The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

jeffreyw: Yet another ignorant and deluded "paper"

II have written a new paper. I have called it, "The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Yet another ignorant and deluded "paper"!
I hardly need to read the paper to know that it is just more of your ignorance and delusions.
For example a small debunking of the delusion that the planets and moons and asteroids and comets and grains of dust in the Solar System are randomly collected old stars is that all orbits will be randomly oriented. The Solar System does not exist in your world :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: A fantasy that the equatorial plane has to match the Sun's equator exactly

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A fantasy that the equatorial plane has to match the Sun's equator exactly.
The disk that the Sun and planets formed from 4.6 billion years ago had a finite thickness. That allowed the initial inclination of the planetary orbits to vary. Add 4.6 billion years of interactions. Add the probable migration of Jupiter from close to the Sun to its present position. The surprise is rather that the inclination of the planets to the Sun's equator is so consistent :eye-poppi! It is Mercury and Venus that are the outliers with ~4 degrees. The other planets are ~6-7 degrees.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Arguments from incredibility and ignorance about solar system formation

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Arguments from incredibility and ignorance about solar system formation.
You being ignorant about solar system formation does not make mainstream, working models wrong. You expressing incredibility does not make mainstream, working models wrong.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Ignorance about Pluto (it is not a planet!)

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorance about Pluto (it is not a planet and is in the Solar system!).
Pluto is defined as a dwarf planet, one of the trillions of Kuiper belt objects and one of several similar sized Kuiper belt objects. These trillions of Kuiper belt objects, including Pluto, orbit the Sun. They are part of the Solar System.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about exoplanet orbital inclinatons

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Ignorant fantasies about exoplanet orbital inclinations.
You seem abysmally ignorant about the TRAPPIST-1 system. The 7 planets in that system all have the same orbital inclination of ~89 degrees. They are more consistent than the Solar System planets!
None of the TRAPPIST-1 are in retrograde orbits (inclination of > 90 degrees).
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Basic ignorance about the transit method of detecting exoplanets

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Basic ignorance about the transit method of detecting exoplanets.
Of course we can tell which way an exoplanet is orbiting from the transit method, e.g. see the nearly identical inclinations of the TRAPPIST-1 system measured from transits.
A transit is a planet starting from one side of a star, transiting across the face of the star and getting to the other side of the star. The direction of the transit is the direction of the planet orbit :eye-poppi! The inclination of exoplanets or members of multiple stars is the angle of the plane of the orbit relative to the plane perpendicular to the line-of-sight from Earth to the object.
 
jeffreyw: A delusion that all planets in the galaxy must match the Sun's axis

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that all planets in the galaxy must have "the same inclination of the Sun’s axis"!
Milky Way stars do not all rotate in the same plane.
 
jeffreyw: The usual persistent delusion that astronomy is dogma

"The Principle of Equatorial Planes in Planet Formation (Stellar Evolution) in Stellar Metamorphosis"
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: The usual persistent delusion that astronomy is dogma.
 
jeffreyw: Denying the facts about stars and planets is beyond "absolutely insane"

To believe all of these objects are related to each other via formation is absolutely insane. Yet that is what the people on this forum believe.
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: Denying the physical facts about stars and planets is beyond "absolutely insane".
The facts have been given to you many times before, e.g.
  • The age of the Earth is measured to be a little younger than the age of the Sun :jaw-dropp!
  • There are trillions of objects just in the Solar System that your "planets = old stars" delusion demands be old stars.
  • Old stars (white dwarfs , neutron stars, black holes!, etc.) are hundreds of thousands of times heavier than planets.
  • Old stars are not made of rock.
    There has to be a mechanism for lighter elements to be blown away leaving rocky grains, etc. to form rocky planets. That is young stars and their fierce solar winds that we observe doing just that.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: An ignorant lie about Hubble's discovery that "spiral nebula" were galaxies

The whole "single disk forming solar systems" idea was debunked by Hubble when he discovered that the spiral nebulas were not new solar systems, but entire galaxies full of hundreds of billions of stars.
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant lie about Hubble's discovery that "spiral nebula" were galaxies.
The molecular hydrogen—giant molecular clouds in the Nebular hypothesis that you linked to have never been considered to be "spiral nebula" because they are not spiral shaped :jaw-dropp!
Spiral nebula
"Spiral nebula" was a term used to describe galaxies with a visible spiral structure, such as the Whirlpool Galaxy, before it was understood that these objects existed outside our Milky Way galaxy. The question of whether such objects were separate galaxies independent of the Milky Way, or a type of nebula existing within our own galaxy, was the subject of the Great Debate of 1920, between Heber Curtis of Lick Observatory and Harlow Shapley of Mt. Wilson Observatory. Beginning in 1923, Edwin Hubble[17][18] observed Cepheid variables in several spiral nebulae, including the so-called "Andromeda Nebula", proving that they are, in fact, entire galaxies outside our own. The term "spiral nebula" has since fallen into disuse.
The Spiral Nebulae and the Great Debate has an example of a 1910 image of the M51 spiral nebula clearly showing the spirals.


What you also ignore in the history of the nebular hypothesis is that it was not considered to be correct at the time of Hubble's discovery: "As a result, astronomers largely abandoned this theory of planet formation at the beginning of the 20th century". The modern accepted theory is the solar nebular disk model first described by to the Soviet astronomer Victor Safronov in 1969.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: A second lie about Hubble's discovery on "spiral nebula"

The argument was the "nebular hypothesis" vs. "the island universe".
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A second lie about Hubble's discovery on "spiral nebula".
The argument was whether "spiral nebula" were outside of the Milky Way or inside the Milky Way. That is "the universe of islands" versus "the island universe" argument as in the Great Debate. Hubble found that "spiral nebula" were too far away to be considered part of the Milky Way.
 
jeffreyw: A lie about the nebular hypothesis being debunked almost 100 years ago.

It is crazy to still believe an idea that has been debunked almost 100 years ago.
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about the nebular hypothesis being debunked almost 100 years ago.
The history of the nebular hypothesis is that the modern theory did not exist until 1969. The old "Laplacian theory" was abandoned for many decades mainly because of the problem of angular momentum distribution. Now we have viable mechanisms to distribute stellar angular momentum to the planetary system.
 
jeffreyw: A lying cartoon is not support of a delusion that planets are old stars

...where they are on this graph.
31 July 2017 jeffreyw: A lying cartoon is not support of a delusion that Blue giant stars are the end point of the evolution of main sequence stars. They are older than main sequence stars :jaw-dropp!
"White" stars do not exist :eek:! There are stars that look white, yellow, blue, red, etc. There are real spectral classification for these as used in the original Hertzsprung–Russell diagram (the modern form mostly use the B-V color index).
Spectral type 1 stars ("white") do not change to spectral type G ("yellow" ) stars, e.g. the Sun has never been a white star.
 
I didn't expect you to know KindaGamey, he is a member at Skeptiko that is a fan of yours. As I said previously Skeptiko members would likely be receptive to your beliefs go post there too.
There's no rational reason not to think all celestial bodies are associated. All of the celestial bodies in 5his and every other galaxy are. Galaxies are tremendously bigger than this little solar system.

People such as you for example whom have such unwavering unrelenting passion for their ill concieved ideas always cause me to wonder what's going on in their minds. Is how they think some form of psychosis, maybe there's a genetic component. Perhaps they a narsicistic? Leading them to believe they are smarter than everyone else. I don't know. What I do know is you are an intriguing individual. Don't construe this as a compliment.

That's the thing. You call me crazy yet... Here's another paper that addresses the iron deposition rate in the cores of evolving stars.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

I've already fully replaced the iron catastrophe, which is a good thing, because it does not address the iron cores of any highly evolved star, except for Earth. With stellar metamorphosis the iron cores of all evolved stars are addressed. Not just the ones establishment has cherry picked.
 
Last edited:
That's the thing. You call me crazy yet... Here's another paper that addresses the iron deposition rate in the cores of evolving stars.

http://vixra.org/pdf/1707.0407v1.pdf

I've already fully replaced the iron catastrophe, which is a good thing, because it does not address the iron cores of any highly evolved star, except for Earth. With stellar metamorphosis the iron cores of all evolved stars are addressed. Not just the ones establishment has cherry picked.

The problems are there is too much iron in our own sun to date the formation of the sun to the 8200 years per meter deposition of iron and where does this iron that is deposited come from?

The sun has enough iron to make over 500 earths, if the earth was 100% iron.
 
The problems are there is too much iron in our own sun to date the formation of the sun to the 8200 years per meter deposition of iron and where does this iron that is deposited come from?

The sun has enough iron to make over 500 earths, if the earth was 100% iron.

That's why I included the mass loss principle.

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Stellar_metamorphosis#Mass_loss

and the mass continuum principle.

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Stellar_metamorphosis#Mass_continuum_principle

and the principle of diminishing solar abundances.

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Stellar_metamorphosis#Diminishing_solar_abundances

As well, the Sun does not possess an iron core yet. So dating the Sun based off its presumed current iron is not even mentioned. The beginning of iron core formation happens during red dwarf/flare star stages, so it would be more accurate to take what ever equation you used to apply to the iron content of stars past red dwarf/flare star stages. The Sun is still too hot. This is overviewed in congruence with the magnetosphere evolution of a star:

http://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Stellar_metamorphosis#Magnetosphere_evolution

Basically the star's magnetosphere becomes global when in red dwarf stages, which in turn overpower the sun spots. We should expect to see sun spots disappear around red dwarf stages as a global magnetic field would prevent, or strongly reduce their ability to form. This also means all brown dwarfs and more evolved stars past brown dwarf stages which still have internal dynamos will only have a single, global magnetic field.

Thank you for asking a question, instead of being called crazy. Most people here seem to not get it, or bother reading what I'm saying because their minds are already made up. Ridicule and call the person crazy and hope they go away. Well, I'm still here, still developing the theory, posting the progress. Oh well!
 
Last edited:
Oh BTW Reality Check, I have just ignored all your posts because you do not want to talk about this issue in an adult manner. It is a waste of time for you to post. Just saying, I don't even see what you are writing.
 
Oh BTW Reality Check, I have just ignored all your posts because you do not want to talk about this issue in an adult manner. It is a waste of time for you to post. Just saying, I don't even see what you are writing.

You think RC is writing stuff for you to read? Well, that's another thing you're wrong about.
 
Oh BTW Reality Check, I have just ignored all your posts because you do not want to talk about this issue in an adult manner.
BTW nothing has really changed :eye-poppi! Jeffrey Wolynski has been ignoring every knowledgeable person in the world for many, many years!

He is content to indulge in an obsession with an infantile idea that high school science students know is wrong and thus dig himself ever deeper into a pit of ignorance and delusion. He may think that this makes him special in some way but this is normal behavior for Internet physics cranks. Jeffrey Wolynski is not much different from Miles Mathis (the pi=4 guy :eek:!), more coherent than Gene Ray which is not hard (the Time Cube crank) and the Thunderbolts "cult" which is also produces ignorant and deluded propaganda on YouTube. Thunderbolts are literally crazy neo-Velikovskians, e.g. their dogma includes that comets are rocks blasted off the Earth, etc. by electrical discharges between the planets and witnessed by human beings.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom