The Psychic Picture Test - martinv, ferj, mayday

kosai

Recently Audited Thetan Cluster
Joined
Aug 19, 2005
Messages
565
I'm becoming tired of the many claims here and hee-hawing about how to set up a test. So I decided to create as fair of an electronic test as I could. You can choose to play or not, psychic or not. The rules are simple and I feel they are fair but I am open to discussion if you feel something is off . This test can be run infinate times and you are free to use whatever "powers" you feel you may have to play the game.

So here's the rules.

Below is a file, in this file is 10 folders, in each folder you will find a file called "Image.jpg." Your job it to tell me and the board WHAT picture is in each folder. We do not care about the method you will be using or how you will do it. Please simply submit a list, 1-10 what you think the Image.jpg is in each folder. This file has a password on it, so you can't peak inside. Please download a copy of the RAR file, save it to your computer so that later you can verify the results yourself. The 10 images are as follows:

testob6.gif

By travisjd at 2008-02-17

The file "Test.rar" can be downloaded here:
http://www.mediafire.com/?0wx3wvtpavn

The program to open RAR files can be found here:
http://www.rarlab.com/download.htm

The MD5 Hash for the file is:
09cc45f6c962cd51b2c3120e99d58225

Which was generated using the file here:
http://www.whitsoftdev.com/md5/

If you have concerns about a possible exploit in this test please don't post it publically, instead PM me. Thank you.
 
Last edited:
Kosai, when I try to get the file from imageshack, it says "File upload seems to be abandoned by sender". Perhaps it's not finished uploading?

It sounds like a pretty fool proof scheme, though. I would ask any "psychics" participating to state first how many right they claim they'll be able to get.

And, I guess someone needs to do the math to tell us how many hits it takes to rule out chance with some level of confidence.
 
Joe: Thanks for the heads up, I've fixed the link. The "By Chance" rate would be 1 in 10 correct. I will leave it to the guesser to make a claim.
 
Joe: Thanks for the heads up, I've fixed the link.

That's got it!

The "By Chance" rate would be 1 in 10 correct. I will leave it to the guesser to make a claim.
I understand that--chance predicts an average of 1 right--but that doesn't mean that 2 right or 3 right is statistically significant (you can't rule out chance with much of any confidence).

Also, if they're allowed to submit as many guesses as they want, that should be counted into the probability calculation. (I could theoretically submit all possible combinations of images in folders and have a 100% probability that one of my guesses will result in 10 of 10.)

ETA: BaronSamedi?
 
Last edited:
Also, if they're allowed to submit as many guesses as they want, that should be counted into the probability calculation. (I could theoretically submit all possible combinations of images in folders and have a 100% probability that one of my guesses will result in 10 of 10.)

ETA: BaronSamedi?


Ah great point, I didn't think to state it because it was obvious to me but you are right some may try to exploit this. Let us establish now there will only be allowed one guess per person.
 
Also, if they're allowed to submit as many guesses as they want, that should be counted into the probability calculation. (I could theoretically submit all possible combinations of images in folders and have a 100% probability that one of my guesses will result in 10 of 10.)


You'd have to submit 3.6 million guesses.

In any case, here is my psychic predictionation:

Lemons - 6
Bird - 8
Brush - 2
Seashells - 4
Mugs - 1
Piano - 3
Watering Can - 10
Guitar - 7
Box - 9
Gambling Wheel Or Whatever It Is - 5

I expect I got all ten. Please send me the brush, piano, guitar and skill-o-wheel or whatever.
 
You'd have to submit 3.6 million guesses.
Wow! I would've guestimated somewhere in the tens of thousands. (Which is why I don't want to rely on my guestimation skills to assess the outcome of this!)

Still, your chance of getting a few right would increase dramatically with even a handful of repeated attempts, so I'm glad that's out.

ETA: How is the number of possible combinations calculated? Is it 10! ?
 
Last edited:
What date will you post the results and details of the pictures/folders?
 
My prediction, scientifically produced from atmospheric noise:

1. Guitar
2. Shell
3. Mugs
4. Bird
5. Box
6. Lemons
7. Wheel
8. Piano keys
9. Brush
10. Watering can.
 
ETA: How is the number of possible combinations calculated? Is it 10! ?

Yes. You have ten choices for image 1. Once image 1 has been chosen you have nine choices for image 2. Then you have eight choices for image 3, and so on.

The total number of combinations is 10 x 9 x 8 x 7 x 6 x 5 x 4 x 3 x 2 = 10! = 3628800.
 
What date will you post the results and details of the pictures/folders?

Let's go with... Wednesday 2/20, People here don't like long waits on these type things. I can't say I blame them.

I will post the PASSWORD and results, this means you can look yourself since you will have the file.
 
Last edited:
1. Watering Can
2. Mugs
3. Lemons
4. Brush
5. Box
6. Piano Keys
7. Bird
8. Shell
9. Guitar
10. Wheel

I would say that I expect to do as well as the "real" psychics, but I don't want my negative waves affecting their guesse--, err, predictions.
 
...I understand that--chance predicts an average of 1 right--but that doesn't mean that 2 right or 3 right is statistically significant (you can't rule out chance with much of any confidence)...
Quite right.
Using the Binomial Test, 3 hits p=.0574, 4 hits p=.0112, 5 hits p= 0015, 6 hits p = .00014.
By the standards of psychological science, 5 hits would be significant at p < .01. Randi's test for extraordinary claims would probably more rigorous, say 6 hits.
 
I think I know how this is done:

1: The bird, or maybe the seashell, because they have similar shapes and colors, but there's a chance it could be the lemons, because if you turn the lemon at the right angle, it looks a little like the shell.

2. The brush. I'm pretty sure it's the brush, if it isn't the piano keys, which have a similar vertical pattern to the brush bristles. Or maybe I'm getting the guitar strings, it's hard to tell. But one of them. Or maybe the bird.

3. Well, you get the idea.....
 
1. Brush
2. Guitar
3. Box
4. Mugs
5. Lemons
6. Bird
7. Wheel
8. Shell
9. Watering Can
10. Piano Keys
 
1. Lemons
2. Watering Can
3. Guitar
4. Bird
5. Shell
6. Brush
7. Piano Keys
8. Box of packing peanuts
9. Gambling spinner or wheel or thingie or whatever
10. Mugs

If I get a statistically significant number of items right, then my butt is psychic, because that's from where I pulled my guesses.
 
Last edited:
1 Brush
2 Piano
3 Watering can
4 Mugs
5 Bird
6 Box
7 Guitar
8 Lemons
9 Wheel
10 Seashell

I expect to get at least six right.
 
Hi All,
I have no idea how to psychically or otherwise get into a file.
I want to show that I am looking for good tests,
but this tests something I don't know how to do.

I know everyone wants an official answer from me:

since I don't know how to get the psychic answer
I will go with using them in order listed.

First lemon,bird, brush, shell, cup
then keys, watering can, guitar, box, thingy

This kind of brings me back to one of my earlier posts about
having tests designed that are from a psychics point of view.

The test protocol with holding an object works for me
Then me matching my result with a known list of objects
then have a third party comparing my object pick to the sending object
I thought was a pretty clear protocol.
 
Hi All,
I have no idea how to psychically or otherwise get into a file.
I want to show that I am looking for good tests,
but this tests something I don't know how to do.

I know everyone wants an official answer from me:

since I don't know how to get the psychic answer
I will go with using them in order listed.

First lemon,bird, brush, shell, cup
then keys, watering can, guitar, box, thingy

This kind of brings me back to one of my earlier posts about
having tests designed that are from a psychics point of view.

The test protocol with holding an object works for me
Then me matching my result with a known list of objects
then have a third party comparing my object pick to the sending object
I thought was a pretty clear protocol.

In other words: While a dozen other posters would simply reply to this thread with their list of objects, the psychic won't do such a thing because, well, because - well! Because! He'd rather write about this and that and things and stuff and protocols and don't feel like it and clear not so clear works for me works not for this et cetera et cetera. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom