The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Comets are merely asteroids on elliptical orbits.
Any cursory examination of the many asteroids on elliptical orbits shows this to be wrong.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

So, where are the papers describing why an elliptical orbit should induce outgassing? How would this happen, and what is the evidence? Why are many asteroids on elliptical orbits not outgassing? Score will soon be 0 - 2.
 
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Oh boy this will cause a stir
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

OSIRIS-REx discovers water on asteroid, confirms Bennu as excellent mission target

Sol88's is not only insane about comets, Sol88 is insanely ignorant about asteroids. Some asteroids are water-rich and even considered as a source of Earth's oceans. It is well known that C-type asteroids like Bennu have some water content in their minerals.


Added to Sol88's insane electric comet playbook: Sol88's insanity that the known fact that c-type asteroids contain water in their minerals support whatever insane delusions he makes up.
OSIRIS-REx
By 10 December 2018, spectroscopic surveys of the asteroid's surface detected the presence of hydroxyl (oxygen-hydrogen) bonds, likely part of hydrates in the clay material of the asteroid. While researchers suspect that Bennu was too small to host water, these hydroxyl groups and hydrates may have come from water present in Bennu's parent body.[26]

Added to Sol88's insane electric comet playbook: Sol88's insanity of not being to do basic research when asteroid 101955 Bennu is one of the many that his electric comet insanity says should be a comet!
There were 605,650 asteroids in 2013 with eccentricities greater than the minimum observed eccentricity of comets (0.0279). These should be EC comets.

101955 Bennu has an eccentricity of 0.20375 :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Lets follow the OSIRIS-REx mission wrt comets/asteroids eccentric orbits, hydrated minerals etc etc
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

101955 Bennu is an asteroid not a comet.

Sol88's insanity includes denying the existence of asteroids on similar obits as comets that are to comets :jaw-dropp!
 
Last edited:
Sol88's comet delusions start with the deluded Thunderbolts cult insanity. Comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks;electrical discharge machining (EDM needs a dielectric fluid!) insanity.
Then we get his touches:
21 20 ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to his cult electric comet insanity.
4 ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to his cult electric comet insanity
Persistently lies about what other posters write
5 ignorant, lying and even insane items Sol88 has added to his cult electric comet insanity

32. "Comets are VERY bad conductors of heat" insanity.
The first insanity is that he has a quote about mainstream comets (67P). The real insanity is that astronomers know what the thermal inertia of comets is and there is no problem with that "very low thermal inertia" :jaw-dropp!
The rest of the insanity is:
  • Sol88 is abysmally ignorant of and deluded about physics. Sol88 has no idea what effects that very low thermal inertia has.
  • The quote is about the surface of 67P. The bulk thermal inertia is not mentioned.
  • Thermal inertia is a measure of how long it takes heat to pass through a volume. The Sun heats a comet for days, weeks, months or years.
33. An insane "dust covers the vacuum" statement
We have landed a spacecraft on comet 67P and found a layer of dust that does not cover a vacuum. It covers a hard layer consistent with sintered ice (Sol88's MUPUS insanity is that this is actual rock). We know that the bulk of 67P has a high porosity of ~70%. That means grains of ices and dust adhering with gaps like loose snow. Loose snow is not a vacuum :eye-poppi!

34. Sol88 spews deluded lies about a ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae paper.
35. Sol88 spews an insanely deluded lie about mainstream comet papers "reinforcing" his electric comet insanity.
36. Sol88 repeats his deluded lies about comets not needing sublimation and electric field around comets.
37. Sol88 spews out his deluded "circuit" lie about a paper on the generation and neutralization of plasma ions in the coma of 67P
38. Adds blatant lies about other posters to Sol88's electric comet insanity.
39. Sol88 has the insane idea that the scientific literature on astronomy will not have words in it that are already in papers he has cited.
40. Sol88's insanity that the known fact that c-type asteroids contain water in their minerals support whatever insane delusions he makes up.
41. Sol88's insanity of not being to do basic research - asteroid 101955 Bennu is one of the many that his electric comet insanity says should be a comet!
42. Sol88's insanity includes that his electric comet insanity does not have to explain physical data about comets :eek:!
 
Last edited:
So, you've failed the first point. You have zero evidence, and cannot explain the volatiles that cannot possibly have been from a planetary surface, due to their sublimation temperatures. Strike one. EC 0 Real Science 1.


Don’t need to explain the volatiles you do.

In the electric comet they are coming from the rock that is the nucleus.

You know hydrated minerals being dissociated = anhydrous refractory minerals + h2o

Dissociated carbonates = organics + CO2/CO

Seems these minerals are common. Tempel 1, Bennu, Ceres...


You should be asking the hard questions, like what’s doing the dissociating?

The latest paper proves, on cometary sublimation, Yu. V. Skorov correct. :D
 
No, I want a scientifically viable mechanism, and the evidence for it. You have failed to provide one because, as I pointed out, such impossible fantasies only exist in the minds of EU fruitloops. Like I said, 0 - 1.


You choose to ignore it. :D

Not my problem.


But just in case


ELECTRIC FIELDS, CHARGE SEPERATION, POTENTIAL DIFFERENCE

the electric universe :cool:

You deny these plasma phenomena are real?

That’s your problem right there champ! :jaw-dropp
 
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Which one is not correct jd116?
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Real comets have plasma around them and thus charges that are separated. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about charge separation.
Real comets have electric fields in their coma and tail (plasma!). Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about electric fields.
Real comets may have temporary electric fields across their surface lifting dust during low activity. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about electric fields.
Real comets have real dust and ice grains that are charged. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about charged dust.
 
Last edited:
So, where are the papers describing why an elliptical orbit should induce outgassing? How would this happen, and what is the evidence? Why are many asteroids on elliptical orbits not outgassing? Score will soon be 0 - 2.

The elliptical orbit increases the ambipolar electric field, thereby increasing the strength of the voltage differential. At some point it will begin emitting.

Outgassing is your Whipple Dirtysnowball model.

Do you know the strength of the electric field at comet Tempel 1?

Bet you can’t find any peer reviewed papers on that little chestnut. Does it mean it wasn’t there or the mainstream just never looked because Dirtysnowballs dint do that. They sublimate, Electric comets emit. :D
 
Sol88's electric comet insanity includes not explaining physical data

Don’t need to explain the volatiles you do.
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

The mainstream model of comets does explain the volatiles. Sol88's electric comet insanity does not.

Added: Sol88's insanity includes that his electric comet insanity does not have to explain physical data about comets :jaw-dropp!
Sol88's electric comet insanity does have to explain the observed volatiles from comets. Ditto for their density. Ditto for their jets. Ditto for their coma. Ditto for their tails. Ditto for their spectra. etc.

We already know from the last 9 years here (over 12 years elsewhere) that all Sol88 has is mindless vomiting up of his cult's ignorant, deluded and insane fantasies. To that Sol88 adds his own ignorance, delusions, lies and insults.
 
Last edited:
Usual insane lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Real comets have plasma around them and thus charges that are separated. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about charge separation.
Real comets have electric fields in their coma and tail (plasma!). Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about electric fields.
Real comets may have temporary electric fields across their surface lifting dust during low activity. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about electric fields.
Real comets have real dust and ice grains that are charged. Nothing to do with Sol88's insane delusions about charged dust.


Thanks for the succinct summary, rc! :thumbsup:

But you forgot the ions are allready decoupled from the neutrals instantly, not after some distance in the coma. The dust is also charged, this responds to any electric fields it “sees”.

This constitutes the “jets” that are Observatoire finer and finer resolutions.

Don’t care if if believe it or not really, but there the facts.

But I’m happy to wait until some mainstreamed breaks ranks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom