KRAMER said:
Yeah, folks. I am not happy about accepting this claim. And Randi is not happy with me for my "high moral" position.
It's moral in part, but it's also a practical concern. This claim is a complete and utter waste of our limited time and resources.
Please argue this with me if you believe me to be wrong.
This is actually a tricky one.
I agree totally with your view Kramer that it does the JREF no good to be testing such stupid claims.
But having said that, if this idiot is actually becoming quote renowned then offering to test him might possibly be constructive.
Hopefully if you can pin him down to exactly what he is claiming to be able to do, and what specifically he is summoning then he will withdraw of his own volition.
Ask him specifically if what he is summoning is a spececraft built and piloted by creatures from another world.
See is he will define exactly what he means by UFOs (because obviously I could summon a UFO tomorrow in the literal sense of the meaning - but it wouldn't be alien).
Get him to do the work of making it explicitly a paranormal claim.
Then if he continues I guess you'll have to follow the claim up. Regrettably.
But to be honest is his claim any more ludicrous than Paul Carey's? And that was agreed to.
Is it really fair to make judgements betwen the different levels of ludicrousnes of claims?
Personally I thought the Angela Patel claim was every bit as silly and a waste of time as this guy, but they all deserve to be tested if the challenge is there.
And I see where Randi is coming from in that the better known an applicant is the more relevant testing their claim is.
Finally steenkh's point is a good one - people will always get mileage out of not being tested by the JREF - look at the breatharian nonsense.
Randi refuses to test someone offering to starve themselves, and somehow he is made to look like the villain!
I don't think Yahweh/Watkins is expecting you to say yes, so it'll be interesting to see his reaction if you do.
And maybe just one person who might have believed his idiocy will be dissuaded by his failure to complete the JREF challenge.
Surely it'd be worth it for that?