unconnected nonsense. Thank you.
 
The pattern of the blood drips over the sink and the bidet, was, in Stefanoni's experience, the same as that of a dripping knife.

However, because it reveals a bleeding Knox who bled the same time as the fatally wounded victim, it is a great help to the investigation.


No it wasn't.

Or can you provide evidence to support your claim that (not-a-real-doctor) Stefanoni stated that the pattern of blood drops over the sink and bidet was "the same as that of a dripping knife"?

No. Thought not. Another "fact" pulled out of thin air. Quelle surprise.
 
It is a straightforward explanation of how she became a columnist at WSH.


No, it's not, Vixen.

It's a warped fantasy pulled out of thin air, to bolster your own jaundiced view of Knox.

Or perhaps you have evidence to support your claim?

No, of course you don't Vixen. You just made it up, based on your own prejudices, didn't you?
 
Who cares whether she is a nice person or not. In her ROLLING STONE rehabilitation attempt, she claims to be able to charm people who meet her into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all!

As if this is about personalities, and not a disgusting heinous crime.


What are you on about?

Where did I even discuss whether Knox was "nice or not"? Or whether this should be a factor worth discussing in any evaluation of the case?

Your habit of providing "responses" which bear little or no relation to the post that you're addressing is getting very tiresome (but very telling at the same time....).
 
Someone told me you were linked to some guy linked to Knox. Is that not true then?


"Someone told me"?

What the hell are you doing being "told" about alleged relationships between pro-acquittal commentators and Knox?

Horrible. As is the person who (allegedly) "told" you. Who is obviously a nasty little PGP nutter (if he/she even exists, that is.....).
 
If she doesn't want people commenting on her conduct, she should stop making herself a public figure.

That you think that just because a person is a public figure it gives you the right to insult and make disparaging comments about them is a demonstration of character.

I was only quoting what Christianity says. I am all for people finding their soulmate, of whatever gender. After all, Tom of Finland who made Gay Pride real, came from the next county to mine (Kaarina).
So? That wasn't the point. The point was how disingenuous comments like 'hate the sin, not the sinners is' and 'you don't dislike Amanda, just everything she says and does'.
 
Last edited:
And
According to her own publicity, wasn't she supposed to be 'engaged to be married' to a rock star, Johnny Thunderstrike Sutherland at the time she was carrying on with the other guy?

Tell me, what does this have to do with the case? You're slut shaming again.
 
Who cares whether she is a nice person or not. In her ROLLING STONE rehabilitation attempt, she claims to be able to charm people who meet her into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all!

As if this is about personalities, and not a disgusting heinous crime.

Absolutely incredible. No wonder you have things so screwed up. You can't even get the details of a short interview correct. Here's the actual quote;

"If someone wants to think of me as a femme fatale for whatever reason or wants to think that I am guilty, then they are going to see that. There is nothing that I can do to change their minds, unless say, I happen to stumble upon them and interact with them in some way and they realize, "Oh, crap. She was a real person all along." Maybe then I can change a person's mind. But I'm not setting my heart on doing that, because I don't feel like that's my job. I feel like my job is to live my life and to heal from what happened to me."

So what did you get wrong? Well, let's see...

1) "..she claims to be able to charm people" - Nope, she doesn't say that.
2) "..into thinking, wow she's not really so bad after all" - Nope, she doesn't say that either.
3) You are implying she is trying to change peoples opinion about her. - Nope, she never says anything of the kind.

The point she is making is people will make her what ever they want to make her (i.e., a fictional character) and there is nothing she can do to change that. That is, unless someone actually meets her and comes to realize there is a real person behind the name and not the fictional character created by the media, authors and online bloggers. It really wasn't very difficult to follow.

So is it horrendous reading comprehension or are you just incapable of not making things up to fit your narrative?

Wow, just wow! (tm) williams
 
I love the irony of this:
I was the lucky one, because what happened to Meredith could have easily happened to me," she says
.

As if Meredith would ever have done anything of the sort.
This means nothing. Rudy killed Meredith. If Amanda had returned home alone at 9 pm that evening Amanda would probably be dead.

LOL Mignini prosecuting the pair had nothing to do with evidence, of course.
Now you're catching on. Little slow, but still.
More 'arrested development' infantalisation of herself.
You just look for ways to insult her, don't you? And you don't dislike Amanda and you're a Christian. Sure.... :rolleyes:

So, once again she fails to mention her contemptible crime against Patrick Lumumba yet claims to represent 'impoverished black men who are unable to defend themselves'.
And of course you would never buckle during an interrogation. Amanda's contemptible crime was saying the wrong thing under duress.

Get out those stones Christians. We've got a live one here.
 
The pattern of the blood drips over the sink and the bidet, was, in Stefanoni's experience, the same as that of a dripping knife.

However, because it reveals a bleeding Knox who bled the same time as the fatally wounded victim, it is a great help to the investigation.

First of all, I don't recall Stefanoni ever making such a claim. I don't suppose you'd be willing to provide a cite, eh?

Regardless, it would be entirely illogical to make such an observation since, aside from the one drop of Amanda's blood on the faucet, everything else was water diluted blood which could have come from anything being rinsed off.

The diluted blood spots don't in any way reveal a bleeding Knox, nor is there any evidence that would support the claim of Amanda bleeding the same time as Meredith.

Finally, the question was how Amanda's DNA being found in the bathroom helped the forensic investigation. Absolutely nothing that you said in this post even remotely addresses that question. Swabbing a diluted blood drop along with half the sink and picking up Amanda's DNA in the process proves only that Amanda was in the bathroom at some point, either before, during or after the murder, and left her DNA on the sink. But since Amanda lived there and used the sink daily, this proves absolutely nothing.

So once again, HOW does finding Amanda's DNA in Amanda's bathroom help the forensic investigation?

As an aside, I'm really interested to learn how blood dripping from a knife leaves a pattern unique to a knife. If someone is stabbed with a screwdriver or ice pick, or is bludgeoned with a hammer, does blood drip off those things differently? It's incredible what you can learn on these boards...
 
The pattern of the blood drips over the sink and the bidet, was, in Stefanoni's experience, the same as that of a dripping knife..

First of all, I don't recall Stefanoni ever making such a claim. I don't suppose you'd be willing to provide a cite, eh?

As an aside, I'm really interested to learn how blood dripping from a knife leaves a pattern unique to a knife. If someone is stabbed with a screwdriver or ice pick, or is bludgeoned with a hammer, does blood drip off those things differently? It's incredible what you can learn on these boards...
Or a leaf or a chin or a nose? I was thinking EXACTLY the same thing TC. I'm calling major bs on this. NO WAY did Stefanoni say this. This is another bald faced lie by Vixen. I really want to know how blood drips differently from object to object and how one could tell from the stain that results?
 
Last edited:
So is it horrendous reading comprehension or are you just incapable of not making things up to fit your narrative?

Wow, just wow! (tm) williams

I'm surprised anyone remembers. BTW - I have a paypal account if you want to send in residuals.

Back to the matter at hand with the Mignini-surrogates. That's the trouble with making stuff up, isn't it? It's hard to make made-up stuff fit into a comprehensible narrative.

Vixen made up this, about both me and Judge Massei (from 2010):

It found the kids guilty beyond a shadow of a doubt despite Massei's prejudices against African immigrant Rudy, which you yourself point out....​

Whoever it is who is keeping track, could you add this to your list of, "Can you please provide a cite which demonstrates this?....." stuff.

I think we're up to 9,999 made up claims with no citation to prove any of it. As mentioned, the most crass was the claim of not being a slutshamer, and then in the next sentence called someone a nymphomaniac.

That one was a keeper.
 
And

Tell me, what does this have to do with the case? You're slut shaming again.

I noted years ago that the PGP often tend to have some kind of fascination with Amanda's sex life, both before and after the murder. They are prone to slut-shaming, calling her a ◊◊◊◊, wh***, nymphomaniac, accusing her of cheating on boyfriends, of using sex to get jobs, etc. This obsession with her sex life is psychologically fascinating.

“Women are indeed very capable of aggressing against others, especially women they perceive as rivals,” said Dr. Vaillancourt, now a psychologist at the University of Ottawa. “The research also shows that suppression of female sexuality is by women, not necessarily by men.”
Stigmatizing female promiscuity — a.k.a. slut-shaming — has often been blamed on men, who have a Darwinian incentive to discourage their spouses from straying. But they also have a Darwinian incentive to encourage other women to be promiscuous. Dr. Vaillancourt said the experiment and other research suggest the stigma is enforced mainly by women.
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/science/a-cold-war-fought-by-women.html?pagewanted=all

It is also noted in the same article that married women are less inclined to this kind of catty behavior than single (and that would include older divorced/widowed) women:

The results of the experiment jibe with evidence that this “mean girl” form of indirect aggression is used more by adolescents and young women than by older women, who have less incentive to handicap rivals once they marry. Other studies have shown that the more attractive an adolescent girl or woman is, the more likely she is to become a target for indirect aggression from her female peers.

Does this need to slut-shame, denigrate, and insult younger and more attractive females have a connection to sexual frustration in older, single, less attractive women who just aren't getting sex anymore? I suspect it does.
 
I noted years ago that the PGP often tend to have some kind of fascination with Amanda's sex life, both before and after the murder. They are prone to slut-shaming, calling her a ◊◊◊◊, wh***, nymphomaniac, accusing her of cheating on boyfriends, of using sex to get jobs, etc. This obsession with her sex life is psychologically fascinating.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/11/19/science/a-cold-war-fought-by-women.html?pagewanted=all

It is also noted in the same article that married women are less inclined to this kind of catty behavior than single (and that would include older divorced/widowed) women:



Does this need to slut-shame, denigrate, and insult younger and more attractive females have a connection to sexual frustration in older, single, less attractive women who just aren't getting sex anymore? I suspect it does.

At the risk of being argumentative, Stacyhs, even this has nothing at all to do with the trials.

The issue is - why did Mignini need to make something sexual out of this, meaning why did he need to incorporate "sex-game gone wrong", which even the 2013 Cassation ruling said was the forgotten, unexplored motive to this crime?

Mignini at his 2009 closing argument, made this into a psycho-sexual contest that Amanda had imaged in her head about Meredith. Mignini-surrogates since have taken that as permission to venture into all sorts of psychopathological fantasies......

....... none of which are supported at ANY of the courts, much less the two courts which convicted. (That was the very reason why the 2013 Cassation court directed the, then, Nencini trial to re-explore, "sex-game gone wrong", which both the new prosecutor, Crini, and the court itself completely ignored.)

Other that Rudy Guede's non-consentual leaving of his DNA in the victim, no one else had a sexual motive for anything - even Judge Massei conceded that in his 2010 Motivations report, when he says he can see no reason why Amanda would have had a motive to urge Rudy to sexually assault Meredith.

It's why when the Mignini-surrogates go in that direction, they are trying, really, to rehabilitate Mignini - who lost. He did not just lose at the 2015 Cassation acquittals - which called his investigation "amnesiac" - he lost even at the courts which convicted; who'd abandoned his wild theories.

Those who are Mignini-surrogates are only taking orders.
 
Last edited:
I'm surprised anyone remembers. BTW - I have a paypal account if you want to send in residuals.

Back to the matter at hand with the Mignini-surrogates. That's the trouble with making stuff up, isn't it? It's hard to make made-up stuff fit into a comprehensible narrative.

Vixen made up this, about both me and Judge Massei (from 2010):

​

Whoever it is who is keeping track, could you add this to your list of, "Can you please provide a cite which demonstrates this?....." stuff.

I think we're up to 9,999 made up claims with no citation to prove any of it. As mentioned, the most crass was the claim of not being a slutshamer, and then in the next sentence called someone a nymphomaniac.

That one was a keeper.

Perhaps we can make this more manageable if we use "false claim subsections". That is, where multiple false claims are made within the same sentence, perhaps we can use a xx.x format. In this way we can likely keep the primary number under 10,000.

Another idea might be to maintain two lists.. one for those false claims that elicit a "wow, just wow" reaction and those that only warrant a "wow" response. Of course, then we'd need a committee to decide whether a false claim is a one or two 'wow' claim, but still...

But seriously, how can you explain such a thing. I mean, you've been commenting on this case for the better part of seven years (I believe) so it's at least mildly understandable if someone were to *think* you said something at some point. But in this case she is commenting on an interview that was just posted hours ago and still she gets things completely wrong. It's like if I say "I really like that blue house on the mountain side" and Vixen turns around and claims I said I hate the brown beach house - and we JUST had the conversation!! What do you do with that?? Early onset of Alzheimer perhaps? I dunno...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom