The main reason behind Creationism in schools.

I agree with everything you wrote except last sentence. I see nothing entertaining about right-wing fundamentalists, and a lot of things scary. Yes they are doomed in the long run, but can do a lot of damage in the meantime. Up to and including nuclear war -- low probability, but after all, they are pretty much the only people who think it is (or can be) a positive thing.

Considering the concentration of nuclear war technology and assets, located in areas where the Christian fundamentalists have large numbers of followers and political power; I too see nothing entertaining about the possible long term outcome of their religious organizations losing control. When they get desperate, that's when things could get very scary indeed. Hopefully, logic will prevail; but logic isn't one of the strong points of religious fundamentalists.
 
westprog said:
I own a book on geology written by a Church of England clergyman who clearly states that the Earth is many millions of years old, and that this does not produce a conflict with religious belief. It considerably predates Darwin.
Yes, yes, we know--some religions, and some members of most of the hard-line religions, accept facts. HOWEVER, the fact that some do is irrelevent to my point. The ones who don't are trying to creat a theocracy, and have stated as much. Their first step is getting us to accept Creationism in schools. The fact that some people in England aren't in no way invalidates this.

If I say "The main goal of al Quada is to get the USA out of the Middle East", saying that Saladin was generous when he conquered Jerusalem isn't a counter-argument.

Mojo said:
The Dover trial (and Behe's work) was about ID, not YEC.
The Panda's Thumb pretty much proves that the difference between ID and YEC is that ID has a different name.

SonOfLaertes said:
Would the Christian Right love a theocracy? No doubt. Is that their main concern right now? No. They are simply trying to tread water, no matter what brave face they are putting up in public.
Than why do we have multiple states trying to ban homosexual marrage at any given time? Why do we have "vice taxes"? Why do we have multiple states trying to push Creationism into the schools? I agree that they're losing ground--but I strongly disagree with your interpretation of the speed of that loss.
 
Haven't you heard? "Melting Pot" is now politically incorrect. The preferred term is "Salad Bowl".

I've always preferred "Stew." In a salad all the ingredients are still too separated. There's a thin sheen of dressing gluing it all together but mostly things keep to themselves. But in a stew, while each addition is still recognizable in the finished product, everything that got put in has contributed a little to everything else, and the dish as a whole is richer for it.

The other week I had a short rib and kimchi burrito served to me by a dude wearing an anime t-shirt out of a taco truck blasting ghetto rap at nearly a hundred decibels. That is my new vision for America.
 
I'm not seeing the "theocracy" part. Can you cite your support for that?
TFA said:
* To defeat scientific materialism and its destructive moral, cultural and political legacies.
* To replace materialistic explanations with the theistic understanding that nature and hurnan beings are created by God.
I can see how this would be hard to miss.
 
Still not seeing it.

Maybe it would help if someone would explain to me what they mean by theocracy.

It's not seriously disputed that in the late 18th century, our government as well as most of our citizens had a generally theistic understanding of the universe. The Creator was widely invoked by government officials and in founding documents, and even most scientists of that time had a "theistic understanding that nature and human beings are created by God".

Is it your assertion, then, that our country was founded as a theocracy? Because I certainly don't see it.

Which is why I'm asking the question, what do you mean by "theocracy", and how do you expect that this particular organization's goals (which are primarily to make special creation the primary paradigm in science and general understanding in our culture) would lead to a theocratic form of government?
 
Still not seeing it.

Maybe it would help if someone would explain to me what they mean by theocracy.

It's not seriously disputed that in the late 18th century, our government as well as most of our citizens had a generally theistic understanding of the universe. The Creator was widely invoked by government officials and in founding documents, and even most scientists of that time had a "theistic understanding that nature and human beings are created by God".

Is it your assertion, then, that our country was founded as a theocracy? Because I certainly don't see it.

Which is why I'm asking the question, what do you mean by "theocracy", and how do you expect that this particular organization's goals (which are primarily to make special creation the primary paradigm in science and general understanding in our culture) would lead to a theocratic form of government?
Fair questions.

Now one for you.

Do you support the teaching of creationism in science class?
 
Fair questions.

Thanks, I hope they'll be answered.

Now one for you.

Do you support the teaching of creationism in science class?

Not yet. I think science class should generally match the scientific consensus. That's not creationism right now.

EDIT: I'll switch that up to "maybe". It really depends on how it's taught.

I want science to be more than geography or stamp-collecting; I want it to be about teaching methods of evidence-based thought. So I'm okay with teaching any theory in the science classroom as long as the approach of the conversation is "What evidence supports this theory?" and "What testing can be done to support or falsify this theory?" That includes various flavors of creationism.

All right; I tried to articulate a serious answer to the question. Now I hope we can get closer back on topic, and that somebody will address mine.
 
Last edited:
Still not seeing it.

Maybe it would help if someone would explain to me what they mean by theocracy.

It's not seriously disputed that in the late 18th century, our government as well as most of our citizens had a generally theistic understanding of the universe. The Creator was widely invoked by government officials and in founding documents, and even most scientists of that time had a "theistic understanding that nature and human beings are created by God".

Is it your assertion, then, that our country was founded as a theocracy? Because I certainly don't see it.

Which is why I'm asking the question, what do you mean by "theocracy", and how do you expect that this particular organization's goals (which are primarily to make special creation the primary paradigm in science and general understanding in our culture) would lead to a theocratic form of government?


That is a distinction without a difference. If they are trying to instill their version of science and morality as the cultural norm via legislation and enforcement, that is pretty much a theocracy in everything but name. The Discovery Institute isn't stupid enough to outright admit that is what they are doing, so in the same way they relabeled "Creationism" as "Inteliigent Design", they are relabeling theocracy.

It wouldn't be theocracy if they were only trying to establish their claims via the normal scientific channels, but once they brought politics and judicial matters into the mix, it definitely slanted that way.
 
Not yet. I think science class should generally match the scientific consensus. That's not creationism right now.
Your response seems to indicate that you think the scientific consensus will one day favor creationism.

If that is an accurate characterization of your response, what makes you think this?
 
I'm not seeing the "theocracy" part. Can you cite your support for that?

Governing Goals

To defeat scientific materialism and its destructive moral, cultural and political legacies.
To replace materialistic explanations with the theistic understanding that nature and hurnan beings are created by God.

Twenty Year Goals

To see intelligent design theory as the dominant perspective in science.
To see design theory application in specific fields, including molecular biology, biochemistry, paleontology, physics and cosmology in the natural sciences, psychology, ethics, politics, theology and philosophy in the humanities; to see its innuence in the fine arts. To see design theory permeate our religious, cultural, moral and political life.

I've highlighted the parts. You may not see the word "theocracy" anywhere, but I'm at a loss for anything else to call religious control of politics and philosopy, or religious dogma (which is all Creationism is, as has been proven in several court cases) "permeat[ing] our....moral and political life."

AvalonXQ said:
Maybe it would help if someone would explain to me what they mean by theocracy.
Religious control of the government.

Is it your assertion, then, that our country was founded as a theocracy?
No. However, religious dogma didn't permeate as much of life as people think back then. Read Thomas Paine's Age of Reason, or Adam Smith's Wealth of Nations. While Thomas Jefferson was no atheist he also did not believe in an interventionist god. In fact, many of the Founding Fathers were deists, a position that's pretty hard to use to dictate social policy.
 
AvalonXQ said:
I want science to be more than geography or stamp-collecting; I want it to be about teaching methods of evidence-based thought. So I'm okay with teaching any theory in the science classroom as long as the approach of the conversation is "What evidence supports this theory?" and "What testing can be done to support or falsify this theory?" That includes various flavors of creationism.
I'll agree with this--but only in as much as I agree that alchemy shoudl be taught. Creationism is a disproven theory. How it was disproven is interesting and informative, but iti must always be presented as what it is, an idea that was proven wrong.

I also must suggest you make an error in taking the word of institutions like the Discovery Institute at face value. They've already pushed for legal action to force Creationism (ID is nothing but Creationism and anyone who says differently is either too ignorant to discuss the issue or simply lying) on school systems. Given such tactics, theocracy is not an unreasonable conclusion to their plan. They're already legislating religious beliefs, so pure theocracy is merely a difference of degree, rather than of principle.
 
Religious control of the government.
I really don't see anything in their goals that would be tantamount to "religious control of the government".

It just seems to be that the way the US was in the late 1700s and early 1800s, where God and intelligent design were taken for granted by just about everyone, is entirely consistent with what the wedge document describes -- and is certainly not a theocracy.
 
AvalonXQ said:
I really don't see anything in their goals that would be tantamount to "religious control of the government".

~shrug~ You want to give them the benefit of the doubt. Once someone's proven to have engaged in fraud, I tend to not do that.

ETA: AvalonXQ, the Discovery Institute is ON RECORD IN COURT as being guilty of fraud. That's not poisoing the well, it's recognizing proven facts. The fact that you refuse to acknowledge WHAT HAS BEEN PROVEN doesn't make those facts go away.
 
Last edited:
That includes various flavors of creationism.
Which one(s)?

What evidence are you referring to?

All right; I tried to articulate a serious answer to the question. Now I hope we can get closer back on topic, and that somebody will address mine.
Appreciated, although the thread topic is both a combination of the notion of creationism being taught in science class and why creationists are trying to have it taught in science class.

So exploring your rationale as to the 'why,' if you believe it should be taught (you said 'not yet,' and then 'maybe'), is on-topic and relevant to the discussion.
 
~shrug~ You want to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Again, your claim: "They've stated that their goal is a theocracy."

I don't see support for this claim.

Now, if your new claim is "They've state that their goal is to take over culture, and I believe that the end result of this would be a theocracy", then you can back up that claim with additional evidence.

Once someone's proven to have engaged in fraud, I tend to not do that.

They have engaged in fraud? According to whom?

Or are you just saying that by re-branding creationism as ID, they were engaging in fraud?
 
Yes, yes, we know--some religions, and some members of most of the hard-line religions, accept facts. HOWEVER, the fact that some do is irrelevent to my point. The ones who don't are trying to creat a theocracy, and have stated as much. Their first step is getting us to accept Creationism in schools. The fact that some people in England aren't in no way invalidates this.

That's not my argument. I'm well aware that there are people who want the USA to be more of a theocracy. I'm making the point that having a religious faith and wanting a theocracy are not necessarily equivalent.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom