The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
We have dna evidence,
Of what? Please direct us to a peer-reviewed journal article that supports your claim. Then we can discuss the merits of the published article rather than your vague assertion that such evidence indicates the reality of bigfoot.

forensic hair anaylysis evidence,
Of what? Please direct us to a peer-reviewed journal article that supports your claim. Then we can discuss the merits of the published article rather than your vague assertion that such evidence indicates the reality of bigfoot.

track trait distribution curve evidence.
Fahrenbach's paper, I assume? If you can demonstrate how hoaxed prints were discerned from "real" ones in those data, and why a particular distribution should be interpreted as coming from a "real" population of bigfoots, then we might have an interesting discussion about this.

We have at least one audio recording of good provenance.
Which one, pray tell?

I guess I'll never understand why you cling to such things as important pieces of evidence when time and time again they've been pointed out to hold no water. There's nothing wrong with wanting a "body on a slab" to describe a new species - that's the standard we've had in place for over 200 years of exploration and discovery. Why are "scientists" a bunch of jerks for following our long-accepted standard?
 
I am not aware of any such evidence, and I've been paying attention for a long time.

Me neither. I have heard people talk of 'Unknown Primate' DNA results, but I have yet to actually see a signed report stating this.

Even this isn't good enough until all the 'unknown primate' DNA samples are compared to see if there is some commonality between them.


So, whilst this is off topic, it is worth asking what evidence we actually have, particlarly since people on this form have speculated as to where I stand, and in some cases have quoted a blog written by someone who misquoted a presentation I once gave as 'evidence' of what I believe, so here it is, from the horses mouth as it were...


Hair - The last 'hair' sample I saw that was originally identified as 'similar to human', had been examined by a 'scientist' connected to bigfoot research. I immediately asked if they could send the hair sample to me so that I could have it re-examined using an independent forensic laboratory here in England. You won't be suprised to hear that the next email I got from the 'researcher' said that the hair had been re-examined and determined to be canine! I suspect that if I hadn't asked for the re-examination, it would still be touted as 'similar to human - unknown primate'


Footprints - hmmm - seems like every vaguely foot-shaped depression in the ground these days is called a 'track', even when there is only one. I think they are interesting, but it has been a long time since I've seen a 'classic' footprint appear, or, more importantly, a track. I'd like someone to take John Green up on his challenge, but likewise, I'd like John Green to demonstrate with photographs that he has documented every section of his infamous $100,000 challenge.


Dermal ridges - no, thanks to Matt Crowley, and frankly, no thanks to Jimmy Chillcut who after a decade, still hasn't prepared a signed report relating to his findings, which considering he is an Expert Witness by profession is shoddy.


Tree breaks/stick formations - Give me a break - I documented this naturally occuring phenomena nearly eight years ago occuring in the forest behind my house in England, so either Bigfoot lives behind my house in England, or we have to dismiss tree breaks and teepee style stick formations as evidence completely - we can't have it both ways.


Vocals - okay, some of these are interesting - they need further analysis, but ideally by people who know what they are talking about and don't have any interest in the bigfoot subject.


Witness sightings - Witnesses are unreliable, and these days there is too much information available on the internet for a witness not to be able to pick up buzz-words they can use when talking to a 'researcher'. But, if just 5% of those witnesses are genuine, then there are still questions that need answering.


DNA - I remain to be convinced


The PGF - I remain to be convinced - its compelling, and if it is a hoax, it is a damn good one. I stand by my assertion that ther are too many inconsistancies between Bob H's version of events and Philip Morris' version of events for either of their stories to be considered to be 'the truth', but there are questions that remain unanswered and always will remain unanswered.

Personally, I find the hero-worship of Bob Gimlin, a man who was simply along for the ride a little disturbing. Sure, he might be a great guy now in his late 70s/early 80s (and I've met him, he is a charming old man), but what was he like in his mid-30s, and what does it matter whether he is Christian, Jewish or Hindu? Being religious doesn't make him any more honest than an atheist like me.

Tom Yamarone told me in September 2004, that Bob Gimlin used to hang out with Robert 'Evel' Kneival in the 60s - if that is true, it doesn't say much for the people Gimlin used to hang out with, since Kneival was a convicted criminal prone to outbursts of violence.


Other photos/videos - I've not seen anything that will convince me.


For the past eight years I have offerred to personally fund the independent examination of hair or DNA at one of three respected labs - in all that time, only one person took me up on that offer.


People have often asked where I stand. I do not 'believe' that bigfoot exists - I don't think I ever have, but I do believe that there is sufficient evidence to make it worthy of investigation - that said, as time goes on, there is less and less of that evidence, and I think it is high time that people stopped playing at being bigfoot researchers and started acting like real researchers - unless of course they don't *want* to discover bigfoot...

Anyway, thats me - take from that what you like. I sometimes wonder why I am still interested in this subject!
 
So, whilst this is off topic, it is worth asking what evidence we actually have, particlarly since people on this form have speculated as to where I stand...


This is particularly dangerous Paul (and others). There was a mod warning in this thread (post #170) that explains that derailing (off topic) will result in thread closing and suspensions/bannings. This is serious stuff.

General discussions of Bigfoot and evidence MUST go into another thread. This thread is about the BFF and ongoing status.
 
Hey, I'm not the person who took this thread off-topic There has been little discussion of the 'implosion of the (old) BFF' for some time, which I'm sure you would accept.
 
Muldur,
whatever you think may be the issues with those who don't see eye to eye with you, you aren't choosing an effective way to make your points. Bringing a lot of ranting and obscure old disputes over here just isn't going to work. A few at JREF may have followed the BFF, but many of us haven't. So if you want to be constructive, then present information that relates to this thread; but ranting will only get you ridiculed.


finally, let's not derail this thread into a discussion of bigfoot evidence.

I think there should definitely be a thread on eyewitness reliability.
 
Last edited:
I'm not blaming you, Paul. It's obvious the Muldur thing went way into evidence discussion and then your post would prompt more evidence discussion.

The mods have their ray guns set on zero tolerance for this thread.
 
feral persons

I think I could make fun of the CFZ from now until forever. They have the craziest damn forum that you've ever seen. They have a section on Feral Children. I'm not fooling. Kids as cryptids! But there isn't any newer posts at all. A zillion sections and there are no posts for 2010. The people that are taking over the BFF are zany mofos.

The cheese fell off their crumpets.

But seriously, the old newspaper accounts that are touted as evidence of bigfoot are actually, for the most part, stories of unshaven crazy, deaf, homeless, or retarded outcasts or recluses, or just members of another race. Feral children or feral adults, in other words. So I think the Brits are actually onto something that bigfoot history buffs might be able to incorporate into their thinking.
 
They have a grand total of 127 members. So it's pretty much an elite group.

Most of the threads don't have any replies, and I haven't seen one that's newer than 2008 thus far. One would presume that the original posters have wandered off to other places. I'd assume that this forum will become all-Bigfoot, all-the-time. I suppose we'll have to wait and see, but personally, if a forum I frequented was closed for two years, I probably wouldn't come back without getting an email with a personal invite, and most likely not even then.
 
So far, only Americans have been invited, so why don't you quit the wild speculations?

The wild speculations are harmless and meant to be funny. You have to understand the climate inside this forum. We poke at Bigfootery. It's what we do.


A little support would be nice - if you can't do that, then at least stop insulting the people who are trying to help the mostly American and Canadian members of BFF.

More power to you guys - but it would be odd for me to support an agency of Bigfoot belief. You all have chosen a fringe and very cultish interest. It is quite obvious that Bigfoot is not out there. Most of the world has ridicule for Bigfooters because it just seems like the right thing to do given the factual and historical circumstances. But again... more power to you.
 
so here it is, from the horses mouth as it were...


People have often asked where I stand. I do not 'believe' that bigfoot exists - I don't think I ever have, but I do believe that there is sufficient evidence to make it worthy of investigation - that said, as time goes on, there is less and less of that evidence, and I think it is high time that people stopped playing at being bigfoot researchers and started acting like real researchers - unless of course they don't *want* to discover bigfoot...

Thanks PaulV, I appreciate you discussing your views even if it is off topic. I hope you will continue to participate in other threads on JREF.

In a way it's going to be interesting to see how the new BFF deals with the banned and angry crowd. If those people do what most likely can be expected from them, there will be no blaming cliques for their removal.

I wish the new BFF the best in their move and new direction. Perhaps with this new version people will "understand" that a discussion forum is not a "witness reporting system".

I'm far more interested in the prediction that the other BF forums would fill up with the BFF'ers, still ghost towns out there :rolleyes:

I hope the old BFF info can be maintained as an archive as I spent quite a bit of time recently going over some of the old Greg Long/Making of Bigfoot threads. Lots of discussion on BFF that shouldn't disappear into the ether. It is still a useful resource for all things Bigfootery.
 
Last edited:
I'm far more interested in the prediction that the other BF forums would fill up with the BFF'ers, still ghost towns out there :rolleyes:


I look at other forums. They have been showing up. Not in droves at all.

But each different forum is already a clique of sorts. Any given BFFer might not necessarily be accepted into another forum because of their previously established BFF persona. For many, the BFF was/is their only ship.
 
I should have stated moderator/admin cliques.

I agree that each forum has their own style and personality, the majority seem to be anti BFF take offs. When it all comes down to where actual continuing discussion took place on pro bigfoot, the BFF was the ship to board if you wanted to voice your opinion and interact in lively daily discussion with a larger participating membership.

Personally I didn't see this gang mentality of mods or admins that is being thrown about. I saw daily discussion in threads, lots of people interacting with each other and the occassional taking it a bit too personally.

Whatever went on in the background was the business of those that volunteer to oversee a large discussion forum and honestly, I don't put the blame on them. If anything, the BFF had so many different personalities and some stronger than others, just as in real life. The bringing to JREF personal background battles only shows the mentality that exists within a moderating systems daily dealings.

Over the years you see the changes in BFF membership with the past few years mostly based on media/ego driven hype that increased the different (romanticizing) types of personalities involved over time. The Georgia Hoax brought in an influx of very interesting personalities and drove off some intelligent members.

The one crowd that I felt had a negative impact on the BFF was the political correctness pushers. A discussion forum is made up of memberships with differing cultural views and belief systems and trying to enforce a specific cultural standard on those who view things differently from all parts of the world was in my opinion "ignorant" and destructive to continuing debate and the discussion forum atmosphere. (my opinion).

Debate is not peaceful, it 's debate and it can get heated. ;) Opposing views shouldn't be silenced by those that can't tolerate a challenge.

Perhaps the new and improved BFF overseen by a society outside of the long term membership as administrators will be successful? Can only wait and see how and where this goes. I just can't imagine the banned and angry won't step back in with a chip on their shoulders. I definitely don't buy into let bygones be bygones. People will still push their agendas, still try to shout the loudest and will continue to target their old nemesis for wrongs they can't just seem to get over. Such is life and such is Bigfootery.
 
Ah - now I understand. I thought JREF was a forum for skeptical and critical thinking, but as you say, you are really here to poke fun at people.

"You Guys Are Supposed To Always Be Skeptical Critical Thinkers Only" Card

"You Guys Are Supposed To Always Be Friendly Just Like It Says On Your Banner" Card

"Dead Bears Are Always Not Found In The Woods" Card
 
Ah - now I understand. I thought JREF was a forum for skeptical and critical thinking, but as you say, you are really here to poke fun at people.

You're right, poking fun at people is wrong, but come on CFZ members, in the world of Digital cameras, take 10 or 20 photos before picking one to go on the website.
 
Ah - now I understand. I thought JREF was a forum for skeptical and critical thinking, but as you say, you are really here to poke fun at people.

I agree that, on the surface, it does appear as such and I have came to the same conclusion; however, no single member solely represents the JREF - there are a whole host of other members whom have demonstrated the ability to conduct themselves in a very reasonable manner without using an inordinate amount of scorn and derision. I do enjoy the sarcasm and lighthearted fun-poking(I sometimes join in with my own cracking wise), but it's the darker, more pathological aspects which tend to disturb me the most.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom