The Hacking of the American Mind

I don't quite understand the "non-nutritious food marketed to children" complaint. Beyond a snack here and there, don't the parents have primary control over what the kid eats? I saw ads for Lucky Charms as a kid. At the grocery store, I begged and pleaded with my mother, on a weekly basis. She simply said, "No, that's not healthy. It's just sugar. Grab some Cheerios, and stop whining!"

I understand that not all parents are around as much as my mom was (and thank **** for that), but unless a domestic situation is highly unusual, most young children would not be responsible for the family's grocery shopping choices. Most also don't have much extra pocket money. So is the advertisers' "targeting" of kids really that evil? The worst things a kid can do as a result are either whine for their parents to buy crap, or purchase a few sugary snacks on the sly here and there. Are the advertisers really the problem?

Just something I've wondered about off and on whenever I read these discussions. I'm not trying to be flip. I don't have any children, so I don't know what they're like. Maybe I'm missing something.
 
I don't quite understand the "non-nutritious food marketed to children" complaint. Beyond a snack here and there, don't the parents have primary control over what the kid eats? I saw ads for Lucky Charms as a kid. At the grocery store, I begged and pleaded with my mother, on a weekly basis. She simply said, "No, that's not healthy. It's just sugar. Grab some Cheerios, and stop whining!"

I understand that not all parents are around as much as my mom was (and thank **** for that), but unless a domestic situation is highly unusual, most young children would not be responsible for the family's grocery shopping choices. Most also don't have much extra pocket money. So is the advertisers' "targeting" of kids really that evil? The worst things a kid can do as a result are either whine for their parents to buy crap, or purchase a few sugary snacks on the sly here and there. Are the advertisers really the problem?

Just something I've wondered about off and on whenever I read these discussions. I'm not trying to be flip. I don't have any children, so I don't know what they're like. Maybe I'm missing something.

Quite a few parents take their kids to the supermarket where they will connect an advert to what is on the shelf - usually placed at kid-height - and they might yell and scream until the goodies go into the trolley.
 
Quite a few parents take their kids to the supermarket where they will connect an advert to what is on the shelf - usually placed at kid-height - and they might yell and scream until the goodies go into the trolley.

Yelling and screaming are an early indication of bad parenting. Giving in to such behaviour guarantees more of it in future.

Not long ago my mother said to me that as a kid, she can't remember me ever asking for anything. Asking, mind, not demanding or screaming. I can't either. I laid a few hints and I had a great childhood but I was no means spoiled. The idea of screaming until I received what I wanted was as alien to me at four as it is now, at forty-four. Not that I'm forty four but my actual age doesn't scan as well.
 
Yelling and screaming are an early indication of bad parenting. Giving in to such behaviour guarantees more of it in future.

Not long ago my mother said to me that as a kid, she can't remember me ever asking for anything. Asking, mind, not demanding or screaming. I can't either. I laid a few hints and I had a great childhood but I was no means spoiled. The idea of screaming until I received what I wanted was as alien to me at four as it is now, at forty-four. Not that I'm forty four but my actual age doesn't scan as well.

There's plenty of bad parenting around, and companies will take advantage of it, of course.

You're entitled to have any age you want, but of course we're entitled to be sceptical - or even skeptical - about it.:)
 
I don't quite understand the "non-nutritious food marketed to children" complaint. ..........

Do you understand the epidemics of obesity and type 2 diabetes taking place in this country?

This from 2011, and it's worse today.
The Epidemic of Obesity and Diabetes
Excess weight affects two thirds of the U.S. adult population and increases risk for cardiovascular disease and diabetes.


Do you think it might have something to do with the mass marketing of nutritional garbage ?
It's not so much marketed to children, as it is ' for ' children.. Children don't buy the groceries.


I understand how you feel about ' hack '..
However I can't fault the author for jumping on a ' catch ' word to sell his book.
 
I asked for things, without shouting or whining for them.

Occasionally, I got them. Nothing wrong with some Lucky Charms now and then.

Of course, back then they only had wholesome pink hearts, yellow moons, orange stars, and green clovers. Now they've got pots, rainbows, unicorns, diamonds and all kinds of other questionable shapes and colors. Alas, Babylon!
 
I don't quite understand the "non-nutritious food marketed to children" complaint. Beyond a snack here and there, don't the parents have primary control over what the kid eats? I saw ads for Lucky Charms as a kid. At the grocery store, I begged and pleaded with my mother, on a weekly basis. She simply said, "No, that's not healthy. It's just sugar. Grab some Cheerios, and stop whining!"

I understand that not all parents are around as much as my mom was (and thank **** for that), but unless a domestic situation is highly unusual, most young children would not be responsible for the family's grocery shopping choices. Most also don't have much extra pocket money. So is the advertisers' "targeting" of kids really that evil? The worst things a kid can do as a result are either whine for their parents to buy crap, or purchase a few sugary snacks on the sly here and there. Are the advertisers really the problem?

Just something I've wondered about off and on whenever I read these discussions. I'm not trying to be flip. I don't have any children, so I don't know what they're like. Maybe I'm missing something.


It's not as easy as you think, but, basically, you're right. Especially at the whiny years (anywhere from 2 to about 11, depending on the kid) they are pretty easy to say no to.
 
Buying billions of dollars of crap for food is a sign of bad parenting...

Yeah, it's easy to say no, but apparently a lot of parents must be saying yes. Of course, a lot of that junk food is being consumed by adults. I speak from experience on this subject.
 
On the other hand, the major food companies definitely do have food scientists working to find the right combinations of hyper-palatable combinations to be enticing, but not satiating. Michael Moss detailed this a few years back in Salt Sugar Fat. I think he was similarly hyperbolic in making the foods sound addictive like narcotics, but there is definitely a lot of research and work going into making foods hyper-palatable, rather than nutritious or promoting a balanced diet, which is definitely due to profit motive.

On the other other hand, does consumer demand have a responsibility? Especially with the calls we see for the various fads, organic, etc. It makes you wonder. On the other other hand, food companies market to children and prey on uninformed consumers and indulge and promote whatever fad or misinformation they can.

I wonder if there's anything government can, or should, do about it. We already have food labels that are pretty informative. If we don't care to take advantage of the information, beating people over the head about it probably won't improve the situation. The fact is that food companies are creating foods that are yummy, easy to make, and cheap, and we like all of that. It kills us and makes us fat, but that won't happen until tomorrow. Right now, I want Twinkies!

(For the record, I do not, and never have, eaten Twinkies, except for a handful of them as a kid. Now, Hostess cupcakes.....)
 
Depending on the parent..

If only I had that level of power over my children. For what it's worth, my kid was never a whiny sort, but he had all sorts of other flaws that people were certain would have gone away if only I or his mother had been better parents.
 
If only I had that level of power over my children. For what it's worth, my kid was never a whiny sort, but he had all sorts of other flaws that people were certain would have gone away if only I or his mother had been better parents.

I have 2 kids with radically different inborn personalities. I wish I could pat myself on the back for the bizarrely angelic one's behavior, but that would mean I'd have to take the blame for the, ahem, "spirited" one's early challenging years.
 
Buying billions of dollars of crap for food is a sign of bad parenting...


Who the hell has time for parenting?

Modern economics requires that, unless one parent has a very well paying job, both parents have to work. This means parenting is something that's crammed into the time available between work and sleep and is coloured by the stresses and difficulties of that work.

I was always told that being a parent is a full time job. Today, for most people, it's far too much of a financial luxury for one parent to dedicate their time to raising a child. Any task is incredibly difficult to perform well when there's not the time to complete it.
 
Who the hell has time for parenting?

Modern economics requires that, unless one parent has a very well paying job, both parents have to work. This means parenting is something that's crammed into the time available between work and sleep and is coloured by the stresses and difficulties of that work.

I was always told that being a parent is a full time job. Today, for most people, it's far too much of a financial luxury for one parent to dedicate their time to raising a child. Any task is incredibly difficult to perform well when there's not the time to complete it.

Yet these people still pop out kids. Many put as much thought into that as they do their diets.

I see extremely fat people riding around in carts (because they can't walk apparently) at the stores buying cupcakes and crap all the time. They feed their very fat kids the same stuff of course. It makes me want to scream at them.

But there is no shortage of dietary information in this country and I am living proof that you can eat cheap and be healthy, so being poor is no excuse either. It's entirely personal decision.

I live in the same world, same food. I'm 50 and I weigh 175 (after hitting 200 once) because I want to be healthy. I'm aware that companies put sugar in bread and everything else these days. You can taste it in some bread and it pisses me off.

I don't even eat that well but by cutting certain things out of my diet I maintain my weight and get good scores on my blood tests. It isn't that difficult and I'm pretty poor these days but manage to eat well enough.

People just need to care about themselves enough to do it. It does make me angry that companies load sugar into foods, but I don't have to eat it.

Knowledge and a little self control is all it takes. If people want to blame the food manufacturers, well that's just typically American these days...it's someone else's fault.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom