The Implosion of the BFF

Status
Not open for further replies.
I already know the truth cause i was part of the staff and talked the talk, i'll let it rest here cause you are never going to come clean and i have no wish to go any further with it. . .

Tim
 
I think everyone here can see through that, but I'll happily move on to better things. Best of luck to you.
 
I think I could make fun of the CFZ from now until forever. They have the craziest damn forum that you've ever seen. They have a section on Feral Children. I'm not fooling. Kids as cryptids! But there isn't any newer posts at all. A zillion sections and there are no posts for 2010. The people that are taking over the BFF are zany mofos.

Feral children
For when a wild child turns up.

Strange Falls
Discussing falls of frogs, fish and other things that really shouldn't fall from they sky...

Vampirology
Discuss sightings, evidence and phenomena of Vampirology including Chupacabra.

Transmorphic Zooform Phenomena
Discuss sightings, evidence and phenomena of Transmorphic Zooform Phenomena. This includes shapeshifters, were-beasts and similar.
 
Oh boy. . .

Mulder, why is it mean-spirited to tell someone the truth that there is no bigfoot?

There you go again...I thought the point was to "teach people HOW to think, not tell them WHAT to think", (your words) and then you pop off again with your OPINION (unsupported and unsupportable) presented as the "truth" that a person is to be "told".

Hi, Mulder, and welcome to the JREF. I was wondering when the drought would snap your resolve.

I didn't even know the place was closed. I don't spend every hour of every day in and out of there.

I would say you are just about one of the most credulous Bigfooters that I had communication with at the BFF. The thing that was so dependable with you was the consistency with which you would insert your own foot into your mouth.

Ahahah *wags finger*..."friendly" debate.

Credulous believers such as you often have a habit of being blatantly hypocritical and woefully lacking in self-awareness. Watch. I'll show you how easy it is.

What's so amusing for me is that you come in your first post and not only set yourself up like that, you already did that at the BFF and there too I promptly pointed out your hypocrisy. I usually reserve this for Sweaty, but because you are so similar in credulous behaviour and attitude towards skepticism, I think you too have a pronounced case of Ballzheimer's.

I have no problem with skeptics. I have a REAL problem with people who CALL themselves "skeptics" and then pop off with comments like yours, who constantly move the goalposts evideniarilly (sp?), and who generally refuse to engage in honest debate. No one is likely to forget your "kitchen sink" attempts at character assassination on Patterson. The only thing you ever proved was that he welshed on some of his debts. Not one thing you posted ever proved ANY of Bob H's bar stories about faking Patty at Bluff Creek.

And I'm STILL waiting for you to produce even anecdotal evidence of Patterson or someone in his camp having had medical treatment for a groin injury after the BF that you allege was a Patterson fake got it's junk mangled by a dog in Yakima...

The friendly part of the banner is a bit of a lie. It's hopeful but untrue.

I call it downright cynical.

I recall reading your posts on BFF and even on Unexplained Mysteries. You are a VERY unfriendly poster.

1) I've never posted on Unexplained Mysteries (whatever that is), at least not sofar as I can recall. I don't even know the web adress for it.

2) I get along just fine with honest researchers like Bill, Big Tex, and Neil (IIRC the name) from Australia (to name a few). I DO however, get in the face of goal-post moving, evidence denying, mind set AGAINST BF psuedo-skeptics like Kit, and "lab coat brigade" types who sit on their proverbial duffs and say "'tain't so" to any evidence short of a full body corpse conveniently laid out for them on their dissection slabs.

ETA: Why spell it that way? Mulder isn't taken yet.

Typo filling out the registration and I didn't catch it until it had already been submitted.

It is to laugh. What do these people expect? To come from the places where the rail against science and skepticism and will be greeted by Stuart Smalley who will hang doilies on your creduloid gobbledy-gook maulings of logic and reason? Expect to be greeted by Al Franken types who will tell you that you are a lying liar who tells lies if that is indeed the case. "A place to discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal, and science in a friendly and lively way," means have a good, clean debate/discussion and don't have Tourette's while doing it.

Mulder, you will see that people like you and Sweaty who have fanatical beliefs and wildly distorted views of reality are very tolerated here. You can use Sweaty's history as a barometer for what you can expect. Express your fortean addiction without acting like Lyndon and calling people gay slurs, etc, and you should be fine.

So you can be as dismissive and name-calling as you want to "creduloids" and such just so long as it isn't a ethnic slur, etc? Nice...:rolleyes:


You have scorn and derision for real science and I have scorn and derision for people like you who distort and misrepresent real science. I can express my sentiment and my thoughts while maintaining civility. If you can do better at it than you did at the BFF, everything will be hunkey-dory.

No, I have scorn for psuedo-skeptical "science" like that which you practice that passes itself off as being real, objective science.

And now a sampling of Mulder's anti-science rhetoric...

Originally Posted by Mulder @ BFF
I have backed it up, and posted the evidence many many times right in this forum. And the bias of "objective science" is well known, which is why the expert from Wyoming Fish and Game was disinvited from presenting his findings in the 70s at a synposium, and why Goodall's people keep having her pro-BF statement taken down from public fora. Also there is the considerable scorn heaped on scientists like Meldrum, whose tenure and credentials have been called into question by his peers for his interest in the subject.
Originally Posted by Mulder @ BFF
The only way to get Science to consider BF evidence is to first prove BF exists to them. The only way to prove BF exists to Science is by providing evidence, which they refuse to consider because BF has not been proven to exist
Originally Posted by Mulder @ BFF
When those "mainstream science" publications drop their biases and allow papers to BE presented for debate, you might have a point.
Originally Posted by Mulder @ BFF
So the proponents of the "scientific standard" get to say that "proof" means whatever THEY say it does, rather than an objective standard...that may be "the way it is", but it's not the way it should be, nor is it true science.
Originally Posted by Mulder @ BFF
I don't give a rat what the "scientific community" accepts or doesn't accept, since the community as a whole has been shown to NOT be practicing true (that is to say objective) science. Objective scientists accepts the facts as they are, rather than invent elaborate explanations why findings they don't like don't say what they say.

None of which is "anti-science", just anti-YOUR brand of "science" which makes arrogant statements like the below:

There is no reliable evidence for Bigfoot. 911, Mulder needs you...

It happened to a lot of people WP. A LOT.

H*ll, it almost happened to ME, for no other reason that not backing down from people like Ray and Kit when they started pulling stuff. Which is why I laugh at the notion that the BFF was some sort of "romantic" or "b'leever" forum.
 
Why does "Muldur" sound so much like Huntster?
Huntster @ BFF said:
I just made it up to point out two things I find troublesome in the field of BF research.

1. When there is questions or negative criticism regarding BF's existence there are soon a new theory or explanation to why it has not been found.
2. A lot of people seem to take those "new explanations" as fully plausible
3. It is hard for me to put "scientific" and "research" in the same phrase when it comes to BF. I am sure a lot of people here are trained in various academic fields and I am sure we all can agree that very little is actually scientific in the research of BF. Mostly it is pure speculations or empirical material collected from for example eye witnesses. Non can be considered scientific as far as I am concerned.


1) Those are three things, not two

2) When there is evidence of a sasquatch, skeptics offer all manner of explanations why it cannot be what the witness says it was

3) A lot of skeptics will accept just about anything in order to brush away any and all evidence. This is particularly true of the strongest evidence, for example, the PG film. The conspiracy theories and storylines have gotten downright entertaining over the years.

4) Perhaps the reason why bigfoot research has been so unscientific is because the larger scientific community has simply ignored or pooh-poohed the phenomenon and left it to amateurs. What else would you expect but amateurish results?
 
Last edited:
I'm not (as you are not so subtly implying) Huntster, but I do agree with just about every point he made there. Is that a crime?

Those are some fairly convoluted points for anyone to accept, imo.

2) When there is evidence of a sasquatch, skeptics offer all manner of explanations why it cannot be what the witness says it was

Witnesses are often wrong. This is not a new idea, nor is it limited to bigfoot witnesses. it is widely known and accepted. Why not just accept what the witness says and don't discuss it further? Okay, you saw a bigfoot, mark it down, and move on.

3) A lot of skeptics will accept just about anything in order to brush away any and all evidence. This is particularly true of the strongest evidence, for example, the PG film. The conspiracy theories and storylines have gotten downright entertaining over the years.

A lot? How many? Why don't I just accept that BH wore a Patty suit then? Why have we discussed the PGF nearly endlessly here if we are just brushing it away? Why have we discussed casts and tracks here nearly endlessly if we are just brushing them off? Why have we bothered to try and make casts and tracks if we are just brushing evidence away unconsidered? Why did I purchase items at my own expense to learn about the camera Roger used if I could just brush the PGF away?

4) Perhaps the reason why bigfoot research has been so unscientific is because the larger scientific community has simply ignored or pooh-poohed the phenomenon and left it to amateurs. What else would you expect but amateurish results?

The large amount of money invested with scientists, and the many scientists who are, or have, investigated bigfoot is well known. The amount of money given to Meldrum alone is frankly stunning to me.
 
Existing BFF members are likely to have ongoing alliances and particular dislikes. CFZ members are probably 90% European and would represent a meaningful cultural divide. Do they understand what "Good Ole Boy" means?

A committee to oversee the mods? That means nobody gets silenced, suspended or banned until a bunch of Madmen Across the Water get together for a chat with tea to decide the outcome?


As for 'madmen across the water'... presumably you know who is going to be on the committee, which is great, can you let me know who they are then, because I don't have a clue. So far, only Americans have been invited, so why don't you quit the wild speculations?

I would expect the vast majority of committee members and moderators to be American or Canadian. BFF will be hosted and operated seperately from the rest of the CFZ website for the forseeable future, and in particular the existing CFZ forum, which I too think is pretty awful - there are plans to re-launch it at some point in the future, but thats a discussion for another day. I don't imagine that significant numbers of existing CFZ members will suddenly discover a interest in bigfoot and swampt the forum with euro-centric ideas - that would be rediculous.

Here is the thing William. Either CFZ host BFF and try to do the very best for its members, old and new, or it and its 600,000 posts are gone - period. If you think BFF should die, then the answer is simple - stop worrying about it and don't visit.

There is no intention to turn this into some brit-centric website - heck, I was the chief admin for more than five years - in all that time did it ever turn into a 'european' website? Get real! the vast majority of members are American and Canadian and it will continue to be operated that way - it would be stupid to do anything different.

A little support would be nice - if you can't do that, then at least stop insulting the people who are trying to help the mostly American and Canadian members of BFF.
 
Last edited:
Nobody will be able to understand anything on the new BFF after the Brits take over. Total WTF.

Ah, so you have finally accepted that it isn't me taking over! :D



Sorry, I know I said I was leaving, but the wild speculation in this thread (which has gone way off topic) is just fascinating - I'm drawn to it like a moth to a flame.
 
Last edited:
Those are some fairly convoluted points for anyone to accept, imo.

How so?

Witnesses are often wrong. This is not a new idea, nor is it limited to bigfoot witnesses. it is widely known and accepted. Why not just accept what the witness says and don't discuss it further? Okay, you saw a bigfoot, mark it down, and move on.


Conversely, witnesses are always wrong/lying/hoaxed? And it is incumbent on the witness to prove in that theyaren't lying/mistaken and/or were not hoaxed?

"Prove the negative" seems to be the default "skeptic" position.

A lot? How many? Why don't I just accept that BH wore a Patty suit then? Why have we discussed the PGF nearly endlessly here if we are just brushing it away? Why have we discussed casts and tracks here nearly endlessly if we are just brushing them off? Why have we bothered to try and make casts and tracks if we are just brushing evidence away unconsidered? Why did I purchase items at my own expense to learn about the camera Roger used if I could just brush the PGF away?

When you ask for evidence type A and then dismiss it when it's provided that's brushing it off. We have dna evidence, forensic hair anaylysis evidence, track trait distribution curve evidence. We have at least one audio recording of good provenance.

On top of that we have 100s of eyewitness reports that are VERY clear about what they saw (a larger than human, bipedal animal NOT a bear). Many of those witnesses are professional people of good standing in their community. Many of those people also have skills/training that makes them good observers, not easily startled/distracted and able to remain calm and focused even under stress.

We also have oral histories from the First Nations (assuming that's still the preferred term) of these creatures whose appearance and habits is consistent with modern day reports, indicating a continuity of presence pre-dating the era of mass communications (indeed predating modern communications entirely).

Short of the proverbial "slab monkey", that's quite a bit.

The large amount of money invested with scientists, and the many scientists who are, or have, investigated bigfoot is well known. The amount of money given to Meldrum alone is frankly stunning to me.

A couple of $100,000 dollars given over what? 10 years or more? That's not even "couch cushion" money in terms of paying for a dedicated hard-science effort.
 
It happened to a lot of people WP. A LOT. It happens on all Bigfoot forums. They tend to be very clicky you know? :D

I like the way the mods work here at the JREF. I have been slapped when I deserve it and I have no problem with it.

I hope the New BFF can overcome the clicks.

Cliques.
 
Advantages of The BFF being run by the CFZ

1. Double the mystery wildcat threads!
2. using 'Bloody' in a post is now a suspendable offense
3. Paul V and John WS will have a place to discuss Labor v. Conservative party platforms
4. Neil Burgstahler's ideas will be considered equal to the Flesh and Blood footers'
5. CROP CIRCLES BABY!
 
Paul's right. Given the two choices of where that forum could have gone, the CFZ was the better choice.

ETA:
Thanks for the warm welcome, Parnassus. It's good to be here.
 
Last edited:
Conversely, witnesses are always wrong/lying/hoaxed? And it is incumbent on the witness to prove in that theyaren't lying/mistaken and/or were not hoaxed?

Sure, when they say they've seen something that science considers non-existent, the default position of science is that they are wrong. That's the way it has to be. Why take it personally? You have to prove things in science. You can't just claim you witnessed them and call it good. Informally you can, but not here and not in the real world. This is a skeptic board. Why is this even a question? Why would anyone complain or expect to be accomodated?

"Prove the negative" seems to be the default "skeptic" position.

I've never seen that used here in any serious way. Not by skeptics, anyway.

You can't have meant, "Prove that it isn't bigfoot." because that's ridiculous. Or could you?
 
Last edited:
A couple of $100,000 dollars given over what? 10 years or more? That's not even "couch cushion" money in terms of paying for a dedicated hard-science effort.

It was counted up at least once here. I think that number is low.

Even so, that would buy a lot of game cams...and a lot of month long stays in the woods to gather evidence of a giant primate that must alter it's environment in a big way.
 
We have dna evidence, forensic hair anaylysis evidence, track trait distribution curve evidence. We have at least one audio recording of good provenance.

I am not aware of any such evidence, and I've been paying attention for a long time.

If there were conclusive DNA or hair or track or audio evidence, I certainly would not dismiss it.

I have never dismissed any such evidence.
 
On top of that we have 100s of eyewitness reports that are VERY clear about what they saw (a larger than human, bipedal animal NOT a bear). Many of those witnesses are professional people of good standing in their community. Many of those people also have skills/training that makes them good observers, not easily startled/distracted and able to remain calm and focused even under stress
.

If you accept this as good evidence of bigfoot's existence, then you have your proof.

If these witnesses are so good and reliable, then what more do you need?

Why do you need grant money and the help of scientists?

Go ahead and publish and set out your traps then. Bigfoot exists.

Why aren't you setting up bigfoot traps? You have a largish community that believes bigfoot exists. You say you have lots of evidence. Traps are not that expensive, and you have money.

If I believed creature X existed, and I believed I had lots of evidence, and I believed I knew all about creature X, I'd be setting up traps.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom