The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Irrelevant. Where is the mechanism for non-existent discharges? Where is the mechanism to cause outgassing due to an elliptical orbit? Stop avoiding the questions. What is it? Where is it written up? You don't have anything, do you?

Focus jd116, focus.

You asked me a question, I’m giving an answer but if your going to ignore out spin off into another dummy spit...:rolleyes:


Is the dust charged? Yes or no?

Your obstufication is very telling. :blush:

Why can’t/won’t you answer a question? Because you know exactly how it’s going to end up, not good for Whipple’s model, your beloved and cherished dirty snowball.

So it’s not irrelevant it’s on topic. :boggled:
 
And what the hell has that got to do with anything? The impact excavated a shed load of solid ice. End of electric comet woo.

Nothing, just significant “ice” on the surface, not mentioned by either A’Hearn or Sunshine.

So subsurface ice, meh.
 
Nothing, just significant “ice” on the surface, not mentioned by either A’Hearn or Sunshine.

So subsurface ice, meh.

What? Try making sense for once. No ice in impact area. Bang, 8 - 18 000 tonnes of ice in the ejecta. Where the hell do you think it came from? EC says no ice. We see ice, above and below the surface. You lose. Again.
 
Is the dust charged? Yes or no?

Irrelevant. What has that got to do with non-existent discharges? What has it got to do with elliptical orbits (not) making asteroids outgas? Just answer the questions. What is the mechanism? Charged dust is an irrelevance. You are avoiding the questions because you have no answers. You lose.
 
Irrelevant. What has that got to do with non-existent discharges? What has it got to do with elliptical orbits (not) making asteroids outgas? Just answer the questions. What is the mechanism? Charged dust is an irrelevance. You are avoiding the questions because you have no answers. You lose.


Is the dust charged jd116?


I can retrieve the mainstream peer reviewed papers if you like? Though I’ve done this many times before but to progress your question to me, forward you will have to answer yes or no.

So I least I know we are reading from the same page, otherwise troll away. :D
 
Is the dust charged jd116?


I can retrieve the mainstream peer reviewed papers if you like? Though I’ve done this many times before but to progress your question to me, forward you will have to answer yes or no.

So I least I know we are reading from the same page, otherwise troll away. :D

We have known about charged dust for decades. What is the relevance? None. Spell it out instead of talking crap. Charged dust means elliptical orbits (don't) cause outgassing, how? Spell out the chain of unobservable events in your fantasy.
Charged dust proves non-existent discharges, how? Spell it out. You have nothing, and are just avoiding the fatal flaws in your idiotic belief system.
 
Last edited:
Just for the record, Thornhill said there would be no dust at the comet due to electrostatic cleaning! Lol.
 
We have known about charged dust for decades. What is the relevance? None. Spell it out instead of talking crap. Charged dust means elliptical orbits (don't) cause outgassing, how? Spell out the chain of unobservable events in your fantasy.
Charged dust proves non-existent discharges, how? Spell it out. You have nothing, and are just avoiding the fatal flaws in your idiotic belief system.

So that’s a yes?

Just for the record, Thornhill said there would be no dust at the comet due to electrostatic cleaning! Lol.

Electrostatic cleaning you say? Well you’d need an electric field to be able to ACCELERATE dust of the nucleus, ya duffer.
 
Last edited:
So that’s a yes?

What the hell has it got to do with the questions I asked? Stop avoiding the questions and answer them, or admit that you haven't got a clue.

The dynamics of charged dust in the tail of comet Giacobini‐Zinner
M. Horanyi & D. A. Mendis
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1029/JA091iA01p00355 (1986)

A full 20 years before the idiot Thornhill said there wouldn't be any dust! Another failure for the EC woo.

Electrostatic cleaning you say? Well you’d need an electric field to be able to ACCELERATE dust of the nucleus, ya duffer.

And the idiot was wrong, wasn't he?
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup: good find jd116 the dust is charged in the tail of a comet. Though this paper New insights on comet tails are blowing in the solar wind is a little newer but confirms the dust in a comets extremely long tail is indeed charged and responding to electric fields.


But

What we are talking about here are
The jets observed are electric discharges to (from?) the nucleus.

So we agree the dust is charged from the tail, the very long tail.

And just to confirm you acknowledge the mainstream papers stating the dust on the surface is also charged?
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup: good find jd116 the dust is charged in the tail of a comet. Though this paper New insights on comet tails are blowing in the solar wind is a little newer but confirms the dust in a comets extremely long tail is indeed charged and responding to electric fields.


But

What we are talking about here are

So we agree the dust is charged from the tail, the very long tail.

And just to confirm you acknowledge the mainstream papers stating the dust on the surface is also charged?

Just answer the question, yes? Where are your non-existent discharges? Why are asteroids on elliptical orbits not outgassing? This has nothing to do with dust, charged or otherwise. I'll take your continued refusal to answer these questions as meaning you have no explanation, otherwise we'd have heard it by now. Still 0 - 3.
 
There is little to no ice, and the water observed is actually OH.
Water has been definitively detected at comets since 1986. So that was a lie.
Therefore the electric comet model fails.

So, moving along, as Sol has essentially admitted defeat on the previous questions.
OK, why did Thornhill lie to you about the H2O being OH?
Where are you getting O- from? There is none to sod all in the data. How is it combining with H+ at those energies? Where is the H2O coming from when the solar wind is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods?
 
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Nothing, just significant “ice” on the surface, not mentioned by either A’Hearn or Sunshine.
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

It was not enough water ices on the surface that rationally gives subsurface water ices :jaw-dropp!
Usual insanity from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88's insanity of citing and quoting mainstream ices and dust comet papers debunking his electric comet insanity.

Sol88's insanity of not even reading the author list of what he cites! This is an ices and dust comet paper with the authors including M. F. A'Hearn stating that comets have solid waster deposits and subsurface sources of water outgassing. Sol88 persistently and insanely insults A'Hearn by accusing A'Hearn of being insanely ignorant enough to write comets are actual rock.

Exposed Water Ice Deposits on the Surface of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 is that there is no enough water ices on the surface to explain outgassing and thus there must be subsurface water ices outgassing.

Exposed Water Ice Deposits on the Surface of Comet 9P/Tempel 1 by J M Sunshine,
M F A'Hearn, O Groussin and D D Wellnitz.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom