The Hacking of the American Mind

That would imply that thin people don't have to worry about CVD and type 2 diabetes, but I know you don't believe that..

Not so. As an analogy, hurricanes will be driving the rise of power outages this month, but that doesn't mean all power outages are caused by hurricanes, or that living in the plains means I won't get a power outage. Power outages, like CVD and T2D, can have multiple causes, and there can be an increase in a particular cause. And at the same time, I can also say pixies are not one of the causes.
 
It is my understanding that protein takes more calories to digest than simple sugars.

That is why it is not unreasonable to point out that the " In " part of CICO, doesn't just mean your mouth..

Like, if you're eating carrots, you have to burn some calories in digestion to get to the calories in the carrot?

Yeah, I'm sure there's at least some small effect there. Seems like eating low calorie food will have the biggest bang for it's caloric buck in hunger satiation, tho.
 
I certainly agree with that, but I don't believe most weight control programs
account for that.

It is my understanding that protein takes more calories to digest than simple sugars.

That is why it is not unreasonable to point out that the " In " part of CICO, doesn't just mean your mouth..

While it is certainly plausible, because I don't think anyone is in denial of the Thermic Effect of Food as a component of energy expenditure, it is another thing to demonstrate this as significant when it comes to whole diets or populations.

It has therefore been suggested that a low-carbohydrate diet may provide a metabolic advantage (an increase in energy expenditure), resulting in a positive effect on weight loss and maintenance. However, a review of studies in which 24-hour energy expenditure was measured did not provide evidence to support a metabolic advantage of low-carbohydrate diets and showed little evidence of a metabolic advantage of high-protein (>25% of energy) diets.

Linky.

As noted, Hall previously has found no significant different in energy expenditure between fat and carb focused diets.
 
”Not that simple, say Copenhagen group”

It's actually extremely complicated.

Professor Cristopher Gardner, who co-authored the JAMA study, says his study shouldn’t be seen as an automatic deathblow to the new blood sugar diet.
“What may have happened in our study is that we strongly advised both the low-fat and low-carb group to go as low as they could in added sugars and refined grains, and as high as both of them could in vegetables. This was, in essence, the foundational diet, and from here they then worked on including more steel cut oats and lentils (low-fat), or more avocadoes, nuts and fatty salmon (low-carb),” writes Gardner, who is a research professor at the Stanford Prevention Research Center at Stanford University, in an email to Videnskab.dk.
“It may have been that the insulin response to these two dietary approaches, with a foundation in low added sugars and refined grains, and high in vegetables, diminished the importance of personal insulin metabolism,” writes Gardner.
In other words, you might lose weight by cutting down on sugar and increasing the amount of vegetables you eat – regardless of whether a blood sugar test categorises you as type A, B, or C on the Copenhagen group’s scale.
Thin evidence behind “revolutionary” blood sugar diet: Scientists (Science Nordic, June 23, 2018)


The article is a very comprehensive presentation of all the current pro and contra arguments in this debate. It also mentions some of the financial interests in the case.

However, the ”Copenhagen group” appear to be doing something right:
ShanghaiRanking's Global Ranking of Sport Science Schools and Departments 2018.

Denmark has been a front runner in many important nutritional initiatives in recent years: Trans fat: Denmark (And I do know that that doesn’t mean that Danish researchers are always right! :) )
 
It's actually extremely complicated.




The article is a very comprehensive presentation of all the current pro and contra arguments in this debate. It also mentions some of the financial interests in the case.

Isn't that the same thing he said in the article I linked to above?

“This study closes the door on some questions — but it opens the door to others. We have gobs of data that we can use in secondary, exploratory studies,” he said. Gardner and his team are continuing to delve into their databanks, now asking if the microbiome, epigenetics or a different gene expression pattern can clue them in to why there’s such drastic variability between dieting individuals.

Perhaps the biggest takeaway from this study, Gardner said, is that the fundamental strategy for losing weight with either a low-fat or a low-carb approach is similar. Eat less sugar, less refined flour and as many vegetables as possible.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom