The Hacking of the American Mind

Yet these people still pop out kids. Many put as much thought into that as they do their diets.

I see extremely fat people riding around in carts (because they can't walk apparently) at the stores buying cupcakes and crap all the time. They feed their very fat kids the same stuff of course. It makes me want to scream at them.

But there is no shortage of dietary information in this country and I am living proof that you can eat cheap and be healthy, so being poor is no excuse either. It's entirely personal decision.

I live in the same world, same food. I'm 50 and I weigh 175 (after hitting 200 once) because I want to be healthy. I'm aware that companies put sugar in bread and everything else these days. You can taste it in some bread and it pisses me off.

I don't even eat that well but by cutting certain things out of my diet I maintain my weight and get good scores on my blood tests. It isn't that difficult and I'm pretty poor these days but manage to eat well enough.

People just need to care about themselves enough to do it. It does make me angry that companies load sugar into foods, but I don't have to eat it.

Knowledge and a little self control is all it takes. If people want to blame the food manufacturers, well that's just typically American these days...it's someone else's fault.

Correct, but it's even worse when considering parents as opposed to the individual. If someone wants to stuff themselves with junk then OK, bad decision, no excuses, don't whine about it when you're 350lbs, etc. But a parent has a moral duty not to jeopardise the health of their kids through their own laziness and selfishness, yet millions do, and then they have the balls (or the meat balls) to complain that boo hoo, it's not their fault, it's the fault of the government, the food company, the economy, McDonalds. It's infuriating, it makes me want to slap their fat self-entitled faces with the fresh fish they should be feeding to their kids.
 
Yet these people still pop out kids. Many put as much thought into that as they do their diets.

I see extremely fat people riding around in carts (because they can't walk apparently) at the stores buying cupcakes and crap all the time. They feed their very fat kids the same stuff of course. It makes me want to scream at them.

But there is no shortage of dietary information in this country and I am living proof that you can eat cheap and be healthy, so being poor is no excuse either. It's entirely personal decision.

I live in the same world, same food. I'm 50 and I weigh 175 (after hitting 200 once) because I want to be healthy. I'm aware that companies put sugar in bread and everything else these days. You can taste it in some bread and it pisses me off.

I don't even eat that well but by cutting certain things out of my diet I maintain my weight and get good scores on my blood tests. It isn't that difficult and I'm pretty poor these days but manage to eat well enough.

People just need to care about themselves enough to do it. It does make me angry that companies load sugar into foods, but I don't have to eat it.

Knowledge and a little self control is all it takes. If people want to blame the food manufacturers, well that's just typically American these days...it's someone else's fault.


Perhaps you're just a much, much better person than they are? Your genetic stock is stronger, your will more powerful and your intelligence higher?

Shame on them for not being the paragon you are!


I take it you believe that advertising doesn't work and that the 180 odd billion dollars that is spent on advertising each year is just money down the drain for the companies concerned?
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, the major food companies definitely do have food scientists working to find the right combinations of hyper-palatable combinations to be enticing, but not satiating.

This is what seems to me too, eating till you feel full could be WAY more calories with one food source than another apparently

Anyone following along on facebook, or even the science and health section of the JREF saw me lose just over 100 pounds in four and a half months, and keep it off.

At this point, most afternoons I gorge on cheap donuts as our local supermarket puts them on sale after half a day, and I really crave the carbs....I'm not so much counting the calories anymore, but I know in general how many different things are and I dont write it down anymore, but know when I'm at my limit generally.

Writing the stuff down seriously seemed to be the easiest way to lose weight, I can't say for sure why, but it just was like a computer program, you have this many buffers to fill and thats IT, past there is error. At that time, I avoided stuff that didn't make me feel full...fruits were OUT unless I was consuming them at the skatepark, but now I just gorge
 
I don't think you can ever get around CICO. The concept of weight-loss is very simple; eat less, move more. It's actually doing so that is very difficult. Our bodies fight us. If you are sedentary, it's very difficult to start exercise. You get tired easy, you suffer. It's much more pleasurable to sit in front of our screens. But more importantly, it's extremely difficult to change our diets . It's all tied into the endocrine system and the brain's reward system. Those high-carb foods reward us for eating them and trigger hormonal responses that reduce satiety. Reducing sugar intake and increasing protein intake increases the secretion of stuff like Peptide YY.

So the studies cited earlier don't surprise me at all. It makes sense that you can lose weight by reducing your calories in no matter which macronutrients you focus on. The real long-term benefits, I think, will be found with a diet that tends to increase satiety. That diet is one that is high in protein and includes complex carbs such as those found in fruits, vegetables and whole grains. The Mediterranean diet is one that I have found the most support for in the literature.
 
I saw ads for Lucky Charms as a kid. At the grocery store, I begged and pleaded with my mother, on a weekly basis. She simply said, "No, that's not healthy. It's just sugar. Grab some Cheerios, and stop whining!"
I always ended up with the Cheerios too, though my mom never cited health as a reason.

So, I ate the Cheerios...after dumping a ton of sugar on them!
 
I always ended up with the Cheerios too, though my mom never cited health as a reason.

So, I ate the Cheerios...after dumping a ton of sugar on them!

Sugar is fifty cents/pound. Boxes of cereal are about $8/lb. You did good.
 
My wife is out of town.

I just drank 2 beers, ate 10 wings and also like 20 Totino's pizza rolls.

Im 36.
Life is good.
 
I don't think you can ever get around CICO. The concept of weight-loss is very simple; eat less, move more. It's actually doing so that is very difficult. Our bodies fight us. If you are sedentary, it's very difficult to start exercise. You get tired easy, you suffer. It's much more pleasurable to sit in front of our screens. But more importantly, it's extremely difficult to change our diets . It's all tied into the endocrine system and the brain's reward system. Those high-carb foods reward us for eating them and trigger hormonal responses that reduce satiety. Reducing sugar intake and increasing protein intake increases the secretion of stuff like Peptide YY.

So the studies cited earlier don't surprise me at all. It makes sense that you can lose weight by reducing your calories in no matter which macronutrients you focus on. The real long-term benefits, I think, will be found with a diet that tends to increase satiety. That diet is one that is high in protein and includes complex carbs such as those found in fruits, vegetables and whole grains. The Mediterranean diet is one that I have found the most support for in the literature.

I like this guy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3z-_6JgMiwA&t=

( I cant get the Youtube thingy to work )

He makes an interesting case for " not all calories are created equal " ..

Jump to 13:02 if you want to get to his arguments for the above..
 
I always ended up with the Cheerios too, though my mom never cited health as a reason.

So, I ate the Cheerios...after dumping a ton of sugar on them!

We only bought sugary cereal when we were taking the kids on vacations. Usually that is the only cereal in those small boxes that are really convenient when traveling. To this day my adult kids refer to sugary cereal as "vacation cereal" and their friends just laugh. No, that is just good cereal!

We never had a bowl of sugar in our kitchen for kids to sugar their own cereal. I remember having it on the kitchen table as a kid, along with honey and salt and pepper. But as an adult that is just not something i would even consider.
 
I'm unconvinced that this took any "programming". Biologically, the human body has developed to keenly like sugar and fat; so including these ingredients in food makes people like them more. It's not a "conspiracy", it's not a "plot" to make people "want sugar". It's simple market research and designing your product around what people provably like more.
 
I like this guy:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3z-_6JgMiwA&t=

( I cant get the Youtube thingy to work )

He makes an interesting case for " not all calories are created equal " ..

Jump to 13:02 if you want to get to his arguments for the above..

His ideas haven't withstood scientific scrutiny:

The highest level of evidence from systematic reviews and meta-analyses of controlled trials has not shown that fructose-containing sugars behave any differently from other forms of digestible carbohydrates. Fructose-containing sugars can only lead to weight gain and other unintended harms on cardiometabolic risk factors insofar as the excess calories they provide.

Linky.

In this 12-month weight loss diet study, there was no significant difference in weight change between a healthy low-fat diet vs a healthy low-carbohydrate diet, and neither genotype pattern nor baseline insulin secretion was associated with the dietary effects on weight loss.

Linky.

The aim of Lustig’s nine-day experiment, which involved 43 obese children, was to see what happens when someone maintains their calorie intake but reduces their sugar consumption. Mainstream scientists would expect to see no change in body mass. Lustig expected to see weight loss, and he did.

There’s a simple way to conduct a study like this. Give half the kids a 1,500 calorie per day diet that is high in sugar and give the other half a 1,500 calorie per day diet that is low in sugar. Make sure they eat it (don’t just send them home with it, as Lustig does) and see what happens.

Alas, that’s not how Lustig went about things. Instead, he asked 43 fat kids what they usually ate and then gave them an equivalent number of calories in low-sugar meals for nine days. At the end of the period, he observed an average weight loss of 0.9 per cent. Bingo! A calorie from sugar is more fattening than a calorie from pizzas, crisps, hot dogs, popcorn and burritos (for that is what the low-sugar meals consisted of). Tax sugar now!

...

This small, uncontrolled study, which made no attempt to verify what its subjects normally eat, tells us nothing useful whatsoever. The claim of the Guardian‘s headline writer that ‘the science is in’ would be laughable if it were not so depressingly typical of the standard of scientific analysis in the popular press.

Linky,

He's a bit of a crank on a pop crusade against sugar. He's not a very good source.
 
Wow! Nothing useful in suggesting we shift from dietary choices that have created an epidemic of obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes ..

That all sounds like a great reason to continue loading yourself and your kids up on sugar...

Fructose and NAFLD: The Multifaceted Aspects of Fructose Metabolism
Among various factors, such as an unhealthy diet or a sedentarity lifestyle, excessive fructose consumption is known to favor nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), as fructose is both a substrate and an inducer of hepatic de novo lipogenesis.

What would be your take on the increase in obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes in the last 70 years?

Also, with regard to:
The highest level of evidence from systematic reviews and meta-analyses of controlled trials has not shown that fructose-containing sugars behave any differently from other forms of digestible carbohydrates. Fructose-containing sugars can only lead to weight gain and other unintended harms on cardiometabolic risk factors insofar as the excess calories they provide.

That does not address what Lustig is pointing out.

Is he wrong in claiming that there is a difference in the calories that make it into the blood stream from a 100 calorie serving of table sugar vs a 100 calorie serving of raw carrots?
 
Last edited:
Wow! Nothing useful in suggesting we shift from dietary choices that have created an epidemic of obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes ..

That all sounds like a great reason to continue loading yourself and your kids up on sugar...

Huh? :confused:

Tsukasa Buddha was just presenting the (very strong and compelling, IMO) evidence that 1 calorie = 1 calorie regardless of source.

What would be your take on the increase in obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes in the last 70 years?

My own guess would be the addition more calories to people's diets relative to their caloric expenditure. Putting extra sugar in everything would be part of that.


Is he wrong in claiming that there is a difference in the calories that make it into the blood stream from a 100 calorie serving of table sugar vs a 100 calorie serving of raw carrots?

I believe the 100 calorie figure with carrots will only account for what makes it into the bloodstream.
 
It is true, of course, that it's not the number of calories eaten but the number of calories absorbed by the body that counts.
However, the kind of calories that you should eat (in general and in particular if you're trying to lose weight) depends on which blood-sugar group you belong to. Calories aren't simply calories. The calories from fat, proteins and carbs don't affect you the same way.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31812-9/fulltext
https://thebloodsugardiet.com
 
It is true, of course, that it's not the number of calories eaten but the number of calories absorbed by the body that counts.
However, the kind of calories that you should eat (in general and in particular if you're trying to lose weight) depends on which blood-sugar group you belong to. Calories aren't simply calories. The calories from fat, proteins and carbs don't affect you the same way.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31812-9/fulltext
https://thebloodsugardiet.com

I agreed with you just a year or so ago, but Tsukasa Buddha has some evidence that I think completely debunks the notion. It's pretty recent evidence, iirc, and from a randomized controlled trial. The researchers were out to prove that the theory was correct, it seemed, but the evidence was surprisingly the opposite of what was expected.

Hopefully he/she will link it again.
 
Last edited:
Wow! Nothing useful in suggesting we shift from dietary choices that have created an epidemic of obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes ..

That all sounds like a great reason to continue loading yourself and your kids up on sugar...

Exactly, except not at all what I said :p .


As with the previous topic of fructose, mechanistic and animal studies are not the end of the road. Meta-analyses are superior:

A meta-analysis of all available human trials published in the European Journal of Clinical Nutrition says fructose in and of itself is not to blame for the increase in non-alcoholic fatty liver disease.

But excess consumption of calories can contribute to the disease, regardless of whether those calories came from fructose or other carbohydrates, said the lead author, Dr. John Sievenpiper, a researcher in the Clinical Nutrition and Risk Factor Modification Centre of St. Michael's Hospital.

"The one thing fructose is supposed to do above all else is give you fatty liver disease, which some say is a starting point for metabolic syndrome--a term used to describe a group of conditions that puts people at higher risk of developing Type 2 diabetes, heart disease and other heart-related problems--and Type 2 diabetes itself," Dr. Sievenpiper said.

"But we found it behaves no differently than glucose or refined starches. It is only when you consume excess calories in the form of fructose that you see a signal for harm but no more harm than if you consume excess calories as glucose."

...

Previous research by Dr. Sievenpiper has found that fructose by itself does not cause weight gain and does not itself have any impact on an emerging marker for the risk of cardiovascular disease known as postprandial triglycerides when it is substituted for other carbohydrates. It is when fructose is overconsumed providing excess calories that you see the adverse effects on health, but no more than when other carbohydrates are overconsumed.

A study he published in the February issue of Current Opinion in Lipidology also found no benefit in replacing fructose with glucose in commercially prepared foods. That research again showed that that when portion sizes and calories are the same, fructose does not cause any more harm than glucose.

"The debate over the role of fructose in obesity, fatty liver and other metabolic diseases has distracted us from the issue of overconsumption," Dr. Sievenpiper said. "Our data should serve to remind people that the excess calories, whether they are from fructose or other sources, are the issue."

Linky.

What would be your take on the increase in obesity, CVD and type 2 diabetes in the last 70 years?

It's not a "take", the evidence is simply that it is overconsumption of calories.

That does not address what Lustig is pointing out.

Is he wrong in claiming that there is a difference in the calories that make it into the blood stream from a 100 calorie serving of table sugar vs a 100 calorie serving of raw carrots?

As with the beginning of your post, you are sanitizing his statements of his actual claims.
 
Last edited:
It is true, of course, that it's not the number of calories eaten but the number of calories absorbed by the body that counts.
However, the kind of calories that you should eat (in general and in particular if you're trying to lose weight) depends on which blood-sugar group you belong to. Calories aren't simply calories. The calories from fat, proteins and carbs don't affect you the same way.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(18)31812-9/fulltext
https://thebloodsugardiet.com

I think this is an article about the study/studies I'm remembering:

https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2018/02/low-fat-or-low-carb-its-a-draw-study-finds.html

eta:
What is a "blood-sugar group"?
 
Last edited:
.............

It's not a "take", the evidence is simply that it is overconsumption of calories.

That would imply that thin people don't have to worry about CVD and type 2 diabetes, but I know you don't believe that..


So it's not simply " overconsumption of calories ", is it?
How about " over consumption of nutritionally deficient, easily digested calories " ?

This is born out by the fact that there are obese people who do not have CVD and diabetes, or the markers to indicate they will, any time soon.


P.S.
There are problems with meta analyses, and observational dietary studies, which I'm confident you are aware of also.

That doesn't make the observations, that today's nutritional deficiencies graph well with the increase in sugar, processed fat ( particularly seed oils )
processed grains and other processed foods containing these ingredients.
 
Last edited:
..

I believe the 100 calorie figure with carrots will only account for what makes it into the bloodstream.

I certainly agree with that, but I don't believe most weight control programs
account for that.

It is my understanding that protein takes more calories to digest than simple sugars.

That is why it is not unreasonable to point out that the " In " part of CICO, doesn't just mean your mouth..
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom