The main reason behind Creationism in schools.

I haven't seen anything in the wedge document that would dismantle those protections.

A society in which most people, including scientists, agree with special creation as an explanation for origins is not necessarily a society run based on religion. The Founders recognized that; I'm not sure why you believe we couldn't recognize that today.

When this theory of special creation is being promoted in the US as a method to increase exposure of Christianity* to children in secular public schools, it is part of an agenda to promote a religious, specifically Christian society. The constitution was designed to protect us from that, so I believe the founders may have had a problem with it.

* Unless you think DI would be ok with promoting the Islamic creation story.
 
When this theory of special creation is being promoted in the US as a method to increase exposure of Christianity* to children in secular public schools, it is part of an agenda to promote a religious, specifically Christian society. The constitution was designed to protect us from that, so I believe the founders may have had a problem with it.

I expect the Founders would have.

It's still not tantamount to establishing a theocracy.
 
I expect the Founders would have.

It's still not tantamount to establishing a theocracy.

No, you're right. Pushing for Christian creation theories in the class room is not, in and of itself, the same as establishing a theocracy. But it is one of the symptoms of encroaching Christian fundamentalism into every social and political sphere.
 
I don't agree with that.

I also don't agree that that's what the decision in Dover said.

But since nobody's actually citing to the case, I guess we'll just end up keeping our opinions, huh?
When you read the Kitzmiller decision, did you miss this part or something?

Citation.

Although as noted Defendants have consistently asserted that the ID Policy was enacted for the secular purposes of improving science education and encouraging students to exercise critical thinking (Case 4:04-cv-02688-JEJ Document 342 Filed 12/20/2005 Page 130 of 139 131) skills, the Board took none of the steps that school officials would take if these stated goals had truly been their objective. The Board consulted no scientific materials. The Board contacted no scientists or scientific organizations. The Board failed to consider the views of the District’s science teachers. The Board relied solely on legal advice from two organizations with demonstrably religious, cultural, and legal missions, the Discovery Institute and the TMLC. Moreover, Defendants’ asserted secular purpose of improving science education is belied by the fact that most if not all of the Board members who voted in favor of the biology curriculum change conceded that they still do not know, nor have they ever known, precisely what ID is. To assert a secular purpose against this backdrop is ludicrous. Finally, although Defendants have unceasingly attempted in vain to distance themselves from their own actions and statements, which culminated in repetitious, untruthful testimony, such a strategy constitutes additional strong evidence of improper purpose under the first prong of the Lemon test. As exhaustively detailed herein, the thought leaders on the Board made it their considered purpose to inject some form of creationism into the science classrooms, and by the dint of their personalities and persistence they were able to pull the majority of the Board along in their collective wake.

Case 4:04-cv-02688-JEJ Document 342 Filed 12/20/2005 Page 131 of 139 132 Any asserted secular purposes by the Board are a sham and are merely secondary to a religious objective. McCreary, 125 S. Ct. at 2735; accord, e.g., Santa Fe, 530 U.S. at 308 (“it is . . . the duty of the courts to ‘distinguish a sham secular purpose from a sincere one.’” (citation omitted)); Edwards, 482 U.S. at 586-87 (“While the Court is normally deferential to a State’s articulation of a secular purpose, it is required that the statement of such purpose be sincere and not a sham.”). Defendants’ previously referenced flagrant and insulting falsehoods to the Court provide sufficient and compelling evidence for us to deduce that any allegedly secular purposes that have been offered in support of the ID policy are equally insincere.

Accordingly, we find that the secular purposes claimed by the Board amount
to a pretext for the Board’s real purpose, which was to promote religion in the
public school classroom, in violation of the Establishment Clause.
Judge Jones doesn't agree with you at all. Taste his boomstick.

Now, the DI argued on behalf of the defendants (Behe), gave them legal advice, was in touch with them throughout the trial, etc.

Are you really suggesting that the defendants in the case were not trying to assert that ID was not a re-branding of creationism?
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to take the document at face value, since that's the claim Dinwar made.
Then you shouldn't be leaving "and also politics" out of their statements in a discussion about their political intent.

Example: one of their twenty-year goals is:
TFA said:
To see design theory permeate our religious, cultural, moral and political life.

It's damned disingenuous to leave that out and you know I'm not the kind of person to back down and let you get away with it if only you're obtuse enough. You're a schmott guy; I know you aren't doing it mistakenly.

You can argue that the kind of political influence they're gunning for doesn't count in some kind of way, but don't try to argue that getting it isn't part of their stated intent.
 
I'll re-cite the most relevant passage again:

Defendants’ previously referenced flagrant and insulting falsehoods to the Court provide sufficient and compelling evidence for us to deduce that any allegedly secular purposes that have been offered in support of the ID policy are equally insincere.

Yes, "flagrant and insulting falsehoods". I think that satisfies Dinwar's earlier statement that the Court recorded DI as having committed fraud.
 
I haven't seen anything in the wedge document that would dismantle those protections.

A society in which most people, including scientists, agree with special creation as an explanation for origins is not necessarily a society run based on religion. The Founders recognized that; I'm not sure why you believe we couldn't recognize that today.

Wow, creation without a creator. Wonder of wonders.

Or total BS.


I can guess...
 
Again, your claim: "They've stated that their goal is a theocracy."

I don't see support for this claim.

Now, if your new claim is "They've state that their goal is to take over culture, and I believe that the end result of this would be a theocracy", then you can back up that claim with additional evidence.

I don't know about the claim of fraud, but if you want evidence of the highlighted claim about the goal being theocracy, you need look no further than the Discovery Institute's Wedge Document. Seeing as how the Discovery Institute was/is the clearinghouse for creationism since the mid-1990s, this would seem to constitute significant evidence.

There are a number of very specific statements in the Wedge Document which back up the claim made above. One of the most obvious is, and I quote:

... Alongside a focus on the influential opinion-makers, we also seek to build up a popular base of support among our natural constituency, namely, Christians. We will do this primarily through apologetics seminars. We intend these to encourage and equip believers with new scientific evidences that support the faith, as well as to popularize our ideas in the broader culture.

And another big one, titled "Twenty Year Goals", which really shows the aim of placing a theocratic government into power is:

*To see intelligent design theory as the dominant perspective in science.
*To see design theory application in specific fields, including molecular biology, biochemistry, paleontology, physics and cosmology in the natural sciences, psychology, ethics, politics, theology and philosophy in the humanities; to see its influence in the fine arts.
*To see design theory permeate our religious, cultural, moral and political life.

Will that suffice?

ETA: Seems like someone else already nailed the fraud claim by referencing the court decision in Dover v. Kitzmiller. Ouch.

I guess lying is okay so long as you do it in the name of God :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I'll re-cite the most relevant passage again:



Yes, "flagrant and insulting falsehoods". I think that satisfies Dinwar's earlier statement that the Court recorded DI as having committed fraud.
I'd say so. DI wasn't on trial there - the school board members were - but DI was acting as a legal adviser, and provided 'expert testimony' in the trial in the form of one of their members, Michael Behe.

And considering that the DI was acting on behalf of the defendants (the school board members), I'd say that this places the DI in the category of having helped them commit "flagrant and insulting falsehoods" in court.

The judge thought so.
 
When this theory of special creation is being promoted in the US as a method to increase exposure of Christianity* to children in secular public schools, it is part of an agenda to promote a religious, specifically Christian society. The constitution was designed to protect us from that, so I believe the founders may have had a problem with it.

* Unless you think DI would be ok with promoting the Islamic creation story.

Better yet, ask whether or not the DI would be okay with promoting Raelianism, which is an atheistic version of "intelligent design".
 
Ah, no. We were already discussing the wedge document. My point was that the goals articulated in the wedge document are perfectly consistent with a non-theocratic government.

How so? When the document clearly states that it considers its natural constituents to be evangelical Christians, and then proposes to take "ID-theory", which they admit is based upon their version of Christian ideas, and then further proposes to infuse all those ideas into the political life of the nation, it's pretty easy to connect the dots.

It was pretty clear from the well-worded ruling in the Dover trial that the DI got caught pretty badly on promoting their clearly unconstitutional strategy. If you would bother to take the time to read what Judge Jones wrote instead of cherry-picking and ignoring the parts you don't like, then you might see this fact.

Of course, if one wants to be willfully obtuse and ignore the obvious, I can't help that.
 
It was pretty clear from the well-worded ruling in the Dover trial that the DI got caught pretty badly on promoting their clearly unconstitutional strategy. If you would bother to take the time to read what Judge Jones wrote instead of cherry-picking and ignoring the parts you don't like, then you might see this fact.

Calm down, sparky. I've already acceded to the fact that I haven't read the Dover opinion since it came out and, sure enough, hadn't remembered the cited portions of the opinion.

Take a step back and read the whole thread before you start throwing around personal insults. It doesn't help.

I was primarily interested in how the judge was stretching the Establishment Clause to cover this situation.
 
Calm down, sparky. I've already acceded to the fact that I haven't read the Dover opinion since it came out and, sure enough, hadn't remembered the cited portions of the opinion.

Take a step back and read the whole thread before you start throwing around personal insults. It doesn't help.

I was primarily interested in how the judge was stretching the Establishment Clause to cover this situation.

Perhaps, before you start to form an ill-informed opinion, you should consider taking all of the relevant facts into account. Otherwise, don't whine when people here call you out on your lack of rigor, especially when you make unsupported claims.

Btw, I did read the whole thread. Perhaps you should read the whole Wedge Document and re-read the Dover ruling, and stop throwing stones while you sit in your glass house.

ETA: So, you can start to argue the facts of the situation (which are a part of the federal court record) and gain some respect here, or you can stick with your ill-informed opinion and hang yourself up on a cross while crying about how people are insulting you when they call you out. Either way, I don't care.
 
Last edited:
When this theory of special creation is being promoted in the US as a method to increase exposure of Christianity* to children in secular public schools, it is part of an agenda to promote a religious, specifically Christian society. The constitution was designed to protect us from that, so I believe the founders may have had a problem with it.

* Unless you think DI would be ok with promoting the Islamic creation story.
Well, since Islamic creation story is the same one (Old Testament), I do not think ID would have a problem with that :)

Hindoo creation story, OTOH...
 
I always had a fantasy that if I were ever a science teacher, and they made me teach creationism, I would teach the ancient Egyptian creationism story that starts out with Ra hatching from an egg in an endless sea, and then explain how evolution offers much more meaningful information. But of course I would be accused of being afraid to teach real creationism.

Namely, the Cherokee story of Beaver's Grandchild the water-beetle kicking mud up from the bottom of the sea to create the earth.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom