The main reason behind Creationism in schools.

BTW, I tried to do a quick Google search to see where DI had been tried or convicted of fraud, but couldn't find anything. Hopefully you have more facts in evidence and can spin out a citation.

I'm very much hoping your not talking about the Dover decision, because I've read it, and it certainly doesn't include a conviction of fraud.
 
They have engaged in fraud? According to whom?

Or are you just saying that by re-branding creationism as ID, they were engaging in fraud?
Probably the latter, and by fraud, it might have been better to just say "lying," but it's a pretty thin hair to be splittting.

Creationists in Kitzmiller v. Dover tried to argue - in court - that ID was not a re-branding of creationism. The plaintiffs produced evidence from the original drafts of Of Pandas and People (which were obtained via subpoena) in which the editors of the creationist textbook had altered phrases in early editions to change occurrences of the word "creationism" to "intelligent design" in later editions. That creationist textbook was the book that the defendants (the creationists on the Dover school board) were trying to force into the Dover science classrooms.

Pretty dishonest to then argue that ID and creationism aren't one and the same thing. Creationists themselves know they are.
 
Last edited:
That's not my argument. I'm well aware that there are people who want the USA to be more of a theocracy. I'm making the point that having a religious faith and wanting a theocracy are not necessarily equivalent.

I think this is a very important point.

Most Americans have religious faith; that doesn't mean most of us want a theocracy. I certainly don't.
 
Maybe it would help if someone would explain to me what they mean by theocracy.
What I mean is the setting of government policy according to divine doctrine instead of any system of ethics or, y'know, evidence. Theocracy in this manner is not an all-or-nothing term, it's perfectly possible for the state government of Alabama to be more theocratic than New York but less than Utah.

These people are trying to wedge Church back into State, and as such are pushing a theocracy.

It's not seriously disputed that in the late 18th century, our government as well as most of our citizens had a generally theistic understanding of the universe. The Creator was widely invoked by government officials and in founding documents, and even most scientists of that time had a "theistic understanding that nature and human beings are created by God".
Deist, not theist. The Creator Created, he didn't say how, nor stick around afterwards to tell us how to handle things.

Is it your assertion, then, that our country was founded as a theocracy? Because I certainly don't see it.
No. Despite invoking the Creator in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution lacked even that. The actual structure of early government was purely secular.

how do you expect that this particular organization's goals (which are primarily to make special creation the primary paradigm in science and general understanding in our culture and politics) would lead to a theocratic form of government?
I added "and politics" back in, as you seem to have mistakenly left it out of your description. The goal of influencing politics is mentioned multiple times in the Wedge Document, I really don't see how you could have neglected it.
 
I suggest that if you don't know enough to see the link between the Discovery Institute and this trial that you do not know enough about the background of this debate to hold an informed opinion on it. If you DO know about these connections and still believe that the Discovery Institute is honest, I can only conclude that you are viewing these events through so great a bias as to be insurmountable.

AvalonXQ said:
They have engaged in fraud? According to whom?

Or are you just saying that by re-branding creationism as ID, they were engaging in fraud?
it's more than re-branding. A textbook was thrown out for violating the Establishment Clause. They did a "replace all" function, poorly, and tried to use the same book. That's fraud--it's presenting the book as a secular textbook after it's been proven to be religious in nature, without removing the parts that make it religious. It's a cover-up and a sham. And it's according to the legal system.

Now let's play this game consistently: Please prove, with adequate citations (which, since you assume the right to evaluate my sources, I get to evaluate), that the Discovery Institute is NOT guilty of fraud. Please prove that they are NOT trying to establish a theocracy. Obviously allusions aren't good enough, since you rejected clear allusions to it from me.
 
'm very much hoping your not talking about the Dover decision, because I've read it, and it certainly doesn't include a conviction of fraud.
I see. So you are in fact unaware of the posibility of someone committing an offense without being convincted of it. :rolleyes:

I'm sorry, but you're simply not being honest here.
 
I suggest that if you don't know enough to see the link between the Discovery Institute and this trial that you do not know enough about the background of this debate to hold an informed opinion on it. If you DO know about these connections and still believe that the Discovery Institute is honest, I can only conclude that you are viewing these events through so great a bias as to be insurmountable.

Ah, so either I'm ignorant or biased. Why are you still talking to me?
 
Again, I think you're way overstating the conclusions of the Dover court. But maybe you're right; I read the opinion when it came out and not since.

Can you provide an actual citation to the part of the opinion, or other court document, where the Discovery Institute is "ON RECORD IN COURT for being guilty of fraud", please?
 
I really don't see anything in their goals that would be tantamount to "religious control of the government".

It just seems to be that the way the US was in the late 1700s and early 1800s, where God and intelligent design were taken for granted by just about everyone, is entirely consistent with what the wedge document describes -- and is certainly not a theocracy.


While it is true that the concept of a creator god was widely accepted in the US, the moral and cultural values that most associate with Christianity were not as revered. Early American politics were heavily influenced by Enlightenment, which dramatically opposed the notions espousesd by the Discovery Institute.

The other main issue is that those things may have been taken for granted, but they weren't legislated into being taken for granted. Also, they did change over time precisely because the science and culture drifted, not by government decree.

Forcing acceptance of the DI's science and culture is a theocracy in all but name.
 
I really don't see anything in their goals that would be tantamount to "religious control of the government".

It just seems to be that the way the US was in the late 1700s and early 1800s, where God and intelligent design were taken for granted by just about everyone, is entirely consistent with what the wedge document describes -- and is certainly not a theocracy.

There have been a few scientific breakthroughs and changing social mores since then. Taken for granted by a population that had very few alternatives is not the same thing as ignoring advancements in science in order to promote a religious agenda. Especially one that has proven to be harmful.

More importantly, the founding fathers were able to look a bit farther than the way things were. Although they may not have foreseen a country with a high percentage of non-Christian citizens, they created a constitution which protected those with other or no religion.

ETA: Dang it! Hokulele beat me to it.
 
Now let's play this game consistently: Please prove, with adequate citations (which, since you assume the right to evaluate my sources, I get to evaluate), that the Discovery Institute is NOT guilty of fraud. Please prove that they are NOT trying to establish a theocracy. Obviously allusions aren't good enough, since you rejected clear allusions to it from me.

You've been around skeptics long enough to know that this sort of burden-shifting doesn't hold water.

You made affirmative claims about DI. It's not my responsibility to prove they're not true.
 
You've been around skeptics long enough to know that this sort of burden-shifting doesn't hold water.

You made affirmative claims about DI. It's not my responsibility to prove they're not true.

Alright. Please prove that the goals of the DI are the advancement of science and not the advancement of a religious agenda.
 
Again, I think you're way overstating the conclusions of the Dover court. But maybe you're right; I read the opinion when it came out and not since.

Can you provide an actual citation to the part of the opinion, or other court document, where the Discovery Institute is "ON RECORD IN COURT for being guilty of fraud", please?
Can't speak for Dinwar, but I think I adequately addressed this question.
Probably the latter, and by fraud, it might have been better to just say "lying," but it's a pretty thin hair to be splittting.

Creationists in Kitzmiller v. Dover tried to argue - in court - that ID was not a re-branding of creationism. The plaintiffs produced evidence from the original drafts of Of Pandas and People (which were obtained via subpoena) in which the editors of the creationist textbook had altered phrases in early editions to change occurrences of the word "creationism" to "intelligent design" in later editions. That creationist textbook was the book that the defendants (the creationists on the Dover school board) were trying to force into the Dover science classrooms.

Pretty dishonest to then argue that ID and creationism aren't one and the same thing. Creationists themselves know they are.
 
More importantly, the founding fathers were able to look a bit farther than the way things were. Although they may not have foreseen a country with a high percentage of non-Christian citizens, they created a constitution which protected those with other or no religion.

I haven't seen anything in the wedge document that would dismantle those protections.

A society in which most people, including scientists, agree with special creation as an explanation for origins is not necessarily a society run based on religion. The Founders recognized that; I'm not sure why you believe we couldn't recognize that today.
 
Please prove that the goals of the DI are the advancement of science and not the advancement of a religious agenda.

I believe the goals of DI are the advancement of a religious agenda.

It doesn't follow that they're trying to establish a theocracy, or that they're lying to us.
 
A society in which most people, including scientists, agree with special creation as an explanation for origins is not necessarily a society run based on religion. The Founders recognized that; I'm not sure why you believe we couldn't recognize that today.
When it's being taught as science in public schools, that's the government teaching as fact (ie, endorsing) religion.

That's a violation of the 1st Amendment.
 
I believe the goals of DI are the advancement of a religious agenda
As long as we agree that their agenda has nothing to do with science.

They were arguing in Kitzmiller that intelligent design WAS science. Which makes them, you know, kind of duplicitous. At best.
It doesn't follow that they're trying to establish a theocracy, or that they're lying to us.
It does follow, however, that they're trying to use the force of government - through the public school system - to advance that religious agenda and to force it on every child in the public school.
 
Last edited:
They were arguing in Kitzmiller that intelligent designe WAS science. Which makes them, you know, kind of duplicitous.

I don't agree with that.

I also don't agree that that's what the decision in Dover said.

But since nobody's actually citing to the case, I guess we'll just end up keeping our opinions, huh?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom