The Psychic Picture Test - martinv, ferj, mayday

Kosai. Wow you really are trying. That is so refreshing.
I don't know if holding a picture is the same as holding the object.
I find that odd since in your thread this is how you described the protocol you and your claimed group of PhDs, scientists, researchers and psychics put together:

We also do photographs inside sealed envelopes. Everybody in the group brings in photographs. One person is the test admin and places the photos into identical envelopes and numbers them randomly. The envelopes are sealed and handed around the room to everyone in random order. Then everyone is given a recording sheet with the numbers from the envelopes and has to record as much detail from the photos as they can. Then we pass the photos to our right, and evaluate the next photo handed to us. It makes for a reasonable size dataset to get reasonable statistics.

(italics mine)
 
Last edited:
1. Box
2. Guitar
3. Piano keys
4. Wheel
5. Mugs
6. Shell
7. Watering can
8. Brush
9. Lemons
10. Bird

I actually expect to do a lot better than by chance alone. I predict I will get at least half of them correct, due to what I believe is a test flaw. If my list is indeed close to the truth, then kosai might want to consider redesigning the test.
 
1. Box
2. Guitar
3. Piano keys
4. Wheel
5. Mugs
6. Shell
7. Watering can
8. Brush
9. Lemons
10. Bird

I actually expect to do a lot better than by chance alone. I predict I will get at least half of them correct, due to what I believe is a test flaw. If my list is indeed close to the truth, then kosai might want to consider redesigning the test.

You have, of course, solved the puzzle!

What this goes to show is... When people are in a situation where they need to be "psychic" they can either guess and hope to get lucky or, as you or John Edward or Sylvia Browne or any other person who runs a successful "psychic" business, they can find a way to cheat. You just happen to be more honest than those who claim "powers."

The solution to the puzzle is to crop each of the images in the GIF I posted originally, save them as JPG's, then compare the file sizes to those in the RAR file. Nicely done, you got them all correct.

If we can, I'd like to rework the test without this flaw. Is there some way to hide the file size information in the RAR? Is it possible to recompess the images so they are all the same size? I have photoshop however there is not an option I know of for this.

To those of you who just guessed... Some of you did quite well with it! Devnull was also on the right track and in a PM to me yesterday was going off file sizes alone. Simply by the content of the pictures, he did manage to skew his result to 4 of 10 so good job to him also for beginning to figure it out.

I'd be happy to re-work the test so, at least this method, can't be used to determine the pictures.

The password to the file is: uuKvK9h8P4NTDMZ3JoD6
 
If we can, I'd like to rework the test without this flaw. Is there some way to hide the file size information in the RAR? Is it possible to recompess the images so they are all the same size? I have photoshop however there is not an option I know of for this.

Save them as bitmaps with no compression at all. As long as they're the same physical size, they'll have the same file size.
 
Well, that is still not good enough, since the files will compress differently when rar'ed. It would still be possible to gain some information from that.

It would possibly be best to just save as bitmaps, then encrypt the files in an achive without any compression.
 
Where can I find that option in WinRAR?

Edit: I think I found the option, they call it "Store" rather than "None" for compression method.

The new file can be downloaded here:

http://www.mediafire.com/?0tjcz9ugmwy

People who have guessed previously are free to guess again. Hopefully some of those who have claimed abilities here won't be so shy this time around. Also, the more tech savvy here are free to try and cheat to improve the method.
 
Last edited:
I will maintain my original prediction. I had foreseen this development and predicted the correct order in advance.
 
1. Box
2. Guitar
3. Piano keys
4. Wheel
5. Mugs
6. Shell
7. Watering can
8. Brush
9. Lemons
10. Bird

I actually expect to do a lot better than by chance alone. I predict I will get at least half of them correct, due to what I believe is a test flaw. If my list is indeed close to the truth, then kosai might want to consider redesigning the test.

Sweet! Awesome job! I'm impressed.

Me, I was going to guess mug for everything, then blame it on the psychic interference from my cup of coffee, and then whine about how unfair the test was to begin with. :D
 
Maybe .rar the images, then put that .rar in another? There is also an option to encrypt file names; that will prompt for a password before doing anything else. (I don't know how particularly secure this is, just mentioning it.)
 
Why bother? The only people who didn't post a guess are the psychics. Not posting and blaming it on protocol, interference, or the fact that this is something they can't actually do (despite claiming they could previously) is better than posting and getting it wrong. A good scammer will never get caught.
 
Just paste all 10 individual images into one "super-image" that contains all 10 objects in order from top to bottom. That way there is only one file to encrypt, and no clues to be had from file size.

Oh my god... are you TRYING to mess with my psychic image?? My reception isn't that good already and now you are going to mash all the pictures together to make it even harder? Don't make me have to squint in my mind's eye buddy!!
 
Last edited:
Surely, with all these psychics at your disposal, marvin, one of them can at LEAST pluck the password from kosai's mind.
Oh, and I'm still waiting for the answer to my question.
 
Hi All,
I have no idea how to psychically or otherwise get into a file.
I want to show that I am looking for good tests,
but this tests something I don't know how to do.

I know everyone wants an official answer from me:

since I don't know how to get the psychic answer
I will go with using them in order listed.

First lemon,bird, brush, shell, cup
then keys, watering can, guitar, box, thingy

This kind of brings me back to one of my earlier posts about
having tests designed that are from a psychics point of view.

The test protocol with holding an object works for me
Then me matching my result with a known list of objects
then have a third party comparing my object pick to the sending object
I thought was a pretty clear protocol.

Martinv, that is an excellent response, and should serve as a reminder to all the 'skeptics' here that we cannot ask anyone to participate in any test solely of our own devising.

And Martin, you should know, if you do not already, that were you to apply for the One Million Dollar Challenge, any test you underwent would have been designed "from a 'psychic's' point of view, because it would have been designed by you. The JREF is very clear on this matter. Any applicant must clearly state exactly what they are able to do, and how they would go about demonstrating that ability. That is to say that the applicant submits the test design.

Now, the JREF will not hesitate to point out to the applicant where their test has design flaws or loopholes which would allow the applicant to pass the test using mundane means, and such loopholes will not be allowed. So the applicant and the JREF must work together to arrive at a test design that will be acceptable by both sides. If that cannot be worked out, then of course a test will not take place.
 
Martinv, that is an excellent response, and should serve as a reminder to all the 'skeptics' here that we cannot ask anyone to participate in any test solely of our own devising.

And Martin, you should know, if you do not already, that were you to apply for the One Million Dollar Challenge, any test you underwent would have been designed "from a 'psychic's' point of view, because it would have been designed by you. The JREF is very clear on this matter. Any applicant must clearly state exactly what they are able to do, and how they would go about demonstrating that ability. That is to say that the applicant submits the test design.

Now, the JREF will not hesitate to point out to the applicant where their test has design flaws or loopholes which would allow the applicant to pass the test using mundane means, and such loopholes will not be allowed. So the applicant and the JREF must work together to arrive at a test design that will be acceptable by both sides. If that cannot be worked out, then of course a test will not take place.

This would be all well and good if he hadn't basically made the same claim in another thread already. He says psychic tests should be designed by psychics, he made an assumption that I am not psychic myself. Well I would like to state I believe I am every bit as psychic as he is. "Psychic" ability can only be tested by knowing that which you shouldn't know. I do not care the method you've used to come across the information, from mind reading, remote viewing, or asking your dead uncle to peek for you. The information is known by me, it exists in the physical world as a list on my desk as well. I think a big reason the Million Dollar Challenge is being closed is the very idea we let them make up the test. That's fine for a test of the "supernatural" but a test of psychic ability is kind of a one trick pony isn't it?
 
I believe the motivation for kosai offering another test was Martinv's footdragging on the protocol he said he liked (Rasmus'). In fact, Martinv didn't seem to have any intention of actually participating in a test whose protocol would be at all acceptable for the MDC.

He didn't seem to understand major points like that the results had to be self-evident and not subject to judging or interpretation.

To the business of who makes the test, the wording is "claimant" so your point, kosai, about being every bit as much a psychic as him while true is irrelevant. But Gr8wight's right. Just because we can come up with a great protocol doesn't mean it actually fits with what he's claiming to be able to do. That's for the claimant to say.

Personally, I think MartinV understood all the concepts quite clearly. I also think he had no intention whatsoever of participating in any test that wouldn't let him retrofit and cherry pick the results.
 
Last edited:
It's an interesting example of one of the woo-purveyor types.

There are those who believe because they have never been exposed to counter-information and come here honestly thinking they are presenting claims or interpretations or philosophies new to us.

There are those who--like MartinV, I think--ultimately know they have no real case but who think their supposed skills at presentation and debate will leave us befuddled.

There are other types, of course, but I'll not try to list them except for Interesting Ian who was in his own category and a true gem.
 
I believe the motivation for kosai offering another test was Martinv's footdragging on the protocol he said he liked (Rasmus'). In fact, Martinv didn't seem to have any intention of actually participating in a test whose protocol would be at all acceptable for the MDC.

Nono! It's not Rasmus' test... It's the electronic equivalent of MartinV's own test! This was pointed out by madurobob earlier in the thread.

Originally Posted by martinv:
We also do photographs inside sealed envelopes. Everybody in the group brings in photographs. One person is the test admin and places the photos into identical envelopes and numbers them randomly. The envelopes are sealed and handed around the room to everyone in random order. Then everyone is given a recording sheet with the numbers from the envelopes and has to record as much detail from the photos as they can. Then we pass the photos to our right, and evaluate the next photo handed to us. It makes for a reasonable size dataset to get reasonable statistics.

That is martinv's own claim, somewhere in his thread I believe he also said distance from the testing medium INCREASES hit%. So we were ready for breakthrough levels here. He said he can't read in files, I said I'd print them. He said I'm refreshing. He said he's not sure about pictures (though you can read the pictures thing was HIS idea.) Today, he left the forum.

The only difference between my test and martinv's was the fact that my test requires specific answers. He wants answers like "orange and curvy" to score 60 out of a hundred rather than 0 for a photo of a lemon.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom