The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Actually he said it should be electrostaticly cleaned, as in like charged dust responding to electric fields.
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

The ignorant, deluded liar Wal Thornhill has been ignorant, deluded and lying about comets since at least 2005. Thornhill's "electrostaticly cleaned" would be electrical discharges or electrical discharge machining insanity.
 
And it would appear that sub-micron sized dust is likely not lifted from the nucleus, but is due to electrostatic disruption of larger grains;

The amount of electric charge collected by fluffy and sub-µm dust particles affects their motion in comae and tails and their lifetime against electrostatic fragmentation. The Rosetta mission provided the first direct evidence for the presence of electrically charged dust particles in a coma. These observations were possible as a result of the interaction between dust and the spacecraft electric potential, which was oscillating around −10 V (Nilsson et al. 2015) within 100 km from the 67P/C-G nucleus. The fundamental physics of charged cometary dust has been studied for a long time (Mendis and Horányi 2013). Dust charging is a delicate interplay between several currents, including electron and ion collection currents from the surrounding plasma, ultraviolet induced photoelectron currents, secondary electron emission (due to energetic ion and/or electron bombardment), thermo-ionic emission, field emission (due to large surface fields), etc.
As a rule of thumb, a dust particle collects about 700 extra electrons per unit particle volume-equivalent radius (measured in µm) and unit electric potential difference between the particle surface and the surrounding plasma (measured in V). This means that in the solar wind a particle of 1 µm size can have about 104 extra electrons. Based on our experience with mesospheric dust charging at Earth it can be assumed that most of the extra electrons are deep inside the dust particle and they can electrostatically disrupt fluffy, highly friable dust particles (Hill and Mendis 1981). An updated version (Mendis and Horányi 2013) predicts that a 10−19 kg particle can be electrostatically disrupted if its tensile strength is less than about 0.5 MPa. In general, the tensile strength of a particle charged at the potential U is T = ϵ0/2 (U/R)2 (Boehnhardt and Fechtig 1987). Regarding dust electrical resistance, COSIMA estimates a specific resistance of 1016 ohm mm2 m−1 after the interaction of an Indium ion beam with the particles (Hilchenbach et al. 2017).

Cometary Dust
Levasseur-Regourd, A-C., et al.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11214-018-0496-3
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Is it? not according reality check...
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

jonesdave116 quoted the deluded Thornhill's actual words which are not Sol88's delusions of "charged dust responding to electric fields" about mainstream cometary science. Real comets should have the solar wind charging dust and the electric fields between the dust lifting the dust during low activity.

I wrote
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

This is the real world of comets where the solar wind is should charge dust and electrostatically accelerate the dust during periods of low activity. This stops when a coma forms. This is viable but not observed physics.
Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity

Sol88's insane delusions are never a viable mechanism.
Sol88's insanity is persistently citing a paper that has noting to do with his electric comet insanity.
Sol88's insanity is persistently citing a viable alternative mechanism to eject submicron dust grains if sublimation cannot do it.
 
Last edited:
An insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Ergo, sublimation is not viable for the dust detected at Rosetta.
An insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Sol88 knows that the dust detected by Rosetta detected fluffy dust aggregates exactly as expected by the paper Sol88 has cited :jaw-dropp!
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface shows that sublimation of water ice can remove aggregates of dust and we observed this dust.
The authors assert "Homogeneous dust layers consisting of µm-sized dust particles possess cohesive strengths orders of magnitude too high to cause dust activity.". This is from sublimation of water ice. Water is not the only ice on comets :jaw-dropp.

For others, some real science: Profiling COSIMA’s dust grain family
The images reveal the particles are extremely diverse at scales of just a few 10s of micrometers (μm) to several 100 μm. The grains were characterized according to factors such as the complexity of its appearance and its height above target – determined by analysing its shadow –, which in turn is related to strength of particle.
That instrument did not detect any μm or submicron dust particles. The particles were > a 10s of micrometers in scale.

Now look what Sol88 quotes from Experiments on cometary activity: ejection of dust aggregates from a sublimating water-ice surface
(i) Cometary dust aggregates can be emitted by the gas pressure build-up at the ice-dust interface. Dust emission only works for surfaces consisting of aggregates because of their very low tensile strengths. Homogeneous dust layers consisting of µm-sized dust particles possess cohesive strengths orders of magnitude too high to cause dust activity.
It looks like the authors are giving a reason why we only detected dust particles > a 10s of µm in scale!

Sol88 might take a break from his insanity, cite the detection of µm-sized dust particles around any comet (I suspect there may be some) and then give a physically coherent electric comet mechanism (not the usual deluded fantasies). We should not hold our breathes :p!
 
Last edited:
Another spate of ~662 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 13 December 2018
Another spate of ~684 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion, derails, insults, and lies from 27 July 2018 to 14 December 2018
 
And it would appear that sub-micron sized dust is likely not lifted from the nucleus, but is due to electrostatic disruption of larger grains;



Cometary Dust
Levasseur-Regourd, A-C., et al.
https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11214-018-0496-3

So, we have a viable mechanism jd116?

Totally inline with mainstream thinking?

Otherwise, my head hurts. :o

And it would appear that sub-micron sized dust is likely not lifted from the nucleus, but is due to electrostatic disruption of larger grains.....or rock that is the surface of nucleus!


If this rock was hydrated minerals and carbonates then what?

Baby steps champ, baby steps..
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

So, we have a viable mechanism jd116?
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Cometary Dust by Levasseur-Regourd, A-C., et al.
Based on our experience with mesospheric dust charging at Earth it can be assumed that most of the extra electrons are deep inside the dust particle and they can electrostatically disrupt fluffy, highly friable dust particles (Hill and Mendis 1981)

Sol88's insane lie is that a mainstream ices and dust comet paper is about comets made of rock.
 
Last edited:
Asaruleofthumb,adustparticle collects about 700 extra electrons per unit particle volumeequivalent radius (measured in µm) and unit electric potential difference between the particle surface and the surrounding plasma (measured in V). This means that in the solar wind a particle of 1 µm size can have about 104 extra electrons

Lots of electrons!

All leaving the nucleus as colimated jets. This is a discharge. :D
 
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Lots of electrons!
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Sol88's insanity includes that jets made of ice and dust are electrical discharges. Comet jets are dark on the night side and are seen by reflected light!\ :jaw-dropp!
Sol88's insane lie is that paper is about jets when it is a review of cometary dust :jaw-dropp!
Sol88's insane lie is that the paper has collimated electrons fro the nucleus :jaw-dropp!

Cometary Dust by Levasseur-Regourd, A-C., et al.
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity and insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook

Sol88's insanity includes that jets made of ice and dust are electrical discharges. Comet jets are dark on the night side and are seen by reflected light!\ :jaw-dropp!
Sol88's insane lie is that paper is about jets when it is a review of cometary dust :jaw-dropp!
Sol88's insane lie is that the paper has collimated electrons fro the nucleus :jaw-dropp!

Cometary Dust by Levasseur-Regourd, A-C., et al.

There are three modes of discharge depending on the power.

Dark mode
Glow mode
Arc mode

This is a low activity comet, most discharges are in dark mode, as seen the magnetometer/MIP/LAP data.

And that’s why tusenfem’s bugger off. He’s seen this data since day one.

You still think a big lightning bolt from the Sun or something???

Well makes sense I spose, you still think the nucleus is mostly ice and sublimation is the KEY driver for the dust we see, the CHARGED dust.
 
Last edited:
Ok, here’s one for you jd116, where are all these electrons comming from?

If you’ve got a brain that is and it can think for its self. :confused:

Errrr, lost the power of comprehension again, have we? I bloody well quoted it for you;

The fundamental physics of charged cometary dust has been studied for a long time (Mendis and Horányi 2013). Dust charging is a delicate interplay between several currents, including electron and ion collection currents from the surrounding plasma, ultraviolet induced photoelectron currents, secondary electron emission (due to energetic ion and/or electron bombardment), thermo-ionic emission, field emission (due to large surface fields), etc.

So, why not go read Mendis and Horanyi, 2013?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom