The Psychic Picture Test - martinv, ferj, mayday

Regarding the previous posts, this is all nice and true. But how come that all of these psychics who join here write post after post without simply doing their stunt: Make some nice little psychic guesses or predictions.

If any of them had any powers whatsoever, why don't they post right here, right now below my post, stuff like:

kosai was drinking green tea with too much sugar while typing post #57.

JoeTheJuggler was wearing green shorts while typing post #58.

Garrette felt cold and closed the window while typing post #59.​

Seriously, am I asking too much?
 
Regarding the previous posts, this is all nice and true. But how come that all of these psychics who join here write post after post without simply doing their stunt: Make some nice little psychic guesses or predictions.

If any of them had any powers whatsoever, why don't they post right here, right now below my post, stuff like:

kosai was drinking green tea with too much sugar while typing post #57.

JoeTheJuggler was wearing green shorts while typing post #58.

Garrette felt cold and closed the window while typing post #59.​

Seriously, am I asking too much?

Do any of them claim to be able to do such things?
 
Personally, I think MartinV understood all the concepts quite clearly. I also think he had no intention whatsoever of participating in any test that wouldn't let him retrofit and cherry pick the results.

JtJ has it, of course. Once he realised he wasn't going to pull one over on us, he fled.
 
Do any of them claim to be able to do such things?

That was not the point of my post, and I think you know that.

Why don't the psychics just pop in here and blow us away with a couple of predictions or guesses to shut us up for good?

Why don't they post those UK lottery numbers and get them right? Why do they blather about this and that instead of astonishing us with three correct guesses what this or that person is holding in the hand right now? Why can none of them correctly guess the colour of JoeTheJuggler's trousers whilst they claim to talk to the dead and have intimate relationships with orbs floating around them?

[/end of rant]
 
That was not the point of my post, and I think you know that.

Why don't the psychics just pop in here and blow us away with a couple of predictions or guesses to shut us up for good?

Why don't they post those UK lottery numbers and get them right? Why do they blather about this and that instead of astonishing us with three correct guesses what this or that person is holding in the hand right now? Why can none of them correctly guess the colour of JoeTheJuggler's trousers whilst they claim to talk to the dead and have intimate relationships with orbs floating around them?

[/end of rant]

Again, do any of them claim to be able to do these things? Or are you asking why an evolutionary biologist doesn't submit proof of the big bang? Close, but no cigar. Randi is scrupulous in his insistence in only testing exactly what the applicants claim for a very good reason.
 
Again, do any of them claim to be able to do these things?

Yes. Martinv claimed to be able to psychically view pictures. Ferj claims to be able to predict lottery results. Mayday claims to be able to vist a psychic. All of them ramble on for months without ever actually trying to do what they claim to do all the time.
 
(Woops, didn't read whole thread before posting guess. Will wait for recycled .RAR :)
 
Last edited:
Yes. Martinv claimed to be able to psychically view pictures. Ferj claims to be able to predict lottery results. Mayday claims to be able to vist a psychic. All of them ramble on for months without ever actually trying to do what they claim to do all the time.

And not only that, ferj and Martinv both agreed to a protocol and then walked away from it. (In martin's case, he said he liked the protocol suggested by Rasmus, but then walked away--he never quite got to a formal protocol, but it was headed that way quickly, and that's when he dropped it.) I haven't kept up with the mayday threads, but I'd bet she too has agreed to tests or demonstrations of her ability but failed to follow through.

Say didn't Sylvia Browne do the same thing?

On the other hand, Gr8wight's point is valid.

That's why when MartinV first appeared on ferj's thread with a proposed exercise in retrofitting and cherry picking, my first question was what specifically are you claiming and how will we know at the end of this test whether or not you have demonstrated it? His "triple blinding" notwithstanding, his proposed protocol had no claim and no way of measuring the outcome. We showed him several ways that the claim he was at least implying (that he could remotely "read" objects held by people and come up with a description of them) could be tested.

As for ferj, he once stated his claim (the ability to make at least 10 detailed and specific psychic predictions in a year's time with 90% accuracy). We knocked out a pretty good protocol to test that, which he agreed to, and then he abandoned it. Since then he has been extra careful to avoid stating a claim.

So I applaud Kosai's efforts at coming up with an acceptable protocol. I deplore Martinv's lack of effort at working on a protocol. I'm certain that there was a way to modify Kosai's protocol that would have fitted Martinv's claimed ability. (In fact, the idea of a password protected "answer key" could have been incorporated into Rasmus's protocol--or, another way of saying it is use actual objects in Kosai's protocol, and the rar file would merely be an answer key so MartinV would know that the remote participant wasn't cheating.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom