Hi Paul,
I understand the difficulty with keeping things civil. I suppose all threads could be dealt with on a case by case basis, in the full awareness that some will get out of hand and are best terminated. I just have a problem with blanket bans and taboo subjects, it runs against the grain of open debate and free enquiry. After all, the USA didn't decide to ban the institution of the Presidency after Richard Nixon turned out to be a bad apple....
I realise comparing and contrasting the BFF with the JREF is fraught with difficulty: as a sceptics forum it is implicit here that everything is up for discussion and nothing should be taken at face value. On the other hand, the BFF has never been a 'believers only' forum and sceptics were always highly placed within the organisation, so why should it be so very different after all?
I think a lot comes down to 'light touch' moderation. This forum's a riot compared to the BFF, but that seems the way most people like it. I understand that discipline is important, but I believe it should be used to underscore fairness and fighting cliqueyness and bullying, not the imposition of a party line and the defence of a list of banned subjects.
Paul, congratulations on saving the forum for a second time. I'm glad the CFZ, an organisation I'm poised to join, will have an input. I think that Jon Downes 'anarcho' approach to discipline and organisation might be just the tonic the BFF needs, though I realise his input will be limited.
Strick