The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Usual insane lie from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88's insanity that textbook and easily understood plasma physics is wrong.
Sol88's insanity that ambipolar electric fields have to do with his electric comet insanity.
Sol88's insanity that I will answer questions that are part of Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

For lurkers only:
Thus all comets have plasma with ambipolar electric fields.

Cheers again. :thumbsup:

Are you willing to confirm the surface electric fields as well? That'd be tops champ.
 
Sol88's insanity includes not understanding this basic fact about plasma after that source was given to him many times.

What's the earliest you can find of ambipolar electric field in operation at comets?

P.S

My moneys still on nested electric fields, DOUBLE LAYERS standard plasma physics, which reality check rightfully states, is your garden variety PLASMA PHYSICS!

While I can not do the maths, I do understand the concept! It's pretty basic, wonder why the mainstream experts are really only just getting into it?

Any who, cheers again sport. :D
 
Found this one from 1985 The role of electric fields in the cometary environment

Polarization electric fields in the cometary environment are shown to influence both the cometary plasma and the fine cometary dust. The role of the ambipolar electric field on the dynamics and thermodymamics of the cometary ionosphere is discussed. It is shown that this field decelerates and cools the plasma in the outer cometary ionosphere, and shock waves can develop in the plasma flow due to this deceleration. The consequences of electrostatic change of the cometary dust are considered. It is shown that while the consequences are minimal within the cometary ionosphere, they are substantial outside. The convectional electric field in the in flowing solar wind (both outside and inside the outer shock), as well as the Coulomb drag of this plasma on the charged dust, affect significantly the dynamics of the lower end of the dust mass spectrum.

Well well well now its popped up again in 2017!

Why didn't the mainstream look for them at Tempel 1?

To ELECTRIC COMET-EY?


What did you find rc?
 
Last edited:
What's the earliest you can find of ambipolar electric field in operation at comets?

P.S

My moneys still on nested electric fields, DOUBLE LAYERS standard plasma physics, which reality check rightfully states, is your garden variety PLASMA PHYSICS!

While I can not do the maths, I do understand the concept! It's pretty basic, wonder why the mainstream experts are really only just getting into it?

Any who, cheers again sport. :D

No, you do not understand the concept. Not even close. As Tusenfem has told you many times. You are a rank amateur who believes in neo-Velikovskian, scientifically impossible woo.
 
Any mention of the ambipolar electric field at comet 9P/Tempel 1?

Cant find any mention, can you help reality check?

You've done an awesome job so far, lets see if we can keep it moving forward.

Did 9P/Tempel 1's ambipolar electric field get a mention? Did we see one there? Did we look?

And what the hell relevance has that got to do with the failed EC woo? It was a flyby mission! They detected solid ice from the impact. End of electric comet woo, right there. And, to the best of my knowledge, they haven't detected an ambipolar field at 67P. It is modelled, and could explain some of the plasma behaviour at low activity levels.
 
Don’t need to explain the volatiles you do.

In the electric comet they are coming from the rock that is the nucleus.

You know hydrated minerals being dissociated = anhydrous refractory minerals + h2o

Dissociated carbonates = organics + CO2/CO

Seems these minerals are common. Tempel 1, Bennu, Ceres...


You should be asking the hard questions, like what’s doing the dissociating?

The latest paper proves, on cometary sublimation, Yu. V. Skorov correct. :D

Another pile of idiocy and fail. Where are the papers describing how hydrated minerals are dissociated at a comet? What temperature is required? How are you turning it back to ice? Total and utter idiotic woo. You haven't got a clue what you're talking about. As usual. You lost. Still batting zero.
 
The elliptical orbit increases the ambipolar electric field, thereby increasing the strength of the voltage differential. At some point it will begin emitting.

Outgassing is your Whipple Dirtysnowball model.

Do you know the strength of the electric field at comet Tempel 1?

Bet you can’t find any peer reviewed papers on that little chestnut. Does it mean it wasn’t there or the mainstream just never looked because Dirtysnowballs dint do that. They sublimate, Electric comets emit. :D

What the hell is this crap? How would an elliptical orbit increase the ambipolar electric field, and what relevance has that to the failed EC model? Asteroids don't have an ambipolar field, because they are not outgassing! That is the point! Why does an elliptical orbit turn asteroids into comets, when we see thousands of asteroids on those sort of orbits that are not outgassing? What is the mechanism? You haven't got one. It is pure fantasy, with zero science behind it. It was dreamed up by clueless Velikovskians. You lose. No mechanism, no support.

EC 0 - Real Science 2.
 
The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.
Electric discharges would show up in the magnetometer data. There was nothing. The jets are observed to be gas, dust and, sometimes, ice.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

So, where is the scientific mechanism for this described in the scientific literature? Why is there zero evidence for it? Why do observations show that the jets are not electrical woo?

EC 0 - Real Science 3.
 
So, where is the scientific mechanism for this described in the scientific literature? Why is there zero evidence for it? Why do observations show that the jets are not electrical woo?

EC 0 - Real Science 3.

You were shown, you ignored. :(
 
And what the hell relevance has that got to do with the failed EC woo? It was a flyby mission! They detected solid ice from the impact. End of electric comet woo, right there. And, to the best of my knowledge, they haven't detected an ambipolar field at 67P. It is modelled, and could explain some of the plasma behaviour at low activity levels.

Yawn, we see “icy” cliffs.
 
Last edited:
Too easy ya goose.

We’ll go slowly so you can keep up, ok?

Let’s start with the basics.

Is the dust charged? :rolleyes:

Irrelevant. Where is the mechanism for non-existent discharges? Where is the mechanism to cause outgassing due to an elliptical orbit? Stop avoiding the questions. What is it? Where is it written up? You don't have anything, do you?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom