The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
I did too. I think there was a automatic "do not let JC on the BFF" I needed to overcome. :D I am good to go now.
 
I understand the difficulty with keeping things civil. I suppose all threads could be dealt with on a case by case basis, in the full awareness that some will get out of hand and are best terminated. I just have a problem with blanket bans and taboo subjects, it runs against the grain of open debate and free enquiry. After all, the USA didn't decide to ban the institution of the Presidency after Richard Nixon turned out to be a bad apple....

True, but religion and politics has been problematic over and over again - I think if every president had turned out to be as problematic as Nixon, the USA would have figured out a different way of doing things by now :)


I realise comparing and contrasting the BFF with the JREF is fraught with difficulty: as a sceptics forum it is implicit here that everything is up for discussion and nothing should be taken at face value. On the other hand, the BFF has never been a 'believers only' forum and sceptics were always highly placed within the organisation, so why should it be so very different after all?

One of the big differences as I see it is that JREF is vast - few of the people posting in this section know who the moderators are, and the moderators have a heck of a lot more to do than worry about bigfoot.


Paul, congratulations on saving the forum for a second time. I'm glad the CFZ, an organisation I'm poised to join, will have an input. I think that Jon Downes 'anarcho' approach to discipline and organisation might be just the tonic the BFF needs, though I realise his input will be limited.

Strick

I think the slightly anarchistic way of doing things at CFZ will make the place very different, and if we can put the scheme of rotating moderators in place too, no-one is going to develop the 'god-complex' style of moderating that we have had in the past. Anyone moderating a forum like the old BFF will get burned out and jaded after a while - that not only affects their style of moderating and their judgement, but it affects the way they post and the way they are perceived too - if we can restrict moderators to a limited tour-of-duty, we can avoid these problems in the future. Even problems such as the one HarryH had can be avoided, since with the new model, he wouldn't have to put up with the other moderators indefinately.

It will be interesting to see if it can work - of all forums, if this new model can work on a bigfoot forum, it can work anywhere.
 
Paul,

This is just my personal opinion but I think a handful of overzealous bigfoot believers who made a lot of posts (I'm sure you know who they are) stifled participation by the more moderate members and were taking the BFF down to the discussion level of playground taunts.

I understand that it's almost impossible to moderate the tone of threads if everyone abides by the rules but if there is no way to control the less-mature posters the new BFF will end up just like the old BFF, with a small number of radical posters driving out the moderate posters and setting its tone.
 
Like a zombie rising from the dead, what Bigfoot Forums needs now is brains.
 
I think the slightly anarchistic way of doing things at CFZ will make the place very different...


The logo shows an extinct marsupial carnivore. Great irony on a Bigfoot forum. For those who fantasize that the world is different than it actually is. LOL
 
The 'no religion' rule was put in place by Bipto following a couple of huge bust-ups on the old BFF that got completely out of hand.

Religious fundamentalism and Bigfoot go together. You will find their outspoken representation among the BF believers.


The same applies to the 'no politics' rule - see if you can find the infamous 'war' thread in the members lounge before the old board dissapears and you will understand what can happen.

Conservatism is the more common political theme among Bigfooters.
 
The logo shows an extinct marsupial carnivore. Great irony on a Bigfoot forum. For those who fantasize that the world is different than it actually is. LOL

I find it odd beng welcomed to the BFF by a thylacine. But hey, at least we have thylacine bones and unambiguous thylacine footage. Maybe something that was real and is not now should introduce you to something that is not real and never was.
 
What is the Reputation rating that each member has? I noticed that TooRisky has the lowest (in the negative) and Bill Green is negative too. Then kitakaze has a pretty high number but ShadoAngel is higher and is already past "neutral" into the "good" territory.

What is the basis for this thing?
 
What is the Reputation rating that each member has? I noticed that TooRisky has the lowest (in the negative) and Bill Green is negative too. Then kitakaze has a pretty high number but ShadoAngel is higher and is already past "neutral" into the "good" territory.

What is the basis for this thing?


From the ip .board site.

Users can rate posts up or down, earning the author of that post repuation points. Users can earn badges and titles for having a good reputation, encouraging high quality posts across the board.

Topic Rating
Topics can be rated one to five stars, so users can identify the topics that others rate highly - or poorly!

I'm not sure this is a good idea.
 
I find it odd beng welcomed to the BFF by a thylacine. But hey, at least we have thylacine bones and unambiguous thylacine footage. Maybe something that was real and is not now should introduce you to something that is not real and never was.

I feel the wider scope of the "new" BFF is a plus, as many North Americans such as myself are woefully lacking in knowledge of such exotic, foreign cryptids as Trolls. Honestly, I had a gross misconception of what a Troll really looked like until this useful representation was posted:

http://img257.imageshack.us/img257/1827/vadrdetta.png
 
I can't believe people are mean enough to give Bill Green bad ratings for posting smileys. Poor guy.
 
I just knew it was going to happen. Makaya325 joined the BFF again as "alex". The faucet of stupid is open and the handle is broken off. Poor KKZ. :(
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom