The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

jeffreyw: 145 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi to which we can add:
  1. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: A fantasy that stars "grow" in the opposite way to human beings !
  2. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion about "host stars".
  3. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant assertion of "modeled the Sun and all stars as being thermodynamically closed systems".
  4. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: Usual dogma delusion.
  5. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: A video repeating delusions (but slower!) and a lying Wolynski-Taylor cartoon.
  6. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: A video lying about "gaps" being invented in stellar evolution.
  7. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: Yet another ignorant and deluded PDF.
  8. 3 July 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorance of orbital mechanics as we do not need to observe a planet for a "year" to measure its period.
  9. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: New video - same old delusion about planets being stars, same old delusion of science is done by crank videos!
  10. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of two "ice giants".
  11. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: The inanity of renaming Uranus as Uranium!
  12. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion That "Neptunes" are about 2 billion years old" because he has a cartoon!
  13. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: An irrelevant cartoon of natural gas reservoirs on Earth!
  14. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that the Solar System is a "system of adopted objects"
  15. 7 July 2017 jeffreyw: The usual dogma delusion.
  16. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: New ignorant and deluded one page (!) PDF about galaxies this time.
  17. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: The planets are dead stars delusion.
  18. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: The idiocy of predicting that there will be vastly more planets than stars from the Solar System.
  19. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "two blue dwarfs" (a predicted stage of the formation of red dwarf stars) in the Solar System.
  20. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "accepted percentages of the number of stars in specific spectrum classes".
  21. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: Thinks that repeating an obvious delusion that planets are old stars makes it true!
 
From the last fortnight:
  1. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A 1 paragraph ignorant and deluded PDF about red giants!
  2. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A partial lie of "In the case of mis-shapen asteroids they were created by impacts".
  3. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant and deluded statement that red giants are not stars :jaw-dropp!
  4. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: Delusions about the sizes and distances to red giants being "mis-measured".
  5. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that red giants are "just might be the very beginning of a star’s birthing".
  6. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that red giants are "nebulas with which a single star is born in".
  7. 17 July 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant fairy story about the imaginary nebula "evaporating" to reveal a white dwarf, etc.
  8. 18 July 2017 jeffreyw: Cannot recognize his own Dunning-Kruger Effect from his own PDF :p!
  9. 18 July 2017 jeffreyw: His "Cornell Effect" is his personal insults of some highly educated people.
  10. 18 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that only accredited people discover things in science.
  11. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Yet another ignorant and deluded "paper"!
  12. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A fantasy that the equatorial plane has to match the Sun's equator exactly.
  13. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Arguments from incredibility and ignorance about solar system formation.
  14. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorance about Pluto (it is not a planet and is in the Solar system!).
  15. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about exoplanet orbital inclinations.
  16. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Basic ignorance about the transit method of detecting exoplanets.
  17. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that all planets in the galaxy must have "the same inclination of the Sun’s axis"!
  18. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: The usual persistent delusion that astronomy is dogma.
  19. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Denying the physical facts about stars and planets is beyond "absolutely insane".
  20. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant lie about Hubble's discovery that "spiral nebula" were galaxies.
  21. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A second lie about Hubble's discovery on "spiral nebula".
  22. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about the nebular hypothesis being debunked almost 100 years ago.
  23. 31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lying cartoon is not support of a delusion that blue giant stars are young stars.
 
Oh BTW Reality Check, I have just ignored all your posts because you do not want to talk about this issue in an adult manner. It is a waste of time for you to post. Just saying, I don't even see what you are writing.

No, you have RC on ignore because you simply are unable to handle the multifarious holes in you swiss cheese argument and try to avoid at all costs recognising those holes.

Never fear, everyone else is reading those replies and is fully aware how disfunctional your actual claims really are.

Since you cite rationalwiki as a source, here is your own entry on that wiki.
 
That's the thing. You call me crazy yet... Here's another paper that addresses the iron deposition rate in the cores of evolving stars.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

I've already fully replaced the iron catastrophe, which is a good thing, because it does not address the iron cores of any highly evolved star, except for Earth. With stellar metamorphosis the iron cores of all evolved stars are addressed. Not just the ones establishment has cherry picked.

You seem to be unable to comprehend your papers are as worthless as the words you've been typing for umpteen pages. These papers would find better use in the bathroom. You are a bright fellow that's for certain, but it's ashame you are wasting all this effort on what will amount to being a fools errand.
 
Last edited:
That's the thing. You call me crazy yet... Here's another paper that addresses the iron deposition rate in the cores of evolving stars.
We call you crazy because you insist on linking to PDFs that are abysmally ignorant about stars and planets to the point of delusion :jaw-dropp.
2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A PDF with the massively crazy idea that stars get an iron core as they age.
In the real world (not yours!), main sequence stars such as the Sun have a tiny percentage of Fe (0.12% by mass in the solar photosphere) and have convection mixing a proportion of their volume.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the measured age of the Earth.
The age of the Earth cannot be assumed to be 10 billion years - it is measured to be 4.54 billion years.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant fantasy that the iron core of the Earth was deposited.
Iron does not magically travel through basically solid rock :eek:! It is the iron core of the Earth that generates the Earth's magnetic field which has not increased over the last few billion years.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that Earth is a star.
The Earth is not made of mostly hydrogen plasma! The Earth has been a rocky planet since it formed 4.54 billions years ago.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the measured age of the Moon.
The Moon's age is 4.51 billion years. This is younger than the Earth and contradicts the delusion that planets and moons are old stars.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The usual delusion of "establishment dogma".

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about the iron catastrophe which is about the Earth, not stars.
Iron catastrophe

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that molten iron in molten rock in a gravitational field will take "billions of years" to be drawn to the center of the Earth.
Earth's iron core took less than 1 billon years to form and start to generate a magnetic field. Earth's Magnetic Field Is 3.5 Billion Years Old

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the estimated age of Mars.
The age of Mars is estimated to be 4.5 billion years from the oldest surface rocks, cratering and dating Martian meteorites.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of assigning Mars an age greater than the age of the universe!

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion of "big bang dogma".
The big Bang is a scientific theory with an enormous body of empirical evidence.

2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "non-observation offered by Big Bang" when everyone knows about the observations offered by the Big Bang.
Those observations started in 1610 with the observation that in an infinite, eternal static universe every line of sight would end in a star - thus Olbers' paradox (the night sky should be bright) and a solution (the universe is not eternal static). There is Hubble's law. There is the existence of the CMB. etc.
 
Last edited:
That's why I included the mass loss principle.
2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Unsupported and ignorance fantasies are not "principles" and RationaWiki has a list of irrational "principles" you have made up to fit a delusion that planets are old stars.

Stellar metamorphosis
Stellar metamorphosis is a fringe alternative cosmology theory that explains stellar evolution.[1][2] The theory claims to successfully explain what happens as a star cools and combines its elements into molecular compounds, mixtures, colloids, solutions and suspensions. This contradicts a fact of astrophysics that stars and planets are entirely different entities ...

What you link to are
  1. An ignorant fantasy of mass magically vanishing from stars.
    There are real mechanism for stars to lose mass, e.g. solar winds, nova, supernova. The end product are stars with masses much greater than planets. For example red giants lose about half their mass when forming white dwarfs. The Sun will end up as a white dwarf with half its mass, i.e. ~150,000 Earths!
  2. A deluded "stars are not the location for any significant fusion processes" statement.
    The Sun is a star and is powered by fusion :eye-poppi!
  3. An ignorant "mass continuum" fantasy.
    Stars are classified by the light that they emit. The Sun has a spectral classification of G2V.
    There are no "steps". Each spectral class butts up continuously against the next spectral class.
    The light that a main sequence star emits is related to its mass where colder, red stars have low mass and hotter blue stars have high mass.
  4. An ignorant fantasy of "diminishing solar abundances".
    You start with the delusion that planets are old stars and make up a fairy story to fit.
  5. An ignorant, incoherent "magnetosphere evolution" fantasy.
    A delusion about "differentiation" in stars. Main sequence stars are mostly mixed up by convection.
    A delusion of "magnetized rocks on all black dwarfs" applied to Mars (a planet)!
    Abysmal ignorance of black dwarfs. There are none because the universe is not old enough for white dwarfs to cool enough. The lowest estimate is 1015 (1 quadrillion) years.
 
Last edited:
You think RC is writing stuff for you to read? Well, that's another thing you're wrong about.

Why post on my thread then? Why not make his own thread?

Oh I forgot to post these papers too, because you wanted to see the work of course.

http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals-Papers/Author/1151/Jeffrey,%20Wolynski

Oh and you do realize that every time you comment it bumps this thread to the top, which is what my goal is. Both you and him are helping the visibility of the thread. Bad publicity is still publicity. It is extra energy that I get without doing anything really, but presenting a new idea in a giant pseudoskeptic echo chamber.
 
You seem to be unable to comprehend your papers are as worthless as the words you've been typing for umpteen pages. These papers would find better use in the bathroom. You are a bright fellow that's for certain, but it's ashame you are wasting all this effort on what will amount to being a fools errand.

I have already thought that through.

We all die. Living is a fools errand.

What I think you mean is this, do I have anything to lose? Nope. I have nothing to lose. As well, do I have anything to gain? Yes. I have lots to gain. See. What has seemed to slip the people's minds here is that if I really am correct, that planets are just evolving stars, then I've stumbled upon the single greatest insight in the history of humanity.

The stars in the sky are young Earths?

If I'm wrong? Nothing happens. I'm just crazy and the snarky people here get nothing but wasted time commenting on this thread.

If I'm right? I am one of the greatest scientists/philosophers who ever lived.

It is the chance of a lifetime and I'm not going to let it slip. What it will take is continuous hard work and dedication. I will also keep this thread updated with the ideas.

I have a new paper I have written explaining the lower end cut off for life formation in stellar evolution. The Taylor Threshold.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1708.0014v1.pdf

The Taylor Threshold is much more advanced than the 1950's overly simplistic Goldilocks Zone stuff. It is unfair to its fullest, modern scientists don't even realize what they are standing on.
 
I have already thought that through.

We all die. Living is a fools errand.

What I think you mean is this, do I have anything to lose? Nope. I have nothing to lose. As well, do I have anything to gain? Yes. I have lots to gain. See. What has seemed to slip the people's minds here is that if I really am correct, that planets are just evolving stars, then I've stumbled upon the single greatest insight in the history of humanity.

The stars in the sky are young Earths?

If I'm wrong? Nothing happens. I'm just crazy and the snarky people here get nothing but wasted time commenting on this thread.

If I'm right? I am one of the greatest scientists/philosophers who ever lived.

It is the chance of a lifetime and I'm not going to let it slip. What it will take is continuous hard work and dedication. I will also keep this thread updated with the ideas.

I have a new paper I have written explaining the lower end cut off for life formation in stellar evolution. The Taylor Threshold.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1708.0014v1.pdf

The Taylor Threshold is much more advanced than the 1950's overly simplistic Goldilocks Zone stuff. It is unfair to its fullest, modern scientists don't even realize what they are standing on.

Look, that's not even a paper. It has no data, no model, no prediction and no observations.

There is no explanation for what is necessary for life, just size and age and there is no correlation for that there.

sorry try again
 
I have already thought that through.

We all die. Living is a fools errand.

What I think you mean is this, do I have anything to lose? Nope. I have nothing to lose. As well, do I have anything to gain? Yes. I have lots to gain. See. What has seemed to slip the people's minds here is that if I really am correct, that planets are just evolving stars, then I've stumbled upon the single greatest insight in the history of humanity.

The stars in the sky are young Earths?

If I'm wrong? Nothing happens. I'm just crazy and the snarky people here get nothing but wasted time commenting on this thread.

If I'm right? I am one of the greatest scientists/philosophers who ever lived.

It is the chance of a lifetime and I'm not going to let it slip. What it will take is continuous hard work and dedication. I will also keep this thread updated with the ideas.

.
That's like a secular Pascal's wager. Pascal's wager fails and so does this.
 
Why post on my thread then?
This is not your own personal thread for your own personal use :p! You started the thread with your delusion that planets are old stars. Anyone in the forum is free to post here.
I am documenting how ignorant and deluded the idea is so the everyone in the world will know that for the lifetime of the Internet. As a bonus I occasionally cover real astronomy to educate other people (you are beyond help).
You are persisting in emphasizing just how ignorant and deluded the idea is by linking to ignorant and deluded PDFs. Before today we had
jeffreyw: 166 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi
and
23 items of ignorance and delusion form the last fortnight
and
  1. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A PDF with the massively crazy idea that stars get an iron core as they age.
  2. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the measured age of the Earth.
  3. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant fantasy that the iron core of the Earth was "deposited".
  4. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion that Earth is or was a star.
  5. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the measured age of the Moon.
  6. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The usual delusion of "establishment dogma".
  7. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about the iron catastrophe which is about the Earth, not stars.
  8. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that molten iron in molten rock in a gravitational field will take "billions of years" to be drawn to the center of the Earth.
  9. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance or denial of the estimated age of Mars.
  10. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of assigning Mars an age greater than the age of the universe!
  11. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: The delusion of "big bang dogma".
  12. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "non-observation offered by Big Bang" when everyone knows about the observations offered by the Big Bang.
  13. 2 August 2017 jeffreyw: Unsupported and ignorance fantasies are not "principles" and RationaWiki has a list of irrational "principles" you have made up to fit a delusion that planets are old stars.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Accuses Baz Taylor of being ignorant about the Moon

...The Taylor Threshold.
Another ignorant and deluded PDF.
4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Accuses Baz Taylor of being ignorant about the Moon which never was habitable, e.g. never has had an atmosphere.
This is something that high school science students know. I expect that Baz Taylor is a bit older and did have a standard science education.

Jeffrey Wolynsk, are you brave enough to invite Baz Taylor to join this thread so that he can (re)learn some astronomy and physics?
For example how we measure the age of the Earth to be less than half of 10 billion years? What the Sun will eventually turn into (a white dwarf with the mass of 150,000 Earths)? What the Hertzsprung–Russell diagram contains and means? etc.

4 August 2017 jeffreyw: A line is written on an abysmally ignorant and lying cartoon!
The Earth is measured to be 4.54 billon years old so "Earths" at 10 billion years is a lie.
The Moon is measured to be 4.53 billon years old, the age of the universe is 13.8 billion years so "Dead Moons" at 65 billion years is a delusional lie.
A lie about "grey dwarfs" - there are no such things.
No red giants in the cartoon :eek:!
Lies about blue giants, blue dwarfs, white dwarfs, white stars, yellow stars (the Sun!) being less than 90 million years old.

In short every point on that cartoon is a lie to support his delusions :jaw-dropp.

4 August 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that Mars is a star and took ~14 billon years to form.
 
Last edited:
Why post on my thread then? Why not make his own thread?

Oh I forgot to post these papers too, because you wanted to see the work of course.

http://gsjournal.net/Science-Journals-Papers/Author/1151/Jeffrey,%20Wolynski

Oh and you do realize that every time you comment it bumps this thread to the top, which is what my goal is. Both you and him are helping the visibility of the thread. Bad publicity is still publicity. It is extra energy that I get without doing anything really, but presenting a new idea in a giant pseudoskeptic echo chamber.
Wow. You have no idea what RC has posted, given that you have proudly declaimed that you have RC on ignore.

That admission tells everyone that you have your fingers in your ears while yelling "LaLaLaLa" all the while. It may well be that you think that makes your crank ideas immune to criticism, but it does not. It makes it plain that your idea is a one trick pony which you fear to have challenged since you are unable to offer any defence for valid critique of said deluded idea.
 
If I'm wrong? Nothing happens. I'm just crazy and the snarky people here get nothing but wasted time commenting on this thread.
Your idea is totally wrong so you are "just crazy" as you put it. That is not nothing happening - sometime in the past you want "just crazy" and are continuing to be crazy by persisting with the delusion that planets are old stars. You have known your idea was wrong since at least the beginning of the thread, e.g. see the post by ben m on 27 December 2014. Continuing with the wrong idea for almost 3 years is one thing that makes it into a delusion.
On the same page: jeffreyw, sadly you have brought a knife to a gunfight here. There are people who know what they are talking about in this thread. Put your beliefs aside, listen and learn. I happen to know that those people include a working nuclear physicist and a ex-solid state physicist. But anyone with the ability to read Wikipedia can see how abysmal your idea is.

Things get worse. You have a I have worked on theory for 3 years post on the first page which puts us to December 2011 (at least). You have had almost 6 years to learn what stars are and you have not bothered. You still have a delusion of stars being "thermochemical" when they are thermonuclear. :jaw-dropp!

The people posting in this thread are not wasting their time showing that yet another of the thousands of ignorant Internet physics cranks is wrong.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Another deluded PDF (Earth is a Black Dwarf Star)

Oh I forgot to post these papers too, because you wanted to see the work of course.
No one really wants see more ignorant fairy stories. But if you insist on showing just how ignorant you are about stars then I will oblige.
4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Another deluded PDF (Earth is a Black Dwarf Star).
No black dwarf stars exist as reading Wikipedia would have told you back in 2012 :jaw-dropp!
It takes a minimum of 1,000,000,000,000,000 years for a white dwarf to cool down enough to be a black dwarf. The mass of a white dwarf is about half that of the original star, e.g. the Sun will become a white dwarf with a mess of 150,000 Earths. This is also on Wikipedia.

4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Another lying PDF (What a New Planet Looks Like)
You lie about having empirical evidence for what a new planet looks like ("It will be shown with empirical observation what a new planet looks like"). Stating your delusion that planets are stars and showing pictures of stars is not empirical evidence.

The references are mostly broken PDFs but a couple are obvious lies:
4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Another lying PDF (The Sun is Younger than the Earth).
The Earth is measured to be younger than the Sun.
4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Another lying PDF (Ockham’s Razor Definition for Planet and Star).
Ockham’s Razor is not a definition for anything. Ockham’s Razor is a criteria for deciding which valid theories with identical predictions is to more likely to be correct (the one with the fewer postulated entities). You have a delusion with no predictions.

4 August 2017 jeffreyw: Another lying PDF (What a Dead Star Looks Like)
Starts with a picture of the Moon and lies that it is "an ancient star vastly older than the Earth" - the Moon's age is less than the Earth's.
A complete delusion that the Moon "more than likely came from another galaxy entirely"! Ignorant delusions about Mercury, e.g. it is meteor impacts that make lava by heating the surface not magical "regeneration" that would erase all of the craters :eek:!
The multiple idiocy of an
  1. uncited,
  2. cherry picked
  3. table of "Variation in Ages for Apollo Sample Material" that shows that the most of the samples give an average age of the Moon below that of the Earth.
    There are 4 outlying samples with a too high upper limits and 1 with a too low lower limit.
A delusion that people do not know about Google and so cannot find the dating of Apollo samples. Took me 1 press of the key to get 3 PDFs with some dating :eek:. Followed by the paranoia of "threatens careers and the flow of grant money".
 
Last edited:
I feel it is time to move this thread to a more suitable forum. The only science is provided by the posters pointing out how wrong JW is..
Since JW ignores most replies and harps about real astronomy and astrophysics are in collusion to stifle his, um, theories it should be moved to the conspiracy forum.
 
For the lurkers.

New papers:

The Taylor Threshold

http://vixra.org/pdf/1708.0014v1.pdf

Relative and Absolute Ages in Stellar Metamorphosis

http://vixra.org/pdf/1708.0035v1.pdf

The numbers of views of the main paper is still climbing and has reached 3,076 unique I.P. Downloads. I expect that number to reach into the tens of thousands of the next couple years.

Lurkers are reading this theory (more like worldview change). With the help of this forum, hopefully all the scientific communities on the Earth will know what the Earth is. An ancient star vastly older than the Sun.
 
Look, that's not even a paper. It has no data, no model, no prediction and no observations.

There is no explanation for what is necessary for life, just size and age and there is no correlation for that there.

sorry try again

There is lots of data. I have shown an alternative concept to replace the outdated "Goldilocks Zone" based on the general theory.

Essentially there will be a cut off for the ability for a star to host life, this of course is based on other principles outlined here:

The Mobility, Volume and Gravity Principles of Life Formation.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1608.0115v1.pdf

Basically the threshold outlines the area where the mobility, volume and gravity principles would hold true. On asteroids, there is very little molecular mobility, volume (atmospheric/oceanic) and almost nil gravitation, so we can be 100% sure life does not form on asteroids, thus rendering the panspermia idea false. Life formed on the Earth when it had a much higher volume, the molecules were much more mobile and the gravitation was much stronger so as to not lose the molecules as they formed.

These principles are going to be used to set the foundation of life formation in terms of a more complete statistical theory, which has never been done before. Essentially, the statistical likelihood of molecules forming in stars that have larger volumes, a larger ability to interact with other molecules and higher gravitation increases, and decreases given certain conditions are not met. That is the whole point of the threshold.

I had to point out where the threshold was so that I could further refine the basic principles, thus further refining the theory to be more predictive.

Essentially all of this boils down to figuring out if it will be worth our time to visit objects like the oceans of Europa, because it probably did not have enough volume for the molecules to interact on the scale necessary to form the first amino acids. It is most likely just a sterile ocean.

This is for the lurkers I guess, because you would rather continue participation in this thread for echo purposes only.
 
Last edited:
If I were you I would realize that the views of your page are akin to the monkey cage at the zoo. People stop by, point and laugh.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom